1116Accesses
6Altmetric
Abstract
Following the offshoring of production to developing countries by transnational corporations (TNCs), unions and non-governmental organisations (NGOs) have criticised working conditions at TNCs’ offshore factories. This has led to the emergence of two different approaches to operationalising TNC responsibilities for workers’ rights in developing countries: codes of conduct and global agreements. Despite the importance of this development, few studies have systematically compared the effects of these two different ways of dealing with workers’ rights. This article addresses this gap by analysing how codes of conduct and global agreements bothindependently andinteractively affect workers’ rights. We do this based on a qualitative study of the Sri Lankan operations of a Swedish TNC in Sri␣Lanka, and on interviews with union and NGO representatives actively involved in codes of conduct and global agreements. Our results indicate that global agreementsindependently address all the aspects included in codes of conduct, while also addressing additional, more process-oriented aspects of workers’ rights. Hence, on their own, global agreements seem to comprise the superior approach to promoting workers’ rights. Furthermore, our results indicate that promoting codes of conduct has negativeinteractive effects on global agreements. Based on these results, we argue that the current focus on codes of conduct is counterproductive for the promotion of workers’ rights.
This is a preview of subscription content,log in via an institution to check access.
Access this article
Subscribe and save
- Get 10 units per month
- Download Article/Chapter or eBook
- 1 Unit = 1 Article or 1 Chapter
- Cancel anytime
Buy Now
Price includes VAT (Japan)
Instant access to the full article PDF.
References
Ählström, J. and N. Egels-Zandén: 2007, ‚The Processes of Defining Corporate Responsibility: A Study of Swedish Garment Retailers’ Responsibility’,Business Strategy and the Environment (forthcoming)
Albrecht S., S. Deutsch: 2002, The Challenge of Economic Democracy: The Case of Sweden, in W. P. Woodworth (ed.),Economic Democracy: Essays and Research on Workers’ Empowerment (Sledgehammer Press, Pittsburgh, PA), pp. 71–92
Anner M., I. Greer, M. Hauptmeier, N. Lillie and N. Winchester: 2006, The Industrial Determinants of Transnational Solidarity: Global Interunion Politics in Three Sectors,European Journal of Industrial Relations,12(1), 7–27
Arthaud-Day M. L.: 2005, Transnational Corporate Social Responsibility: A Tri-Dimensional Approach to International CSR Research,Business Ethics Quarterly,15(1), 1–22
Bernstein P.: 1976, Necessary Elements for Effective Worker Participation in Decision-Making,Journal of Economic Issues,10(2), 490–522
Bernstein P.: 1980,Workplace Democratization: Its Internal Dynamics (Transaction Books, New Brunswick, NJ)
Bluestone B. and I. Bluestone: 1992,Negotiating the Future: A Labor Perspective on American Business (Basic Books, New York)
Blum F. H.: 1953,Toward a Democratic Work Process (Harper and Bros, New York)
Bondy K., D. Matten and J. Moon: 2004, The Adoption of Voluntary Codes of Conduct in MNCs: A Three-Country Comparative Study,Business and Society Review,109(4), 449–477
Braun R. and J. Gearhart: 2004, Who Should Code Your Conduct? Trade Union and NGO Differences in the Fight for Workers’ Rights,Development in Practice,14(1–2), 183–196
Broadhurst A.: 2000, Corporations and the Ethics of Social Responsibility: An Emerging Regime of Expansion and Compliance,Business Ethics: A European Review,9(2), 86–98
Brunsson N.: 2002,The Organization of Hypocrisy: Talk, Decisions and Actions in Organizations (Liber ekonomi, Malmö)
Burnett, E. and J. Mahon Jr.: 2001, ‚Monitoring Compliance with International Labor Standards’,Challenge March–April, 51–72
Carley M.: 2005, Global Agreements – State of Play,European Industrial Relations Review,381, 14–18
Carasco E. and J. Singh: 2003, The Content and Focus of the Codes of Ethics of the World’s Largest Transnational Corporations,Business and Society Review,108(1), 71–94
Cassell C., P. Johnson and K. Smith: 1997, Opening the Black Box: Corporate Codes of Ethics in Their Organizational Context,Journal of Business Ethics,16(10), 1077–1093
Chan A.: 1998, Labor Standards and Human Rights: The Case of Chinese Workers Under Market Socialism,Human Rights Quarterly,20(4), 886–904
Chan A.: 2000, Globalization, China’s Free (Read Bonded) Labour Market, and the Chinese Trade Unions,Asia Pacific Business Review,6(3–4), 260–281
Chan A. and R. J. S. Ross: 2003, Racing to the Bottom: International Trade without a Social Clause,Third World Quarterly,24(6), 1011–1028
Chan A. and R. A. Senser: 1997, China’s Troubled Workers,Foreign Affairs,76(2), 104–117
Christerson B. and R. P. Appelbaum: 1995, Global and Local Subcontracting: Space, Ethnicity, and the Organization of Apparel Production,World Development,23(8), 1363–1374
Cohen-Rosenthal E. and C. E. Burton: 1987,Mutual Gains: A Guide to Union-Management Cooperation (Praeger Publishers, New York)
Compa L.: 2004, Trade Unions, NGOs, and Corporate Codes of Conduct,Development in Practice,14(1–2), 210–215
Connor T.: 2004, Time to Scale Up Cooperation? Trade Unions, NGOs, and the International Anti-Sweatshop Movement,Development in Practice,14(1–2), 61–70
Cooke W. N.: 1991,Labor-Management Cooperation (W.E. Upjohn Institute, Kalamazoo)
Cowton C. J. and P. Thompson: 2000, Do Codes Make a Difference? The Case of Bank Lending and the Environment,Journal of Business Ethics,24(2), 165–178
Derber M.: 1970,The American Idea of Industrial Democracy, 1865–1965 (University of Illinois Press, Urbana)
Diller J.: 1999, A Social Conscience in the Global Marketplace? Labour Dimensions of Codes of Conduct, Social Labelling and Investor Initiatives,International Labour Review,138(2), 99–129
Eade D.: 2004, Editorial Overview,Development in Practice,14(1–2), 5–12
Eaton A. E.: 1990, The Extent and Determinants of Local Union Control of Participative Programs,Industrial and Labor Relations Review,43(5), 604–620
Egels-Zandén, N.: 2007, ‚Suppliers’ Compliance with MNCs’ Codes of Conduct: Behind the Scenes at Chinese Toy Suppliers’,Journal of Business Ethics (forthcoming)
Egels-Zandén N. and P. Hyllman: 2006, Exploring the Effects of Union-NGO Relationships on Corporate Responsibility: The Case of the Swedish Clean Clothes Campaign,Journal of Business Ethics,64(3), 303–316
Emmelhainz M. A. and R. J. Adams: 1999, The Apparel Industry Response to ‚Sweetshop’ Concerns: A Review and Analysis of Codes of Conduct,Journal of Supply Chain Management,35(3), 51–57
Fairbrother P. and N. Hammer: 2005, Global Unions – Past Efforts and Future Prospects,Relations Industrielles/Industrial Relations,60(3), 405–431
Florini A.: 2003, Business and Global Governance: The Growing Role of Corporate Codes of Conduct,Brookings Review,21(2), 4–8
French, J. L. and R. E. Wokutch: 2005, ‚Child Workers, Globalization and International Business Ethics: A Case Study in Brazil's Export-oriented Shoe Industry’,Business Ethics Quarterly,15(4), 615–640
Frenkel S.: 2001, Globalization, Athletic Footwear Commodity Chains and Employment Relations in China,Organization Studies,22(4), 531–562
Frenkel S. and S. Kim: 2004, Corporate Codes of Labour Practice and Employment Relations in Sports Shoe Contractor Factories in South Korea,Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources,42(1), 6–31
Frenkel S. and D. Scott: 2002, Compliance, Collaboration, and Codes of Labor Practice: Theadidas Connection,California Management Review,45(1), 29–49
Frundt H. J.: 2004, Unions Wrestle with Corporate Codes of Conduct,WorkingUSA,7(4), 36–69
Gallin D.: 2000,Trade Unions and NGOs: A Necessary Partnership for Social Development (United Nations Research Institute for Social Development, Geneva)
Graafland J. J.: 2002, Sourcing Ethics in the Textile Sector: The Case of C&A,Business Ethics: A European Review,11(3), 282–294
Greenberg, E. S.: 1975, ‚The Consequences of Worker Participation: A Clarification of the Theoretical Literature’,Social Science Quarterly September, 191–207
Guillén M., D. Melé and P. Murphy: 2002, European vs. American Approaches to Institutionalization of Business Ethics: The Spanish Case,Business Ethics: A European Review,11(2), 167–178
Hale A.: 2004, Beyond the Barriers: New Forms of Labour Internationalism,Development in Practice,14(1&2), 158–162
Hammer, N.: 2004, ‚International Framework Agreements: Overview and Key Issues’, Working paper presented at theIndustrial Relations in Europe Conference, Utrecht 2004
Hathcote J., I. -J. Nam: 1999, Advantages of Sourcing Apparel from China, Taiwan, South Korea and Mexico,International Trade Journal,13(2), 157–185
Healy M. and J. Iles: 2002, The Establishment and Enforcement of Codes,Journal of Business Ethics,39(1/2), 117–124
Henrekson, M. and U. Jakobsson: 2002, ‚The Transformation of Ownership Policy and Structure in Sweden: Convergence towards the Anglo-Saxon Model?’ SSE/EFI working paper series inEconomics and Finance, vol.␣469
Herbst P.: 1976,Alternatives to Hierarchies (Martinus Nijhoff Social Science Division, Leiden)
Hunnius G., G. D. Carson and J. Case: 1973,Workers’ Control (Vintage, New York)
