| 1947–1948 civil war in Mandatory Palestine | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Part of theintercommunal conflict in Mandatory Palestine, the1948 Palestine War and thedecolonisation of Asia | ||||||||
 Palestinian fighters in front of a burningHaganah armoured supply truck near the city ofJerusalem (March 1948) | ||||||||
| ||||||||
| Belligerents | ||||||||
| Commanders and leaders | ||||||||
 David Ben-GurionYaakov DoriYigael YadinYigal AllonMenachem Begin |  Fawzi al-QawuqjiAbd al-Qadir al-Husayni † |  Gordon MacMillan | ||||||
| Strength | ||||||||
| 15,000(start)[1] 35,000(end) | Arabs: A few thousand British deserters: ~100–200 | 70,000 | ||||||
| Casualties and losses | ||||||||
| 9 April: 895 killed[2] | 9 April: 991 killed[2] | 9 April: 123 killed 300 wounded[3] | ||||||
The1947–1948 civil war in Mandatory Palestine was the first phase of the1948 Palestine war. It broke out after theGeneral Assembly of theUnited Nations adopted a resolution on 29 November 1947 recommending the adoption of thePartition Plan for Palestine.[4]
During the civil war,Palestine'sJewish andArab communities clashed (the latter supported by theArab Liberation Army) while the British, who had the obligation to maintain order,[5][6] organized their withdrawal and intervened only occasionally.
At the end of the civil war phase of the war, from April 1948 to mid-May,Zionist forces embarked on an offensive (Plan Dalet) that involved conquering cities and territories in Palestine allocated to a future Jewish state, as well as those allocated to thecorpus separatum of Jerusalem and a future Arab state according to the 1947 Partition plan for Palestine.[7] This offensive greatly accelerated the1948 Palestinian expulsion and flight, which waseffected by various violent means, includinga number of massacres such as the widely publicizedDeir Yassin massacre.[8][9]
When theBritish Mandate of Palestineended on 14 May 1948, and with theDeclaration of the Establishment of the State of Israel, the surrounding Arab states—Egypt,Transjordan,Iraq, andSyria—invaded what had just ceased to be Mandatory Palestine[10] and immediately attacked Israeli forces and several Jewish settlements.[11] The conflict thus escalated and became the1948 Arab–Israeli War.
Under the control of a British administration since 1920, Palestine found itself the object of a battle betweenPalestinian andZionist nationalists, groups that opposed both the British mandate and each other.
The Palestinian opposition culminated in the1936–1939 Arab revolt in Palestine, a deadly civil conflict that saw the deaths of nearly 5,000 Palestinian Arabs and 500 Jews and drove much of the Palestinian political leadership, includingAmin al-Husseini, leader of theArab Higher Committee, into exile. Britain also reduced Jewish immigration in response to the violence, as legislated by the1939 White Paper.
AfterWorld War II andThe Holocaust, theZionist movement gained attention and sympathy. In Mandatory Palestine,Zionist groups fought against the British administration. In the two and a half years from 1945 to June 1947, British law enforcement forces lost 103 dead and sustained 391 wounded by Jewish militants.[12] Palestinian Arab nationalists reorganized, but their organization remained inferior to the Zionists'.[citation needed]
On 15 August 1947, theHaganah blew up the house of a Palestinian family nearPetah Tikva, killing 12 occupants, including a woman and six children.[13] After November 1947, the dynamiting of houses formed a key component of most Haganah strikes.[14]
Diplomacy failed to reconcile the different points of view on Palestine's future. In early November, the Haganah began mobilizing for war, and issued an order that all men between 17 and 25 register.[15] On 18 February 1947, the British announced their withdrawal from the region and on 29 November, the General Assembly of the United Nations voted to recommend the adoption and implementation of thepartition plan with the support of the big global powers, though the Arab states opposed it.
In the aftermath of theadoption of Resolution 181(II) by theUnited Nations General Assembly recommending the adoption and implementation of the Plan of Partition,[16] the manifestations of joy of the Jewish community were counterbalanced by protests by Arabs throughout the country[17] and after 1 December, theArab Higher Committee enacted ageneral strike that lasted three days.[18]
A "wind of violence"[19] took hold of the country, foreboding civil war between the two communities.[20] Murders, reprisals, and counter-reprisals resulted in dozens killed on both sides in the process. The impasse persisted as British forces did not intervene to stop the violence.[21][22][23][24]
The first casualties after the adoption of Resolution 181(II) were passengers on a Jewish bus nearKfar Sirkin on 30 November, after an eight-man gang from Jaffaambushed the bus killing five and wounding others. Half an hour later they ambushed a second bus, southbound fromHadera, killing two more, and shots were fired at Jewish buses in Jerusalem and Haifa.[22][25] This was said to be a retaliation for theShubaki family assassination, the killing ten days earlier of five Palestinian Arabs byLehi nearHerzliya.[26][27][28]
Irgun andLehi (the latter also known as the Stern Gang) followed their strategy of placing bombs in crowded markets and bus stops.[29] On 30 December, in Haifa, members of theIrgun threw two bombs at a crowd of Arab workers who were queueing in front of a refinery, killing 6 and injuring 42. An angry crowdmassacred 39 Jewish people in revenge until British soldiers reestablished calm.[23][30] In reprisal, soldiers from thePalmach and theCarmeli brigade attacked the villages ofBalad ash-Sheikh and Hawassa. In what became known as theBalad al-Shaykh massacre, between 60 and 70 villagers were killed.[31][32][33]
On December 31, 1947, having recruited a few thousand volunteers,Abd al-Qadir al-Husayni organized the blockade of Jerusalem's 100,000 Jewish residents.[34] To counter this, theYishuv authorities tried to supply the city with convoys of up to 100 armoured vehicles, but the operation became increasingly impractical as casualties in the relief convoys surged. By March, Al-Husayni's tactic had paid off. Almost all the Haganah's armoured vehicles had been destroyed, the blockade was in full operation, and hundreds of Haganah members who had tried to bring supplies into the city were killed.[35] The situation for those who dwelt in the Jewish settlements in the highly isolatedNegev and North of Galilee was even more critical.
From January onward, operations became increasingly militarized. In all the mixed zones where both communities lived, particularlyJerusalem andHaifa, there were increasingly violent attacks,riots, reprisals and counter-reprisals. Isolated shootings evolved into all-outbattles. Attacks against traffic, for instance, turned into ambushes as one bloody attack led to another.
