Abstract
Historiography has tended to connect the fossil animals discovered in the soil of the Americas with the evidence of the theory of evolution. This chapter reveals the problems created by this perspective for understanding the questions at stake. An introduction to the main historiographical issues is followed by a perspective on the emergence of the nineteenth-century neologism “palaeontology” that discusses the locations where this term was first proposed and used, as well as unsolved questions regarding its circulation. The discussion reveals how important it is to go beyond the main characters identified by historians and beyond intellectual centers in Britain and France. The discussion turns to the discovery of the fossil genus Megatherium in a context where “palaeontology” did not yet exist as a discipline and where fossils did not provide evidence for evolutionary theory. The meaning of those bones must be understood in a context without Darwin’sOrigin of species. Examining a series of episodes about the extraction of the skeleton that was going to be known asMegatherium, this chapter reflects upon how historiography has ignored many agents, ideas, and interests at stake, most importantly the crucial role of Spanish bureaucracy and bureaucrats. It examines what happened in Buenos Aires after the departure of the skeletons, how the news circulated in the region – in Montevideo, Rio de Janeiro, and Lima. The result provides a new perspective on the generation of ideas as well as the communication and the flow of scientific news across places.
This is a preview of subscription content,log in via an institution to check access.
Access this chapter
Subscribe and save
- Get 10 units per month
- Download Article/Chapter or eBook
- 1 Unit = 1 Article or 1 Chapter
- Cancel anytime
Buy Now
- Chapter
- JPY 3498
- Price includes VAT (Japan)
- eBook
- JPY 40039
- Price includes VAT (Japan)
- Hardcover Book
- JPY 40039
- Price includes VAT (Japan)
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ameghino F (1889) Contribución al conocimiento de los mamíferos fósiles de la República Argentina, Actas de la Academia Nacional de Ciencias de Córdoba. Impr. de P.E. Coni é Hijos, Buenos Aires
Appel T (1980) Henri de Blainville and the animal series: a nineteenth century chain of being. J Hist Biol 13(2):291–319
Barahona A, Suárez E, Rheinberger H-J (eds) (2011) Darwin, el arte de hacer ciencia. UNAM, Mexico City
Blainville HD (1822) Analyse des principaux travaux dans les Sciences physiques, publiés dans l’année 1821. J Phys Chim Hist Nat 44:54
Boulinier G (1995) Les leçons du tatou: d’Orbigny et Darwin en Amérique du Sud. In: Laissus Y (ed) Les naturalistes français en Amérique du Sud XVXIe–XIXe siècle. CTHS, Paris, pp 277–290
Brendecke A (2009) Imperium und Empirie. Funktionen des Wissens in der Spanischen Kolonialherrschaft. Böhlau, Cologne
Brinkman P (2010a) The second Jurassic dinosaur rush: museums and paleontology in America at the turn of the twentieth century. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Brinkman P (2010b) Charles Darwin’s beagle voyage, fossil vertebrate succession, and the gradual birth & death of species. J Hist Biol 43(2):363–399
Caponi G (2009) George Cuvier. Un fisiólogo de museo. Limusa, Mexico City
Cohen C (2004) The fate of the mammoth: fossils, myth and history. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Corsi P (2020) A chair for two: Georges Cuvier and Jean-Claude Delamétherie at the Collège de France. In: Darwin au Collège de France [online]. Collège de France, Paris.http://books.openedition.org/cdf/7311. Accessed 21 Jan 2020
Escamilla-González F, Morelos-Rodríguez L (2020) Bringing Werner’s teachings to the new world: Andrés Manuel del Río and the Chair of Mineralogy in the School of Mines of Mexico (1795–1805). Earth Sci Hist 39(2):246–261
Klein U, Lefèvre W (2007) Materials in eighteenth-century sciences: a historical ontology. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Lister A (2018) Darwin’s fossils. Discoveries that shaped the theory of evolution. Natural History Museum, London
Lleó Cañal V (2008) Julian Benjamin Williams y el comercio de arte en la Sevilla del XIX. Bol Acad Sevillana Buenas Letras 36:187–204
Lopes MM (2010) Parentesco entre los muertos y los vivos nas cavernas de Lagoa Santa, no Brasil. Anu IEHS 25:353–337
Lopes MM, Podgorny I (2000) The shaping of Latin American museums of natural history. Osiris 15:108–118
López Piñero JM (1993) La tradición de la historiografía de la ciencia y su coyuntura actual: los condicionantes de un congreso. In: Mundialización de la ciencia y la cultura nacional. Actas del Congreso Internacional Ciencia, Descubrimiento y Mundo Colonial. Doce Calles, Madrid, pp 23–52
López Piñero JM, Glick T (1993) El megaterio de Bru y el presidente Jefferson, Cuadernos Valencianos de Historia de la Medicina y de la Ciencia 42. CSIC, Valencia
Ochoa C, Barahona A (2014) El Jano de la morfología: de la homología a la homoplasia. Historia, debates y evolución. Centro de Estudios V. Lombardo Tolesano, Mexico City
Owen R (1840) The zoology of the voyage of H.M.S. Beagle. Part 1. Fossil mammalia. Smith Elder, London
Pelayo F (2002) El Orden Natural y los Gigantes: la “Gigantologia Spagnola Vendicata” (1760) de José Torrubia. Archivo Teol Granadino 65:129–186
Pimentel J (2010) El Rinoceronte y el megaterio. Marcial Pons, Madrid
