Movatterモバイル変換


[0]ホーム

URL:


1932
Annual Reviews logo
Skip to content

Review Article

Free

Dynamical Evolution of the Early Solar System

Abstract

Several properties of the Solar System, including the wide radial spacing of the giant planets, can be explained if planets radially migrated by exchanging orbital energy and momentum with outer disk planetesimals. Neptune's planetesimal-driven migration, in particular, has a strong advocate in the dynamical structure of the Kuiper belt. A dynamical instability is thought to have occurred during the early stages with Jupiter having close encounters with a Neptune-class planet. As a result of the encounters, Jupiter acquired its current orbital eccentricity and jumped inward by a fraction of an astronomical unit, as required for the survival of the terrestrial planets and from asteroid belt constraints. Planetary encounters also contributed to capture of Jupiter Trojans and irregular satellites of the giant planets. Here we discuss the dynamical evolution of the early Solar System with an eye to determining how models of planetary migration/instability can be constrained from its present architecture. Specifically, we review arguments suggesting that the Solar System may have originally contained a third ice giant on a resonant orbit between Saturn and Uranus. This hypothesized planet was presumably ejected into interstellar space during the instability. The Kuiper belt kernel and other dynamical structures in the trans-Neptunian region may provide evidence for the ejected planet. We favor the early version of the instability where Neptune migrated into the outer planetesimal disk within a few tens of millions of years after the dispersal of the protosolar nebula. If so, the planetary migration/instability was not the cause of the Late Heavy Bombardment. Mercury's orbit may have been excited during the instability.

    Keyword(s):Solar System
    Loading

    Article metrics loading...

    /content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-081817-052028
    2018-09-14
    2026-02-14

    Metrics

    Download as PowerPoint
    Loading full text...

    Full text loading...

    /deliver/fulltext/astro/56/1/annurev-astro-081817-052028.html?itemId=/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-081817-052028&mimeType=html&fmt=ahah