On 22 February 1948, supporters ofMohammad Amin al-Husayni, with the help of certain British deserters, organized three attacks against the Jewish community. Usingcar bombs aimed at the headquarters of the ZionistPalestine Post newspaper, theBen Yehuda St. market, and the backyard of the Jewish Agency's offices, they killed 22, 53, and 13 Jews respectively, a total of 88 fatalities. Hundreds of others were injured.[36][37]
In retaliation,Lehi put alandmine on the railroad track inRehovot on which a train fromCairo toHaifa was travelling, killing 28 British soldiers and injuring 35.[38] This was copied on 31 March, close toCaesarea Maritima, which led to the death of 40 people and injured 60, mostly Arab civilians.[39]
David Ben-Gurion reorganized the Haganah and made conscription obligatory. Every Jew in the country had to receive military training.[citation needed]
This situation caused theUnited States to withdraw its support for the partition plan and insteadpropose a trusteeship for Palestine in March 1948, thus encouraging theArab League to believe that the Palestinian Arabs, reinforced by the Arab Liberation Army, could quash the partition plan. The British, on the other hand, decided on 7 February 1948 to supportTransjordan's annexation of the Arab part of Palestine.[40]
While the Jewish population had received strict orders requiring it to hold its ground everywhere at all costs,[41] the Arab population was more affected by the general conditions of insecurity to which the country was exposed. Up to 100,000 Arabs, from the urban upper and middle classes in Haifa, Jaffa and Jerusalem, or Jewish-dominated areas, evacuated abroad or to Arab centres eastwards.[42]
As a consequence of funds raised byGolda Meir from sympathisers in the United States, andStalin's decision to support the Zionist cause, the Jewish representatives of Palestine were able to sign very important armament contracts in the East. Other Haganah agents recovered stockpiles from World War II, which helped improve the army's equipment and logistics. TheJewish Agency had set aside $28 million for foreign arms purchases alone. By comparison, theArab Higher Committee's total budget at this time amounted to $2,250,000, equivalent to theHaganah's annual budget in prewar times.[43]
SeveralArab Liberation Army regiments intervened in Palestine, each active in a variety of distinct sectors around the different coastal towns. They consolidated their presence inGalilee andSamaria.[44]Abd al-Qadir al-Husayni came from Egypt with several hundred men of theArmy of the Holy War.
German and Bosnian WWII veterans, including a handful of former intelligence,Wehrmacht, andWaffen SS officers, were among the volunteers fighting for the Palestinian cause.[45] Veterans of WWIIAxis militaries were represented in the ranks of the ALA forces commanded byFawzi al-Qawuqji (who had been awarded an officer's rank in the Wehrmacht during WWII)[46] and in the Mufti's forces, commanded by Abd al-Qadir (who had fought with the Germans against the British in Iraq) and Salama (who trained in Germany as a commando during WWII and took part in a failedparachute mission into Palestine).[47] In addition, roughly 100 to 200 British soldiers and police officers, many of whom had developed bitterness towards the Zionist movement and/or pity for the Palestinians over the course of the British counterinsurgency campaign against the Zionists, deserted to help the Palestinians. In contrast, only 17 deserters fought for the Yishuv.[48]
Benny Morris writes that the Yishuv was more successful in attracting and effectively deploying foreign military professionals than its Arab adversaries. He concludes that the ex-Nazis and Bosnian Muslims recruited by the Palestinians, Egyptians, and Syrians "proved of little significance" to the outcome of the conflict.[49]
In December 1947, the Jewish death toll was estimated at over 200, and, according toAlec Kirkbride, by 18 January 1948, 333 Jews and 345 Arabs had been killed while 643 Jews and 877 Arabs had been injured.[50] The overall death toll between December 1947 and January 1948 (including British personnel) was estimated at 1,000 people, with 2,000 injured.[51]
Ilan Pappé estimates that 400 Jews and 1,500 Arabs were killed by January 1948.[52] Morris says that by the end of March 1948, the Yishuv had suffered about a thousand dead.[53] According to Yoav Gelber, by the end of March, 2,000 were dead and 4,000 wounded.[2] These figures correspond to an average of more than 100 deaths and 200 casualties per week among a population of 2,000,000.[citation needed]
Violence kept intensifying with the intervention of military units. Although responsible for law and order up until the end of the mandate, the British did not try to take control of the situation, being more involved in the liquidation of the administration and the evacuation of their troops.[54][55] Furthermore, the authorities felt that they had lost enough men already in the conflict.
The British either could not or did not want to impede the intervention of foreign forces into Palestine.[56][57] According to a special report by the UN Special Commission on Palestine:[58]
This description corresponds to the entry of Arab Liberation Army troops between 10 January and the start of March:[44]
Fawzi al-Qawuqji, Field Commander of the Arab Liberation Army, arrived, according to his own account, on 4 March, with the rest of the logistics and around 100Bosniak volunteers in Jab'a, a small village on the route betweenNablus andJenin. He established a headquarters there and a training centre for Palestinian Arab volunteers.Alan Cunningham, the BritishHigh Commissioner in Palestine, thoroughly protested against the incursions and the fact that "no serious effort is being made to stop incursions." The only reaction came from Alec Kirkbride, who complained toErnest Bevin about Cunningham's "hostile tone and threats."[60] The British and the information service of Yishuv expected an offensive for 15 February, but it would not take place, seemingly because the Mufti troops were not ready.[61]
In March, an Iraqi regiment of the Arab Liberation Army came to reinforce the Palestinian Arab troops ofSalameh in the area aroundLydda andRamleh, while Al-Husayni started a headquarters in Bir Zeit, 10 km to the north of Ramallah.[62] At the same time, a number of North African troops, principallyLibyans, and hundreds of members of theMuslim Brotherhood entered Palestine. In March, an initial regiment arrived inGaza and certain militants among them reachedJaffa.
The Arab combatants' initial victories reinforced morale among them.[63] TheArab Higher Committee was confident and decided to prevent the set-up of the UN-backed partition plan. In an announcement made to the Secretary-General on 6 February, they declared:[64]
The Palestinian Arabs consider any attempt by Jewish people or by whatever power or group of power to establish a Jewish state in an Arab territory to be an act of aggression that will be resisted by force [...]
The prestige of the United Nations would be better served by abandoning this plan and by not imposing such an injustice [...]
The Palestinian Arabs make a grave declaration before the UN, before God and before history that they will never submit to any power that comes to Palestine to impose a partition. The only way to establish a partition is to get rid of them all: men, women, and children.
At the beginning of February 1948, the morale of the Jewish leaders was not high: "distress and despair arose clearly from the notes taken at the meetings of the Mapai party."[65] "The attacks against the Jewish settlements and main roads worsened the direction of the Jewish people, who underestimated the intensity of the Arab reaction."[66]
The situation of the 100,000 Jews situated inJerusalem was precarious, and supplies to the city, already slim in number, were likely to be stopped. Nonetheless, despite the setbacks suffered, the Jewish forces, in particularHaganah, remained superior in number and quality to those of the Arab forces.[40]
| Part ofa series on the |
| Nakba |
|---|
_(cropped).jpg) |
The high morale of the Arab fighters and politicians was not shared by the Palestinian Arab civilian population. The UN Palestine Commission reported 'Panic continues to increase, however, throughout the Arab middle classes, and there is a steady exodus of those who can afford to leave the country.[63] 'From December 1947 to January 1948, around 70,000 Arabs fled,[67] and, by the end of March, that number had grown to around 100,000.[42]
These people were part of the first wave of Palestinian refugees of the conflict. Mostly the middle and upper classes fled, including the majority of the families of local governors and representatives of theArab Higher Committee.[42] Non-Palestinian Arabs also fled in large numbers. Most of them did not abandon the hope of returning to Palestine once the hostilities had ended.[68]
Many decisions were made abroad that had an important influence over the outcome of the conflict.
