Movatterモバイル変換


[0]ホーム

URL:


Jump to content
WikipediaThe Free Encyclopedia
Search

Change and continuity

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Dichotomy
For the academic journal, seeContinuity and Change.
Historians have questioned whether the New Deal in the US is best seen as a decisive change or more as being a case of societal continuity in the context ofAmerican history. The picture shows two children pumping water by hand. This was the sole water supply in this section ofWilder, Tennessee in 1942)
icon
This articlemay need to be rewritten to comply with Wikipedia'squality standards.You can help. Thetalk page may contain suggestions.(February 2021)

Change and continuity is a classicdichotomy within the fields ofhistory,historical sociology, and thesocial sciences more broadly. The question of change and continuity is considered a classic discussion in the study of historical developments.[1] The dichotomy is used to discuss and evaluate the extent to which a historical development or event represents a decisive historical change or whether a situation remains largely unchanged. A good example of this discussion is the question of how much thePeace of Westphalia in 1648 represents an important change inEuropean history. In a similar vein, historianRichard Kirkendall once questioned whetherFDR'sNew Deal represented "a radical innovation or a continuation of earlier themes in American life?" and posed the question of whether "historical interpretations of the New Deal [should] stress change or emphasize continuity?"[2] The issue here is if the New Deal marks something radically new (change) in US history or if the New Deal can be understood as a continuation (continuity) of tendencies in American history that were in place well before the 1930.

The dichotomy is important in relation to constructing, discussing, and evaluating historicalperiodizations. In terms of creating and discussing periodization (e.g.the Enlightenment orthe Victorian Era,) the dichotomy can be used to assess when a period can be said to start and end, thus making the dichotomy important in relation to understanding historicalchronology. Economic historianAlexander Gerschenkron has taken issue with the dichotomy, arguing that continuity "appears to mean no more than absence of change, i.e. stability."[3] German historianReinhart Koselleck, however, has been said to challenge this dichotomy.[4]

Notes

[edit]
  1. ^Jørn Henrik Petersen og Klaus Petersen. "Præsentation: Dansk velfærdshistorie."Historisk Tidsskrift (Denmark), bind 110, hæfte 1, s. 217.
  2. ^Richard Kirkendall. "The New Deal As Watershed: The Recent Literature."The Journal of American History Vol. 54, No. 4 (1968), pp. 839.
  3. ^Alexander Gerschenkron. "On the Concept of Continuity in History."Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society Vol. 106, No. 3 (Jun. 29, 1962), pp. 195–209.
  4. ^Reinhardt Koselleck (2006) "Conceptual History, Memory, and Identity: An Interview with Reinhart Koselleck." Interview by Javiér Fernández Sebastián and Juan Francisco FuentesContributions to the History of Concepts Vol. 2, pp. 110–12.
Primary
Interdisciplinary
List
Other categorizations
Types
Sources
By scale
By source
By topic
Approaches,
schools
Concepts
General
Specific
Periodization of
modern history
By country or region
Africa
Americas
Latin America
United States
Eurasia
Ancient Rome
China
France
Germany
India
Ireland
Italy
Poland
Russia
Spain
Turkey
United
Kingdom
British
Empire
Oceania
By war, conflict
Pre-18th century
conflicts
18th and 19th
century conflicts
Coalition Wars
(1792–1815)
World War I
Treaty of
Versailles
Interwar period
World War II
Eastern Front
The Holocaust
Pacific War
Western Front
Cold War
Post-Cold War
Related
By person
Political
leaders
Historical
rankings
Others
Other topics
Economics
Religion
Science /
Technology
Organizations, publications
Related
Disciplines
Interdisciplinary fields
Themes
Journals
Academia
Related


Stub icon

Thissocial science-related article is astub. You can help Wikipedia byexpanding it.

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Change_and_continuity&oldid=1302867333"
Categories:
Hidden categories:

[8]ページ先頭

©2009-2025 Movatter.jp