Podgorny I (2001) El camino de los fósiles: las colecciones de mamíferos pampeanos en los museos franceses e ingleses. Asclepio 53(2):97–116
Podgorny I (2010) Mercaderes del Pasado: Teodoro Vilardebó, Pedro de Angelis y el comercio de huesos y documentos en el Río de la Plata, 1830–1850. Circumscribere 9:29–77
Podgorny I (2011) El león de Hércules: Francisco X. Muñiz, Charles Darwin, Richard Owen y el género Machairodus. In: Barahona A, Suárez E, Rheinberger H-J (eds) Darwin. El arte de hacer ciencia. UNAM, Mexico City, pp 95–115
Podgorny I (2013) Fossil dealers, the practices of comparative anatomy, and British diplomacy in Latin America, 1820–1840. Br J Hist Sci 46(4):647–674
Podgorny I (2016) Recyclen. Vom Schrott der Ausrottung zur Ökonomie der (Sub)Fossilien. In: Güttler N, Heumann I (eds) Sammlungsökonomien. Vom Wert wissenschaftlicher Dinge. Kadmos, Berlin, pp 23–46
Podgorny I (2017) Manifest ambiguity: intermediate forms, variation, and mammal paleontology in Argentina, 1830–1880. Stud Hist Phil Biol Biomed Sci 66:27–36
Podgorny I (2018) The elk, the ass, the tapir, their hooves, and the falling sickness: a story of substitution and animal medical substances. J Glob Hist 13:46–68
Podgorny I (2019) Bureaucracy, instructions, and paperwork. The gathering of data about the three kingdoms of nature in the Americas, 1770–1815. Nuevo Mundo Mundos Nuevos.https://journals.openedition.org/nuevomundo/75454
Podgorny I (2020) La guerre, la paix et la querelle. Les sociétés paléontologiques d’Auvergne sous la Seconde Restauration. Colligo 3(3).https://perma.cc/C6ZK-TQF
Podgorny I (2021) Los argentinos vienen de los peces. Ensayo de filogenia nacional. Beatriz Viterbo, Rosario
Rafinesque C (1814) Principes fondamentaux de Somiologie ou les Loix de la nomenclature et de la classification des animaux et végétaux. Abate, Palermo
Rafinesque C (1815) Analyse de la Nature, ou tableau de l’univers et des corps organisés. Abate, Palermo
Rudwick M (1972) The meaning of fossils: essays in the history of paleontology. Elsevier, New York
Rudwick M (1992) Scenes from deep time: early pictorial images of the prehistoric world. Chicago University Press, Chicago
Rudwick M (1997a) Georges Cuvier, fossil bones, and geological catastrophes. New translations & interpretations of the primary texts. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Rudwick M (1997b) Recherches sur les ossements fossiles: Georges Cuvier et le collecte des alliés internationaux. In: Blanckaert C, Cohen C, Corsi P, Fischer J-L (eds) Le Muséum au premier siècle de son histoire. Archives/Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle, Paris, pp 591–606
Rupke N (1994) Richard Owen. Victorian naturalist. Yale University Press, New Haven
Simpson GG (1980) Splendid isolation. The curious history of South American mammals. Yale University Press, New Haven
Simpson GG (1984) Discoverers of the lost world: an account of some of those who brought back to life South American mammals long buried in the abyss of time. Yale University Press, New Haven
Tamborini M (2016) “If the Americans can do it, so can we”: how dinosaur bones shaped German paleontology. Hist Sci 54(3):225–256
Ure A (1829) A new system of geology: in which the great revolutions of the Earth and animated nature are reconciled at once to modern science and sacred history. Longman, Rees, Orme, Brown, & Green, London
Vergés M (2019) El dibujante de peces Manuel Clos y la impostura de Juan Baustista Bru. Naturalmente 24:47–53
von Baer K (1860) Über das Aussterben der Thierarten in physiologischer und nicht physiologischer Hinsicht überhaupt, und der Untergang von Arten, die mit den Menschen zusammen gelebt haben. Bull Acad des Sciences 3:1367–1396
von Zittel K (1901) History of geology and palæontology to the end of the nineteenth century. Scott, London
Zischler H, Hackethal S, Eckert C (2013) Die Erkundung Brasiliens: Friedrich Sellows unvollendete Reise. Galiani, Cologne
Acknowledgments
This chapter is part of the H2020-MSCA- EU RISE Project SciCOMove (Scientific Collections on the Move – Project Number 101007579) and the PIP 0153 (CONICET). I would like to thank the comments on earlier drafts of the chapter by Ana Barahona, Pietro Corsi, Margaret Lopes, and Richard Fariña.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Archivo Histórico del Museo de La Plata, Facultad de Ciencias Naturales y Museo, Universidad Nacional de La Plata/CONICET, La Plata, Argentina
Irina Podgorny
- Irina Podgorny
You can also search for this author inPubMed Google Scholar
Corresponding author
Correspondence toIrina Podgorny.
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Departamento de Biología Evolutiva, Facultad de Ciencias, UNAM, Mexico City, Mexico
Ana Barahona
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2022 Springer Nature Switzerland AG
About this entry
Cite this entry
Podgorny, I. (2022). Palaeontology in South America. In: Barahona, A. (eds) Handbook of the Historiography of Latin American Studies on the Life Sciences and Medicine. Historiographies of Science. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-74723-7_6
Download citation
Published:
Publisher Name:Springer, Cham
Print ISBN:978-3-030-74722-0
Online ISBN:978-3-030-74723-7
eBook Packages:Religion and PhilosophyReference Module Humanities and Social SciencesReference Module Humanities
Share this entry
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:
Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.
Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative