 | 1851 | | | Howden v St George's | Howden | misc260922 |
| May 1851 | | | Emmanuel College, Cambridge v Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge | Cambridge | misc638987 |
| 06 May 1851 | | | Winchester College v Winchester College Next XV | Ridding Field, Winchester | misc940758 |
| 07 May 1851 | | | Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge College Residents v Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge Town Residents | Cambridge | misc940759 |
| 12 May 1851 | | | Lord Guernsey's XI v R Grimston's XI | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | misc135841 |
| 13 May 1851 | | | Durham University North v Durham University South | The Racecourse, Durham | misc943098 |
| 13 May 1851 | | | Royal Horse Guards Blues v I Zingari | Kennington Oval, Kennington | misc167761 |
| 13 May 1851 | | | Winchester College v Winchester College Next XV | Ridding Field, Winchester | misc943097 |
| 17 May 1851 | | | Birmingham and Edgbaston Proprietary School v King Edward's School, Birmingham | Birmingham | misc954042 |
| 19 May 1851 | | | Earl of Stamford's XI v Lord Burghley's XI | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | misc135842 |
| 21 May 1851 | | | Manchester v Liverpool | Botanical Gardens, Manchester | misc95037 |
| 24 May 1851 | | # | King Edward's School, Birmingham v Bromsgrove School | King Edward's School Birmingham Ground, Birmingham | misc688848 |
| 27 May 1851 | | | Denne Park v I Zingari | CG Eversfield's Ground, Denne Park | misc167762 |
| Jun 1851 | | | Yorkshire v Nottingham Commercial Club | Hyde Park Ground, Sheffield | misc168842 |
| 02 Jun 1851 | | | Birmingham v Shrewsbury | Edgbaston Reservoir Ground, Birmingham | misc169549 |
| 02 Jun 1851 | | | Cambridge University v Quidnuncs | FP Fenner's Ground, Cambridge | misc |
| 06 Jun 1851 | | | Bishop's Stortford v Quidnuncs | Cricketfield Lane, Bishop's Stortford | misc |
| 07 Jun 1851 | | | Royal Horse Guards Blues v I Zingari | Windsor Cavalry Barracks, Windsor | misc167763 |
| 09 Jun 1851 | | | Gravesend v Town Malling | Bat and Ball Ground, Gravesend | misc168843 |
| 09 Jun 1851 | | | Leeds v Bradford | Leeds | misc168844 |
| 11 Jun 1851 | | | Penshurst v Wateringbury | Penshurst Park, Penshurst | misc169550 |
| 13 Jun 1851 | | | Town Malling v Hollingbourne | Malling | misc168845 |
| 14 Jun 1851 | | | Harrow School v Old Harrovians | Harrow School Cricket Ground, Harrow-on-the-Hill | misc95039 |
| 14 Jun 1851 | | | I Zingari v Lords and Commons | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | misc135843 |
| 16 Jun 1851 | | | Streatham v Quidnuncs | Streatham Cricket Club Ground, Streatham | misc |
| 18 Jun 1851 | | | Bullingdon v I Zingari | Magdalen Ground, Oxford | misc95040 |
| 20 Jun 1851 | | | Eton College v Marylebone Cricket Club | Agar's Plough, Eton College | misc95041 |
| 21 Jun 1851 | | | Guards Club v I Zingari | Kennington Oval, Kennington | misc167764 |
| 21 Jun 1851 | | | Harrow School v Quidnuncs | Harrow School Cricket Ground, Harrow-on-the-Hill | misc95042 |
| 23 Jun 1851 | | | Town Malling v Gravesend | Old County Ground, Town Malling | misc168846 |
| 24 Jun 1851 | | | Eton College v Royal Horse Guards Blues | Agar's Plough, Eton College | misc165998 |
| 25 Jun 1851 | | | Glossop v Sheffield | North Road, Glossop | misc168847 |
| 25 Jun 1851 | | | Leeds Clarence v Huddersfield | Victoria Ground, Leeds | misc168848 |
| 25 Jun 1851 | | | Rugby School v Haileybury College | Rugby School Ground, Rugby | misc228610 |
| 25 Jun 1851 | | | Westminster School v I Zingari | Vincent Square, Westminster | misc106471 |
| 26 Jun 1851 | | | Marylebone Cricket Club v Rugby School | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | misc106472 |
| 27 Jun 1851 | | # | King Edward's School, Birmingham v Old Edwardians | King Edward's School Birmingham Ground, Birmingham | misc651521 |
| 28 Jun 1851 | | | Eton College v Quidnuncs | Agar's Plough, Eton College | misc95043 |
| 30 Jun 1851 | | | Bradford v Leeds | Horton Lane, Bradford | misc168849 |
| Jul 1851 | | | Manchester v Chester | Botanical Gardens, Manchester | misc124316 |
| 01 Jul 1851 | | | Harrow School v Harrow Town | Harrow School Cricket Ground, Harrow-on-the-Hill | misc165999 |
| 02 Jul 1851 | | | Manchester v Shrewsbury | Botanical Gardens, Manchester | misc124315 |
| 05 Jul 1851 | | | Harrow School v I Zingari | Harrow School Cricket Ground, Harrow-on-the-Hill | misc95044 |
| 08 Jul 1851 | | | Eton College v I Zingari | Agar's Plough, Eton College | misc95045 |
| 09 Jul 1851 | | | Farnham v Godalming | Holt Pound Cricket Ground, Wrecclesham | misc169551 |
| 10 Jul 1851 | | | Eton College v Old Etonians | Agar's Plough, Eton College | misc95046 |