ICFTU: 2004,Behind the Brand Names – Working Conditions and Labour Rights in Export Processing Zones (ICFTU, Geneva)
Jones M. T.: 2005, The Transnational Corporation, Corporate Social Responsibility and the ‚Outsourcing’ Debate,Journal of American Academy of Business,6(2), 91–97
Justice D. W.: 2003, Corporate Social Responsibility: Challenges and Opportunities for Trade Unionists,Labour Education,130, 1–13
Kaptein M.: 2004, Business Codes of Multinational Firms: What Do They Say?Journal of Business Ethics,50(1), 13–31
Kathryn G. and M. Miyake: 2001, Business Approaches to Combating Bribery: A Study of Codes of Conduct,Journal of Business Ethics,34(3/4), 161–173
Kolk A. and R. van Tulder: 2002a, Child Labor and Multinational Conduct: A Comparison of International Business and Stakeholder Codes,Journal of Business Ethics,36(3), 291–301
Kolk A. and R. van Tulder: 2002b, The Effectiveness of Self-Regulation: Corporate Codes of Conduct and Child Labour,European Management Journal,20(3), 260–271
Korpi W.: 1978, The Working Class in the Welfare Capitalism (Prisma, Kristianstad)
Leahy J. T.: 2001, Making Room for Labor in Business Ethics,Journal of Business Ethics,29(1–2), 33–43
Lee C. K.: 1998,Gender and the South China Miracle: Two Worlds of Factory Women (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
Lee C. K.: 1999, From Organized Dependence to Disorganized Despotism: Changing Labour Regimes in Chinese Factories,The China Quarterly,57, 44–71
Lipschutz R. D.: 2004, Sweating It Out: NGO Campaigns and Trade Union Empowerment,Development in Practice,14(1&2), 197–209
Meyer J. W. and B. Rowan: 1977, Institutionalized Organizations: Formal Structure as Myth and Ceremony,The American Journal of Sociology,83(2), 340–363
Michalos A. C.: 1997, Issues for Business Ethics in the Nineties and Beyond,Journal of Business Ethics,16(3), 219–230
Montoya I. and A. Richard: 1994, A Comparative Study of Codes of Ethics in Health Care Facilities and Energy Companies,Journal of Business Ethics,13(9), 713–717
Murphy D., D. Mathew: 2001,Nike and Global Labour Practices: A Case Study Prepared for the New Academy of Business Innovation Network for Socially Responsible Business (New Academy of Business, Bristol)
Murphy P. E.: 1995, Corporate Ethics Statements: Current Status and Future Prospects,Journal of Business Ethics,14(9), 727–735
Murray G. and G. Trudeau: 2004, Towards a Social Regulation of the Global Firm?Industrial Relations,59(1), 15–25
Nijhof A., S. Cludts, O. Fisscher and A. Laan: 2003, Measuring the Implementation of Codes of Conduct: An Assessment Method Based on a Process Approach of the Responsible Organisation,Journal of Business Ethics,45(1), 65–78
O’Rourke D.: 1997,Smoke from a Hired Gun: A Critique of Nike’s Labor and Environmental Auditing in Vietnam as Performed by Ernst & Young (Transnational Resource and Action Center, San Francisco, CA)
O’Rourke D.: 2000,Monitoring the Monitors: A Critque of PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) Labor Monitoring (Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Boston, MA)
O’Rourke D.: 2002, Monitoring the Monitors: A Critique of Third-Party Labor Monitoring, in R. Jenkins, R. Pearson and G. Seyfang (eds.),Corporate Responsibility and Labour Rights: Codes of Conduct in the Global Economy (Earthscan, London), pp. 196–208
O’Rourke D.: 2003, Outsourcing Regulation: Analyzing Nongovernmental Systems of Labor Standards and Monitoring,The Policy Study Journal,31(1), 1–29
Orton D. J. and K. E. Weick: 1990, Loosely Coupled Systems: A Reconceptualization,Academy of Management Review,15(2), 203–223
Pateman C.: 1970,Participation and Democratic Theory (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
Riisgaard L.: 2005. Industrial Framework Agreements: A New Model of Securing Workers Rights?Industrial Relations,44(4), 707–737
Roberts S.: 2003, Supply Chain Specific? Understanding the Patchy Success of Ethical Sourcing Initiatives,Journal of Business Ethics,44(2&3), 159–170
Roman J.: 2004, The Trade Union Solution or the NGO Problem? The Fight for Global Labour Rights,Development in Practice,14(1&2), 100–109
Schlegelmilch B., J. Houston: 1989, Corporate Codes of Ethics in Large U.K. Companies: An Empirical Investigation of Use, Content and Attitudes,European Journal of Marketing,23(6), 7–24
Schurman S. J. and A. E. Eaton: 1996, Labor and Workplace Democracy: Past, Present and Future,Labor Studies Journal,21(2), 3–26
Schwartz M.: 2002, A Code of Ethics for Corporate Code of Ethics,Journal of Business Ethics,41(1/2), 27–43
