Everything you need to know about ranked-choice voting in one spot.Click to learn more!

Pennsylvania Attorney General election, 2012

From Ballotpedia
Ballotpedia Election Coverage Badge-smaller use.png
Pennsylvania's 2012 elections
U.S. Senate • U.S. House • Attorney General • Other executive offices • State Senate • State House • Candidate ballot access
Flag of Pennsylvania.png


2016→


Pennsylvania Attorney General
StateExecLogo.png
Primary Date:
April 24, 2012
General Election Date:
November 6, 2012
State Executive Elections
State executive official elections in 2012

ThePennsylvania attorney general election took place onNovember 6, 2012, following a primary on April 24, 2012.

Republican PartyDavid Freed
Democratic PartyKathleen KaneGreen check mark transparent.png
Libertarian PartyMarakay Rogers

Kathleen Kane won the general election on November 6, 2012, earning over 56% of the vote. She became the first woman and the first Democrat elected as attorney general in Pennsylvania.[1]

The incumbent attorney general,Linda Kelly (R), was appointed by formerAttorney General andGovernorTom Corbett(R) upon his ascension to the governorship in 2010. Kelly chose not to seek election to a full term in 2012, which left Cumberland County District AttorneyDavid Freed unopposed in the party's primary. Bypassing the primary provided the Republican candidate the extra time to focus on fundraising and preparing his general election strategy.[2]

The Democratic primary contest was settled at the polls on April 24th, with ex-Assistant District Attorney for Lackawanna CountyKathleen Kane defeating Bucks County Congressman and Iraq vetPatrick Murphy. She went on to defeat Freed andLibertarianMarakay Rogers in the general election on November 6, 2012.[3]

Freed's campaign operatives described the Democratic candidates as the strongest group the party has presented for attorney general since 1978, the year Pennsylvania voters approved a constitutional amendment making the office an elected position instead of an appointed one. The first attorney general election was held in 1980; until Kane's victory in November 2012, no Democrat had ever won the office.[2]

The race was originally rated as a toss-up, butGoverning Politics shifted the contest to leaning Democratic as a result of Kane's lead in the polls and in fundraising.[4]

Election Results

General Election Results

Attorney General of Pennsylvania General Election, 2012
PartyCandidateVote %Votes
    DemocraticGreen check mark transparent.pngKathleen Kane56.1%3,125,557
    Republican David Freed41.6%2,313,506
    Libertarian Marakay Rogers2.3%128,140
Total Votes5,567,203
Election results viaPennsylvania Department of State

Primary Results

Attorney General of Pennsylvania, Democratic Primary, 2012
CandidateVote %Votes
Green check mark transparent.pngKathleen Kane52.8%371,862
Patrick Murphy47.2%331,778
Total Votes703,640
Election results viaPennsylvania Department of State (accessed April 25, 2012).


Background

2013→
←2011
2012
State Executive Official Elections
2012SEO.png
Alabama •Arizona •Delaware
Georgia •Indiana •Louisiana
Missouri •Montana •Nebraska
New Hampshire •New Mexico
North Carolina •North Dakota
Oklahoma •Oregon
Pennsylvania •South Dakota
Texas •Utah •Vermont
Washington •West Virginia
News •Calendar


Key dates

  • Administrative deadlines were at close of business (5:00) unless otherwise noted.
DeadlineEvent
Mar. 26Voter registration for primary election
Apr. 24Primary election
Oct. 9Voter registration for general election
Nov. 6General election

Race background

General

Heading into the fall, major party nominees Freed and Kane each had the backing of a powerful PAC. In late September, the Republican State Leadership Committee—a PAC supporting Freed (R)—spent $558,700 to air a television advertisement on select Philadelphia stations that included claims about Kane, which were later proven to be false.[5] The RSLC ad cited an example of a plea bargain that had been made in a rape case during Kane's stint at the Lackawanna District Attorney's office, inaccurately portraying her involvement in the deal to make her look soft on rape. Being tough on sex-abuse crime was one of the defining themes of Kane's campaign and her identity as a prosecutor; the ad, which stated, “Of Kane’s few cases, a judge rejected a weak plea deal she made because of the brutality of the crime and age of the victim,” was designed to undermine that image.[6] Soon after the ad aired, the father of one of the two victims referenced in the case publicly disputed its claims. Records from the District Attorney’s office supported his statement, showing that Kane’s role was limited to administrative duties and concluded after the initial filing. As a result, the PAC withdrew the ad and issued a public acknowledgment of the mistake.[7] The RSLC removed any reference to the rape case and promptly re-released the edited version, but continued airing the original ad on their website. Kane’s campaign responded critically to the ad. A spokesperson stated, "Freed needs to tell his people to take their ad down immediately and take their special interest money and their dirty tricks and get out of Pennsylvania. The people of Pennsylvania deserve better."[8]