    Literature Cited

    1. AdamsFC2010.Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys.48:47–85
      [Google Scholar]
    2. AdamsER,GulbisAAS,ElliotJL et al.2014.Astron. J.148:55
      [Google Scholar]
    3. AgnorCB,HamiltonDP2006.Nature441:192–94
      [Google Scholar]
    4. AgnorCB,LinDNC2012.Ap. J.745:143
      [Google Scholar]
    5. AsphaugE,ReuferA2014.Nat. Geosci.7:564–68
      [Google Scholar]
    6. BarucciMA,BoehnhardtH,CruikshankDP,MorbidelliA2008.The Solar System Beyond Neptune Tucson, AZ: Univ. Ariz. Press
      [Google Scholar]
    7. BatyginK,BrownME2016.Astron. J.151:22
      [Google Scholar]
    8. BatyginK,BrownME,BettsH2012.Ap. J. Lett.744:L3
      [Google Scholar]
    9. BatyginK,BrownME,FraserWC2011.Ap. J.738:13
      [Google Scholar]
    10. BeaugéC,RoigF,NesvornýD2002.Icarus158:483–98
      [Google Scholar]
    11. BernsteinGM,TrillingDE,AllenRL et al.2004.Astron. J.128:1364–90
      [Google Scholar]
    12. BottkeWF,LevisonHF,NesvornýD,DonesL2007.Icarus190:203–23
      [Google Scholar]
    13. BottkeWF,NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,MorbidelliA2010.Astron. J.139:994–1014
      [Google Scholar]
    14. BottkeWF,NormanMD2017.Annu. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci.45:619–47
      [Google Scholar]
    15. BottkeWF,VokrouhlickýD,MintonD et al.2012.Nature485:78–81
      [Google Scholar]
    16. BouéG,LaskarJ,KuchynkaP2009.Ap. J. Lett.702:L19–22
      [Google Scholar]
    17. BrasserR,LeeMH2015.Astron. J.150:157
      [Google Scholar]
    18. BrasserR,MorbidelliA2013.Icarus225:40–49
      [Google Scholar]
    19. BrasserR,MorbidelliA,GomesR,TsiganisK,LevisonHF2009.Astron. Astrophys.507:1053–65
      [Google Scholar]
    20. BrasserR,WalshKJ,NesvornýD2013.MNRAS433:3417–27
      [Google Scholar]
    21. BrownME2001.Astron. J.121:2804–14
      [Google Scholar]
    22. BrownME,SchallerEL,FraserWC2011.Ap. J. Lett.739:L60
      [Google Scholar]
    23. BruckerMJ,GrundyWM,StansberryJA et al.2009.Icarus201:284–94
      [Google Scholar]
    24. BuieMW,OlkinCB,MerlineWJ et al.2015.Astron. J.149:113
      [Google Scholar]
    25. ChapmanCR,CohenBA,GrinspoonDH2007.Icarus189:233–45
      [Google Scholar]
    26. CharnozS,SalmonJ,CridaA2010.Nature465:752–54
      [Google Scholar]
    27. CorreiaACM2009.Ap. J. Lett.704:L1–4
      [Google Scholar]
    28. ĆukM2007. Presented at the 39th AAS/Division for Planetary Sciences Meeting, Orlando, FL, October 2007.6005
    29. ĆukM,BurnsJA2004.Icarus167:369–81
      [Google Scholar]
    30. DawsonRI,Murray-ClayR2012.Ap. J.750:43
      [Google Scholar]
    31. DeiennoR,GomesRS,WalshKJ,MorbidelliA,NesvornýD2016.Icarus272:114–24
      [Google Scholar]
    32. DeiennoR,MorbidelliA,GomesRS,NesvornýD2017.Astron. J.153:153
      [Google Scholar]
    33. DeiennoR,NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,YokoyamaT2014.Astron. J.148:25
      [Google Scholar]
    34. DeiennoR,YokoyamaT,NogueiraEC,CallegariN,SantosMT2011.Astron. Astrophys.536:A57
      [Google Scholar]
    35. DeMeoFE,AlexanderCMO,WalshKJ,ChapmanCR,BinzelRP2015.Asteroids IV P Michel, FE DeMeo, WF Bottke13–41 Tucson, AZ: Univ. Ariz. Press
      [Google Scholar]
    36. DonesL,BrasserR,KaibN,RickmanH2015.Space Sci. Rev.197:191–269
      [Google Scholar]
    37. DuncanMJ,LevisonHF1997.Science276:1670–72
      [Google Scholar]
    38. DuncanM,QuinnT,TremaineS1988.Ap. J. Lett.328:L69–73
      [Google Scholar]
    39. FernándezJA1980.Icarus42:406–21
      [Google Scholar]
    40. FernándezJA,IpW-H1984.Icarus58:109–20
      [Google Scholar]
    41. FordEB,ChiangEI2007.Ap. J.661:602–15
      [Google Scholar]
    42. FraserWC,BrownME,MorbidelliA,ParkerA,BatyginK2014.Ap. J.782:100
      [Google Scholar]
    43. GladmanB,LawlerSM,PetitJ-M et al.2012.Astron. J.144:23
      [Google Scholar]
    44. GladmanB,MarsdenBG,VanlaerhovenC2008. See Barucci et al. 200843–57
    45. GomesR,LevisonHF,TsiganisK,MorbidelliA2005.Nature435:466–69
      [Google Scholar]
    46. GomesRS2003.Icarus161:404–18
      [Google Scholar]
    47. GomesRS2011.Icarus215:661–68
      [Google Scholar]
    48. GomesRS,MorbidelliA,LevisonHF2004.Icarus170:492–507
      [Google Scholar]
    49. GradieJ,TedescoE1982.Science216:1405–7
      [Google Scholar]
    50. GravT,MainzerAK,BauerJ et al.2011.Ap. J.742:40
      [Google Scholar]
    51. GulbisAAS,ElliotJL,AdamsER et al.2010.Astron. J.140:350–69
      [Google Scholar]
    52. HahnJM,MalhotraR1999.Astron. J.117:3041–53
      [Google Scholar]
    53. HahnJM,MalhotraR2005.Astron. J.130:2392–414
      [Google Scholar]
    54. HamiltonDP,WardWR2004.Astron. J.128:2510–17
      [Google Scholar]
    55. HayashiC1981.Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl.70:35–53
      [Google Scholar]
    56. HelledR,AndersonJD,SchubertG,StevensonDJ2011.Icarus216:440–48
      [Google Scholar]
    57. HelledR,SchubertG,AndersonJD2009.Icarus199:368–77
      [Google Scholar]
    58. IzidoroA,MorbidelliA,RaymondSN,HersantF,PierensA2015.Astron. Astrophys.582:A99
