Still others were sayingThis phrase indicates that there were multiple groups among the Israelites facing different issues. The context of
Nehemiah 5 reveals a time of economic distress and social injustice among the returned exiles. The phrase suggests a communal outcry, highlighting the widespread nature of the problem. This communal aspect is reminiscent of other biblical instances where the people of Israel collectively express their grievances, such as in
Exodus 2:23, where the Israelites groan under Egyptian bondage.
We have borrowed money
Borrowing money in ancient times often led to severe consequences, including servitude or loss of property. The Law of Moses provided guidelines for lending and borrowing, emphasizing fairness and compassion (Exodus 22:25-27,Leviticus 25:35-37). The need to borrow indicates a failure in the community to uphold these laws, reflecting a deeper spiritual and social crisis. This situation parallels the warnings in Proverbs about the dangers of debt (Proverbs 22:7).
to pay the king’s tax
The king referred to here is likely Artaxerxes I of Persia, under whose reign Nehemiah served as governor. The Persian Empire imposed heavy taxes on its provinces, which could be burdensome for the local populations. This taxation system is corroborated by historical records from the Persian period, which describe the administrative and fiscal policies of the empire. The burden of taxation is a recurring theme in the Bible, as seen in1 Samuel 8:10-18, where Samuel warns the Israelites about the demands a king would place on them.
on our fields and vineyards
Fields and vineyards were vital to the agrarian economy of ancient Israel, representing both sustenance and wealth. The loss or mortgaging of these lands would have been devastating, threatening the livelihood and heritage of families. This situation echoes the warnings inDeuteronomy 28:30-33 about the consequences of disobedience to God’s covenant, where foreign powers would consume the produce of the land. The mention of fields and vineyards also evokes the imagery of the Promised Land, a place of abundance and blessing, now under threat due to external pressures and internal failings.
Persons / Places / Events
1.
NehemiahThe central figure in the book, Nehemiah is a Jewish leader who is serving as the governor of Judah. He is known for his leadership in rebuilding the walls of Jerusalem and addressing social injustices among the people.
2.
The Jewish PeopleThe community in Jerusalem, including those who are struggling financially and are burdened by debt and taxes.
3.
The King’s TaxRefers to the financial obligations imposed by the Persian Empire on its subjects, which were a significant burden on the people of Judah.
4.
Fields and VineyardsRepresents the primary means of livelihood for the Jewish people, which were under threat due to the financial pressures they faced.
5.
JerusalemThe city where these events are taking place, significant as the center of Jewish worship and identity.
Teaching Points
The Burden of DebtFinancial burdens can lead to significant stress and hardship. It is important to seek wise counsel and make prudent financial decisions to avoid unnecessary debt.
Social Justice and CompassionAs Christians, we are called to be aware of the injustices around us and to act with compassion and fairness, especially towards those who are economically disadvantaged.
Leadership and ResponsibilityNehemiah’s response to the plight of his people teaches us about the importance of responsible leadership that prioritizes the well-being of the community.
Trust in God’s ProvisionIn times of financial difficulty, it is crucial to trust in God’s provision and to seek His guidance in managing resources.
Community SupportThe church community should be a place where members support one another, especially in times of financial need, reflecting the early church’s practice of sharing resources.
Bible Study Questions and Answers
1.What is the meaning of Nehemiah 5:4?
2.How does Nehemiah 5:4 illustrate the burden of debt on God's people?
3.What lessons about financial stewardship can we learn from Nehemiah 5:4?
4.How does Nehemiah 5:4 connect with Proverbs' teachings on debt and lending?
5.In what ways can we support those struggling financially, as seen in Nehemiah 5:4?
6.How can we apply Nehemiah 5:4 to address economic injustices in our communities?
7.What historical context surrounds Nehemiah 5:4 and its economic implications for the Israelites?
8.How does Nehemiah 5:4 reflect on social justice issues in biblical times?
9.What theological lessons can be drawn from Nehemiah 5:4 regarding debt and financial responsibility?
10.What are the top 10 Lessons from Nehemiah 5?
11.Nehemiah 5:7 suggests interest-taking was widespread despite Mosaic Law prohibitions (e.g., Exodus 22:25); how can this contradiction be reconciled?
12.In Nehemiah 5:4-5, why do no contemporary records outside the Bible mention Jewish families losing their children to servitude under Persian rule?
13.In Nehemiah 5:3, how could a widespread famine have occurred without more historical or archaeological evidence supporting such socio-economic turmoil in Jerusalem at that time?
14.What does the Bible say about handling debt?What Does Nehemiah 5:4 Mean
Still others were saying• Nehemiah records a chorus of complaints; this third group speaks up after those who lacked grain (Nehemiah 5:2) and those who mortgaged property (Nehemiah 5:3).
• Their words widen the picture of distress, showing that hardship was not isolated but widespread—much like the groaning of Israel under Pharaoh (Exodus 2:23-24) or the lament of the returned exiles inEzra 9:4.
• By including “others,” Scripture underscores unity in suffering and sets the stage for Nehemiah’s corporate response (Nehemiah 5:6-11; cf.1 Corinthians 12:26).
We have borrowed money• Debt signals desperation; the people resorted to loans because ordinary means had failed.
– The law warned that Israel would become a borrower, not a lender, when unfaithful (Deuteronomy 28:43-45).
– Proverbs cautions, “The borrower is slave to the lender” (Proverbs 22:7), a reality now felt in Jerusalem.
• God’s heart is for generosity, not exploitation. Commands to lend without interest (Exodus 22:25;Leviticus 25:35-37) stand in sharp contrast to the oppressive terms these families faced.
• Nehemiah soon rebukes the nobles for exacting interest (Nehemiah 5:7-10), echoing earlier prophets who condemned economic injustice (Isaiah 5:8;Amos 2:6-7).
To pay the king’s tax• The Persian empire required land taxes, a burden that fell hardest on smallholders. Ezra’s contemporaries already knew such levies could “damage the revenue of the king” if unpaid (Ezra 4:13).
• Taxation had long been a sore point in Israelite history; Samuel warned that kings would “take a tenth of your grain and your vintage” (1 Samuel 8:15).
• By specifying “the king’s,” the text highlights foreign domination. Even in their own land, the returned exiles served another ruler (cf.Nehemiah 9:36-37).
• This financial strain threatened both worship (tithes) and livelihood, mirroring the later poll-tax crisis under Caesar that provoked Jesus’ famous “Render to Caesar” teaching (Matthew 22:17-21).
On our fields and vineyards• Fields and vineyards were covenant gifts (Deuteronomy 6:10-11). Losing them jeopardized family inheritance, a central component of God’s promise (Numbers 36:7-9).
• Such property symbolized stability and joy—vineyards often picture blessing (Psalm 128:3;Micah 4:4). To stake them for debt was to mortgage hope itself.
• The scene recalls Naboth, who refused to sell “the inheritance of my fathers” (1 Kings 21:3). Here, however, circumstances forced the people to pledge what should have remained in the family.
• Nehemiah later ensures restoration, compelling lenders to give back fields, vineyards, olive groves, and houses (Nehemiah 5:11), fulfilling the Jubilee spirit (Leviticus 25:10).
summaryNehemiah 5:4 exposes a chain reaction of hardship: widespread complaint, desperate borrowing, oppressive taxation, and threatened inheritance. Literally read, the verse shows families pushed to pledge their God-given land just to satisfy imperial demands. The complaint becomes a catalyst for righteous leadership, as Nehemiah confronts economic injustice and restores covenant faithfulness. The passage reminds believers today that God hears the cry of the oppressed, opposes exploitative systems, and calls His people to practical, compassionate action grounded in His unchanging Word.
(4)
We have borrowed money for the king's tribute.--Literally,
we have made our fields and vineyards answerable for the payment of the Persian tribute. They had pledged the coming produce.
Verse 4. -
The king's tribute. Judaea, like other Persian provinces, had to pay a tribute, partly in money and partly in kind, yearly to the Persian monarch (see the comment on Ezra 4:13); but there is no reason to believe that this burthen was generally felt as oppressive, nor that it was heavier in Judaea than elsewhere. But by the very poor even a small amount of direct taxation is felt as a grievance; and the necessity of meeting the demands of the tax-gatherer was in the ancient world often the turning-point, which compelled the contracting of a debt (Liv., 2:23); and so it seems to have been with these complainants,
Parallel Commentaries ...
Hebrew
Still othersאֲשֶׁ֣ר(’ă·šer)Pronoun - relative
Strong's 834:Who, which, what, that, when, where, how, because, in order thatwere saying,אֹמְרִ֔ים(’ō·mə·rîm)Verb - Qal - Participle - masculine plural
Strong's 559:To utter, say“We have borrowedלָוִ֥ינוּ(lā·wî·nū)Verb - Qal - Perfect - first person common plural
Strong's 3867:To twine, to unite, to remain, to borrow, to lendmoney [to pay]כֶ֖סֶף(ḵe·sep̄)Noun - masculine singular
Strong's 3701:Silver, moneythe king'sהַמֶּ֑לֶךְ(ham·me·leḵ)Article | Noun - masculine singular
Strong's 4428:A kingtaxלְמִדַּ֣ת(lə·mid·daṯ)Preposition-l | Noun - feminine singular construct
Strong's 4060:Extension, height, breadth, a measure, a portion, a vestment, tribute[on] our fieldsשְׂדֹתֵ֖ינוּ(śə·ḏō·ṯê·nū)Noun - masculine plural construct | first person common plural
Strong's 7704:Field, landand vineyards.וּכְרָמֵֽינוּ׃(ū·ḵə·rā·mê·nū)Conjunctive waw | Noun - masculine plural construct | first person common plural
Strong's 3754:A garden, vineyard
Links
Nehemiah 5:4 NIVNehemiah 5:4 NLTNehemiah 5:4 ESVNehemiah 5:4 NASBNehemiah 5:4 KJV
Nehemiah 5:4 BibleApps.comNehemiah 5:4 Biblia ParalelaNehemiah 5:4 Chinese BibleNehemiah 5:4 French BibleNehemiah 5:4 Catholic Bible
OT History: Nehemiah 5:4 There were also that said We have (Neh Ne)