Election law changes? Our legislation tracker’s got you.Check it out!

Impeachment of Donald Trump, 2021

From Ballotpedia

Trump Administration (first term)

US-WhiteHouse-Logo.svg

President Donald Trump
Vice President Mike Pence

CabinetWhite House staffTransition teamTrump's second term

Policy positions
Domestic affairs:AbortionCrime and justiceEducationEnergy and the environmentFederal courtsFirearms policyFirst AmendmentHealthcareImmigrationInfrastructureLGBTQ issuesMarijuanaPuerto RicoSocial welfare programsVeteransVoting issues
Economic affairs and regulations:Agriculture and food policyBudgetFinancial regulationJobsSocial SecurityTaxesTrade
Foreign affairs and national security:AfghanistanArab states of the Persian GulfChinaCubaIranIran nuclear dealIslamic State and terrorismIsrael and PalestineLatin AmericaMilitaryNATONorth KoreaPuerto RicoRussiaSyriaSyrian refugeesTechnology, privacy, and cybersecurity

Polling indexes:Opinion polling during the Trump administration

On February 13, 2021, former PresidentDonald Trump (R) was acquitted of incitement of insurrection. Fifty-seven senators voted to convict and 43 voted to acquit. Conviction requires a two-thirds vote of senators present.[1]

On January 13, 2021, the House of Representatives voted to impeach Trump by a vote of 232-197 for incitement of insurrection. The resolution followed the January 6, 2021,breach of the U.S. Capitol, which disrupted a joint session of Congress convened tocount the electoral votes from the2020 presidential election. Ten Republicans supported the impeachment.[2][3]

The resolution alleged that Trump attempted to subvert and obstruct the certification of the election results and incited a crowd to breach the Capitol, leading to vandalism, threats to members of the government and congressional personnel, the death of law enforcement, and other seditious acts.[2]Click here to read the resolution.

On January 12, 2021, Trump called the impeachment resolution the "continuation of the greatest witch hunt in the history of politics." He added, "For Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer to continue on this path, I think it's causing tremendous danger to our country and it's causing tremendous anger."[4]

Pelosi said the House would deliver the article of impeachment to the U.S. Senate on January 25, 2021.[5] Senate Majority LeaderChuck Schumer (N.Y.) said the trial was scheduled to begin the week of February 8, 2021.[6]

On January 25, 2021, House impeachment managers delivered the article of impeachment to the U.S. Senate.[7] Sen.Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.), the president pro tempore of the Senate, presided over the trial.[8]

This was the first time in U.S. history that a president has been impeached twice. Trump was previouslyimpeached and acquitted of abuse of power and obstruction of Congress charges in 2020.

This page contains an overview of the following topics:

Updates

  • February 13, 2021: The Senate voted to acquit Trump of incitement of insurrection by a vote of 57-43.[1]
  • February 9, 2021: The Senate trial began with the House impeachment managers and the president's attorneys debating the constitutionality of the trial. The Senate upheld the constitutionality of the trial by a vote of 56-44.
  • February 4, 2021: Trump declined a request from the House impeachment managers to testify at the Senate trial.[9]
  • January 31, 2021: Trump announced that he had hired David Schoen and Bruce Castor to represent him during the impeachment trial, replacing five previously announced members of his legal team.[10]
  • January 26, 2021: Senators were sworn in for the impeachment trial.[11]
  • January 25, 2021: The House delivered the article of impeachment to the U.S. Senate.[7]
  • January 22, 2021: Pelosi said the House would deliver the article of impeachment to the U.S. Senate on January 25, 2021.[5] Schumer said the trial was scheduled to begin the week of February 8.[6]
  • January 21, 2021: Trump hired South Carolina attorney Butch Bowers to represent him in the impeachment trial.[12]
  • January 13, 2021: The House voted to impeach Trump by a vote of 232-197. Ten Republicans supported the impeachment resolution.[13]

Overview of impeachment process

See also:Impeachment of federal officials

TheUnited States Congress has the constitutional authority to impeach and remove a federal official from office—including the president—if he or she has committed an impeachable offense. Impeaching and removing an official has two stages. First, articles of impeachment against the official must be passed by a majority vote of theU.S. House of Representatives. Then, a trial is conducted in theUnited States Senate potentially leading to the conviction and removal of the official.[14]