      [Google Scholar]
    59. JacobsonSA,MorbidelliA,RaymondSN et al.2014.Nature508:84–87
      [Google Scholar]
    60. JewittD,SheppardS2005.Space Sci. Rev.116:441–55
      [Google Scholar]
    61. JoyKH,ZolenskyME,NagashimaK et al.2012.Science336:1426–29
      [Google Scholar]
    62. KaibNA,ChambersJE2016.MNRAS455:3561–69
      [Google Scholar]
    63. KaibNA,SheppardSS2016.Astron. J.152:133
      [Google Scholar]
    64. KenyonSJ,BromleyBC,O'BrienDP,DavisDR2008. See Barucci et al. 2008293–313
    65. KleineT,TouboulM,BourdonB et al.2009.Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta73:5150–88
      [Google Scholar]
    66. KleyW,NelsonRP2012.Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys.50:211–49
      [Google Scholar]
    67. KringDA,CohenBA2002.J. Geophys. Res. (Planets)107:5009
      [Google Scholar]
    68. KruijerTS,BurkhardtC,BuddeG,KleineT2017.PNAS114:6712–16
      [Google Scholar]
    69. LaskarJ1996.Celestial Mech. Dyn. Astron.64:115–62
      [Google Scholar]
    70. LaskarJ,PetitAC2017.Astron. Astrophys.605:A72
      [Google Scholar]
    71. LevisonHF,BottkeWF,GounelleM et al.2009.Nature460:364–66
      [Google Scholar]
    72. LevisonHF,DonesL,ChapmanCR et al.2001.aIcarus151:286–306
      [Google Scholar]
    73. LevisonHF,DonesL,DuncanMJ2001.bAstron. J.121:2253–67
      [Google Scholar]
    74. LevisonHF,DuncanMJ1997.Icarus127:13–32
      [Google Scholar]
    75. LevisonHF,DuncanMJ,DonesL,GladmanBJ2006.Icarus184:619–33
      [Google Scholar]
    76. LevisonHFLucy Science Team.2016.Lunar Planet. Sci. Conf.47:2061
      [Google Scholar]
    77. LevisonHF,MorbidelliA2003.Nature426:419–21
      [Google Scholar]
    78. LevisonHF,MorbidelliA,TsiganisK,NesvornýD,GomesR2011.Astron. J.142:152
      [Google Scholar]
    79. LevisonHF,MorbidelliA,Van LaerhovenC,GomesR,TsiganisK2008.Icarus196:258–73
      [Google Scholar]
    80. LuuJ,MarsdenBG,JewittD et al.1997.Nature387:573–75
      [Google Scholar]
    81. MalhotraR1993.Nature365:819–21
      [Google Scholar]
    82. MalhotraR1995.Astron. J.110:420–29
      [Google Scholar]
    83. MarchiS,BottkeWF,KringDA,MorbidelliA2012.Earth Planet. Sci. Lett.325:27–38
      [Google Scholar]
    84. MarchisF,DurechJ,Castillo-RogezJ et al.2014.Ap. J. Lett.783:L37
      [Google Scholar]
    85. MarzariF,SchollH2000.Icarus146:232–39
      [Google Scholar]
    86. MarzariF,SchollH,MurrayC,LagerkvistC2002.Asteroids III WF Bottke Jr., A Cellino, P Paolicchi, RP Binzel725–38 Tucson, AZ: Univ. Ariz. Press
      [Google Scholar]
    87. MasieroJR,GravT,MainzerAK et al.2014.Ap. J.791:121
      [Google Scholar]
    88. MassetF,SnellgroveM2001.MNRAS320:L55
      [Google Scholar]
    89. MintonDA,MalhotraR2009.Nature457:1109–11
      [Google Scholar]
    90. MintonDA,MalhotraR2010.Icarus207:744–57
      [Google Scholar]
    91. MorbidelliA,BrasserR,GomesR,LevisonHF,TsiganisK2010.Astron. J.140:1391–401
      [Google Scholar]
    92. MorbidelliA,BrasserR,TsiganisK,GomesR,LevisonHF2009.aAstron. Astrophys.507:1041–52
      [Google Scholar]
    93. MorbidelliA,CridaA2007.Icarus191:158–71
      [Google Scholar]
    94. MorbidelliA,GasparHS,NesvornýD2014.Icarus232:81–87
      [Google Scholar]
    95. MorbidelliA,LevisonHF,BottkeWF,DonesL,NesvornýD2009.bIcarus202:310–15
      [Google Scholar]
    96. MorbidelliA,LevisonHF,TsiganisK,GomesR2005.Nature435:462–65
      [Google Scholar]
    97. MorbidelliA,MarchiS,BottkeWF,KringDA2012.aEarth Planet. Sci. Lett.355:144–51
      [Google Scholar]
    98. MorbidelliA,NesvornýD,LaurenzV2018.Icarus305:262–76
      [Google Scholar]
    99. MorbidelliA,PetitJ-M,GladmanB,ChambersJ2001.Meteorit. Planet. Sci.36:371–80
      [Google Scholar]
    100. MorbidelliA,TsiganisK,BatyginK,CridaA,GomesR2012.bIcarus219:737–40
      [Google Scholar]
    101. MorbidelliA,TsiganisK,CridaA,LevisonHF,GomesR2007.Astron. J.134:1790–98
      [Google Scholar]
    102. MorbidelliA,WalshKJ,O'BrienDP,MintonDA,BottkeWF2015.Asteroids IV P Michel, FE DeMeo, WF Bottke493–507 Tucson, AZ: Univ. Ariz. Press
      [Google Scholar]
    103. MurrayCD,DermottSF, eds1999.Solar System Dynamics Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Univ. Press
      [Google Scholar]
    104. NesvornýD2011.Ap. J. Lett.742:L22
      [Google Scholar]
    105. NesvornýD2015.aAstron. J.150:68
      [Google Scholar]
    106. NesvornýD2015.bAstron. J.150:73
      [Google Scholar]
    107. NesvornýD,AlvarellosJLA,DonesL,LevisonHF2003.Astron. J.126:398–429
      [Google Scholar]
    108. NesvornýD,MorbidelliA2012.Astron. J.144:117
      [Google Scholar]
    109. NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD2016.Ap. J.825:94
      [Google Scholar]
    110. NesvornýD,RoigF,BottkeWF2017.aAstron. J.153:103
      [Google Scholar]
    111. NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,BottkeWF,NollK,LevisonHF2011.Astron. J.141:159
      [Google Scholar]
    112. NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,DeiennoR2014.aAp. J.784:22
