Election law changes? Our legislation tracker’s got you.Check it out!

San Juan Unified School District recall, California (2021)

From Ballotpedia
San Juan Unified School District recall
Ballotpedia Election Coverage Badge.png
Officeholders
Pam Costa
Zima Creason
Saul Hernandez
Michael McKibbin
Paula Marie Villescaz
Recall status
Did not go to a vote
See also
Recall overview
Political recall efforts, 2021
Recalls in California
California recall laws
School board recalls
Recall reports

An effort to recall all five members of theSan Juan Unified School District Board of Education did not go to a vote in 2021. Recall supporters did not collect enough signatures to put the recalls on the ballot.[1]

The recall effort began in April 2021.Pam Costa,Zima Creason,Saul Hernandez,Michael McKibbin, andPaula Marie Villescaz were named in the recall petitions.[2] To get the recall on the ballot, recall supporters would have had to collect 20,266 signatures per board member by October 19, 2021.[3]

Recall supporters said the board members had failed to represent their constituents, denied students access to district staff and services, and voted to not return students to in-person learning during the 2020-2021 school year.[2] The San Juan Unified School District started the 2020-2021 school year with online instruction due to the COVID-19 pandemic.[4] The district announced in May 2021 that students would start the 2021-2022 school year with full-time in-person instruction.[5]

In response to the recall, Costa said, "The Board has worked hard to balance student learning with safety for all, while complying with the complex layers of local, state, and federal law." Hernandez said he had spoken in favor of returning students to in-person instruction as soon as possible. The other three board members did not submit responses to the recall effort.[2]

Costa, Villescaz, and Hernandez all won re-election to four-year terms on the board in anat-large election onNovember 3, 2020, defeating four opponents. OnNovember 6, 2018, McKibbin was re-elected to a four-year term, and Creason was elected to her first four-year term. They defeated two opponents in the at-large election.

To read about other recall efforts related to the coronavirus and government responses to the pandemic,click here.

Recall supporters

Arguments for recall against Costa

The notice of intent to recall Costa said:[6]

Parents and Citizens of Sacramento seek to recall Pam Costa, Board Member San Juan Unified School District. Costa is failing to represent her

constituents. She is denying and rationing students access to schools, staff, and services. Her actions are having undeniably profound, andnegative consequences on students, of which she is fully aware. Although the health department and the Governor issued guidance andexecutive orders concerning education, Costa is undoubtedly using her local authority to reduce the district's liability and keep students out ofthe classrooms. She continues to survey parents/staff, who have responded with a majority vote to return to school; and continues to voteagainst the return to in-person learning even when it was safe to do so. Much of the "guidance" Costa is using appears to conflict with or hassuperseded long standing taws and education codes. Actions of Costa have clearly reduced the instructional minute students receive. Parentscan no longer condone these reckless and ill-advised actions of Costa. She was elected and sworn to uphold laws; not outside "guidance" shehas allegedly received that facilitates disparities, widens achievement gaps, and harms students in ways she has failed to either calculate,consider, or resolve.[7]

Arguments for recall against Creason

The notice of intent to recall Creason said:[8]

Parents and Citizens of Sacramento seek to recall Zima Creason, Board Member San Juan Unified School District. Creason is failing to represent

her constituents. She is denying and rationing students access to schools, staff, and services. Her actions are having undeniably profound, andnegative consequences on students, of which she is fully aware. Although the health department and the Governor issued guidance andexecutive orders concerning education, Creason is undoubtedly using her local authority to reduce the district's liability and keep students outof the classrooms. She continues to survey parents/staff, who have responded with a majority vote to return to school; and continues to voteagainst the return to in-person learning even when it was safe to do so. Much of the "guidance" Creason is using appears to conflict with or hassuperseded long standing laws and education codes. Actions of Creason have clearly reduced the instructional minute students receive. Parentscan no longer condone these reckless and ill-advised actions of Creason. She was elected and sworn to uphold laws; not outside "guidance" shehas allegedly received that facilitates disparities, widens achievement gaps, and harms students in ways she has failed to either calculate,consider, or resolve.[7]

Arguments for recall against Hernandez

The notice of intent to recall Hernandez said:[9]