Freed's campaign manager commented on the ad, saying, "It’s our sincere hope that our opponent, as well as any outside groups that are supporting our campaign or our opponent’s campaign, conduct themselves in an honest and ethical manner.” He made no mention of the ad or the implications about Freed's relationship to the PAC.[8]

Primary

Originally a three-way race, theDemocratic primary election shrank to a face-off between former Bucks County Congressman and Iraq vetPatrick Murphy and ex-Assistant District Attorney for Lackawanna CountyKathleen Kane. The third candidate, Montgomery County's Dan McCafferty, pulled out in mid-January.[9]

Then, on February 27—two weeks after the filing deadline—the Democratic field grew again to three candidates when former U.S. Representative and State AuditorDon Bailey formalized his bid for the nomination. The late entry was the result of a paperwok mishap, but he was officially cleared to run by the State Department.[10]

A spokesman for Murphy's campaign said of Bailey's entry, "It doesn't change the fact that this is really a two-person race between Patrick, who has dedicated his life to protecting middle-class families, and Kane, who is trying to buy this election using money from her anti-union company."[11] Kane's campaign responded to the comment by highlighting her qualifications and experience as a prosecutor. Murphy's campaign challenged the validity of Bailey's nominating petitions, leading Bailey to withdraw from the race for the Democratic nomination instead of pursuing a legal battle. Bailey said he would run as an independent instead, but failed to obtain the requisite number of signatures to secure a place on the general election ballot.[12]

Candidates

General Election Candidates

Republican PartyDavid Freed

Endorsement List[13] 

Governor of Pennsylvania Tom Corbett

Bob Branstetter, Senior adviser and direct mail consultant

Vince Galko, general consultant

Brabender/Cox, media advisors

Jennifer Holman Zaborney, finance director

Carey Dunn and Amy Petraglia, western Pa. fundraisers

Kristin Clarke, eastern Pa. fundraiser[14]

Adams County District Attorney Shawn C. Wagner

Bedford County District Attorney William J Higgins, Jr

Bucks County District Attorney David Heckler

Butler County District Attorney Richard A. Goldinger

Clarion County District Attorney Mark T. Aaron

Crawford County District Attorney Francis J. Schultz

Dauphin County District Attorney Edward M. Marsico, Jr

Erie County District Attorney Jack Daneri

Franklin County District Attorney Matthew Fogal

Juniata County District Attorney Cory Snook

Huntingdon County District Attorney George N. Zanic

Lancaster District Attorney Craig Stedman

Lebanon County District Attorney David J. Arnold, Jr

Lehigh County District Attorney James B. Martin

Montour County District Attorney Robert W. Buehner, Jr

Pike County District Attorney Raymond J. Tonkin.

Snyder County District Attorney Michael Piecuch

Sullivan County District Attorney Leonard Simpson

Susquehanna County District Attorney Jason J. Legg

Tioga County District Attorney George W. Wheeler

Washington County District Attorney Steven M. Toprani

York County District Attorney Tom Kearney


Democratic PartyKathleen Kane

Endorsement List 
  • Former President Bill Clinton[15]
  • The Philadelphia Inquirer[16]
  • Easttown Democratic Committee
  • The Philadelphia Tribune
  • Patrick Murphy[17]


Libertarian PartyMarakay Rogers

Primary Election Candidates

Donkey symbol.pngDemocratic primary candidates

  • Patrick Murphy was a member of the U.S. House of Representatives, where he made a name for himself championing the repeal effort for "Don't Ask Don't Tell." He is an Iraq veteran, practicing attorney, and law professor.

