Cleanup listing forWikiProject Middle-earth as of February 17, 2026.
Of the 669 articles in this project 158 or 24% are marked for cleanup, with 200 issues in total.
Listings: Alphabetic•By category•CSV•History
| Article | Importance | Class | Count | Oldest | Issues |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adaptations of The Hobbit | Mid | C | 2 | February 2022 | Dead external links {{dead link}} (February 2022, May 2023) |
| Adar (The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power) | Low | B | 1 | September 2022 | Expansion needed (September 2022) |
| All at Sea (ruleset) | Low | Stub | 1 | February 2021 | Notability unclear (February 2021) |
| Alloyed (The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power) | Low | B | 1 | September 2022 | Expansion needed (September 2022) |
| Anachronism in Middle-earth | Low | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Angband (video game) | Low | C | 1 | March 2025 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (March 2025) |
| Balin (Middle-earth) | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Bard the Bowman | Low | C | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Beorn | Low | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Bilbo Baggins | Top | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Brothers Hildebrandt | Low | B | 2 | May 2023 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (May 2023, June 2023) |
| Chris Seeman (BLP) | Low | Start | 1 | February 2015 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (February 2015) |
| Death and immortality in Middle-earth | Low | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Douglas A. Anderson (BLP) | Low | C | 1 | January 2025 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (January 2025) |
| Dragons in Middle-earth | Low | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Dreams and visions in Middle-earth | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Dwarves in Middle-earth | High | GA | 2 | December 2025 | CS1 errors: ISBN date, Dead external links {{dead link}} (December 2025) |
| E. V. Gordon | Low | C | 3 | June 2024 | Failed verification (June 2024), Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (November 2024), Introduction cleanup (November 2024) |
| Eagles in Middle-earth | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Economy of Middle-earth | Low | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Edith Tolkien | Mid | B | 1 | January 2026 | Style editing needed (January 2026) |
| Edward Kloczko (BLP) | Low | Start | 1 | May 2011 | BLP articles lacking sources (May 2011) |
| Elendor | Low | Start | 1 | June 2014 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (June 2014) |
| Elrond | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Elves in Middle-earth | High | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Esgaroth | Low | B | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Evernight (album) | Low | Start | 1 | January 2021 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (January 2021) |
| Farmer Giles of Ham | Low | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Fellowship! | Low | Start | 1 | April 2021 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (April 2021) |
| Forests in Middle-earth | Low | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Francis Xavier Morgan | Low | C | 1 | March 2023 | Page number citations needed (March 2023) |
| Gandalf | Top | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Geography of Middle-earth | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Gollum | High | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Gondolin | Low | B | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Grammar of late Quenya | Mid | C | 1 | September 2024 | Expansion needed (September 2024) |
| Guardians of Middle-earth | Low | Start | 2 | February 2014 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (February 2014, November 2019) |
| Half-elf | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Heroism in The Lord of the Rings | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Hobbit | High | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Holly Ordway (BLP) | Mid | C | 1 | June 2025 | Page number citations needed (June 2025) |
| Impact of Tolkien's Middle-earth writings | Mid | B | 1 | August 2025 | Dead external links {{dead link}} (August 2025) |
| In Dreams (Howard Shore song) | Low | Start | 1 | December 2022 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (December 2022) |
| Influences on Tolkien | High | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Inger Edelfeldt (BLP) | Low | C | 1 | September 2015 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (September 2015) |
| Isengard (band) | Low | Start | 1 | October 2020 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (October 2020) |
| J. R. R. Tolkien | Top | FA | 1 | March 2019 | Page number citations needed (March 2019) |
| J. R. R. Tolkien's Riders of Rohan | Low | Start | 1 | March 2016 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (March 2016) |
| J.R.R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings, Vol. I (1994 video game) | Low | Start | 1 | October 2025 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (October 2025) |
| John Howe (illustrator) (BLP) | Mid | C | 1 | August 2024 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (August 2024) |
| Kirill Yeskov (BLP) | Low | C | 2 | 2002 | Potentially dated statements (2008, 2002) |
| Legolas | High | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| List of Middle-earth role-playing games | Low | List | 1 | May 2023 | Incomplete lists (May 2023) |
| List of Middle-earth video games | Low | List | 1 | Pages with broken anchors (see article talk page, remove when fixed) | |
| List of Tolkien societies | Low | List | 1 | February 2022 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (February 2022) |
| List of accolades received by The Hobbit film series | Low | List | 1 | July 2024 | Dead external links {{dead link}} (July 2024) |
