Burnt by the Sun (Russian:Утомлённые солнцем,translit.Utomlyonnye solntsem, literally "wearied by the sun") is a 1994 Russian drama film starring, directed, written, and produced byNikita Mikhalkov and co-written by Azerbaijani screenwriterRustam Ibragimbekov. The film depicts the story of a seniorRed Army officer, played by Mikhalkov, and his family during theGreat Purge of the late 1930s in theStalinistSoviet Union. While on vacation with his wife, young daughter, and assorted friends and family, things change dramatically for KomDiv Kotov when his wife's old lover, Dmitri, shows up after being away for many years. The film also starsOleg Menshikov,Ingeborga Dapkūnaitė and Mikhalkov's daughterNadezhda Mikhalkova.
The entirety of the film takes place within the course of one day in the summer of 1936 in theSoviet Union. Mitya (Dmitri), an ex-nobleman and veteran of theanti-communistWhite Army, contemplates suicide. The film cuts toKomdiv Sergei Petrovich Kotov, his wife Maroussia, and their young six-year-old daughter Nadia relaxing in abanya when a peasant from the localcollective farm frantically tells them theRed Army's tanks are about to crush thewheat harvest as part of generalmaneuvers. After hearing this news, Kotov rides out to order the tank officer to halt. Kotov carries authority as a seniorOld Bolshevik and legendary hero of the 1917Russian Civil War, and he is also very popular with the common people and local villagers. The opening scene makes it clear that Kotov is a devoted family man, and he claims to be a personal friend ofStalin.
Following this incident, the happy family returns to their countrydacha (country estate), where they join Maroussia's relatives, a large and eccentric family ofChekhovian aristocrats. Mitya (Dmitri), who had been Maroussia's fiancé before disappearing in 1927, arrives in a costume to disguise himself, but when he takes it off he is joyfully embraced by the family and introduced to Nadia as "Uncle Mitya". Maroussia is left feeling deeply conflicted, as she had suffered deeply when Mitya left without explanation and even contemplated suicide, as shown by the self-inflicted marks on her wrists.[citation needed]
Despite his personable nature, it is clear that Mitya has returned with a secret agenda. It is slowly revealed throughout the duration of the afternoon that he works for the Soviet political police, theNKVD, and has arrived to arrest Kotov for a non-existent conspiracy that Mitya had framed him for. Mitya is abusing his power for the purpose of revenge, since ten years ago Kotov had conscripted Mitya into theOGPU, the predecessor of the NKVD, and was therefore the reason for Mitya being taken away. Mitya detests Kotov, whom he blames for causing him to lose Maroussia, his love for Russia, faith, and his profession as apianist. Kotov confronts Mitya about his activities inParis, where he gave up eight White Army generals to the NKVD. All were kidnapped, smuggled to the Soviet Union, and shot dead without trial.
Although eventually realizing that Mitya intends to take him away, Kotov believes that his close relationship with Soviet dictatorJoseph Stalin will save him. However, a black car carrying NKVD agents arrives to remove Kotov, just as a group ofYoung Pioneer children arrives at the dacha to pay tribute to him. Kotov willingly goes with Mitya, pretending to be Mitya's friend and even lets Nadia briefly ride in the car with them. While riding away in the car with his captors, Kotov reminds them who he is and his status, but he quickly realizes that they don't care and that it was Stalin himself who ordered his arrest. Only after looking into Mitya's eyes does Kotov realize the severity of the situation, causing him to breakdown in tears. Kotov is forced to make a false confession to all the charges Mitya framed him for and is shot dead in August 1936. Meanwhile, following Mitya's success in his revenge against Kotov, he ultimately commits suicide, as his revenge did not satisfy him in the way he thought it would. In addition, Maroussia is arrested and dies in theGulag in 1940. Although arrested with her mother and taken to a concentration camp, Nadia lives to see all three sentences overturned during theKhrushchev thaw, in 1956, and works as a music teacher inKazakhstan.
TheRussian Civil War of 1917 was a multi-party civil war in theRussian Empire that followed the two Russian revolutions of 1917. It lasted until 1922 and transformed the lives of many Russians. TheRed Army was led byVladimir Lenin, but after he died in 1924, Stalin was able to establish his position as the ruler of the Soviet regime. Throughout the 1930s, Stalin launched a campaign of political terror that is now known as theGreat Purge. During this time people were regularly rounded up and killed as traitors without a trial.[4] The purges, arrests, and deportations to labor camps affected many people. Loyal party, industry, and military leaders would randomly disappear. People were unable to trust one another as anyone could have been working for theNKVD, a Soviet secret police agency that was a forerunner of theKGB.[5]
ScreenwriterRustam Ibragimbekov said the film represented a statement on totalitarianism, and the sun in the film representsJoseph Stalin.
Nikita Mikhalkov stated in making the film, his belief was that "Bolshevism did not bring happiness to our country". However, he doubted whether "entire generations" could be judged for actions caused by wider social problems.[6] Mikhalkov also took inspiration from his young daughterNadezhda Mikhalkova,[7] and memories of his home.[8] Azerbaijani screenwriterRustam Ibragimbekov created the storyline with Mikhalkov and collaborated with him on the dialogue.[9]
The title derives from a popular 1930s song composed byJerzy Petersburski. Originally the Polishtango, "To ostatnia niedziela" ("This is the last Sunday"), it became popular in the Soviet Union with new Russian lyrics and the title, "Утомлённое солнце" (Utomlyonnoye solntse, "Wearied Sun"). The song is heardrepeatedly in the film; the director Mikhalkov said in 2007 that he learned of the song from his elder brotherAndrei Konchalovsky's1979 filmSiberiade. He compared his use of the music to his having stolen money as a boy from his brother.[10] According to Ibragimbekov, the "sun" depicted in the film is intended to symbolize Stalin, and emphasized a point of the film is that totalitarian regimes "take on a life of their own, destroying not only those whom they were originally intended to destroy but their creators as well".[9]
The film was shot inMoscow whileNikolina Gora was used for the village, and the scenes set inside the dacha were filmed inNizhny Novgorod.[1] It had a budget of $3.6 million, with major sponsorship fromGoskino.[11] The cinematography on the project was done byVilen Kalyuta, a Ukrainian cinematographer. For the part of Kotov's daughter Nadia, Mikhalkov cast his daughter Nadezhda, who hoped her compensation would be a bicycle.[9] Mikhalkov opted to play Kotov himself because he believed it would make his daughter comfortable,[12] explaining "certain scenes [were] especially delicate on an emotional level".[7]
The scenes were filmed between July and November 1993.[1] Mikhalkov decided on a fast shooting schedule out of consideration for Nadezhda, who was six at the time. He remarked that "Children grow quickly and lose the tenderness, the simplicity, and the charm their youth carries".[7]
Throughout the film, a fireball appears and sets off fires wherever it goes. This fireball is a burning sun that represents Stalin's purges that come out of nowhere and destroy the most undeserving.[13] Kotov is under the impression that he can see clearly and can avoid the excesses of the Soviet's harmful rays. He enjoys the warmth of his family and his status as a war hero but he eventually realizes that he too has been blinded by this to his peril and cannot avoid death; Mitya is the burning sun that strikes Kotov.[13] Kotov draws the viewer's sympathy and is portrayed in a positive light.[14]
The film premiered at theCannes Film Festival in May 1994. Although it won theCannes Grand Prix, Mikhalkov was said to be bitterly disappointed with not securing thePalme d'Or, with Russian press declaring "defeat".[15] For marketing within Russia, Mikhalkov personally toured local places and encouraged politicians and businesses to screen his film.[16] It opened in Moscow on 2 November 1994.[17]