Gop logo2.jpgRepublican primary candidates

Freed spoke at the GOP's annual Lincoln Day Dinner the week of the filing deadline, saying, "Tough times and tough issues call for a tough attorney general; I will be an active attorney general, not an activist."[19]
Freed was endorsed by Gov. Corbett, and was the son-in-law of Pennsylvania's first elected attorney general, Leroy Zimmerman, who served two four year terms in the office.[20][21]

Former candidates

Don Bailey

  • Don Bailey was a member of the U.S. House of Representatives, a former Pennsylvania Auditor General, and a decorated Vietnam veteran. He had worked primarily as a civil rights lawyer in Harrisburg since 1998, when he lost the Democratic gubernatorial primary to Ivan Itkin. Before that election, he ran unsuccessfully for U.S. Senate in 1986, for re-election as Auditor in 1988, and again for Auditor in 1992, losing that time in the primary.[22]
Bailey cited his disappointment in the selection of candidates and ongoing concerns about corruption within the attorney general’s office as reasons for entering the race. He said "The Attorney General's Office has been a do-nothing office for too long,"[11][11] He originally filed as a Democratic candidate but withdrew his bid for the nomination after Murphy-allies contested his nominating petitions. He intended to run as anIndependent instead, but ultimately did not qualify for a place on the general election ballot.[23]

Polls & Debates

General Election

Polls

Kane VS. Freed
PollKathleen Kane (D)David Freed (R)Undecided (n/a for Poll#1)Margin of errorSample size
Susquehanna Polling and Research
(October 29-31, 2012)
48%37%14%+/-3.46800
Morning Call/Muhlenberg College Poll
(October 17-21, 2012)
39%26%34%+/-5.0444
The Morning Call/Muhlenberg College
(October 10-15, 2012)

33%28%37%+/-5.0438
Philadelphia Inquirer Poll
(October 4-8, 2012)
41%29%30%+/-4.0600
Muhlenberg College Poll
(September 22-25, 2012)
33%27%38%+/-5.0427
Philadelphia Inquirer Poll
August 28, 2012
40%29%31%+/-4.0601
PPP poll
July 23, 2012
41%34%25%+/-3.56758
Public Policy Poll
May 17-20, 2012]
42%33%25%+/-3.8671
Zata 3 internal poll
May 7, 2012
48%27%0%+/-3.24916
AVERAGES 40.56% 30% 26% +/-4.12 628.33
Note: The polls above may not reflect all polls that have been conducted in this race. Those displayed are a random sampling chosen by Ballotpedia staff. If you would like to nominate another poll for inclusion in the table, send an email toeditor@ballotpedia.org.

**Poll#1 was an internal poll commissioned by the Kane campaign and conducted by Zata 3 on April 20 and May 1. The sample was limited to voters with home phones.**

Primary Election

A poll conducted by the Benenson Strategy Group between November 29-December 1, 2011, initially showed candidate Patrick Murphy leading Kathleen Kane in a head-to-head race. Once voters heard short paragraphs with positive information on both candidates (and no negative content on either), the race flipped and Kane took a 16% lead (Kane 51%, Murphy 35%, and 14% undecided).[24]

Kane vs. Murphy
PollKathleen KanePatrick MurphyUndecidedMargin of errorSample size
Ballot After Both Kane and Murphy Profiles
51%35%14%+/-4600
Initial Two-Way Ballot
24%40%36%+/-4600
AVERAGES 37.5% 37.5% 25% +/-4 600
Note: The polls above may not reflect all polls that have been conducted in this race. Those displayed are a random sampling chosen by Ballotpedia staff. If you would like to nominate another poll for inclusion in the table, send an email toeditor@ballotpedia.org.

On March 30, 2012, Politics PA conducted an unscientific poll asking readers who they think would win the Democratic primary for attorney general. The results showed Murphy as the predicted favorite to win against primary opponent Kathleen Kane.[25]

PoliticsPA Reader Poll
PollPatrick MurphyKathleen KaneMargin of errorSample size
Murphy vs. Kane
71%29%+/-0995
Note: The polls above may not reflect all polls that have been conducted in this race. Those displayed are a random sampling chosen by Ballotpedia staff. If you would like to nominate another poll for inclusion in the table, send an email toeditor@ballotpedia.org.

