Censorship onMTV has been the subject of debate for years. MTV was the first and most popularmusic television network in the U.S., and has come under criticism for alleged censorship in their programming. Throughout the decades, MTV has altered or removed shows from the channel's schedule to address complaints; and music videos have been censored, moved to late-night rotation, or banned from the channel's rotation for various types of controversial content.
The hit showJackass was subject to frequent censorship in the early 2000s. The popularity of the show, combined with the propensity of young viewers to attempt to imitate the show's risky stunts, led to substantialcontroversy. Although the show featured prominent warning messages at its start, end, and upon return from all commercial breaks urging viewers not to re-create any stunts seen on the program, nor submit footage to the network of those stunts for casting consideration on that or other MTV series, the show was nonetheless blamed for many injuries. In 2001, then-SenatorJoe Lieberman urged Viacom to take more responsibility for the program's content;[1] which led MTV to only air the show after 10 p.m. The creators ofJackass expressed frustration over the restraints that MTV's producers imposed on stunts after Lieberman's statement. These limitations eventually led to the departure of several cast members, and to the conclusion of the show.[2]
MTV's influence also affected its famous animated program,Beavis and Butt-Head. In the wake of a controversy that followed a child burning down his house after allegedly watching the show, producers moved the show from its original 7 p.m. time slot to a late-night, 11 p.m. slot. Beavis' tendency to flick a lighter and chant the word "fire" was removed from new episodes, and controversial scenes were removed from existing episodes before rebroadcast.[3] Some of the edits were so extensive that when series creatorMike Judge compiled hisCollection DVDs he commented that "some of those episodes may not even exist actually in their original form".[4]
TheParents Television and Media Council has argued that much of the censored material on MTV is easily discernible because of the context in which it is presented.[5][6]
InMichael Jackson's single "They Don't Care About Us", MTV has replaced the words "Jew me" and "kike me" with "do me" and "strike me" in the line "Jew me, sue me, everybody do me / Kick me,kike me, don't you black or white me."[13][14] Jackson later explained that the song used the words to describe prejudice and that it was poor judgment to select Jewish people as explanatory words.[15]
"This Love" byMaroon 5 had the words "coming" and "sinking" muted out due to possible sexual connotations.[16]
"Pumped Up Kicks" byFoster the People was edited to remove references to the song's subject daring people to "outrun my gun" and to run "faster than my bullet".[17]
"Baby Got Back" bySir Mix-a-Lot was aired only after 9 p.m., due to its depictions of women's bodies. (The station had recently instated a policy against showing female body parts with no reference to a face.)[18][19]
"Closer" by American industrial rock bandNine Inch Nails was heavily censored when aired on MTV due to sexually explicit imagery that contained a nude bald woman wearing a crucifix mask, NIN frontmanTrent Reznor in bondage, and an image of a vulva, along with the song's notorious lyric "I wanna fuck you like an animal." The objectionable content was replaced with a picture that said "scene missing".
In February 2004, following thecontroversial Super Bowl XXXVIII halftime show in which performerJustin Timberlake exposed the breast of co-performerJanet Jackson, MTV made several efforts to limit daytime rotation of music videos that could be perceived to have too much sexual content. Such videos included:
"Smack My Bitch Up" byThe Prodigy was initially given late-night rotation on MTV's120 Minutes on December 7, 1997 due to a fistfight, sexual scenes and allegedlymisogynistic language in the lyrics[21] but was removed from rotation altogether after around two weeks, a decision supported by the feminist groupNational Organization for Women.[22][23] During the brief time it aired, MTV opted to air the video uncensored with an advisory fromMTV News'Kurt Loder, while120 Minutes showed interview footage of artists likeMoby andChumbawumba objecting to the content of the video. In 2002, MTV'sMost Controversial Videos countdown ranked the video as #1;MTV2's version of the countdown showed the video fully uncensored.[24]
Also in 2004, alleged glorification of gun violence led MTV to play an edited version of the video "99 Problems" byJay-Z between 6 p.m. and 6 a.m. only.[28]
"Turn Me On" byRiton andOliver Heldens featuringVula – all shots where some doctors try to cut out a man's heart, along with the close-up of the man were replaced by completely different scenes due to violence.