Parents and Citizens of Sacramento seek to recall Saul Hernandez, Board Member San Juan Unified School District. Hernandez is failing to

represent his constituents. He is denying and rationing students access to schools, staff, and services. His actions are having undeniablyprofound, and negative consequences on students, of which he is fully aware. Although the health department and the Governor issuedguidance and executive orders concerning education, Hernandez is undoubtedly using his local authority to reduce the district's liability andkeep students out of the classrooms. He continues to survey parents/staff, who have responded with a majority vote to return to school; andcontinues to vote against the return to in-person learning even when it was safe to do so. Much of the "guidance" Hernandez is using appearsto conflict with or has superseded long standing laws and education codes. Actions of Hernandez have clearly reduced the instructional minutestudents receive. Parents can no longer condone these reckless and ill-advised actions of Hernandez. He was elected and sworn to uphold laws;not outside "guidance" he has allegedly received that facilitates disparities, widens achievement gaps, and harms students in ways he has failedto either calculate, consider, or resolve.[7]

Arguments for recall against McKibbin

The notice of intent to recall McKibbin said:[10]

Parents and Citizens of Sacramento seek to recall Michael McKibbln, Ed.D., Board Member San Juan Unitied School District. McKibbin is tailing

to represent his constituents. He is denying and rationing students access to schools, staff, and services. His actions are having undeniablyprofound, and negative consequences on students, of which he is fully aware. Although the health department and the Governor issuedguidance and executive orders concerning education, McKibbin is undoubtedly using his local authority to reduce the district's liability and keepstudents out of the classrooms. He continues to survey parents/staff, who have responded with a majority vote to return to school; andcontinues to vote against the return to in-person learning even when it was safe to do so. Much of the "guidance" McKibbin is using appears toconflict with or has superseded long standing laws and education codes. Actions of McKibbin have clearly reduced the instructional minutestudents receive. Parents can no longer condone these reckless and ill-advised actions of McKibbin. He was elected and sworn to uphold laws;•ot outside "guidance" he has allegedly received that facilitates disparities, widens achievement gaps, and harms students in ways he has failedto either calculate, consider, or resolve.[7]

Arguments for recall against Villescaz

The notice of intent to recall Villescaz said:[11]

Parents and Citizens of Sacramento seek to recall Paula Villescaz, Board Member San Juan Unified School District. Villescaz, is failing to

represent her constituents. She is denying and rationing students access to schools, staff, and services. Her actions are having undeniablyprofound, and negative consequences on students, of which she is fully aware. Although the health department and the Governor issuedguidance and executive orders concerning education, Villescaz is undoubtedly using her local authority to reduce the district's liability and keepstudents out of the classrooms. She continues to survey parents/staff, who have responded with a majority vote to return to school; andcontinues to vote against the return to in-person learning even when it was safe to do so. Much of the "guidance" Viltescaz, is using appears toconflict with or has superseded long standing laws and education codes. Actions of Villescaz have clearly reduced the instructional minutestudents receive. Parents can no longer condone these reckless and ill-advised actions of Villescaz. She was elected and sworn to uphold laws;not outside "guidance" she has allegedly received that facilitates disparities, widens achievement gaps, and harms students in ways she hasfailed to either calculate, consider, or resolve.[7]

Recall opponents

Response by Costa

Costa submitted the following response to the recall effort.[12]

There are no grounds to justify an expensive recall of the San

Juan School District trustees, the majority of whom were justre-elected in November 2020. I was proud to be re-elected tomy third term by the San Juan community and have faithfullysought to fairly represent students, staff, and families, not onlyduring this horrible pandemic, but for over 30 years in the SanJuan School District. I have read every email, listened for hoursto public comment at Board meetings, read every survey,Superintendent communication, and California Department ofPublic Health and CDC guidance memo. The Board has workedhard to balance student learning with safety for all, whilecomplying with the complex layers of local, state, and federallaw. We modified students' academic learning programs,followed science and recommendations from our national andstate health officials, instituted distance learning, issuedlaptops and "hot spots" to students who needed help, andincreased social/emotional services through district counselorsand social workers. Students now are returning safely toschools but there is much more that we need to do. The lastthing we need is an expensive and divisive recall election thatdistracts us from the hard work which lays ahead.[7]

Response by Creason

Creason did not submit a response to the recall effort to the Sacramento County Voter Registration and Elections Office.[2]

Response by Hernandez

Hernandez submitted the following response to the recall effort.[13]

I have always felt and expressed publicly that we need to have our students return to in person learning

(for those who wish to do so) as soon as legally possible. I have not been shy in making my voiceextremely clear at every possible opportunity.
Unfortunately through a combination of constant shifting by the State of California, we were preventedfrom a full in person classroom setting until recently.
My comments made publicly from board meeting held on February 23, 2021.
"l would like to thank all that reached out concerning the topic. I too, was hoping/praying that the statewould allow or give us something to return under our current agreement. However, I feel we are passedon relying on the state and we are at a point that we do ALL and Everything we can so that our kidsreturn ASAP. Even if that means our K-6 return first and hopefully our secondary will follow thereafter. Iam hoping we can work together with all parties to make this happen. Districts that surround us havereturned to in person learning and we too must return to in person learning for our kids"[7]

Response by McKibbin

McKibbin did not submit a response to the recall effort to the Sacramento County Voter Registration and Elections Office.[2]

Response by Villescaz

Villescaz did not submit a response to the recall effort to the Sacramento County Voter Registration and Elections Office.[2]

Path to the ballot

See also:Laws governing recall in California

Recall supporters submitted the notices of intent to recall to theSacramento County Voter Registration and Elections Office in April 2021. To get the recall on the ballot, recall supporters would have had to collect 20,266 signatures per board member by October 19, 2021.[3] Recall supporters announced that they submitted petitions on the deadline.[14] They did not collect enough signatures.[1]

About the district

San Juan Unified School District is located in Sacramento County, California.

San Juan Unified School District is located inSacramento County, California. It is classified as a large suburban school district by the National Center for Education Statistics. The district served 39,953 students during the 2018-2019 school year and comprised 68 schools.[15]


During the 2018-2019 school year, 52.7% of the district's students were eligible for free or reduced-price lunch, 14.7% wereEnglish language learners, and 13.5% of students had anIndividual Education Plan (IEP).[16]

Racial Demographics, 2018-2019
RaceSan Juan Unified School District (%)California K-12 students (%)
American Indian/Alaska Native0.60.5
Asian or Asian/Pacific Islander7.911.7
Black6.85.4
Hispanic24.154.6
Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islander0.70.5
Two or More Races6.84.5
White53.222.9

Note: Percentages for race and ethnicity may add up to more than 100 percent because respondents may report more than one race and the Hispanic/Latino ethnicity may be selected in conjunction with any race. Read more about race and ethnicity in the censushere.

Recalls related to the coronavirus

See also:Recalls related to the coronavirus (COVID-19) and government responses to the pandemic

Ballotpedia covered 35 coronavirus-related recall efforts against 94 officials in 2022, accounting for 13% of recalls that year. This is a decrease from both 2020 and 2021. COVID-related recalls accounted for 37% of all recall efforts in both 2020 and 2021. In 2020, there were 87 COVID-related recalls against 89 officials, and in 2021, there were 131 against 214 officials.

The chart below compares coronavirus-related recalls to recalls for all other reasons in 2020, 2021, and 2022.

2021 recall efforts

See also:School board recalls

Ballotpedia tracked 92 school board recall efforts against 237 board members in 2021. Recall elections against 17 board members were held in 2021. The school boardrecall success rate was 0.42%.

The chart below details the status of 2021 recall efforts by individual school board member.

