Review Article
Comparative Perspectives on the State
- Karen Barkey1 andSunita Parikh2
- View Affiliations and Author NotesHide Affiliations and Author NotesDepartment of Sociology, Columbia University, New York, New York 10027Department of Political Science, Columbia University, New York, New York 10027
- Vol. 17:523-549(Volume publication date August 1991)
- © Annual Reviews
- View CitationHide Citation
Karen Barkey, Sunita Parikh. 1991. Comparative Perspectives on the State.Annual Review Sociology.17:523-549.https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.so.17.080191.002515
Abstract
Comparative work on the state, in terms of both new cases and generaltheoretical frameworks, has proliferated in the last decade. In this new work,traditional categories of differentiation such as structural-functionalism,Marxism, and pluralism have lost relevance and have been replaced bycommon conceptual strands that infuse every subfield of research on the state.In this review we select the most important conceptual strands and examinenew research in state formation, the state's role in economic development,and the state's relation to social movements and ethnic identity formation.Despite the frequent criticism that the state is the only explanatory variable inthese studies, we find that the literature has always recognized that statesocietyrelations are critical to understanding state action.





