Gilead remained beyond the Jordan.Gilead refers to a region east of the Jordan River, often associated with the tribes of Gad and the half-tribe of Manasseh. This phrase indicates that these tribes did not participate in the battle against Sisera, choosing instead to stay in their territory. Historically, the area of Gilead was known for its balm, a valuable commodity, suggesting a focus on trade and economic stability over military engagement. The decision to remain "beyond the Jordan" highlights a division among the Israelite tribes, reflecting a lack of unity during the time of the Judges. This division can be seen as a recurring theme in Israel's history, where geographical and tribal loyalties sometimes took precedence over national unity.
Dan, why did you linger by the ships?
The tribe of Dan was originally allocated land in the central coastal region of Israel, but due to pressure from the Philistines, they later migrated northward. The mention of "lingering by the ships" suggests a preoccupation with maritime activities or trade, possibly indicating a reluctance to engage in the inland conflict. This phrase underscores the challenges faced by the tribe of Dan, who struggled to secure their inheritance and often found themselves in conflict with surrounding peoples. The rhetorical question implies a critique of their priorities, as they chose economic pursuits over joining their fellow Israelites in battle. This can be seen as a reflection of the broader theme of Israel's struggle to fully possess the land and remain faithful to their covenantal responsibilities.
Asher stayed at the coast and remained in his harbors.
The tribe of Asher was located along the northern coast of Israel, an area known for its fertile land and access to the Mediterranean Sea. By "staying at the coast," Asher is depicted as choosing the comfort and security of their established settlements over participating in the conflict. The mention of "harbors" suggests a focus on trade and economic prosperity, similar to Dan. This decision reflects the challenges of tribalism and the temptation to prioritize local interests over national concerns. The coastal location of Asher also made them more susceptible to influence from neighboring Canaanite cities, which may have contributed to their reluctance to engage in the battle. This highlights the ongoing struggle for Israel to maintain its distinct identity amidst surrounding cultures.
Persons / Places / Events
1.
GileadA region east of the Jordan River, known for its balm and rugged terrain. In this context, it represents the tribes of Reuben and Gad, who chose to settle there rather than join the battle.
2.
DanOne of the tribes of Israel, originally allocated land in the central coastal region. Here, they are criticized for staying with their ships instead of joining the fight.
3.
AsherAnother tribe of Israel, located along the northern coast. They are noted for remaining in their harbors, indicating a lack of participation in the battle.
4.
The Jordan RiverA significant geographical and spiritual boundary in Israel, often symbolizing a division between commitment and complacency.
5.
The BattleThe context of this verse is the Song of Deborah, celebrating the victory over the Canaanite king Jabin and his commander Sisera. The tribes' participation or lack thereof is highlighted.
Teaching Points
Commitment to God's CallThe tribes' reluctance to join the battle serves as a reminder of the importance of responding to God's call with action, not excuses.
Unity in the Body of ChristJust as the tribes were expected to unite against a common enemy, Christians are called to work together in spiritual battles, supporting one another in faith.
Avoiding ComplacencyThe comfort and security of Gilead, Dan, and Asher can symbolize spiritual complacency. Believers are encouraged to step out of their comfort zones to fulfill God's purposes.
The Cost of InactionThe tribes' inaction had consequences for their reputation and spiritual legacy. Similarly, failing to act on God's directives can lead to missed opportunities for growth and blessing.
Bible Study Questions and Answers
1.What is the meaning of Judges 5:17?
2.Why did "Gilead" and "Dan" remain inactive during the battle in Judges 5:17?
3.How can we avoid complacency like "Gilead" and "Dan" in our faith?
4.What other biblical examples show consequences of inaction in God's work?
5.How does Judges 5:17 challenge us to participate in God's plans today?
6.What steps can we take to ensure active involvement in our church community?
7.Why did Asher remain on the coast instead of joining the battle in Judges 5:17?
8.What does Judges 5:17 reveal about tribal unity in ancient Israel?
9.How does Judges 5:17 reflect the historical context of Israel's tribal divisions?
10.What are the top 10 Lessons from Judges 5?
11.What are Jacob's prophecies in the Bible?
12.What are the names and meanings of Israel's twelve tribes?
13.Judges 5:15-17: Does the criticism of certain tribes for not joining the battle suggest editorial bias or political propaganda?
14.What are Jacob's prophetic blessings for his sons?What Does Judges 5:17 Mean
Gilead remained beyond the Jordan.“Gilead remained beyond the Jordan.” (Judges 5:17)
• The name “Gilead” evokes the territory east of the Jordan where Gad and the half-tribe of Manasseh settled (Numbers 32:1-5;Joshua 22:1-4). Deborah’s song points out that those brethren, geographically separated, chose comfort over covenant duty.
• Their inheritance was legitimate, yet they allowed distance to dull devotion. While Naphtali and Zebulun “risked their lives on the heights of the battlefield” (Judges 5:18), Gilead watched from across the river.
• The verse underscores the sobering truth that convenience often competes with obedience. Physical borders need not become spiritual barriers, but here they did (compareProverbs 24:10).
Dan, why did you linger by the ships?“Dan, why did you linger by the ships?” (Judges 5:17)
• Dan’s allotted land touched the Mediterranean (Joshua 19:40-46). Commerce and shipping held appeal, and the tribe chose docks over duty.
• Their hesitation foreshadowed later compromise: unable to secure their coastal inheritance, they migrated northward inJudges 18:1-2. A pattern of passivity began here.
• The rhetorical question exposes misplaced priorities. While God’s people battled oppression (Judges 4:6-7), Dan busied itself with trade. CompareMatthew 6:33—kingdom first, everything else second.
• The song challenges every believer: profitable pursuits are not wrong, but they must never eclipse God’s call (Luke 12:15-21).
Asher stayed at the coast and remained in his harbors.“Asher stayed at the coast and remained in his harbors.” (Judges 5:17)
• Asher’s rich coastal territory stretched from Carmel to Sidon (Joshua 19:24-31). Fertile plains and safe coves promised prosperity, yet the tribe failed to drive out the Canaanites (Judges 1:31-32).
• Comfort bred complacency. As Sisera’s tyranny threatened Israel (Judges 4:2-3), Asher clung to stability. The word picture of “harbors” illustrates a self-imposed safe zone.
• God never intended His people to anchor in ease while brothers bleed (1 John 3:17). Asher’s example teaches that security outside God’s will is insecurity in disguise (Psalm 20:7).
• Cross-checkDeuteronomy 20:8—fearful hearts can weaken an army. Asher’s absence marked a lost moment to honor the Lord.
summaryJudges 5:17 spotlights three tribes that chose the sidelines. Gilead let geography excuse disengagement, Dan let business blur obligations, and Asher let comfort cancel courage. Their stories caution us against settling, lingering, and staying when God calls us to stand, move, and fight in faith.
(17)
Gilead abode beyond Jordan.--Gilead was the son of Machir, and grandson of Manasseh. The name is here probably meant to include Gad, as well as the half-tribe of Manasseh. The word "abode" means "stayed quietly" (
Psalm 16:9), and is rendered
qniesce-batin the Vulgate.
Why did Dan remain in ships?--The sudden question is very picturesque. The other rendering, "Why did Dan fear the ships (of the enemy)? "is untenable. The possession of Joppa. one of the few seaports of Palestine, naturally influenced the pursuits of the tribe (Joshua 19:46;2Chronicles 2:16;Ezra 3:7); but whether they are here reproached for absorption in commerce, or for cowardice in taking refuge in their ships, is uncertain. The word rendered "remain" often involves a notion of "alarm" (Deuteronomy 32:27).If the Danite migration (Judges 18) had by this time occurred, it is almost impossible that they should not have rendered some assistance to the revolt of the northern tribes. The fact that it is not here alluded to shows the extremely early date at which this narrative must be placed. . . .
Verse 17. -
In ships. The celebrated hat. hour of Joppa (
Jonah 1:3), now Jaffa, was in the tribe of Dan.
His breaches. The creeks and bays where they kept their fishing. boats.
Parallel Commentaries ...
Hebrew
Gileadגִּלְעָ֗ד(gil·‘āḏ)Noun - proper - feminine singular
Strong's 1568:Gilead -- a region in Palestine, also the name of several Israelitesremainedשָׁכֵ֔ן(šā·ḵên)Verb - Qal - Perfect - third person masculine singular
Strong's 7931:To settle down, abide, dwellbeyondבְּעֵ֤בֶר(bə·‘ê·ḇer)Preposition-b | Noun - masculine singular construct
Strong's 5676:A region across, on the opposite sidethe Jordan.הַיַּרְדֵּן֙(hay·yar·dên)Article | Noun - proper - feminine singular
Strong's 3383:Jordan -- the principal river of PalestineDan,וְדָ֕ן(wə·ḏān)Conjunctive waw | Noun - proper - masculine singular
Strong's 1835:Dan -- 'judge', a son of Jacob, also a place in Northern Israelwhyלָ֥מָּה(lām·māh)Interrogative
Strong's 4100:What?, what!, indefinitely whatdid you lingerיָג֖וּר(yā·ḡūr)Verb - Qal - Imperfect - third person masculine singular
Strong's 1481:To turn aside from the road, sojourn, to shrink, fear, to gather for, hostilityby the ships?אֳנִיּ֑וֹת(’o·nî·yō·wṯ)Noun - feminine plural
Strong's 591:A shipAsherאָשֵׁ֗ר(’ā·šêr)Noun - proper - masculine singular
Strong's 836:Asher -- 'happy one', a son of Jacob, also the tribe descended from him, also perhaps a city in Palestinestayedיָשַׁב֙(yā·šaḇ)Verb - Qal - Perfect - third person masculine singular
Strong's 3427:To sit down, to dwell, to remain, to settle, to marryat the coastלְח֣וֹף(lə·ḥō·wp̄)Preposition-l | Noun - masculine singular construct
Strong's 2348:Shore, coastand remainedיִשְׁכּֽוֹן׃(yiš·kō·wn)Verb - Qal - Imperfect - third person masculine singular
Strong's 7931:To settle down, abide, dwellinוְעַ֥ל(wə·‘al)Conjunctive waw | Preposition
Strong's 5921:Above, over, upon, againsthis harbors.מִפְרָצָ֖יו(mip̄·rā·ṣāw)Noun - masculine plural construct | third person masculine singular
Strong's 4664:A break, a haven
Links
Judges 5:17 NIVJudges 5:17 NLTJudges 5:17 ESVJudges 5:17 NASBJudges 5:17 KJV
Judges 5:17 BibleApps.comJudges 5:17 Biblia ParalelaJudges 5:17 Chinese BibleJudges 5:17 French BibleJudges 5:17 Catholic Bible
OT History: Judges 5:17 Gilead lived beyond the Jordan (Jd Judg. Jdg)