      [Google Scholar]
    113. NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,DeiennoR,WalshKJ2014.bAstron. J.148:52
      [Google Scholar]
    114. NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,DonesL et al.2017.bAp. J.845:27
      [Google Scholar]
    115. NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,MorbidelliA2007.Astron. J.133:1962–76
      [Google Scholar]
    116. NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,MorbidelliA2013.Ap. J.768:45
      [Google Scholar]
    117. NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,RoigF2016.Ap. J. Lett.827:L35
      [Google Scholar]
    118. NicholsonPD,CukM,SheppardSS,NesvornýD,JohnsonTV2008. See Barucci et al. 2008411–24
    119. NogueiraEC,GomesRS,BrasserR2013. Presented at the 44th AAS/Division of Dynamical Astronomy Meeting, Paraty, Brazil, May 5–9.20421
    120. NollKS,GrundyWM,ChiangEI,MargotJ-L,KernSD2008. See Barucci et al. 2008345–63
    121. PaetzoldM,AndertT,HahnM et al.2016. Presented at the 48th AAS/Division for Planetary Science Meeting, Pasadena, CA, October 16–21.11627
    122. PanM,SariR2005.Icarus173:342–48
      [Google Scholar]
    123. ParkerAH,KavelaarsJJ2010.Ap. J. Lett.722:L204–8
      [Google Scholar]
    124. PealeSJ1999.Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys.37:533–602
      [Google Scholar]
    125. PetitJ-M,KavelaarsJJ,GladmanBJ et al.2011.Astron. J.142:131
      [Google Scholar]
    126. PierensA,NelsonRP2008.Astron. Astrophys.482:333–40
      [Google Scholar]
    127. PierensA,RaymondSN,NesvornýD,MorbidelliA2014.Ap. J. Lett.795:L11
      [Google Scholar]
    128. PressWH,TeukolskySA,VetterlingWT,FlanneryBP1992.Numerical Recipes in C: The Art of Scientific Computing Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press. , 2nd ed..
      [Google Scholar]
    129. RasioFA,FordEB1996.Science274:954–56
      [Google Scholar]
    130. RoigF,NesvornýD2015.Astron. J.150:186
      [Google Scholar]
    131. RoigF,NesvornýD,DeSouzaSR2016.Ap. J. Lett.820:L30
      [Google Scholar]
    132. RozehnalJ,BrozM,NesvornýD et al.2016.MNRAS462:2319–32
      [Google Scholar]
    133. RubieDC,LaurenzV,JacobsonSA et al.2016.Science353:1141–44
      [Google Scholar]
    134. ShakuraNI,SunyaevRA1973.Astron. Astrophys.24:337–55
      [Google Scholar]
    135. SheppardSS,JewittDC2003.Nature423:261–63
      [Google Scholar]
    136. TeglerSC,RomanishinW2000.Nature407:979–81
      [Google Scholar]
    137. ThommesEW,DuncanMJ,LevisonHF1999.Nature402:635–38
      [Google Scholar]
    138. ToliouA,MorbidelliA,TsiganisK2016.Astron. Astrophys.592:A72
      [Google Scholar]
    139. TrujilloCA,SheppardSS2014.Nature507:471–74
      [Google Scholar]
    140. TsiganisK,GomesR,MorbidelliA,LevisonHF2005.Nature435:459–61
      [Google Scholar]
    141. VinogradovaTA,ChernetenkoYA2015.Solar Syst. Res.49:391–97
      [Google Scholar]
    142. VokrouhlickýD,BottkeWF,NesvornýD2016.Astron. J.152:39
      [Google Scholar]
    143. VokrouhlickýD,NesvornýD2015.Ap. J.806:143
      [Google Scholar]
    144. VokrouhlickýD,NesvornýD,LevisonHF2008.Astron. J.136:1463–76
      [Google Scholar]
    145. VolkK,MalhotraR2008.Ap. J.687:714–25
      [Google Scholar]
    146. VolkK,MalhotraR2011.Ap. J.736:11
      [Google Scholar]
    147. WalshKJ,MorbidelliA,RaymondSN,O'BrienDP,MandellAM2011.Nature475:206–9
      [Google Scholar]
    148. WangJ-H,BrasserR2014.Astron. Astrophys.563:A122
      [Google Scholar]
    149. WardWR,CanupRM2006.Ap. J. Lett.640:L91–94
      [Google Scholar]
    150. WardWR,HahnJM1998.Science280:2104–6
      [Google Scholar]
    151. WardWR,HamiltonDP2004.Astron. J.128:2501–9
      [Google Scholar]
    152. WeidenschillingSJ1977.Ap. Space Sci.51:153–58
      [Google Scholar]
    153. WilliamsJP,CiezaLA2011.Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys.49:67–117
      [Google Scholar]
    154. WolffS,DawsonRI,Murray-ClayRA2012.Ap. J.746:171
      [Google Scholar]
    155. WongI,BrownME2015.Astron. J.150:174
      [Google Scholar]
    156. WongI,BrownME,EmeryJP2014.Astron. J.148:112
      [Google Scholar]
    157. WyattMC2008.Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys.46:339–83
      [Google Scholar]
    158. YoshidaF,TeraiT2017.Astron. J.154:71
      [Google Scholar]
    159. YoudinAN,GoodmanJ2005.Ap. J.620:459–69
      [Google Scholar]
    160. YoudinAN,KenyonSJ2013.Planets, Stars and Stellar Systems. Vol. 3: Solar and Stellar Planetary Systems TD Oswalt, LM French, P Kalas1–62 Dordrecht: Springer
      [Google Scholar]
    /content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-081817-052028
    Loading
    Dynamical Evolution of the Early Solar System
    Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics56, 137 (2018);https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-astro-081817-052028
    /content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-081817-052028
    /content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-081817-052028
    Loading