This edit was made on MTV's sister channelMTV Hits.
Several videos have been perceived as too controversial to play on MTV even in censored form, for varying reasons. In the 1980s, parent-media watchdog groups such as thePMRC criticized MTV over certain music videos that were claimed to have explicit imagery ofSatanism. MTV has developed a strict policy refusing to air videos that may depict devil worship or anti-religious bigotry.[18]
"American Life" (Madonna) – pulled by the artist and replaced with a second version due to it having anti-Iraq War themes.[29]
"Arise" (Sepultura) – banned for apocalyptic religious imagery, including crucified figures wearing gas masks[30]
"Bombs" (Faithless) – banned over use of violent imagery to convey an anti-war message[33]
"California" (Wax) – banned due to its depiction of a stunt involving a man on fire
"Closer" (Nine Inch Nails) – banned for depiction of nudity, S&M bondage, a live monkey being strapped to a crucifix, and sexually charged lyrics. An edited version was also made to censor some of the explicit content.
"Erotica" (Madonna) – banned from the MTV music channel, but later seen in theBeavis and Butt-Head episode "Door to Door"[34]
"Ghost Ride It" (Mistah F.A.B.) – banned due to allegations of encouraging dangerous driving behavior; as well as copyright complaints about the car used in the video[35]
"Happiness in Slavery" (Nine Inch Nails) – banned for nudity, simulated gore, and unsimulated sexual torture by performance artistBob Flanagan
"Jesus Christ Pose" (Soundgarden) – banned for depicting a blindfolded girl and a mechanical skeleton on a cross, followed by several crosses that flashed repeatedly from upright to inverted positions[38]
"Justify My Love" (Madonna) – banned for containing explicit imagery of sadomasochism, voyeurism, and bisexuality[39]
"Lacquer Head" (Primus) – banned for lyrics describing minors using drugs; the music video also featured a child watching TV while a devilish creature administers gasoline to the child, who then explodes into a frenzy (with the creature riding on him) and ultimately crashing into a wall, burning to ashes[40]
"Pagan Poetry" (Björk) – banned due to highly distorted images of sexually explicit scenes involving fellatio and ejaculation. It eventually aired on MTV2's countdown of the '20 Most Controversial Music Videos.'[41]
"Prison Sex" (Tool) – was played initially, but later pulled from the air due to disturbing content and depiction of molestation[42]
"Pumps and a Bump" (MC Hammer) – banned due to Hammer wearing a zebra-print speedo with a visible bulge.[43] An alternate video was filmed to replace it with Hammer fully clothed.[44]
"Quote Unquote" (Mr. Bungle) – banned due to creepy imagery and several characters being hanged.
"Reckoning Day" (Megadeth) – allegedly banned due to management conflicts[45]
"s(AINT)" (Marilyn Manson) – banned for explicit depictions of sex, drug use, and self-inflicted violence.
"Six, Six, Six" (DeGarmo and Key) – pulled due to images of an Anti-Christ engulfed in flames; later re-added to rotation in an edited form[46][47]
"My Favourite Game" byThe Cardigans – filmed with five different endings; most of which were banned on MTV UK due to fears that the video could encourage joyriding and cause car accidents.[52] The two least-violent endings were eventually selected for MTV UK rotation.
^Liu, Marian (2007-05-14)."Mistah F.A.B. walks the walk".San Jose Mercury News. Retrieved2007-05-26.MTV asked for edit after edit on the video, and eventually banned it. Columbia Pictures, which owns the "Ghostbusters" franchise, demanded the video be pulled because it still owned the rights to the likeness of the "Ghostbusters" car and logo, which were altered but used in the video.
^abChonin, Neva (2001-03-23)."Madonna's No 'Pussy Cat': MTV bans her latest video, again".San Francisco Chronicle. Archived fromthe original on January 26, 2004. Retrieved2007-05-26."What It Feels Like For a Girl" was rejected for heavy rotation by MTV and its affiliate VH1. Too violent, they say. This, from a corporation that makes a mint off marketing gangsta culture to the suburban masses.