Britain did not want a Palestinian state led by theMufti, and opted unofficially instead, on 7 February 1948, to support the annexation of the Arab part of Palestine byAbdullah I of Jordan.[40] At a meeting in London between the commander ofTransjordan'sArab Legion,Glubb Pasha, andSecretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs,Ernest Bevin, the two parties agreed that they would facilitate the entry of the Arab Legion into Palestine on 15 May and that the Arab part of Palestine be occupied by it.[40]
They held that the Arab Legion not enter the vicinity of Jerusalem or the Jewish state itself.[40] This option did not envisage a Palestinian Arab state. Although the ambitions of King Abdullah are known, it is not apparent to what extent the authorities of Yishuv, theArab Higher Committee or theArab League knew of this decision.[citation needed]
In mid-March, after the increasing disorder in Palestine and faced with the fear, later judged unfounded, of an Arab petrol embargo,[69] the US government announced the possible withdrawal of its support for the UN's partition plan and for dispatching an international force to guarantee its implementation. The US suggested that Palestine instead be put underUN supervision.[70][71] On 1 April, theUN Security Council voted on the US proposal to convoke a special assembly to reconsider the Palestinian problem; theSoviet Union abstained.[72]
This U-turn by the US caused concern and debate among Yishuv authorities. They thought that after the withdrawal of British troops, the Yishuv could not effectively resist the Arab forces without the support of the US. In this context, Elie Sasson, the director of the Arab section ofJewish Agency, and several other personalities, persuaded David Ben-Gurion andGolda Meyerson to advance a diplomatic initiative to the Arabs. The job of negotiation was delegated to Joshua Palmon, who was prohibited from limiting the Haganah's liberty of action but was authorized to declare that "the Jewish people were ready with a truce."[73]
In the context of the embargo imposed upon Palestinian belligerents—Jewish and Arab alike—and the dire lack of arms by the Yishuv in Palestine, Soviet rulerJoseph Stalin's decision to breach the embargo and support the Yishuv with arms exported fromCzechoslovakia played a role in the war that was differently appreciated.[74] However, Syria also bought arms from Czechoslovakia for theArab Liberation Army, but the shipment never arrived due to Haganah intervention.[75]
Possible motivations for Stalin's decision include his support of the UN Partition plan, and allowing Czechoslovakia to earn some foreign income after being forced to refuseMarshall Plan assistance.[76]
The extent of this support and the concrete role that it played is up for debate. Figures advanced by historians tend to vary. Yoav Gelber spoke of 'small deliveries from Czechoslovakia arriving by air [...] from April 1948 onwards'[77] whereas various historians have argued that there was an unbalanced level of support in favor ofYishuv, given that the Palestinian Arabs did not benefit from an equivalent level of Soviet support.[78] In any case, the embargo that was extended to all Arab states in May 1948 by the UN Security Council caused great problems to them.[79]
Arab leaders did what they could to avoid being directly involved[80] in support for the Palestinian cause.[81]
At theArab League summit of October 1947, inAley, the Iraqi general, Ismail Safwat, painted a realist picture of the situation. He underlined the better organization and greater financial support of the Jewish people in comparison to the Palestinians. He recommended the immediate deployment of the Arab armies at the Palestinian borders, the dispatching of weapons and ammunition to the Palestinians, and the contribution of a millionpounds of financial aid to them. His proposals were rejected, other than the suggestion to send financial support, which was not followed up on.
Nonetheless, a techno-military committee was established to coordinate assistance to the Palestinians. Based inCairo, it was directed by Sawfat, who was supported by Lebanese and Syrian officers and representatives of the Higher Arab Committee. A Transjordian delegate was also appointed, but he did not participate in meetings.
At the December 1947 Cairo summit, under pressure by public opinion, the Arab leaders decided to create a military command that united all the heads of all the major Arab states, headed by Safwat. They still ignored his calls for financial and military aid, preferring to defer any decision until the end of the Mandate,[82] but, nevertheless, decide to form theArab Liberation Army, which would go into action in the following weeks.[83]
On the night of 20–21 January 1948, around 700 armed Syrians entered Palestine via Transjordan.[84] In February 1948, Safwat reiterated his demands, but they fell on deaf ears: the Arab governments hoped that the Palestinians, aided by the Arab Liberation Army, could manage on their own until the International community renounced the partition plan.[82]
TheArab Liberation Army was, in theory, financed and equipped by theArab League. A budget of one million pounds sterling had been promised to them,[85] due to the insistence of Ismail Safwat. In reality, though, funding never arrived, and onlySyria truly supported the Arab volunteers in concrete terms. Syria bought fromCzechoslovakia a quantity of arms for theArab Liberation Army but the shipment never arrived due to Hagana force intervention.[75]
According to Lapierre & Collins, on the ground, logistics were completely neglected, and their leader, Fawzi al-Qawuqji, envisaged that his troops survive only on the expenses accorded to them by the Palestinian population.[86] However, Gelber says that the Arab League had arranged the supplies through special contractors.[87] They were equipped with different types of light weapons, light and medium-sized mortars, a number of 75 mm and 105 mm guns, and armoured vehicles but their stock of shells was small.[88][89]
The situation that theArmy of the Holy War and the Palestinian forces were in was worse. They could not rely on any form of foreign support and had to get by on the funds thatMohammad Amin al-Husayni could raise. The troops' armament was limited to what the fighters already had. To make things even worse, they had to be content with arms bought on theblack market or pillaged from British warehouses, and, as a result, did not really have enough arms to wage war.[90]
Until March, Haganah suffered also a lack of arms. The Jewish fighters benefitted from a number of clandestine factories that manufactured some light weapons,[91] ammunition and explosives. The one weapon of which there was no shortage was locally produced explosives.[92] However, they had far less than what was necessary to carry out a war: in November, only one out of every three Jewish combatants was armed, rising to two out of three within Palmach.[93]
Haganah sent agents to Europe and to the United States, in order to arm and equip this army.To finance all of this,Golda Meir managed, by the end of December, to collect $25 million through a fundraising campaign set about in the United States to capitalize on American sympathisers to the Zionist cause.[94] Out of the 129 million US dollars raised between October 1947 and March 1949 for the Zionist cause, more than $78 million, over 60%, were used to buy arms and munition.[95]
A leased transport plane was used for theOperation Balak first arms ferry flight fromCzechoslovakia on the end of March 1948. At the beginning of April 1948, a shipment of thousands of rifles and hundreds of machine guns arrived at Tel Aviv harbor. With this big shipment, Haganah could supply weapons to a concentrated effort, without taking over the arms of other Jewish territory and risking them being with no weapons.[96] Haganah went into the offensive, although still lacking heavy weapons.
After 'having gotten the Jews of Palestine and of elsewhere to do everything that they could, personally and financially, to helpYishuv,' Ben-Gurion's second greatest achievement was his having successfully transformed Haganah from being a clandestineparamilitary organization into a true army.[97] Ben-Gurion appointedIsrael Galili to the position of head of the High Command counsel of Haganah and divided Haganah into 6infantry brigades, numbered 1 to 6, allotting a precise theatre of operation to each one.[98]
Yaakov Dori was named Chief of Staff. Yigael Yadin assumed the responsibility on the ground as chief of Operations. Palmach, commanded byYigal Allon, was divided into 3 elite brigades, numbered 10–12, and constituted the mobile force of Haganah.[98] Ben-Gurion's attempts to retain personal control over the newly formedIDF lead later in July toThe Generals' Revolt.