    Data & Media loading...

    Most Read This Month

    Article
    content/journals/astro
    Journal
    5
    3
    false
    en
    Loading

    Most CitedMost Cited RSS feed

    knowable Logo

    Science needs us — and you

    Support nonprofit Knowable Magazine and bring facts to light

    Related Articles from Annual Reviews

    /content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-081817-052028
    dcterms_title,dcterms_subject,pub_keyword
    -contentType:Journal -contentType:Contributor -contentType:Concept -contentType:Institution
    4
    4

    Literature Cited

    1. AdamsFC2010.Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys.48:47–85
      [Google Scholar]
    2. AdamsER,GulbisAAS,ElliotJL et al.2014.Astron. J.148:55
      [Google Scholar]
    3. AgnorCB,HamiltonDP2006.Nature441:192–94
      [Google Scholar]
    4. AgnorCB,LinDNC2012.Ap. J.745:143
      [Google Scholar]
    5. AsphaugE,ReuferA2014.Nat. Geosci.7:564–68
      [Google Scholar]
    6. BarucciMA,BoehnhardtH,CruikshankDP,MorbidelliA2008.The Solar System Beyond Neptune Tucson, AZ: Univ. Ariz. Press
      [Google Scholar]
    7. BatyginK,BrownME2016.Astron. J.151:22
      [Google Scholar]
    8. BatyginK,BrownME,BettsH2012.Ap. J. Lett.744:L3
      [Google Scholar]
    9. BatyginK,BrownME,FraserWC2011.Ap. J.738:13
      [Google Scholar]
    10. BeaugéC,RoigF,NesvornýD2002.Icarus158:483–98
      [Google Scholar]
    11. BernsteinGM,TrillingDE,AllenRL et al.2004.Astron. J.128:1364–90
      [Google Scholar]
    12. BottkeWF,LevisonHF,NesvornýD,DonesL2007.Icarus190:203–23
      [Google Scholar]
    13. BottkeWF,NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,MorbidelliA2010.Astron. J.139:994–1014
      [Google Scholar]
    14. BottkeWF,NormanMD2017.Annu. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci.45:619–47
      [Google Scholar]
    15. BottkeWF,VokrouhlickýD,MintonD et al.2012.Nature485:78–81
      [Google Scholar]
    16. BouéG,LaskarJ,KuchynkaP2009.Ap. J. Lett.702:L19–22
      [Google Scholar]
    17. BrasserR,LeeMH2015.Astron. J.150:157
      [Google Scholar]
    18. BrasserR,MorbidelliA2013.Icarus225:40–49
      [Google Scholar]
    19. BrasserR,MorbidelliA,GomesR,TsiganisK,LevisonHF2009.Astron. Astrophys.507:1053–65
      [Google Scholar]
    20. BrasserR,WalshKJ,NesvornýD2013.MNRAS433:3417–27
      [Google Scholar]
    21. BrownME2001.Astron. J.121:2804–14
      [Google Scholar]
    22. BrownME,SchallerEL,FraserWC2011.Ap. J. Lett.739:L60
      [Google Scholar]
    23. BruckerMJ,GrundyWM,StansberryJA et al.2009.Icarus201:284–94
      [Google Scholar]
    24. BuieMW,OlkinCB,MerlineWJ et al.2015.Astron. J.149:113
      [Google Scholar]
    25. ChapmanCR,CohenBA,GrinspoonDH2007.Icarus189:233–45
      [Google Scholar]
    26. CharnozS,SalmonJ,CridaA2010.Nature465:752–54
      [Google Scholar]
    27. CorreiaACM2009.Ap. J. Lett.704:L1–4
      [Google Scholar]
    28. ĆukM2007. Presented at the 39th AAS/Division for Planetary Sciences Meeting, Orlando, FL, October 2007.6005
    29. ĆukM,BurnsJA2004.Icarus167:369–81
      [Google Scholar]
    30. DawsonRI,Murray-ClayR2012.Ap. J.750:43
      [Google Scholar]
    31. DeiennoR,GomesRS,WalshKJ,MorbidelliA,NesvornýD2016.Icarus272:114–24
      [Google Scholar]
    32. DeiennoR,MorbidelliA,GomesRS,NesvornýD2017.Astron. J.153:153
      [Google Scholar]
    33. DeiennoR,NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,YokoyamaT2014.Astron. J.148:25
      [Google Scholar]
    34. DeiennoR,YokoyamaT,NogueiraEC,CallegariN,SantosMT2011.Astron. Astrophys.536:A57
      [Google Scholar]
    35. DeMeoFE,AlexanderCMO,WalshKJ,ChapmanCR,BinzelRP2015.Asteroids IV P Michel, FE DeMeo, WF Bottke13–41 Tucson, AZ: Univ. Ariz. Press
      [Google Scholar]
    36. DonesL,BrasserR,KaibN,RickmanH2015.Space Sci. Rev.197:191–269
      [Google Scholar]
    37. DuncanMJ,LevisonHF1997.Science276:1670–72
      [Google Scholar]