It later had a video release in Russia, where it topped sales for 48 consecutive weeks, demonstrating great popularity.[6] The film was aired on Russian television on the evening before the1996 Russian presidential election, in a possible attempt to discreditGennady Zyuganov'sCommunist Party.[18]
In its native Russia, initial reviews were "largely neutral".[15] Common criticisms in Russia were that the film was "too commercial", and lacked seriousness.[11] Marc Savlov ofAustin Chronicle wrote "A brilliant, Chekhovian meditation on trust, love, and the intrusive horrors that period of time brought to otherwise normal families".[19]Roger Ebert gave the film two stars, judging it to be derivative of "many pre-1991 Eastern bloc epics".[20] Caryn James described the film inThe New York Times as "exquisite, lyrical and tough-minded".[21]Kenneth Turan of theLos Angeles Times wrote "WhatBurnt by the Sun does best is elegantly intertwine the personal and political themes of love, trust and betrayal".[22]David Denby, writing forNew York magazine, said that while he initially found the film had "too much sunshine", concluded "Burnt by the Sun is an extremely powerful work".[23]Desson Howe ofThe Washington Post called the film "old-fashioned, auteurist filmmaking" with "mostly pluses", adding "The Mikhalkovs work together likeAstaire andRogers".[24]Entertainment Weekly's Owen Glieberman gave the film a B+, writing "Burnt by the Sun builds slowly, reaching a climax of quiet devastation", and said the rowboat scene is "so tender I don't think I'll ever forget it".[25]
TheTime Out review states Mikhalkov's "performance is impeccable, and the scenes with his daughter Nadia achieve a rare poignancy".[26] In his2015 Movie Guide,Leonard Maltin gave the film three stars and called it a "Provocative, moving meditation" on Stalinism.[27] The film has an 81% approval rating onRotten Tomatoes, based on 16 reviews, and average rating 7.1/10.[28]
The film received theGrand Prix at the1994 Cannes Film Festival,[29] and theAcademy Award for Best Foreign Language Film.[30] The Academy Award was voted on by attendees of the academy preview screening, sinceBurnt by the Sun was not in theatres in the U.S. at the time, and only attendees had seen all five nominated films.Roger Ebert criticized the award as the result of "the Academy's flawed rules", alleging "A publicist merely has to be sure to invite everyone friendly to the film, while leaving it up to others to find their own way".[20] Both Nikita and Nadezhda Mikhalkov went on stage to accept the Academy Award.[12]
Beumers, Birgit (2000).Burnt By the Sun: The Film Companion. London and New York: I.B.Tauris.ISBN1860643965.
Beumers, Birgit (2005).Nikita Mikhalkov: The Filmmaker's Companion 1. London and New York: I.B.Tauris.
Clark, Katerina, "[Review of] filmsBurnt by the Sun", byNikita Mikhalkov, Michael Seidou, andRustam Ibragimbekov; and ofThe Interpretation of Dreams, by Semen Vinokur and Andrei Zagdansky; inThe American Historical Review, Vol. 100, No. 4 (October 1995), pp. 1223–1224
Faraday, George (2010).Revolt of the Filmmakers: The Struggle for Artistic Autonomy and the Fall of the Soviet Film Industry. University Park, Pennsylvania: Penn State Press.ISBN978-0271042466.
Lawton, Anna M. (2004). "History in the Making and on Screen".Imaging Russia 2000: Film and Facts. Washington, D.C.: New Academia Publishing.ISBN0974493430.
Lovell, Stephen (2003).Summerfolk: A History of the Dacha, 1710-2000. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press.
Menashe, Louis (2014). "On Stalin and Stalinism".Moscow Believes in Tears: Russians and Their Movies. Washington, D.C.: New Academia Publishing.ISBN978-0984583225.
Norris, Stephen M. (2012).Blockbuster History in the New Russia: Movies, Memory, and Patriotism. Indiana University Press.ISBN978-0253006790.