On 19 November 1947, obligatoryconscription was instituted for all men and women aged between 17 and 25. By end of March 21,000 people had been conscripted.[99][100] On 30 March the call-up was extended to men and single women aged between 26 and 35. Five days later a General Mobilization order was issued for all men under 40.[101]
"From November 1947, the Haganah, (...) began to change from a territorial militia into a regular army. (...) Few of the units had been well trained by December. (...) By March–April, it fielded still under-equipped battalion and brigades. By April–May, the Haganah was conducting brigade size offensive."[102]
Apart from on the coastline, Jewishyishuvim, or settlements, were very dispersed. Communication between the coastal area (the main area of Jewish settlements) and the peripheral settlements was by road. These road were an easy target for attacks, as most of them passed through or near entirely Arab localities. The isolation of the 100,000 Jewish people inJerusalem and other Jewish settlements outside the coastal zone, such as kibbutzKfar Etzion, halfway on the strategic road between Jerusalem andHebron, the 27 settlements in the southern region ofNegev[103] and the settlements to the north ofGalilee, were a strategic weakness for the Yishuv.
The possibility of evacuating these difficult to defend zones was considered, but the policy ofHaganah was set by David Ben-Gurion. He stated that "what the Jewish people have has to be conserved. No Jewish person should abandon his or her house, farm,kibbutz or job without authorization. Every outpost, every colony, whether it is isolated or not, must be occupied as though it wereTel Aviv itself."[41] No Jewish settlement was evacuated until the invasion of May 1948. Only a dozen kibbutzim in Galilee, and those in Gush Etzion sent women and children into the safer interior zones.[104]
Ben-Gurion gave instructions that the settlements of Negev be reinforced in number of men and goods,[103] in particular the kibbutzim ofKfar Darom andYad Mordechai (both close toGaza),Revivim (south ofBeersheba), andKfar Etzion. Conscious of the danger that weighed upon Negev, the supreme command ofHaganah assigned a wholePalmach battalion there.[105]
Jerusalem and the great difficulty of accessing the city became even more critical to its Jewish population, who made up one sixth of the total Jewish population in Palestine. The long and difficult route from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, after leaving the Jewish zone atHulda, went through the foothills ofLatrun. The 28-kilometre route betweenBab al-Wad and Jerusalem took no less than three hours,[106] and the route passed near the Arab villages ofSaris,Qaluniya,Al-Qastal, andDeir Yassin.[107]
Abd al-Qadir al-Husayni arrived in Jerusalem with the intent to surround and besiege its Jewish community.[108] He moved toSurif, a village to the southwest of Jerusalem, with his supporters—around a hundred fighters who were trained inSyria before the war and who served as officers in his army,Jihad al-Muqadas, or Army of the Holy War. He was joined by a hundred or so young villagers and Arab veterans of theBritish Army.[109] His militia soon had several thousand men,[110] and it moved its training quarters toBir Zeit, a town nearRamallah.
Abd al-Qadir's zone of influence extended down to the area ofLydda,Ramleh, and the Judean Hills whereHasan Salama commanded 1,000 men.[111] Salama, like Abd al-Qadir, had been affiliated with Mufti Haj Amin al Husseini for years, and had also been a commander in the1936–1939 Arab revolt in Palestine, participated in theRashid Ali coup of 1941 and the subsequentAnglo-Iraqi War.[112] Salama had re-entered Palestine in 1944 inOperation Atlas, parachuting into the Jordan Valley as a member of a special German—Arab commando unit of the Waffen SS.[113] He coordinated with al-Husayni to execute a plan of disruption and harassment of road traffic in an attempt to isolate and blockade Western (Jewish) Jerusalem.[114][115]
On 10 December, the first organized attack occurred when ten members of a convoy betweenBethlehem andKfar Etzion were killed.[114]
On 14 January, Abd al-Qadir himself commanded and took part in an attack against Kfar Etzion, in which 1,000 Palestinian Arab combatants were involved. The attack was a failure, and 200 of al-Husayni's men died. Nonetheless, the attack did not come without losses of Jewish lives: a detachment of35 Palmach men who sought to reinforce the establishment were ambushed and killed.[116]
On 25 January, a Jewish convoy was attacked near the Arab village ofal-Qastal.[117] The attack went badly and several villages to the northeast ofJerusalem answered a call for assistance, although others did not, for fear of reprisals.[117] The campaign for control over the roads became increasingly militaristic in nature, and became a focal point of the Arab war effort.[117] After 22 March, supply convoys to Jerusalem stopped, due to a convoy of around thirty vehicles having been destroyed in thegorges of Bab-el-Wad.[118]
On 27 March, an importantsupply convoy fromKfar Etzion was taken in an ambush in south of Jerusalem. They were forced to surrender all of their arms, ammunition and vehicles to al-Husayni's forces. The Jews of Jerusalem requested the assistance of the United Kingdom after 24 hours of combat. According to a British report, the situation in Jerusalem, where a food rationing system was already in application, risked becoming desperate after 15 May.[119]
The situation in other areas of the country was as critical as the one of Jerusalem. The settlements of Negev were utterly isolated, due to the impossibility of using the Southern coastal road, which passed through zones densely populated by Arabs.[119] On 27 March, a convoy of supplies (the Yehiam convoy)[35] that was intended for the isolatedkibbutzim north-west of Galilee was attacked in the vicinity ofNahariya. In the ensuing battle, 42–47Haganah combatants and around a hundred fighters of theArab Liberation Army were killed, and all vehicles involved were destroyed.[118][119][120]
The second phase of the war, which began in April, marked a huge change in direction, as Haganah moved to the offensive.
In this stage, Arab forces were composed of around 10,000 men among which between 3,000 and 5,000 foreign volunteers serving in theArab Liberation Army.[121][122][123]Haganah andPalmach forces were steadily increasing. In March, they aligned around 15,000 men[124] and in May around 30,000 who were better equipped, trained and organized.[125][126][127]
The armed Palestinian groups were roundly defeated, Yishuv took control of some of the principal routes that linked the Jewish settlements, and as a consequence,Jerusalem was able to receive supplies again. Palestinian society collapsed. Many mixed cities were taken by the Haganah as well asJaffa. A massive exodus was triggered.