    38. DuncanM,QuinnT,TremaineS1988.Ap. J. Lett.328:L69–73
      [Google Scholar]
    39. FernándezJA1980.Icarus42:406–21
      [Google Scholar]
    40. FernándezJA,IpW-H1984.Icarus58:109–20
      [Google Scholar]
    41. FordEB,ChiangEI2007.Ap. J.661:602–15
      [Google Scholar]
    42. FraserWC,BrownME,MorbidelliA,ParkerA,BatyginK2014.Ap. J.782:100
      [Google Scholar]
    43. GladmanB,LawlerSM,PetitJ-M et al.2012.Astron. J.144:23
      [Google Scholar]
    44. GladmanB,MarsdenBG,VanlaerhovenC2008. See Barucci et al. 200843–57
    45. GomesR,LevisonHF,TsiganisK,MorbidelliA2005.Nature435:466–69
      [Google Scholar]
    46. GomesRS2003.Icarus161:404–18
      [Google Scholar]
    47. GomesRS2011.Icarus215:661–68
      [Google Scholar]
    48. GomesRS,MorbidelliA,LevisonHF2004.Icarus170:492–507
      [Google Scholar]
    49. GradieJ,TedescoE1982.Science216:1405–7
      [Google Scholar]
    50. GravT,MainzerAK,BauerJ et al.2011.Ap. J.742:40
      [Google Scholar]
    51. GulbisAAS,ElliotJL,AdamsER et al.2010.Astron. J.140:350–69
      [Google Scholar]
    52. HahnJM,MalhotraR1999.Astron. J.117:3041–53
      [Google Scholar]
    53. HahnJM,MalhotraR2005.Astron. J.130:2392–414
      [Google Scholar]
    54. HamiltonDP,WardWR2004.Astron. J.128:2510–17
      [Google Scholar]
    55. HayashiC1981.Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl.70:35–53
      [Google Scholar]
    56. HelledR,AndersonJD,SchubertG,StevensonDJ2011.Icarus216:440–48
      [Google Scholar]
    57. HelledR,SchubertG,AndersonJD2009.Icarus199:368–77
      [Google Scholar]
    58. IzidoroA,MorbidelliA,RaymondSN,HersantF,PierensA2015.Astron. Astrophys.582:A99
      [Google Scholar]
    59. JacobsonSA,MorbidelliA,RaymondSN et al.2014.Nature508:84–87
      [Google Scholar]
    60. JewittD,SheppardS2005.Space Sci. Rev.116:441–55
      [Google Scholar]
    61. JoyKH,ZolenskyME,NagashimaK et al.2012.Science336:1426–29
      [Google Scholar]
    62. KaibNA,ChambersJE2016.MNRAS455:3561–69
      [Google Scholar]
    63. KaibNA,SheppardSS2016.Astron. J.152:133
      [Google Scholar]
    64. KenyonSJ,BromleyBC,O'BrienDP,DavisDR2008. See Barucci et al. 2008293–313
    65. KleineT,TouboulM,BourdonB et al.2009.Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta73:5150–88
      [Google Scholar]
    66. KleyW,NelsonRP2012.Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys.50:211–49
      [Google Scholar]
    67. KringDA,CohenBA2002.J. Geophys. Res. (Planets)107:5009
      [Google Scholar]
    68. KruijerTS,BurkhardtC,BuddeG,KleineT2017.PNAS114:6712–16
      [Google Scholar]
    69. LaskarJ1996.Celestial Mech. Dyn. Astron.64:115–62
      [Google Scholar]
    70. LaskarJ,PetitAC2017.Astron. Astrophys.605:A72
      [Google Scholar]
    71. LevisonHF,BottkeWF,GounelleM et al.2009.Nature460:364–66
      [Google Scholar]
    72. LevisonHF,DonesL,ChapmanCR et al.2001.aIcarus151:286–306
      [Google Scholar]
    73. LevisonHF,DonesL,DuncanMJ2001.bAstron. J.121:2253–67
      [Google Scholar]
    74. LevisonHF,DuncanMJ1997.Icarus127:13–32
      [Google Scholar]
    75. LevisonHF,DuncanMJ,DonesL,GladmanBJ2006.Icarus184:619–33
      [Google Scholar]
    76. LevisonHFLucy Science Team.2016.Lunar Planet. Sci. Conf.47:2061
      [Google Scholar]
    77. LevisonHF,MorbidelliA2003.Nature426:419–21
      [Google Scholar]
    78. LevisonHF,MorbidelliA,TsiganisK,NesvornýD,GomesR2011.Astron. J.142:152
      [Google Scholar]
    79. LevisonHF,MorbidelliA,Van LaerhovenC,GomesR,TsiganisK2008.Icarus196:258–73
      [Google Scholar]
    80. LuuJ,MarsdenBG,JewittD et al.1997.Nature387:573–75
      [Google Scholar]
    81. MalhotraR1993.Nature365:819–21
      [Google Scholar]
    82. MalhotraR1995.Astron. J.110:420–29
      [Google Scholar]
    83. MarchiS,BottkeWF,KringDA,MorbidelliA2012.Earth Planet. Sci. Lett.325:27–38
      [Google Scholar]
    84. MarchisF,DurechJ,Castillo-RogezJ et al.2014.Ap. J. Lett.783:L37
      [Google Scholar]
    85. MarzariF,SchollH2000.Icarus146:232–39
      [Google Scholar]
    86. MarzariF,SchollH,MurrayC,LagerkvistC2002.Asteroids III WF Bottke Jr., A Cellino, P Paolicchi, RP Binzel725–38 Tucson, AZ: Univ. Ariz. Press
      [Google Scholar]
    87. MasieroJR,GravT,MainzerAK et al.2014.Ap. J.791:121
      [Google Scholar]
    88. MassetF,SnellgroveM2001.MNRAS320:L55
      [Google Scholar]
    89. MintonDA,MalhotraR2009.Nature457:1109–11
      [Google Scholar]
    90. MintonDA,MalhotraR2010.Icarus207:744–57
      [Google Scholar]
    91. MorbidelliA,BrasserR,GomesR,LevisonHF,TsiganisK2010.Astron. J.140:1391–401
      [Google Scholar]
    92. MorbidelliA,BrasserR,TsiganisK,GomesR,LevisonHF2009.aAstron. Astrophys.507:1041–52
      [Google Scholar]
    93. MorbidelliA,CridaA2007.Icarus191:158–71
      [Google Scholar]
    94. MorbidelliA,GasparHS,NesvornýD2014.Icarus232:81–87
      [Google Scholar]
    95. MorbidelliA,LevisonHF,BottkeWF,DonesL,NesvornýD2009.bIcarus202:310–15
      [Google Scholar]
    96. MorbidelliA,LevisonHF,TsiganisK,GomesR2005.Nature435:462–65
      [Google Scholar]
    97. MorbidelliA,MarchiS,BottkeWF,KringDA2012.aEarth Planet. Sci. Lett.355:144–51
      [Google Scholar]
    98. MorbidelliA,NesvornýD,LaurenzV2018.Icarus305:262–76
      [Google Scholar]
    99. MorbidelliA,PetitJ-M,GladmanB,ChambersJ2001.Meteorit. Planet. Sci.36:371–80
      [Google Scholar]
    100. MorbidelliA,TsiganisK,BatyginK,CridaA,GomesR2012.bIcarus219:737–40
      [Google Scholar]
    101. MorbidelliA,TsiganisK,CridaA,LevisonHF,GomesR2007.Astron. J.134:1790–98
      [Google Scholar]
    102. MorbidelliA,WalshKJ,O'BrienDP,MintonDA,BottkeWF2015.Asteroids IV P Michel, FE DeMeo, WF Bottke493–507 Tucson, AZ: Univ. Ariz. Press
      [Google Scholar]
    103. MurrayCD,DermottSF, eds1999.Solar System Dynamics Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Univ. Press
      [Google Scholar]
    104. NesvornýD2011.Ap. J. Lett.742:L22
      [Google Scholar]
    105. NesvornýD2015.aAstron. J.150:68
      [Google Scholar]
    106. NesvornýD2015.bAstron. J.150:73
      [Google Scholar]
    107. NesvornýD,AlvarellosJLA,DonesL,LevisonHF2003.Astron. J.126:398–429
      [Google Scholar]
    108. NesvornýD,MorbidelliA2012.Astron. J.144:117
      [Google Scholar]
    109. NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD2016.Ap. J.825:94
      [Google Scholar]
    110. NesvornýD,RoigF,BottkeWF2017.aAstron. J.153:103
      [Google Scholar]
    111. NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,BottkeWF,NollK,LevisonHF2011.Astron. J.141:159
      [Google Scholar]
    112. NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,DeiennoR2014.aAp. J.784:22
      [Google Scholar]
    113. NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,DeiennoR,WalshKJ2014.bAstron. J.148:52
      [Google Scholar]
    114. NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,DonesL et al.2017.bAp. J.845:27
      [Google Scholar]
    115. NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,MorbidelliA2007.Astron. J.133:1962–76
      [Google Scholar]
    116. NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,MorbidelliA2013.Ap. J.768:45
      [Google Scholar]
    117. NesvornýD,VokrouhlickýD,RoigF2016.Ap. J. Lett.827:L35
      [Google Scholar]
    118. NicholsonPD,CukM,SheppardSS,NesvornýD,JohnsonTV2008. See Barucci et al. 2008411–24
    119. NogueiraEC,GomesRS,BrasserR2013. Presented at the 44th AAS/Division of Dynamical Astronomy Meeting, Paraty, Brazil, May 5–9.20421
    120. NollKS,GrundyWM,ChiangEI,MargotJ-L,KernSD2008. See Barucci et al. 2008345–63
    121. PaetzoldM,AndertT,HahnM et al.2016. Presented at the 48th AAS/Division for Planetary Science Meeting, Pasadena, CA, October 16–21.11627
    122. PanM,SariR2005.Icarus173:342–48
      [Google Scholar]
    123. ParkerAH,KavelaarsJJ2010.Ap. J. Lett.722:L204–8
      [Google Scholar]
    124. PealeSJ1999.Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys.37:533–602