The PA Progressives Summit released straw poll results for the February 10, 2012, debate between Democratic primary candidates Patrick Murphy and Kathleen Kane, which took place at Arch Street United Methodist Church in Center City, Philadelphia.[26] The poll had Murphy leading at 56.1%, Kane holding at 41.4%, and 2.4% reporting as undecided.

Primary Debates

PA Progressive Summit Debate: Murphy vs. Kane

The Murphy vs. Kane debate kicked off the Pennsylvania Progressives Summit on February 10, 2012. The debate covered progressive issues ranging from gun control to gay marriage and the relative credentials of the two candidates seeking their party's nomination in the April 24 primary.[27]

January 30 Shadyside Democrats Debate

Campaign finance

Contents
1 Due dates for reports
2 Candidates

Due dates for reports

The Department of State Bureau of Commissions, Elections, and Legislation administers campaign finance law and maintains all recordsonline.

Primary election report deadlines:

  • First report-- due by March 13, 2012
  • Pre-primary-- due by April 13, 2012
  • Post-primary-- due by May 24, 2012

General election deadlines:

  • First report-- due September 25, 2012
  • Pre-election-- due October 26, 2012
  • Post-election--due December 6, 2012

The year-end annual report for 2012 was due by January 31, 2013.

Candidates

David Freed

David Freed Campaign Finance Reports
ReportDate FiledBeginning BalanceTotal Contributions
for Reporting Period		ExpendituresCash on Hand
Primary FirstMarch 13, 2012$0.00$206,152.11$(339.46)$205,662.65
Pre-PrimaryApril 9, 2012$205,662.65$78,082.76$(25,534.47)$257,785.77
Post-PrimaryMay 24, 2012$257.785.77$226,460.79$(34,608.46)$440,176.32
Pre-General FirstSeptember 25, 2012[28]$0.00$206,152.11$(339.46)$205,662.65
Running totals
$716,847.77$(60,821.85)

Kathleen Kane

Kathleen Kane Campaign Finance Reports
ReportDate FiledBeginning BalanceTotal Contributions
for Reporting Period		ExpendituresCash on Hand
Primary FirstMarch 13, 2012$2,009,991.42$58,477.46$(73,479.30)$1,994.909.58
Pre-PrimaryApril 9, 2012$1,994,909.58$71,938.05$(1,433,579.36)$633,268.27
Post-PrimaryMay 24, 2012$633,268.27$178,815.39$(805,560.03)$1,728.82
Pre-General FirstSeptember 25, 2012[29]$1,728.82$1,481,285.56$(250,739.47)$1,221,764.23
Running totals
$1,790,516.46$(2,563,358.16)

Patrick Murphy

Patrick Murphy Campaign Finance Reports
ReportDate FiledBeginning BalanceTotal Contributions
for Reporting Period		ExpendituresCash on Hand
Primary FirstMarch 13, 2012$1,043,016.65$2,300.00$(33,417.46)$2,871.50
Pre-PrimaryApril 9, 2012$1,043,016.65$307,901.43$(165,240.27)$1,183,177.81
Post-PrimaryMay 24, 2012$415,002.29$474,570.46$(878,801.65)$6,175.47
Running totals
$784,771.89$(1,077,459.38)

Campaign sites/media

Campaign sites

Democrats

Republicans

Third Party

Advertisements & other media

David Freed


Kathleen Kane
PAC ads
Republican State Leadership Committee: "Backpack"