Plan Dalet was finalized on 10 March 1948, under the direction ofYigael Yadin. 75 pages long, it laid down the rules and the objects that were to be followed by Haganah during the second phase of the war. Its principal objective was to secure Yishuv's uninterrupted territorial connections, particularly in response to the war of the roads carried out by Al-Husayni and in preparation for the Arab states' declared intervention. Plan Dalet caused quite a controversy among historians. Some see it as a plan that was primarily defensive and military in nature and a preparation against invasion,[128] whereas others think that the plan was offensive in nature and aimed at conquering as much of Palestine as possible,[129] or enacted with the aim ofethnically cleansing Palestine.[130]
At the end of March 1948, Husayni's troops prevented supply convoys from reaching Jerusalem. The city was besieged and the Jewish population was forced to adhere to a rationing system. Ben-Gurion decided to launch the operation Nachshon to open up the city and provide supplies to Jerusalem.[131]Operation Nachshon marked theHaganah shift to the offensive, even before launchingplan D.[132]
The first orders were given on 2 April 1948 with diversion attacks including Qastel.[133] Between 5–20 April 1500 men from the Givati and Harel brigades took control of the road to Jerusalem[134] and allowed 3 or 4 convoys to reach the city.[135]
The operation was a military success. All the Arab villages that blocked the route were either taken or destroyed, and the Jewish forces were victorious in all their engagements. Nonetheless, not all the objectives of the operation were achieved, since only 1800 tonnes of the 3,000 envisaged were transported to the city, and two months of severe rationing had to be assumed.[136]
Abd al-Qadir al-Husayni was killed during the night of 7–8 April, in the midst of the battles taking place inAl-Qastal. The loss of this charismatic Palestinian leader 'disrupted the Arab strategy and organization in the area of Jerusalem.'[137] His successor,Emil Ghuri, changed tactics: instead of provoking a series of ambushes throughout the route, he had a huge road block erected at Bab al-Wad, and Jerusalem was once again isolated as a consequence.[138]
Operation Nachshon exposed the poor military organization of the Palestinian paramilitary groups. Due to lack of logistics, particularly food and ammunition, they were incapable of maintaining engagements that were more than a few hours away from their permanent bases.[139]
Faced with these events, theArab Higher Committee asked Alan Cunningham to allow the return of the Mufti, the only person capable of redressing the situation. Despite obtaining permission, the Mufti did not get to Jerusalem. His declining prestige cleared the way for the expansion of the influence of the Arab Liberation Army and ofFawzi Al-Qawuqji in the Jerusalem area.[139]
In April, Yishuv forces began to resort tobiological warfare in atop-secret operation called 'Cast Thy Bread', whose aim was to prevent the return of Palestinians to the villages Yishuv forces had conquered, and, as the practice reached beyond the key Tel-Aviv-Jerusalem lines, make conditions difficult for any Arab armies that might retake territory. This consisted in poisoning village wells. In the final months of the ensuing 1948 Arab-Israeli war, as Israel gained the upper hand, orders were apparently given to extend the use of biological agents against the Arab states themselves.[140]
Mishmar HaEmek is akibbutz that was founded byMapam in 1930, in theJezreel Valley, close to the road betweenHaifa andJenin that passes theMegiddo kibbutz. It is situated in a place thatHaganah officers considered to be on one of the most likely axes of penetration for a 'major Arab attack' against the Yishuv.[141][142]
On 4 April, the Arab Liberation Army launched an attack on the kibbutz with the support of artillery. The attack was fought off by the members of the kibbutz, who were supported by Haganah soldiers. The artillery fire that had almost totally destroyed the kibbutz was stopped by a British column, who arrived on the scene by order of General MacMillan, and, on 7 April,Fawzi Al-Qawuqji accepted a 24-hourceasefire, but required that the kibbutz be surrendered. The inhabitants of the kibbutz evacuated their children, and, after having consulted Tel Aviv, refused to surrender.[142][143]
On 8 or 9 April, Haganah prepared a counter-offensive.Yitzhak Sadeh was put in charge of operations, with the order to 'clean out' the region. The battle lasted until 15 April. Sadeh's men besieged all the villages around the kibbutz, and theArab Liberation Army had to retreat to its bases in Jabba. The majority of the inhabitants of the region fled, but those who did not were either imprisoned or expelled to Jenin. The villages were plundered by someKibbutznikim and razed to the ground with explosives with accordance to Plan Dalet.[144][145]
According toMorris, the Arab Liberation Army soldiers were demoralized by reports of theDeir Yassin massacre and the death ofAbd al-Qadir al-Husayni. Throughout battle, they had generally been forced to withdraw and to abandon the people of the villages.[146]Dominique Lapierre andLarry Collins report thatJoshua Palmon, head of a unit of 6 men, failed to seize invaluable pieces of artillery, and they depict the events as a débâcle for whichFawzi Al-Qawuqji offered extravagant excuses, declaring in particular that the Jewish forces has 120 tanks, six squadrons of fighter and bomber aircraft and that they were supported by a regiment of Russian volunteers.[147]
According to Morris, "according to Ben-Gurion, some 640 Haganah soldiers had faced about twenty-five hundred ALA troops, with superior firepower—and bested them".[148] When the battle finished,Palmach forces continued 'cleaning' operations until 19 April, destroying several villages and forcing those who inhabited them to flee. Some villages were also evacuated under the instruction of Arab authorities.[149]
In May,Irgun engaged in several operations in the region, razing a number of villages and killing some of their inhabitants, as did some detachments from the Golani and Alexandroni brigades.[150]
Deir Yassin is a village located 5 kilometres west of Jerusalem. On 9 April 1948, independently of operation Nachshon, around 120Irgun andLehi men attacked the village and ran into resistance, capturing it after a fierce battle with Palmach help. The Irgun and Lehi lost 4 dead and 35 wounded. Between 100 and 120 inhabitants of the village were killed in the attack, mostly civilians.[151] The Haganah had approved the attack and assisted in it.[151]
The operation led to indignation from the international community, the more so since the press of the time reported that the death toll was 254. Ben-Gurion roundly condemned it,[152] as did the principal Jewish authorities: theHaganah, the Great Rabbinate and theJewish Agency for Israel, who sent a letter of condemnation, apology and condolence to KingAbdullah I of Jordan.[153]
According toMorris, "the most important immediate effect of the atrocity and the media campaign that followed it was how one started to report the fear felt in Palestinian towns and villages, and, later, the panicked fleeing from them."[153] Another important repercussion was within the Arab population of neighbouring Arab states, which, once again, increased its pressure on the representatives of these states to intervene and come to the aid of the Palestinian Arabs.[153][154]
On 13 April, partly in revenge for the Deir Yassin massacre, aconvoy that was driving towards Jerusalem's Hadassah Hospital on Mount Scopus was attacked by hundreds of Arabs. In the seven-hour battle 79 Jews were killed including doctors and patients.[75] Thirteen British soldiers were present, but they stood by, only putting in a perfunctory attempt at intervention in the last moments of the massacre.[155]
Lieutenant-ColonelJack Churchill was present at the scene, and later testified that he had attempted to assist the Hadassah convoy by radioing for support, only for the request to be turned down.[156]
Following the 'fiasco'[157] of Mishmar HaEmek, Fawzi Al-Qawuqji ordered theDruze regiment of theArab Liberation Army into action, to carry out diversion operations. Druze soldiers took position in several Arab villages 12 kilometres to the east of Haifa,[158] whence they occasionally attacked traffic and Jewish settlements, includingRamat Yohanan.[150]
The Kibbutznikim and the Haganah soldiers that supported them forced back their attacks and razed the villages from which they launched their attacks. Having run out of ammunition, the Druze withdrew to their base inShefa-'Amr, with one hundred casualties.[159][160] After an initial failure, a battalion-sized Carmeli force on the night of 15–16 April overran the two villages. The Druze Battalion, on 16 April assaulted the Carmeli positions nine times but the Carmeli troops fought back. By afternoon, the exhausted Druze troops retreated. A Haganah report praised "the well trained and very brave enemy forces."[161]
The Druze had already made contact on several occasions with Yishuv agents and following their defeat at Ramat Yohanan, the Druze officers offered to defect and to join the ranks of Haganah. This proposition was discussed withYigael Yadin, who refused the proposal but suggested that they could help to carry out sabotage operations behind the backs of the Arabs and to influence their comrades into deserting the army. By the start of May, 212 Wahab soldiers deserted. Taking into account the attitude of his men, Wahab met with Jewish liaison officers on 9 May and agreed to cooperate with Haganah. The two parties avoided clashes, and Wahab created a neutral enclave in the centre ofGalilee. Wahab's army did not respond to calls for it to help fight Haganah's occupation ofAcre, and avoided being present while Haganah occupied the police fortress of Shefa-'Amr during its evacuation by the British.[159]
The position that the Druze took influenced their fate after the war. Given the good relationship between the Druze and Yishuv from 1930 onwards despite their collaboration with the Arab Higher Council and theArab League, Ben-Gurion insisted that the Druze, as well as theCircassians and theMaronites benefit from a different position to that of the other Arabs.[162]
In the context of Plan Dalet, mixed urban centres, or those on the borders of the Jewish state, were attacked and besieged by Jewish forces.Tiberias was attacked on 10 April and fell six days later;Haifa fell on 23 April, after only one day of combat (Operation Bi'ur Hametz), andJaffa was attacked on 27 April but fell only after the British abandoned it (Operation Hametz).Safed andBeisan (Operation Gideon) fell on 11 May and 13 May respectively, within the framework of Operation Yitfah, andAcre fell on 17 May, within the framework of Operation Ben-Ami.