Sethi S. P.: 1999, Codes of Conduct for Multinational Corporations: An Idea Whose Time has Come,Business & Society Review,104(3), 225–241
Sethi S. P. and O. F. Williams: 2000, Creating and Implementing Global Codes of Conduct: An Assessment of the Sullivan Principles as a Role Model for Developing International Codes of Conduct – Lessons Learned and Unlearned,Business and Society Review,105(2), 169–200
Sethi S. P.: 2002, Standards for Corporate Conduct in the International Arena: Challenges and Opportunities for Multinational Corporations,Business and Society Review,107(1), 20–40
Simmons J. and W. Mares: 1983,Working Together (Knopf, New York)
Somers M. J.: 2001, Ethical Codes of Conduct and Organizational Context: A Study of the Relationship between Codes of Conduct,Journal of Business Ethics,30(2), 186–195
Tannenbaum A., B. Kavicic, M. Rosner, R. Vianello and G. Weiser: 1974,Hierarchy in Organizations (Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA)
Taylor T.: 2005, In Defence of Outsourcing,CATO Journal,25(2), 367–377
Thorsrud E.: 1977, Breaking Down Bureaucracy, in D. W. Vermilye (ed.),Relating Work and Education (Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA)
Valor C.: 2005, Corporate Social Responsibility and Corporate Citizenship: Towards Corporate Accountability,Business & Society Review,110(2), 191–212
Walker K. F.: 1974,Workers’ Participation in Management: Problems, Practice and Prospects (International Institute for Labor Studies, Geneva)
van Tulder R. and A. Kolk: 2001, Multinationality and Corporate Ethics: Codes of Conduct in the Sporting Goods Industry,Journal of International Business Studies,32(2), 267–283
Weaver G. R.: 1993, Corporate Codes of Ethics: Purpose, Process and Content Issues,Business and Society,32(1), 44–58
Weber M.: 1947,The Theory of Social and Economic Organization (Free Press, New York)
White B. J., B. R. Montgomery: 1980, Corporate Codes of Conduct,California Management Review,23(2), 80–87
Wills J.: 2002, Bargaining for the Space to Organize in the Global Economy: A Review of the Accor-IUF Trade Union Rights Agreement,Review of International Political Economy,9(4), 675–700
Wingborg M.: 2005,Lång väg till självklara rättigheter: Trelleborgs försök att hindra bildandet av en fackförening på Sri Lanka (SwedWatch and Fair Trade Center, Stockholm)
Winstanley D., J. Clark and H. Leeson: 2002, Approaches to Child Labour in the Supply Chain,Business Ethics: A European Review,11(3), 210–223
Witte J. F.: 1980,Democracy, Authority, and Alienation at Work: Workers’ Participation in an American Corporation (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
Zwerdling D.: 1978,Workplace Democracy (Harper-Colophon, New York)
Acknowledgement
We gratefully acknowledge the support of Mats Wingborg in collecting data for this study.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Centre for Business in Society, School of Business, Economics and Law at Göteborg University, Box 600, Gothenborg, SE-405 30, Sweden
Niklas Egels-Zandén
Centre for People and Organization, Stockholm School of Economics, Box 6501, Stockholm, SE-113 83, Sweden
Peter Hyllman
- Niklas Egels-Zandén
You can also search for this author inPubMed Google Scholar
- Peter Hyllman
You can also search for this author inPubMed Google Scholar
Corresponding author
Correspondence toNiklas Egels-Zandén.
Additional information
Niklas Egels-Zandén is a PhD student at the School of Business, Economics and Law at Göteborg University, Sweden. His areas of research are international business and coporate social responsibility, especially in relation to multinational corporations in developing countries. He has previously published in Journal of Business Ethics, Business Strategy and the Environment, and Journal of Corporate Citizenship.
Peter Hyllman is a research assistant at the Center for People and organization at the Stockholm School of Economics, Sweden. His areas of research are industrial relations, workplace democracy and employee relations, focusing on management-union relationships in transnational corporations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Egels-Zandén, N., Hyllman, P. Evaluating Strategies for Negotiating Workers’ Rights in Transnational Corporations: The Effects of Codes of Conduct and Global Agreements on Workplace Democracy.J Bus Ethics76, 207–223 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-006-9269-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
Share this article
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:
Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.
Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative