There is an evil I have seen under the sun—The phrase "under the sun" is a recurring theme in Ecclesiastes, emphasizing the earthly, temporal perspective of human life. It suggests a viewpoint limited to the material world, often highlighting the futility and vanity of human endeavors without divine perspective. The "evil" mentioned here refers to a moral or ethical wrong, something that disrupts the natural order or justice. This aligns with the broader theme of Ecclesiastes, which often reflects on the apparent injustices and absurdities of life.
an error that proceeds from the ruler:
The "error" indicates a mistake or misjudgment, particularly in leadership. In ancient Israel and surrounding cultures, rulers were expected to uphold justice and wisdom. When a ruler errs, it can have widespread consequences, affecting the entire nation. This reflects the biblical principle that leadership carries significant responsibility and accountability (Proverbs 29:2). The mention of a ruler connects to the broader biblical narrative of kingship, where leaders like David and Solomon are both celebrated and critiqued for their governance. It also foreshadows the perfect rule of Jesus Christ, the ultimate King, who embodies wisdom and justice (Isaiah 9:6-7).
Persons / Places / Events
1.
SolomonTraditionally considered the author of Ecclesiastes, Solomon was the king of Israel known for his wisdom, wealth, and writings. His reflections in Ecclesiastes often explore the meaning of life and the human condition.
2.
RulerThe term "ruler" in this context refers to those in positions of authority or leadership. The verse highlights the potential for error and folly even among those who govern.
3.
Under the SunA phrase frequently used in Ecclesiastes to denote life on earth, emphasizing the temporal and often perplexing nature of worldly experiences.
Teaching Points
The Fallibility of Human LeadershipEven the most powerful leaders are prone to error and folly. This should remind us of the importance of humility and seeking God's wisdom in positions of authority.
The Impact of Leadership on SocietyThe actions and decisions of rulers can have profound effects on their people. This underscores the need for leaders to act justly and wisely.
The Importance of DiscernmentAs believers, we must discern the actions of those in authority and hold them accountable, while also praying for their guidance and wisdom.
The Sovereignty of GodDespite the errors of human rulers, God remains sovereign. We can trust that He is ultimately in control, even when earthly leadership fails.
The Call to Pray for LeadersScripture calls us to pray for those in authority, recognizing their need for divine guidance to avoid the errors that Solomon observed.
Bible Study Questions and Answers
1.What is the meaning of Ecclesiastes 10:5?
2.How does Ecclesiastes 10:5 illustrate the consequences of foolish leadership decisions?
3.What examples today reflect the "error that proceeds from the ruler"?
4.How can we apply Ecclesiastes 10:5 to discern leadership qualities?
5.Which other Scriptures warn against the dangers of foolishness in leadership?
6.How can believers respond to unjust leadership as described in Ecclesiastes 10:5?
7.What does Ecclesiastes 10:5 reveal about the nature of human folly and leadership?
8.How does Ecclesiastes 10:5 challenge our understanding of justice and fairness in the world?
9.Why does God allow folly to be set in high places, as stated in Ecclesiastes 10:5?
10.What are the top 10 Lessons from Ecclesiastes 10?
11.What are the main themes of the Bible's books?
12.If Satan is the source of evil, why does God allow him to exist instead of destroying him immediately?
13.Ecclesiastes 1:5 - The verse suggests a geocentric view of the sun moving around the earth; does this contradict modern astronomy?
14.Psalm 92:7 says the wicked flourish like grass before perishing--how does this align with historical examples of tyrants who prospered without apparent punishment?What Does Ecclesiastes 10:5 Mean
There is an evil I have seen under the sunEcclesiastes 10:5 opens with the Teacher’s sober observation: “There is an evil I have seen under the sun—”.
• “Under the sun” reminds us the perspective is life in a fallen world, whereGenesis 3 introduced corruption into every sphere (Romans 8:20-22).
• The “evil” is not merely unpleasant; it is morally wrong, echoing earlier laments: “I have also seen under the sun: in the place of judgment, wickedness was there” (Ecclesiastes 3:16).
• Solomon records what he personally “has seen,” underscoring the literal reliability of Scripture and inviting us to look honestly at society’s injustices (Psalm 37:35-36).
• Similar observations surface throughout the book—oppression (4:1), abrupt reversals of fortune (9:11-12)—all painting a consistent portrait of life apart from perfect divine order (Isaiah 24:5-6).
Practical takeaways:
– Expect imperfections in earthly systems; ultimate justice is with God alone (Ecclesiastes 12:14).
– Recognize that noticing evil should move us toward discernment, not despair (Philippians 1:9-10).
an error that proceeds from the rulerThe specific “evil” is identified: “—an error that proceeds from the ruler:”.
• “Error” implies a deviation from God’s righteous standard (Proverbs 16:12;Proverbs 29:12).
• When the top authority goes astray, the damage multiplies. Scripture illustrates this repeatedly:
– Rehoboam’s harsh decree split the kingdom (1 Kings 12:13-16).
– Ahasuerus’ hasty edict empowered Haman’s genocide plot (Esther 3:9-13).
– David’s census brought plague on Israel (2 Samuel 24:10-15).
• Consequences of a ruler’s folly:
◦ Injustice flourishes—“When the wicked rule, the people groan” (Proverbs 29:2).
◦ Competence is ignored while incompetence is elevated (Ecclesiastes 10:6-7).
◦ Nations are led into moral confusion (Isaiah 9:16).
• God still reigns over kings (Daniel 4:17). Believers respond by:
– Praying for all in authority (1 Timothy 2:1-2).
– Submitting where possible without disobeying God (Romans 13:1;Acts 5:29).
– Exercising righteous influence in any sphere of leadership we hold—home, workplace, church (Matthew 5:14-16).
summaryThe Teacher notes a grievous reality: injustice often originates with those in power.Ecclesiastes 10:5 warns that when leaders stray from God’s wisdom, society suffers. Yet the passage simultaneously affirms God’s sovereignty and calls the faithful to discernment, prayer, and integrity in every position of influence.
(5)
Error.--The word is the same as at
Ecclesiastes 10:6.
Verse 5. - Koheleth gives his personal experience of apparent confusion in the ordering of state affairs.
There is an evil which I have seen under the sun. Power gets into the hands of an unwise man, and then errors are committed and injustice reigns.
As an error which proceedeth from the ruler. The
כְּ here is
cash veritatis, which denotes not comparison, but resemblance, the idealization of the individual, the harmony of the particular with the general idea. The evil which he noticed appeared to be (he does not affirm that it is) a mistake caused by the ruler; it so presented itself to his mind. The caution observed in the statement may be owing partly to the tacit feeling that such blots occasioned difficulties in the view taken of the moral government of the world. He does not intend to refer to God under the appellation "Ruler." The Septuagint renders,
Ὡς ἀκούσιον ἐξῆλθεν, "As if it came involuntarily;" Vulgate, to much the same effect,
Quasi per errorem egrediens. The idea here is either gnat the evil is one not produced by any intentional action of the ruler, but resulting from human imperfection, or that what appears to be a mistake is not so really. But these interpretations are unsuitable. Those who adhere to the Solomonic authorship of our book see here a prophetic intimation of the evil of Jeroboam's rule, which evil proceeded from the sins of Solomon himself and his son Rehoboam. (So Wordsworth, Motais, etc.)
Parallel Commentaries ...
Hebrew
There isיֵ֣שׁ(yêš)Adverb
Strong's 3426:Being, substance, existence, isan evilרָעָ֔ה(rā·‘āh)Adjective - feminine singular
Strong's 7451:Bad, evilI have seenרָאִ֖יתִי(rā·’î·ṯî)Verb - Qal - Perfect - first person common singular
Strong's 7200:To seeunderתַּ֣חַת(ta·ḥaṯ)Preposition
Strong's 8478:The bottom, below, in lieu ofthe sun—הַשָּׁ֑מֶשׁ(haš·šā·meš)Article | Noun - common singular
Strong's 8121:The sun, the east, a ray, a notched battlementan errorכִּשְׁגָגָ֕ה(kiš·ḡā·ḡāh)Preposition-k | Noun - feminine singular
Strong's 7684:A mistake, inadvertent transgressionthat proceedsשֶׁיֹּצָ֖א(še·yō·ṣā)Pronoun - relative | Verb - Qal - Participle - feminine singular
Strong's 3318:To go, bring, out, direct and proximfromמִלִּפְנֵ֥י(mil·lip̄·nê)Preposition-m, Preposition-l | Noun - common plural construct
Strong's 6440:The facethe ruler:הַשַּׁלִּֽיט׃(haš·šal·lîṭ)Article | Adjective - masculine singular
Strong's 7989:Having mastery, domineering
Links
Ecclesiastes 10:5 NIVEcclesiastes 10:5 NLTEcclesiastes 10:5 ESVEcclesiastes 10:5 NASBEcclesiastes 10:5 KJV
Ecclesiastes 10:5 BibleApps.comEcclesiastes 10:5 Biblia ParalelaEcclesiastes 10:5 Chinese BibleEcclesiastes 10:5 French BibleEcclesiastes 10:5 Catholic Bible
OT Poetry: Ecclesiastes 10:5 There is an evil which I have (Ecclesiast. Ec Ecc Eccles.)