The Arab inhabitants of these towns fled or were expelled en masse. In these 6 cities, only 13,000 of the total of 177,000 Arab inhabitants remained by the end of May. This phenomenon ricocheted also in the suburbs and the majority of the zone's Arab villages.
Despite the deteriorating situation for the Arabs, a representative of the Arab Higher Committee Representative stated to UN Security Council on April 16 that the Arabs would reject any ceasefire that does not undo the Partition plan.[citation needed]
TheGalilee Panhandle, a zone in northeasternGalilee, between theLake Tiberias andMetula, was the Jewish-controlled area that was the most distant and isolated from the area most densely populated by Jews, the coastal plain. The presence of the Lebanese border to the north, the Syrian border to east and the Arab presence in the rest of Galilee made it a probable target for intervention of the Arab armies.[163] Within the framework of the Dalet plan,Yigael Yadin entrustedYigal Allon, commander of thePalmach, with the responsibility of managing Operation Yiftah, whose objectives were to control all the aforementioned area and consolidate it ahead of the Arab attack that was planned for 15 May.[164]
Allon was in charge the 1st and 3rd Palmachbattalions, which had to face the populace ofSafed and several dozen Arab villages. The situation was made more problematic by the presence of the British, although they began their evacuation of the area. According to his analysis, it was essential that they empty the zone of any Arab presence to completely protect themselves; the exodus would also encumber the roads that the Arab forces would have to penetrate.[165]
On 20 April, Allon launched a campaign that mixed propaganda, attacks, seizing control of strongholds that the British had abandoned, and destroying conquered Arab villages. On 1 May, a counter-offensive was launched by Arab militiamen against Jewish settlements but was ultimately unsuccessful. On 11 May,Safed fell, and the operation finished on 24 May after the villages of the valley of Hula were burnt down. Syrian forces' planned offensive in the area failed and, by the end of June, Galilee panhandle from Tiberias to Metula, incorporating Safed, was emptied of all its Arab population.[166]
On 10 May,Golda Meir and Ezra Danin secretly went toAmman, to the palace of King Abdullah to discuss the situation with him. The situation that Abdullah found himself in was difficult. On one hand, his personal ambitions, the promises made by theYishuv in November 1947[citation needed] and the British approval of these promises pushed him to consider annexing the Arab part ofPalestine without intervening against the future state of Israel. On the other hand, the pressure exerted by his people in reaction to the massacre of Deir Yassin, combined with their feelings with regard to the Palestinian exodus and his agreements with other members of theArab League pushed him to be more strongly involved in the war against Israel.[167] He also found himself in a position of power, having the benefit of military support from not only the Arab League, but the British. In his diary, Ben-Gurion wrote about Golda Meir's reaction to the meeting:
We met [on 10 May] amicably. He was very worried and looks terrible. He did not deny that there had been talk and understanding between us about a desirable arrangement, namely that he would take the Arab part [of Palestine]. (...) But Abdullah had said that he could now, on 10 May, only offer the Jews "autonomy" within an enlarged Hashemite kingdom. He added that while he was not interested in invading the areas allocated for Jewish statehood, the situation was volatile. But he voiced the hope that Jordan and the Yishuv would conclude a peace agreement once the dust had settled.[168]
Historical analyses of the motivations and conclusions of this meeting differ. According to Dominique Lapierre and Larry Collins – as well as Israelihistoriographers[who?][169] – the intention behind the Yishuv's negotiation was to obtain a peace treaty and avoid an attack by Arab forces. At that time, the balance of power was not favourable for them, but Meir did not manage to convince the King.
According to Morris,[170] Abdullah 'reconsidered the promises that he made in November to not be opposed to the partition plan,' but left Meir with the impression that he would make peace with the Jewish state once the civil war had finished.
Avi Shlaim[40] spoke of a 'tacit' agreement to prevent the division of Palestine with the Palestinians, arguing the idea that there was a collusion between the Hashemite Kingdom and Yishuv. The historianYoav Gelber, however, rejected this idea and devoted an entire work to dismounting it.[171]
Pierre Razoux indicated that 'the majority of experts consider it probable'[better source needed] that Ben-Gurion and King Abdullah had an understanding over dividing Palestine, and that only the pressure from the Arab states on Abdullah constrained him from following up on his promise. According to Razoux, this idea explains the attitude of the British, who, following this plan, would thereby fulfill the promises made byArthur Balfour to the Yishuv and the Hashemite empire at the same time. He states that the presence of Arab Legion troops, before 15 May, near strategic positions held by the British is in this way easy to understand.[172]
Ilan Pappé[173] stressed that neither Abdullah's ministers, nor the Arab world itself, seemed to be privy to the discussions held between him and the Yishuv, even if his ambitions on Palestine were widely known. He also stated that SirAlec Kirkbride andGlubb Pasha thought at the time that, at the very least,Azzam Pasha, the Secretary of the Arab League, must have known about Abdullah's double game.
It is certain, on the other hand, that Golda Meir and King Abdullah did not come to an agreement on the status of Jerusalem. On 13 May, the Arab Legion tookKfar Etzion,[174] strategically located halfway along the road between Hebron and Jerusalem. On 17 May, Abdullah orderedGlubb Pasha, commander of the Arab Legion, to launch an attack against the Holy City.