      [Google Scholar]
    125. PetitJ-M,KavelaarsJJ,GladmanBJ et al.2011.Astron. J.142:131
      [Google Scholar]
    126. PierensA,NelsonRP2008.Astron. Astrophys.482:333–40
      [Google Scholar]
    127. PierensA,RaymondSN,NesvornýD,MorbidelliA2014.Ap. J. Lett.795:L11
      [Google Scholar]
    128. PressWH,TeukolskySA,VetterlingWT,FlanneryBP1992.Numerical Recipes in C: The Art of Scientific Computing Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press. , 2nd ed..
      [Google Scholar]
    129. RasioFA,FordEB1996.Science274:954–56
      [Google Scholar]
    130. RoigF,NesvornýD2015.Astron. J.150:186
      [Google Scholar]
    131. RoigF,NesvornýD,DeSouzaSR2016.Ap. J. Lett.820:L30
      [Google Scholar]
    132. RozehnalJ,BrozM,NesvornýD et al.2016.MNRAS462:2319–32
      [Google Scholar]
    133. RubieDC,LaurenzV,JacobsonSA et al.2016.Science353:1141–44
      [Google Scholar]
    134. ShakuraNI,SunyaevRA1973.Astron. Astrophys.24:337–55
      [Google Scholar]
    135. SheppardSS,JewittDC2003.Nature423:261–63
      [Google Scholar]
    136. TeglerSC,RomanishinW2000.Nature407:979–81
      [Google Scholar]
    137. ThommesEW,DuncanMJ,LevisonHF1999.Nature402:635–38
      [Google Scholar]
    138. ToliouA,MorbidelliA,TsiganisK2016.Astron. Astrophys.592:A72
      [Google Scholar]
    139. TrujilloCA,SheppardSS2014.Nature507:471–74
      [Google Scholar]
    140. TsiganisK,GomesR,MorbidelliA,LevisonHF2005.Nature435:459–61
      [Google Scholar]
    141. VinogradovaTA,ChernetenkoYA2015.Solar Syst. Res.49:391–97
      [Google Scholar]
    142. VokrouhlickýD,BottkeWF,NesvornýD2016.Astron. J.152:39
      [Google Scholar]
    143. VokrouhlickýD,NesvornýD2015.Ap. J.806:143
      [Google Scholar]
    144. VokrouhlickýD,NesvornýD,LevisonHF2008.Astron. J.136:1463–76
      [Google Scholar]
    145. VolkK,MalhotraR2008.Ap. J.687:714–25
      [Google Scholar]
    146. VolkK,MalhotraR2011.Ap. J.736:11
      [Google Scholar]
    147. WalshKJ,MorbidelliA,RaymondSN,O'BrienDP,MandellAM2011.Nature475:206–9
      [Google Scholar]
    148. WangJ-H,BrasserR2014.Astron. Astrophys.563:A122
      [Google Scholar]
    149. WardWR,CanupRM2006.Ap. J. Lett.640:L91–94
      [Google Scholar]
    150. WardWR,HahnJM1998.Science280:2104–6
      [Google Scholar]
    151. WardWR,HamiltonDP2004.Astron. J.128:2501–9
      [Google Scholar]
    152. WeidenschillingSJ1977.Ap. Space Sci.51:153–58
      [Google Scholar]
    153. WilliamsJP,CiezaLA2011.Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys.49:67–117
      [Google Scholar]
    154. WolffS,DawsonRI,Murray-ClayRA2012.Ap. J.746:171
      [Google Scholar]
    155. WongI,BrownME2015.Astron. J.150:174
      [Google Scholar]
    156. WongI,BrownME,EmeryJP2014.Astron. J.148:112
      [Google Scholar]
    157. WyattMC2008.Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys.46:339–83
      [Google Scholar]
    158. YoshidaF,TeraiT2017.Astron. J.154:71
      [Google Scholar]
    159. YoudinAN,GoodmanJ2005.Ap. J.620:459–69
      [Google Scholar]
    160. YoudinAN,KenyonSJ2013.Planets, Stars and Stellar Systems. Vol. 3: Solar and Stellar Planetary Systems TD Oswalt, LM French, P Kalas1–62 Dordrecht: Springer
      [Google Scholar]

    FromKnowable Magazine:

    knowable magazine Teen Brain Bootcamp Special

    knowable magazine from Annual Reviews


    Bluesky share image


    Climate Resource Center, Article Collection from Annual Reviews


    Journal News

    This is a required field
    Please enter a valid email address
    Approval was a Success
    Invalid data
    An Error Occurred
    Approval was partially successful, following selected items could not be processed due to error
    Annual Reviews:
    http://instance.metastore.ingenta.com/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-astro-081817-052028
    10.1146/annurev-astro-081817-052028
    SEARCH_EXPAND_ITEM

    [8]ページ先頭

    ©2009-2026 Movatter.jp