See also

External links

Footnotes

  1. 1.01.1Sentinel-Tribune, "Pandemic restrictions fuel recall efforts on fall ballots," October 31, 2021
  2. 2.02.12.22.32.42.5Sacramento County Voter Registration and Elections, "Current Recall Information," accessed June 4, 2021
  3. 3.03.1Abbey Smith, “Email communication with Julia Wick, Los Angeles Times," June 2, 2021
  4. San Juan Unified School District, "COVID-19 Safety Plan," accessed June 4, 2021
  5. San Juan Unified School District, "5-day full-time schedule for 2021-2022," accessed June 4, 2021
  6. Sacramento County Voter Registration and Elections, "Notice of Intent to Circulate Recall Petition: Pam Costa," accessed June 4, 2021
  7. 7.07.17.27.37.47.57.6Note: This text is quoted verbatim from the original source. Any inconsistencies are attributable to the original source.
  8. Sacramento County Voter Registration and Elections, "Notice of Intent to Circulate Recall Petition: Zima Creason," accessed June 4, 2021
  9. Sacramento County Voter Registration and Elections, "Notice of Intent to Circulate Recall Petition: Saul Hernandez," accessed June 4, 2021
  10. Sacramento County Voter Registration and Elections, "Notice of Intent to Circulate Recall Petition: Michael McKibbln," accessed June 4, 2021
  11. Sacramento County Voter Registration and Elections, "Notice of Intent to Circulate Recall Petition: Paula Villescaz," accessed June 4, 2021
  12. Sacramento County Voter Registration and Elections, "Answer to the Notice of Intention to Recall: Pam Costa," accessed June 4, 2021
  13. Sacramento County Voter Registration and Elections, "Answer to the Notice of Intention to Recall: Saul Hernandez," accessed June 4, 2021
  14. Facebook, "Recall San Juan Unified School Board post on October 19, 2021," accessed October 20, 2021
  15. National Center for Education Statistics, "Search for Public School Districts," accessed March 8, 2021
  16. National Center for Education Statistics, "Public Elementary/Secondary School Universe Survey," accessed March 8, 2021
v  e
School board recalls, 2021
On the
ballot
Underway
Antioch Unified School District, CaliforniaBelchertown Public Schools, MassachusettsCave Creek Unified School District, ArizonaCorona-Norco Unified School District, CaliforniaCupertino Union School District, CaliforniaDavison Community Schools, MichiganDesert Sands Unified School District, CaliforniaFairfax County Public Schools, VirginiaForest Hills Public Schools, MichiganGiltner Public Schools, NebraskaGladstone Area Schools, MichiganLeyton Public Schools, NebraskaLitchfield Elementary School District, Arizona (A. Jeremy Hoenack)Loudoun County Public Schools, VirginiaMount Pleasant City School District, MichiganNewberg School District, OregonRegional School Unit 21, MaineSan Francisco Unified School District, CaliforniaTustin Unified School District, CaliforniaVirginia Beach City Public Schools, VirginiaWaverly School District 145, Nebraska
Did not go
to a vote
Ajo Unified School District, ArizonaAmery School District, WisconsinBangor School Department, MaineBenicia Unified School District, CaliforniaBoulder Valley School District, ColoradoCentral Valley School District, WashingtonChelsea School District, MichiganChico Unified School District, CaliforniaChippewa Valley Schools, MichiganChualar Union School District, CaliforniaDouglas County School District, ColoradoElk Grove Unified School District, CaliforniaFairfax Elementary School District, CaliforniaFallbrook Union High School District, CaliforniaFargo Public Schools, North DakotaFremont Union High School District, CaliforniaGadsden Elementary School District, ArizonaKenosha Unified School District, WisconsinKent School District, WashingtonLa Mesa-Spring Valley School District, CaliforniaLas Cruces Public Schools, New MexicoLiberty Elementary School District, ArizonaLitchfield Elementary School District, Arizona (Kimberly Moran and Melissa Zuidema)Los Alamitos Unified School District, CaliforniaLos Gatos-Saratoga Union High School District, CaliforniaLucia Mar Unified School District, CaliforniaMaine School Administrative District 51, MaineManitowoc School District, WisconsinMinden Public Schools, NebraskaMount Diablo Unified School District, CaliforniaNorris School District 160, NebraskaNorthshore School District, WashingtonNutley Public Schools, New JerseyPajaro Valley Unified School District, CaliforniaPapillion-La Vista Public Schools, NebraskaParadise Valley Unified School District, ArizonaPeoria Unified School District, ArizonaRidgefield Park Public Schools, New JerseyRochester Community School District, MichiganRosendale-Brandon School District, WisconsinSan Dieguito Union High School District, California (Michael Allman)San Dieguito Union High School District, California (Kristin Gibson)San Juan Unified School District, CaliforniaSan Ramon Valley Unified School District, CaliforniaSanta Monica-Malibu Unified School District, CaliforniaScottsdale Unified School District, ArizonaSeattle Public Schools, WashingtonShepherd Public School District, MichiganSomerset School District, WisconsinSparta Area School District, WisconsinStevens Point Area Public School DistrictSunnyvale School District, CaliforniaVail Unified School District, ArizonaVista Unified School District, CaliforniaWahoo Public Schools, NebraskaWaunakee Community School District, WisconsinWaupaca School District, WisconsinWeld County School District RE-4, ColoradoWest Sonoma County Union High School District, CaliforniaWhitefish School District, MontanaWinston-Dillard School District, OregonWisconsin Rapids School District, Wisconsin
Regular elections
Flag of California
v  e
State ofCalifornia
Sacramento (capital)
Elections

What's on my ballot? |Elections in 2026 |How to vote |How to run for office |Ballot measures

Government

Who represents me? |U.S. President |U.S. Congress |Federal courts |State executives |State legislature |State and local courts |Counties |Cities |School districts |Public policy