| List of accolades received by The Lord of the Rings film series | Low | FL | 4 | December 2012 | Cites unreliable sources (December 2012, May 2017), CS1 errors: requires URL, Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (February 2023) |
| List of original characters in The Lord of the Rings film series | Low | List | 1 | February 2013 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (February 2013) |
| List of things named after J. R. R. Tolkien and his works | Mid | List | 3 | June 2024 | CS1 errors: archive-url, Failed verification (June 2024), Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (May 2025) |
| List of translations of The Lord of the Rings | Low | List | 1 | May 2024 | Dead external links {{dead link}} (May 2024) |
| List of weapons and armour in Middle-earth | Mid | List | 2 | February 2024 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (February 2024), CS1 errors: ISBN date |
| Lonely Mountain | Low | B | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Lord of the Rings (board game) | Low | C | 1 | June 2024 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (June 2024) |
| Lord of the Rings: Game One | Low | Start | 2 | September 2017 | Weasel-worded phrases (September 2017), Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (September 2025) |
| Lívia Rusz | Low | C | 1 | May 2017 | Dead external links {{dead link}} (May 2017) |
| Magic in Middle-earth | Low | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Men in Middle-earth | High | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Middle-earth Enterprises | Low | C | 1 | May 2023 | Incomplete lists (May 2023) |
| Middle-earth Role Playing | Low | C | 4 | October 2021 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (October 2021, August 2022, August 2025), Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (January 2024) |
| Middle-earth Strategy Battle Game | Mid | C | 11 | September 2005 | Potentially dated statements (August 2006, September 2005), Style editing needed (October 2014), Cites unreliable sources (October 2014), Fact and fiction differentiation (October 2014), Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (October 2014), Promotional tone (October 2014), Original research (October 2014, May 2020), Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (May 2020), Pages with broken anchors (see article talk page, remove when fixed) |
| Middle-earth in video games | Low | C | 1 | 2025 | Potentially dated statements (2025) |
| Middle-earth peoples | Mid | B | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Mirkwood | High | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Mithril | Mid | GA | 2 | September 2025 | CS1 errors: ISBN date, Weasel-worded phrases (September 2025) |
| Mr. Bliss | Low | Start | 1 | June 2015 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (June 2015) |
| Music of Middle-earth | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Mythopoeia | Mid | B | 2 | October 2021 | Page number citations needed (October 2021), CS1 errors: periodical ignored |
| Naming of weapons in Middle-earth | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Nazgûl | Mid | GA | 1 | August 2025 | Dead external links {{dead link}} (August 2025) |
| One Ring | High | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Orc | High | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Partings (The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power) | Low | B | 1 | January 2023 | Expansion needed (January 2023) |
| Poetry in The Lord of the Rings | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Psychological journeys of Middle-earth | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Quenya | Mid | GA | 1 | April 2024 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (April 2024) |
| Quests in Middle-earth | Low | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Radagast | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Red Book of Westmarch | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Ring of Silvianus | Low | C | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Rings of Power | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Rivendell | Mid | GA | 2 | November 2023 | Dead external links {{dead link}} (November 2023), CS1 errors: ISBN date |
| River Sirion | NA | Redirect | 1 | Pages with broken anchors (see article talk page, remove when fixed) | |
| Sarn Ford | NA | Redirect | 1 | Pages with broken anchors (see article talk page, remove when fixed) | |
| Saruman | High | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Scary (Middle-earth) | NA | Redirect | 1 | Pages with broken anchors (see article talk page, remove when fixed) | |
| Shadows of Mordor | Low | Start | 2 | August 2017 | Weasel-worded phrases (August 2017), Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (April 2020) |
| Shelob | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Smaug | High | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Stratford Caldecott | Low | C | 1 | March 2023 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (March 2023) |
| Summoning (band) | Low | Start | 1 | March 2008 | Cites unreliable sources (March 2008) |
| Ted Nasmith (BLP) | Low | C | 1 | January 2026 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (January 2026) |
| Tengwar | Mid | B | 2 | March 2024 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (March 2024), Link rot cleanup (January 2026) |
| The Father Christmas Letters | Low | C | 1 | December 2025 | Dead external links {{dead link}} (December 2025) |
| The Great Wave (The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power) | Low | B | 1 | September 2022 | Expansion needed (September 2022) |
| The Hobbit | Top | GA | 1 | January 2026 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (January 2026) |
| The Hobbit (1977 film) | Mid | C | 1 | December 2023 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (December 2023) |
| The Hobbit (2003 video game) | Mid | B | 1 | Pages with broken anchors (see article talk page, remove when fixed) | |