Kfar Etzion is a group of four settlements established on the strategic route between Hebron and Jerusalem, right in the middle of Arab inhabited territory. It had 400 inhabitants at the end of 1947. After the adoption of Resolution 181(II), it was the object of Arab attacks. Ben-Gurion reinforced it on 7 December, protecting it with a Palmach division, but on 8 January, he authorized the evacuation of the women and children of the settlements.
After 26 March, the last date on which asupply convoy successfully reached it, despite heavy losses of life, the defenders were completely isolated.
On 12 May,Arab Legion units started to attack the settlements. The motivations advanced include their desire to protect one of their last supply convoys before the embargo took effect, which had to travel down the road by Kfar Etzion. Another theory is that the block of settlements obstructed the deployment of the Legion in the area around Hebron, whose attack was one of Abdullah's principal objectives.[175]
External defences fell quickly, and, on 13 May, the first kibbutz was captured. Those who were taken prisoner were massacred; only four survived.[176][177] Of the 131 defenders, 127, including 21 women, were killed, or massacred after they surrendered.[178] The other three establishments surrendered, and the kibbutzim were first plundered, then razed to the ground. In March 1949, 320 prisoners from the Etzion settlements were released from the "Jordan POW camp at Mafrak", including 85 women.[179]
The events that took place at Kfar Etzion made apparent the limitations of the policy prohibiting evacuation. Although it was effective during civil war, when facing militias, isolated Jewish settlements could not resist the firepower of a regular army, and an evacuation could have made it possible to avoid the captivity or death of those who defended the settlements.[176]
According to Yoav Gelber, the fall and massacre of Kfar Etzion influenced Ben-Gurion's decision to engage the Arab Legion on its way to Jerusalem, although the Haganah General Staff were divided about whether the Legion should be challenged inside Jerusalem itself as such a move could harm the Jews in the city. Ben-Gurion left the final decision to Shaltiel. The battle for Jerusalem was thus set in motion.[176]
Operation Yevusi lasted two weeks, from 22 April 1948 to 3 May 1948. Not all objectives were achieved before the British enforced a cease-fire. APalmach force occupied the strategically located San Simon monastery inKatamon. Arab irregulars attacked the monastery and a heavy battle evolved. Both sides had a lot of wounded and killed fighters. ThePalmach considered a retreat while the wounded fighters would blow themselves up, but then it was realized that the Arab force was exhausted and could not continue the fighting. As a result, the Arab residents left the suburb and the southern besieged Jewish suburbs were released.[180]
TheHaganah intended to capture the Old City during the final days of the Mandate.[181] Its attacks on the seam between East and West Jerusalem from 13 to 18 May (known as Operation Kilshon) were planned as the initial phase of this conquest.[181]
InJerusalem, the British held several strategically located security zones named "Bevingrads", at its centre. The city's radio station, telephone exchange and government hospital were located there, along with a number of barracks and the Notre Dame hostel, which dominated the city.[182] One of the main objectives of Operation Kilshon was to take control of these zones of strategic importance while the British withdrew. On 13 May the Haganah extended its control of the Old City's Jewish Quarter and on 14th (having obtained the precise schedule of the evacuation with British complicity) took control of the Bevingrads, including the central post office and the Russian Church compound at 04:00.[181][183] They surprised the Arab troops, who offered no resistance.[184]
A secondary objective of Operation Kilshon was to simultaneously create a continuous frontline between the various isolated Jewish localities. For this aim, Brigadier General David Shaltiel, Haganah's former envoy to Europe, was deployed along with a troop of 400 Haganah soldiers and 600 militia soldiers. Emil Ghuri, the new leader of the Army of the Holy War, also envisaged taking these districts and mobilized 600 soldiers for the mission, but prepared no specific operation.
The secondary aim was also successful. In the North of the city, Jewish forces seized Arab-populatedSheikh Jarrah, made a connection withMount Scopus, and took the villages surrounding the American colony.[181] In the South, they ensured the connection of the German and Greek colonies with Talpiot and Ramat Rahel, after having taken the Allenby barracks. A Palmach unit even re-established contact with the Jewish district in the Old City via theZion Gate.[185]
The irregular Arabic forces were rendered impotent and yielded to panic, calling the situation hopeless and announcing the imminent fall of the city.[186]
Within the framework ofPlan Dalet,Yigael Yadin intended to make a breakthrough in the west ofGalilee, wherein a number of isolated Jewish settlements were situated. This zone, which covers the land fromAcre all the way to theLebaneseborder, was allocated to the Arabs by the Partition plan, but was on the road through which Lebanese forces intended to enter into Palestine.[187]
The command of this operation was entrusted toMoshe Carmel, head of the Carmeli brigade. It consisted of two phases: the first began on the evening of 13 May, when a column of Haganah's armoured vehicles and lorries advanced along the coast with no resistance. The forces of the Arab Liberation Army fled without entering battle, and the first phase of the operation finished when Acre was taken on 18 May. In the second phase, from 19 to 21 May, troops went as far as the Yehi'am kibbutz by the Lebanese border, connecting it and conquering and destroying a number of Arab villages on the way.[188]
Haganah's move to offensive operations during the second phase of the war was accompanied by a huge exodus that involved 350,000 Arab refugees, adding to the 100,000 displaced during the First wave. The term 'Palestinian exodus' is often used to refer to both these and two subsequent waves. These two waves gained a considerable amount of press interest and were widely relayed in the press of the time, more so than most other Palestine-related events.[189]
The causes of and responsibility for this exodus are highly controversial topics among commentators on the conflict and even historians who specialize in this era. Among the various possible causes, Efraim Karsh attributes the exodus mainly to Arab authorities' instructions to escape,[190] whereas others argue that a policy of expulsion had been organized by theYishuv authorities and implemented by Haganah.[191] Others yet reject these two assumptions and see the exodus as the cumulative effect of all the civil war's consequences.[192]
During the last meeting of the Arab League in February 1948, the Arab leaders expressed their convictions in the capacity of theArab Liberation Army to help the Palestinians and to force the international community to give up on the UN-backed partition plan.[82] The following summit took place in Cairo on 10 April, with the situation having clearly developed with the death of Al-Husayni and the debacle at Mishmar Ha'emek.
Once again, Ismail Safwat called for the immediate deployment of the Arab state armies at the borders of Palestine, and for the need to go beyond the established policy of participating in little more than small-scale raids towards taking part in large-scale operations. For the first time, the Arab leaders discussed the possibility of intervening in Palestine.[193]
Syria andLebanon declared themselves ready to intervene immediately, but King Abdullah refused to let theArab Legion forces intervene immediately in favour of the Palestinians, a move which irritated theSecretary-General of the League, who declared that Abdallah only cedes to the British diktat.