| 12 Jul 1851 | | | Harrow School v H Fiennes' Oxford XI | Harrow School Cricket Ground, Harrow-on-the-Hill | misc166000 |
| 12 Jul 1851 | | | Houses of Parliament v I Zingari | Kennington Oval, Kennington | misc167765 |
| 12 Jul 1851 | | | Westminster School v Charterhouse School | Vincent Square, Westminster | misc106473 |
| 15 Jul 1851 | | | Eton College v King's College, Cambridge | Agar's Plough, Eton College | misc166002 |
| 15 Jul 1851 | | | Harrow School v Hampstead | Harrow School Cricket Ground, Harrow-on-the-Hill | misc166001 |
| 17 Jul 1851 | | | Sevenoaks Vine v Kent XI | The Vine, Sevenoaks | misc169552 |
| 17 Jul 1851 | | | Westminster School v Marylebone Cricket Club | Vincent Square, Westminster | misc106474 |
| 21 Jul 1851 | | | Knaresborough v York | Crag Top, Knaresborough | misc169553 |
| 23 Jul 1851 | | | Henfield v Lewes | The Common, Henfield | misc170661 |
| 24 Jul 1851 | | | Marylebone Cricket Club v Leicestershire | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | misc87244 |
| 26 Jul 1851 | | | Harrow School v Marylebone Cricket Club | Harrow School Cricket Ground, Harrow-on-the-Hill | misc95047 |
| 28 Jul 1851 | | | Town Malling v Stilebridge | Old County Ground, Town Malling | misc168851 |
| 30 Jul 1851 | | | Harrow School v Winchester College | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | misc95048 |
| 31 Jul 1851 | | | West Kent v Sevenoaks Vine | West Kent Cricket Club Ground, Chislehurst | misc993257 |
| Aug 1851 | | | Liverpool v Cestrian Club | Wavertree Road Ground, Liverpool | misc173252 |
| 01 Aug 1851 | | | Eton College v Harrow School | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | misc84455 |
| 02 Aug 1851 | | | Eton College v Winchester College | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | misc95049 |
| 06 Aug 1851 | | | Liverpool v Manchester | Wavertree Road Ground, Liverpool | misc95050 |
| 07 Aug 1851 | | | Canterbury v Sevenoaks Vine | St Lawrence Ground, Canterbury | misc168852 |
| 07 Aug 1851 | | | Gentlemen of Surrey v Gentlemen of Sussex | Broadwater Park, Godalming | misc95051 |
| 07 Aug 1851 | | | Royal Artillery v I Zingari | Barrack Field, Woolwich | misc106475 |
| 09 Aug 1851 | | | 2nd Battalion Scots Fusilier Guards v 3rd Battalion Grenadier Guards | Kennington Oval, Kennington | misc651522 |
| 10 Aug 1851 | | | Birmingham v Burton-on-Trent | Small Heath Ground, Birmingham | misc651523 |
| 11 Aug 1851 | | | Trinity College, Cambridge v Cambridge University | FP Fenner's Ground, Cambridge | misc |
| 13 Aug 1851 | | | Gentlemen of Kent v I Zingari | St Lawrence Ground, Canterbury | misc95052 |
| 14 Aug 1851 | | | Lewes v Henfield | Priory Ground, Lewes | misc170662 |
| 18 Aug 1851 | | | Sevenoaks Vine v I Zingari | The Vine, Sevenoaks | misc167766 |
| 19 Aug 1851 | | | Surrey Club v Mitcham | Kennington Oval, Kennington | misc168853 |
| 21 Aug 1851 | | | Leicestershire v Marylebone Cricket Club | Barker's Ground, Leicester | misc87245 |
| 23 Aug 1851 | | | Gentlemen of Huddersfield v Leeds Clarence | Huddersfield | misc170663 |
| 25 Aug 1851 | | | Gentlemen of Sussex v Gentlemen of Surrey | E Tredcroft's Ground, Warnham Court, Horsham | misc95053 |
| 27 Aug 1851 | | | Manchester v Westminster | Botanical Gardens, Manchester | misc124317 |
| 28 Aug 1851 | | | Brighton v Reigate | Royal New Ground, Brighton | misc169554 |
| 28 Aug 1851 | | | Southwell v I Zingari | Brackenhurst Cricket Ground, Southwell | misc167767 |
| 28 Aug 1851 | | | York v Knaresborough | Toft Green Ground, York | misc169555 |
| Sep 1851 | | | Bullingdon v Quidnuncs | Bullingdon Green, Oxford | misc |
| 03 Sep 1851 | | | Shrewsbury v Manchester | The Racecourse, Shrewsbury | misc124318 |
| 04 Sep 1851 | | | Gentlemen of Warwickshire v I Zingari | Parr and Wisden's Ground, Leamington Spa | misc95054 |
| 11 Sep 1851 | | | Holkham v I Zingari | Earl of Leicester's Ground, Holkham | misc167768 |
| 13 Sep 1851 | | | Repton School Past and Present v Swepstone and Neighbourhood | Repton School Ground, Repton | misc665834 |
| 15 Sep 1851 | | | Gentlemen of Sussex v Gentlemen of England | Royal Brunswick Ground, Hove | misc95055 |
| 15 Sep 1851 | | | Middlesex XI v Hampshire XI | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | misc135844 |
| 16 Sep 1851 | | | Norfolk v Marylebone Cricket Club | Earl of Leicester's Ground, Holkham | misc95056 |
| 18 Sep 1851 | | | Knaresborough v Sheffield | Crag Top, Knaresborough | misc168854 |
| 23 Sep 1851 | | | Farnham v North Hants Club | Holt Pound Cricket Ground, Wrecclesham | misc169556 |
| 23 Sep 1851 | | | South Hants Club v Players of Hampshire | Day's (Antelope) Ground, Southampton | misc169557 |
The scorecards marked with a # are potted scores only.