| The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug | Mid | B | 1 | December 2025 | Dead external links {{dead link}} (December 2025) |
| The Lord of the Rings | Top | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: archive-url | |
| The Lord of the Rings (1978 film) | Low | FA | 1 | December 2025 | Dead external links {{dead link}} (December 2025) |
| The Lord of the Rings (1979 radio series) | Low | Start | 1 | April 2020 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (April 2020) |
| The Lord of the Rings (musical) | Low | B | 2 | November 2023 | Page number citations needed (November 2023), Dead external links {{dead link}} (September 2024) |
| The Lord of the Rings Online | Low | B | 1 | June 2023 | Dead external links {{dead link}} (June 2023) |
| The Lord of the Rings Online: Before the Shadow | Low | Start | 1 | February 2024 | Notability unclear (February 2024) |
| The Lord of the Rings Online: Fate of Gundabad | Low | Start | 1 | February 2024 | Notability unclear (February 2024) |
| The Lord of the Rings Online: Mordor | Low | Start | 1 | February 2024 | Notability unclear (February 2024) |
| The Lord of the Rings Online: Riders of Rohan | Low | B | 1 | October 2014 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (October 2014) |
| The Lord of the Rings Online: Rise of Isengard | Low | Start | 2 | December 2023 | Has general references but lacks inline footnotes (December 2023), Expansion needed (December 2025) |
| The Lord of the Rings Online: War of Three Peaks | Low | C | 2 | February 2024 | Notability unclear (February 2024), Expansion needed (December 2025) |
| The Lord of the Rings Roleplaying Game | Low | Start | 1 | May 2023 | Expansion needed (May 2023) |
| The Lord of the Rings: Gollum | Low | Start | 2 | May 2023 | Clarification needed (May 2023), Expansion needed (June 2023) |
| The Lord of the Rings: Journey to Rivendell | Low | Start | 1 | May 2024 | Notability unclear (May 2024) |
| The Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle-earth | Low | C | 1 | October 2024 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (October 2024) |
| The Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle-earth II | Low | FA | 1 | March 2025 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (March 2025) |
| The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (soundtrack) | Low | Start | 1 | March 2023 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (March 2023) |
| The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3 | Mid | C | 1 | December 2025 | Cites unreliable sources (December 2025) |
| The Lord of the Rings: The Third Age (Game Boy Advance video game) | Low | Start | 1 | August 2015 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (August 2015) |
| The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers (video game) | Low | B | 1 | Pages with broken anchors (see article talk page, remove when fixed) | |
| The Lord of the Rings: War in the North | Low | B | 1 | Pages with broken anchors (see article talk page, remove when fixed) | |
| The Lord of the Rings: War of the Ring | Low | C | 1 | March 2008 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (March 2008) |
| The Return of the King (1980 film) | Low | C | 2 | November 2021 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (November 2021), Page number citations needed (September 2023) |
| The Road Goes Ever On (song) | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| The Scouring of the Shire | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| The Silmarillion | Top | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: archive-url | |
| The Soddit | Low | Start | 1 | March 2017 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (March 2017) |
| The Song of Middle Earth | Low | Stub | 1 | March 2022 | Orphaned (March 2022) |
| The War of the Ring online campaign | Low | Start | 3 | October 2014 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (October 2014), Notability unclear (February 2021), Cites unreliable sources (February 2021) |
| Thorin Oakenshield | High | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Thranduil | Low | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Tolkien and Edwardian adventure stories | Low | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Tolkien and the Norse | Low | B | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Tolkien family | Low | B | 2 | September 2020 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (September 2020), Page number citations needed (February 2021) |
| Tolkien fandom | Low | B | 1 | 2025 | Potentially dated statements (2025) |
| Tolkien's frame stories | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Tolkien's maps | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Tolkien's modern sources | Low | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Tolkien's monsters | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Tolkien's moral dilemma | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Trees in Middle-earth | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Trolls in Middle-earth | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Vaiya | NA | Redirect | 1 | Pages with broken anchors (see article talk page, remove when fixed) | |
| Walking Tree Publishers | Low | Start | 1 | May 2024 | Cites unreliable sources (May 2024) |
| Warg | Mid | GA | 1 | CS1 errors: ISBN date | |
| Waymeet | NA | Redirect | 1 | Pages with broken anchors (see article talk page, remove when fixed) | |
| Weather Hills | NA | Redirect | 1 | Pages with broken anchors (see article talk page, remove when fixed) | |
| Wolfgang Krege | Low | Start | 3 | November 2011 | Unsourced passages need footnotes {{citation needed}} (November 2011), Weasel-worded phrases (November 2011), Unsourced passages need footnotes {{More citations needed}} (June 2015) |
| Wētā Workshop | Low | C | 1 | September 2024 | Incomplete lists (September 2024) |
| Yale (Middle-earth) | NA | Redirect | 1 | Pages with broken anchors (see article talk page, remove when fixed) |