Australian rules football award
Scott West has won the award a record seven times.Marcus Bontempelli has won the award six times.TheCharles Sutton Medal is anAustralian rules football award presented annually to the player adjudgedbest and fairest for theWestern Bulldogs throughout theVictorian Football League /Australian Football League season. The medal is named after 1950 winnerCharlie Sutton , who was the Bulldogs' 1954 premiership captain-coach.[ 1] There were many previous names for the medal, which was originally known as the McCarthy Trophy[ 2] from 1927 to 1939, named afterCon McCarthy , who played a key part in getting the club entry into theVictorian Football League . It was also called the Con Weickhardt trophy (also known as the Con Curtain trophy)[ 2] from 1940 to 1954. It was named after the man who chaired the club for 4 years.[ 3] It was renamed to its current name in 1955. The inaugural winner for the award wasIvan McAlpine in 1927.
The voting system as of the2019 AFL season , consists of five members of theWestern Bulldogs match committee awarding a score from zero to five for each player after every game.[ 4] The maximum score that can be obtained after one game is 25. Five players have won the award while also winning theBrownlow Medal , the best and fairest award for theAustralian Football League . Those players wereNorman Ware (1941),John Schultz (1960),Gary Dempsey (1975),Kelvin Templeton (1980) andScott Wynd (1992).Scott West holds the record for most Charles Sutton Medals at the club, winning the accolade seven times in ten years; 1995, 1997, 1998, 2000, 2003, 2004 and 2005.Gary Dempsey andMarcus Bontempelli are in second with a total of six. Dempsey also holds the record for most Charles Sutton Medals won consecutively, his streak running from 1973 to 1977, a total of five years.
Player Medals Seasons Scott West 7 1995, 1997, 1998, 2000, 2003, 2004, 2005 Marcus Bontempelli ^6 2016, 2017, 2019, 2021, 2023, 2024 Gary Dempsey 6 1970, 1973, 1974, 1975, 1976, 1977 John Schultz 5 1960, 1962, 1964, 1965, 1966 Norman Ware 5 1934, 1937, 1938, 1940, 1941 Ted Whitten 5 1954, 1957, 1958, 1959, 1961 Matthew Boyd 3 2009, 2011, 2012 Ian Dunstan 3 1979, 1981, 1982 Harry Hickey 3 1939, 1945, 1948 Brad Johnson 3 1999, 2002, 2006 Ivan McAlpine 3 1927, 1930, 1932 Jack Collins 2 1951, 1952 Chris Grant 2 1994, 1996 Ryan Griffen 2 2010, 2013 Alby Morrison 2 1933, 1936 Arthur Olliver 2 1941, 1944 Joe Ryan 2 1946, 1947 Kelvin Templeton 2 1978, 1980 David Thorpe 2 1968, 1971 Terry Wallace 2 1988, 1989
General Specific ^ "Sutton remembered fondly at service" . 15 June 2012. Archived fromthe original on 30 December 2012.^a b "Western Bulldogs" .Australianrulesfootball.com.au . Retrieved26 August 2020 .^ "Charlie Sutton Footscray's Best" .The Age . National Library of Australia - Trove. 11 September 1950. Retrieved26 August 2020 .^ "Bontempelli wins third Sutton Medal" .Western Bulldogs Football Club Media . 3 October 2019. Retrieved26 August 2020 .^a b c d e f "History of the Brownlow: Bulldogs" .Western Bulldogs FC Media . 22 September 2017. Retrieved26 August 2020 .^ "Western Bulldogs Hall of Fame Inductees" .Western Bulldogs Football Club . Retrieved26 August 2020 .^ "Western Bulldogs History - Timeline - 1950s" . Retrieved26 August 2020 .^ "Western Bulldogs History - Timeline - 1960s" . Retrieved26 August 2020 .^a b c d Bastin, Paul (2 October 2019)."Superstar Dog joins illustrious company with third B&F crown" .AFL.com.au .Bigpond . Retrieved3 October 2019 . ^a b c "Charles Sutton Medal Winners" .DraftGuru . Retrieved26 August 2020 .^ Gigacz, Andrew (5 May 2020)."On this Day: Dougie dances his way to 60" .westernbulldogs.com.au . Retrieved26 August 2020 . ^ "Western Bulldogs History - Timeline - 1980s" . Retrieved26 August 2020 .