Nonetheless, Abdullah declared himself ready to send the Legion to assist the Palestinian cause after 15 May. In response, Syria insisted that the Egyptian army also take part, and, in spite of the opposition of Egypt's prime minister,King Farouk responded favourably to the Syrian request, but due to his aim of curbing theJordanians' hegemonic goals rather than his desire to help the Palestinians.[193]
Later on, following the visit of several Palestinian dignitaries inAmman, and despite the opposition of Syria and the Mufti, Haj Amin al-Husseini, Azzam Pasha accepted Abdullah's proposition and sent Ismail Safwat toAmman to organize a coordination between theArab Liberation Army and Jordan's Arab Legion. It was decided that command over the operations would be reserved for King Abdullah, and that the Iraqis would deploy a brigade in Transjordan to prepare for intervention on 15 May.[194]
On 26 April, the 'intention to occupy Palestine' was officially announced at the Transjordanian parliament and the Jewish people were 'invited to place themselves beneath King Abdullah's jurisdiction.' The intention to spare their lives was also promised. Yishuv perceived this declaration as being one of war and encourages the Western world to pressure the King, through diplomatic means, to prevent his intervention.[195]
On 30 April, Jordanians, Egyptians and Iraqis disputed the command of Abdullah. Abdullah received the honorary title ofCommander-in-Chief, while the Iraqi general, Aldine Nur Mahmud, was named Chief of Staff. Despite this show of unity, it was agreed that each army would act independent of each other in the theatre of operations.[196]
On 4 May, the Iraqi task force arrived atMafraq. It was composed of a regiment of armoured tanks, a regiment of mechanized infantry, and twenty-four artillery weapons, and included 1500 men.[197] The Egyptians formed two brigades, deploying around 700 men into theSinai.[198] The Syrians could not put together a better force, whereas the Lebanese announced that they could not take part in military operations on 10 May.
It was only two days before, on 8 May, that the British Foreign Office was certain of the Arab invasion. Whereas British analysts considered that all Arab armies, except the Arab Legion, were not prepared for the engagements to come,[199] the Egyptian officers claimed that their advance would be 'a parade with the least risk,' and that their army 'would be in Tel Aviv after just two weeks.'
The state of preparation of the army was such that they did not even have maps of Palestine.[200] At the time, the final plans of invasion had not even been established yet. British leaders tried in vain to make the Arab leaders reconsider their decision,[201] and Ismail Safwat resigned in indifference, but the Arab states seemed resolute. On 15 May 1948, theArab League announced officially that it would intervene in Palestine to guarantee the security and right to self-determination of the inhabitants of Palestine in an independent state.
According toBenny Morris, the result of these five and a half months of fighting was a "decisive Jewish victory". On one side, the "Palestinian Arab military power was crushed" and most of the population in the combat zones was fleeing or had been driven out. On the other side, the "Haganah transformed from a militia into an army" and succeeded "in consolidating its hold on a continuous strip of territory embracing the Coastal Plain, the Jezreel Valley, and the Jordan Valley." The Yishuv proved it had the capability to defend itself, persuading the United States and the remainder of the world to support it and the "victory over the Palestinian Arabs gave the Haganah the experience and self-confidence [...] to confront [...] the invading armies of the Arab states."[202]
According toYoav Gelber, during the six weeks between the Haganah offensive on 1 April and the invasion of the Arab armies, the Arabs were defeated in almost every front. The Jewish forces captured four cities (Tiberias,Jaffa,Safed, andHaifa) and 190 villages; most of their residents fled. The refugees floodedSamaria, centralGalilee,Mount Hebron region,Gaza region, as well asTransjordan,Lebanon, and southernSyria. With the defeat of the Palestinian forces and the ALA, the Arab League saw no other option than to invade at the end of the British Mandate. The process of deciding to invade and preparing for the attack began two or three weeks before the end of the Mandate, when the level of the defeat was revealed and it was clear the ALA could not prevent it.[203]
Although the Haganah was somewhat poorly armed, its offensive of the last weeks went well, because Arab villages did not come to the help of their neighboring Arab villages or towns. Moreover, only a few young Arab men from untouched areas (e.g. Nablus, Hebron) participated in the fighting in Jerusalem, Haifa, etc.[204]Anwar Nusseibeh, a supporter of the Mufti, said the Mufti refused to issue arms to anyone except his political supporters and only recruited his supporters for the forces of theHoly War Army. This partially accounts for the absence of an organized Arab force and for the insufficient amount of arms, which plagued the Arab defenders of Jerusalem.[205]
On 14 May 1948, David Ben-Gurion, on behalf of the Jewish leadership,declared the establishment of theState of Israel.[206] The1948 Palestine war entered its second phase with the intervention of the Arab state armies and the beginning of the1948 Arab–Israeli War.
Traditionally, Zionist historiography has cited these attacks as the first acts of Palestinian violence against the partition resolution. But it is probable that the attacks were not directly linked to the resolution – and were a product either of a desire to rob Jews... or of a retaliatory cycle that had begun with a British raid on a LHI training exercise (after an Arab had informed the British about the exercise), that resulted in several Jewish dead... The LHI retaliated by executing five members of the beduin Shubaki clan near Herzliya...; and the Arabs retaliated by attacking the buses on 30 Nov....
In November they again strove to cool tempers, following an attack on a Jewish bus on its way to Holon, in retaliation against the killing of five young men of the Shubaki family by LEHI gunmen (who were in turn taking revenge because one of the members of the family had informed to the British about LEHI activities).
…the majority view in the HIS – supported by an anonymous Arab flyer posted almost immediately on walls in Jaffa – was that the attackers were driven primarily by a desire to avenge an LHI raid ten days before on a house near Raganana belonging to the Abu Kishk bedouin tribe.
The ALA's diverse supply sources created a bizarre arsenal that caused serious logistic problems and rendered maintenance an impossible task. Munitions were often of low quality, damaging the barrels and failing to function when necessary. In December 1947 Syria bought a quantity of small arms from the Skoda plant in Czechoslovakia for the ALA. Jewish saboteurs blew up the ship that carried the cargo to the Middle East and sank it in the Italian port of Bari. The arms were later salvaged and reshipped in August 1948 to Syria – this time for arming Palestinian combatants – but the Israeli navy intercepted the freight and seized the weapons.
to avoid dependence on the population for supplies, and preclude possible intimidation of locals to donate provisions, the League's military committee had arranged to furnish the troops' rations through special contractors. This semblance of logistics apparently marked significant progress in comparison with the 1936–9 rebellion. Introducing medical services for the combatants and the population made an impression on both the British and the Jews.
The British blockade of the Palestinian coast prevented any substantial increase of these quantities until mid-May. Concurrently, the Arabs succeeded in smuggling into the country small arms that their emissaries had purchased in neighbouring countries. The ALA brought a certain number of support arms and a few artillery pieces and armoured vehicles. Although the gap narrowed, the picture did not materially change, and the Haganah continued to maintain its relative edge.
For example, all the land mines used against Rommel came from Jewish factories in Palestine.
"At the time, Ben-Gurion and the HGS believed that they had initiated a one-shot affair, albeit with the implication of a change of tactics and strategy on the Jerusalem front. In fact, they had set in motion a strategic transformation of Haganah policy. Nahshon heralded a shift from the defensive to the offensive and marked the beginning of the implementation of tochnit dalet (Plan D)—without Ben-Gurion or the HGS ever taking an in principle decision to embark on its implementation.
In reality, according to Ben-Gurion, some 640 Haganah soldiers had faced about twenty-five hundred ALA troops, with superior firepower—and bested them.
| Background | |
|---|---|
| 1920s | |
| 1930s |
|
| During World War II | |
| After World War II | |
| Actors | |
| Prominent figures | |
.svg)