Former candidates

Patrick Murphy

News

See also

Pennsylvania

Articles

See above "News" tab

External links

Footnotes

  1. ↑Philadelphia Inquirer, "Election Results 2012," accessed November 7, 2012
  2. ↑2.02.1PoliticsPA, "Burns CM Kelly joins Freed AG campaign," March 8, 2012
  3. ↑PoliticsPA, "McCafferty CM moves to Team Kane," February 20, 2012
  4. ↑Governing Politics, "Attorney General Races: Democrats' odds improving," October 12, 2012
  5. ↑Philadelphia Daily News, "Rape victim's dad called GOP group's ad about Kane a lie," September 21, 2012
  6. ↑YouTube Channel, "Backpack," accessed September 24, 2012
  7. ↑PoliticsPA, "Father of rape victim rebukes anti-Kane group," September 21, 2012
  8. ↑8.08.1PoliticsPA, "3 Days Later, GOP Anti-Kane Ad Still Around (Watch Video)," September 24, 2012
  9. ↑PoliticsPA, "McCafferty CM moves to Team Kane," February 20, 2012
  10. ↑PoliticsPA, "Third Dem – Former U.S. Rep. Don Bailey – Makes Attorney General Ballot," February 27, 2012
  11. ↑11.011.111.2Philly.com, "Third Democrat emerges in PA attorney general race," February 29, 2012
  12. ↑PoliticsPA "Bailey to run for AG as Indy not Dem," March 10, 2012
  13. ↑David Freed for AG, "Endorsements," accessed February 15, 2012
  14. ↑PoliticsPA, "Burns CM Kelly joins Freed AG campaign," March 8, 2012
  15. ↑Kathleen Kane for AG "Press Release-President Clinton Endorses Prosecutor Kathleen Kane for Pennsylvania Attorney General," March 26, 2012
  16. ↑The Associated Press, "Murphy, Kane, bring contrasting backgrounds to Democratic race for attorney general," April 14, 2012
  17. ↑Cumberland Link, "Murphy backs Kane for PA attorney general," May 15, 2012
  18. ↑PoliticsPA, "McCafferty CM moves to Team Kane," February 20, 2012
  19. ↑Thedailyreview.com, "Candidates for Pa. Legislature, statewide office speak in Wysox," February 21, 2012
  20. ↑90.5 Essential Public Radio, "David Freed Unopposed as GOP State Attorney General Candidate," February 20, 2012
  21. ↑San Francisco Chronicle, "In AG race, GOP's Freed favors video as evidence," July 27, 2012
  22. ↑PoliticsPA, "Third Dem – Former U.S. Rep. Don Bailey – Makes Attorney General Ballot," February 27, 2012
  23. ↑PoliticsPA "Bailey to run for AG as Indy not Dem," March 10, 2012
  24. ↑Benenson Strategy GroupKane-Poll-Memo, "Recent Pennsylvania Attorney General Primary Election Polling, " January 30, 2012
  25. ↑PoliticsPA "Reader poll-Murphy runs away with AG race," March 30, 2012
  26. ↑NBC 10 Philadelphia, "Murphy vs. Kane Debate," February 10, 2012
  27. ↑PoliticsPA, Kane & Murphy Debate at Summit," February 11, 2012
  28. ↑Pennsylvania Department of State, "Campaign Finance Reports," accessed OCtober 26, 2012
  29. ↑Pennsylvania Department of State, "Campaign Finance Reports," accessed OCtober 26, 2012
v • e
2012 state executive official elections
GovernorStateExecLogo.png
Lieutenant Governor
Secretary of State
Attorney General
Down ballot offices
Treasurer:Missouri •North Carolina •North Dakota •Oregon •Pennsylvania •Utah •Vermont •Washington •West Virginia
Auditor:Montana •North Carolina •North Dakota •Pennsylvania •Utah •Vermont •Washington •West Virginia
Superintendent of Schools:Indiana •Montana •North Carolina •Washington
Insurance Commissioner:Delaware •North Carolina •North Dakota •Washington
Natural Resources Commissioner:Washington
Agriculture Commissioner:North Carolina •West Virginia
Labor Commissioner:North Carolina •Oregon
Public Service Commissioner:Alabama •Arizona •Georgia •Louisiana •Montana •Nebraska •New Mexico •North Dakota •Oklahoma •South Dakota
Railroad Commissioner:Texas
Election information
Flag of Pennsylvania
v • e
State ofPennsylvania
Harrisburg (capital)
Elections

What's on my ballot? |Elections in 2026 |How to vote |How to run for office |Ballot measures

Government

Who represents me? |U.S. President |U.S. Congress |Federal courts |State executives |State legislature |State and local courts |Counties |Cities |School districts |Public policy