^a b Browne, Ashley (29 May 2018)."Hall of Fame: Terry Wallace, the plough who never let up" .AFL.com.au . Retrieved26 August 2020 . ^ "Western Bulldogs History - Timeline - 1990s" . Retrieved26 August 2020 .^ "The AFL all-time great alphabet teams: Letter L" .The Roar . Microsoft News. 18 July 2020. Retrieved26 August 2020 .^ Zell, Alison (27 April 2016)."The Man in Charge" .GWS Giants Football Club Media . Retrieved26 August 2020 . ^ de Haer, Katie (13 November 2018)."Dogs' draft steals: Chris Grant" .Western Bulldogs Football Club Media . Retrieved26 August 2020 . ^a b c d "Best in the west" .AFL.com.au .Bigpond . 4 June 2013. Archived fromthe original on 10 June 2013. Retrieved23 September 2016 .^a b "Dogs games record-holder Brad Johnson inducted in to AFL Hall of Fame" .WesternBulldogs.com.au .Bigpond . 4 June 2014. Retrieved23 September 2016 .^a b "How the best was won" .The Age . Fairfax Media. 7 October 2002. Retrieved23 September 2016 .^ "AFL club champions 2003" .The Age .Fairfax Media . 5 October 2003. Retrieved23 September 2016 .^ "Daniher extends stay with Demons" .ABC Online . Australian Broadcasting Corporation. 3 October 2004. Retrieved23 September 2016 .^ "Cousins awarded Eagles' best and fairest" .ABC Online . Australian Broadcasting Corporation. 1 October 2005. Retrieved23 September 2016 .^ Duxson, Nick (5 October 2015)."Lake's legacy: is Brian the best bargain?" .HawthornFC.com.au .Bigpond . Retrieved23 September 2016 . ^ "Cooney overlooked for Bulldogs' award" .ABC Online . Australian Broadcasting Corporation. 1 October 2008. Retrieved23 September 2016 .^ "Western Bulldogs midfielder Matthew Boyd wins Charles Sutton Medal" .Fox Sports (Australia) .News Corp Australia . 3 October 2009. Retrieved23 September 2016 .^ Windley, Matt (2 October 2010)."Ryan Griffen wins Western Bulldogs best and fairest" .Herald Sun .News Corp Australia . Retrieved23 September 2016 . ^ Phelan, Jennefer (7 October 2011)."Boyd claims Sutton Medal" .AFL.com.au .Bigpond . Retrieved23 September 2016 . ^ Landsberger, Sam (8 October 2012)."Western Bulldogs captain Matthew Boyd is the top Dog again after claiming a third Sutton Medal" .Herald Sun .News Corp Australia . Retrieved23 September 2016 . ^ Windley, Matt (4 September 2013)."Western Bulldogs superstar Ryan Griffen wins his second Charles Sutton Medal" .Herald Sun .News Corp Australia . Retrieved23 September 2016 . ^ Edwards, Nat (3 September 2014)."Young midfielder takes out Western Bulldogs' best and fairest award" .AFL.com.au .Bigpond . Retrieved23 September 2016 . ^ Nicholson, Larissa (7 October 2015)."Easton Wood wins Western Bulldogs best and fairest" .The Age .Fairfax Media . Retrieved23 September 2016 . ^ Davidson, Ryan (5 October 2016)."Bontempelli adds another medal to his cabinet with best and fairest award" .AFL.com.au .Bigpond . Retrieved5 October 2016 . ^ Davidson, Ryan (4 October 2017)."Back-to-back Bont: Dog sets new club record" .AFL.com.au .Bigpond . Retrieved4 October 2017 . ^ Davidson, Ryan (3 October 2018)."Bulldog wins first B&F by a single vote" .AFL.com.au .Telstra . Retrieved5 October 2018 . ^ "King Caleb: Daniel crowned top Dog" .Western Bulldogs Media . 6 October 2020. Retrieved6 October 2020 .^ "Bontempelli claims sixth Charles Sutton Medal" .Western Bulldogs Media . 2 October 2024.^ "Richards claims maiden Charles Sutton Medal" .Western Bulldogs . Melbourne. 1 October 2025. Retrieved2 October 2025 .
VFL/AFL home grounds AFLW home grounds VFL/AFL premierships (2) Runner-up (2) AFLW premierships (1) Seasons (club articles inbold ) AFLW seasons Related articles Known as the Footscray Football Club from 1925–1996
Current awards Former awards