In most impeachment trials, the vice president presides over the trial. However, in impeachment trials of the president, the chief justice of theU.S. Supreme Court presides. In order to remove the person from office, two-thirds of senators that are present to vote must vote to convict on the articles of impeachment.[14]

Process for impeachment and conviction

The following two charts show the process for impeachment, which begins in the U.S. House with the introduction of an impeachment resolution and a committee inquiry conducted by theUnited States House Committee on the Judiciary. If the committee adopts articles of impeachment against the official, the articles will go to a full floor vote in the U.S. House.

Congress Impeachment - US House.png


When articles of impeachment are adopted by the U.S. House, the process moves to the U.S. Senate where senators will either acquit or convict the official following a trial.

Congress Impeachment - US Senate.png

Trial in U.S. Senate

Trial timeline

This list provides a timeline of the trial proceedings, a link to a recording of each session, and brief summary of the session's activity.

  • February 13, 2021: Senators voted to acquit Trump of incitement of insurrection by a vote of 57-43.
  • February 12, 2021: Trump's defense team delivered arguments. Senators asked questions of the defense team and House impeachment managers.
  • February 11, 2021: The House impeachment managers finished delivering arguments in the trial.
  • February 10, 2021: The House impeachment managers delivered opening arguments in the trial.
  • February 9, 2021: The House impeachment managers and the president's attorneys debated the constitutionality of the trial. The Senate upheld the constitutionality of the trial by a vote of 56-44.

Impeachment managers

On January 12, 2021, House SpeakerNancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) named nine impeachment managers, who are responsible for presenting the case for impeachment to the U.S. Senate:[15]

Trump's defense attorneys

Trump announced on January 31, 2021, that he had hired David Schoen and Bruce Castor to represent him during the impeachment trial. Schoen previously represented Trump adviserRoger Stone, and Castor is a former district attorney from Pennsylvania.[10]

Trump initially hired South Carolina attorney Butch Bowers and four other attorneys to represent him. Bowers previously represented former South Carolina Govs.Mark Sanford (R) andNikki Haley in separate ethics inquiries.[16] The other four attorneys were Deborah Barbier, Johnny Gasser, Greg Harris, and Joshua Howard. Barbier, Gasser, and Harris are former federal prosecutors.[17]

These five attorneys departed from the case due to a disagreement over strategy, ABC News reported on January 30, 2021.[18]

Vote to acquit (February 13, 2021)

The Senate voted to acquit Trump of incitement of insurrection on February 13, 2021. All 48 Democrats, the two independents who caucused with Democrats, and seven Republicans voted guilty. The other 43 Republicans voted not guilty.[1][19]

The seven Republicans to vote guilty were:

List of U.S. Senate votes on incitement of insurrection, Feb. 13, 2021
OfficialPartyStateVote
Tommy TubervilleEnds.pngRepublicanAlabamaNot guilty
Richard ShelbyEnds.pngRepublicanAlabamaNot guilty
Daniel S. SullivanEnds.pngRepublicanAlaskaNot guilty
Lisa MurkowskiEnds.pngRepublicanAlaskaGuilty
Kyrsten SinemaElectiondot.pngDemocraticArizonaGuilty
Mark KellyElectiondot.pngDemocraticArizonaGuilty
Tom CottonEnds.pngRepublicanArkansasNot guilty
John BoozmanEnds.pngRepublicanArkansasNot guilty
Dianne FeinsteinElectiondot.pngDemocraticCaliforniaGuilty
Alex PadillaElectiondot.pngDemocraticCaliforniaGuilty
Michael BennetElectiondot.pngDemocraticColoradoGuilty
John HickenlooperElectiondot.pngDemocraticColoradoGuilty
Christopher S. MurphyElectiondot.pngDemocraticConnecticutGuilty
Richard BlumenthalElectiondot.pngDemocraticConnecticutGuilty
Tom CarperElectiondot.pngDemocraticDelawareGuilty
Chris CoonsElectiondot.pngDemocraticDelawareGuilty
Rick ScottEnds.pngRepublicanFloridaNot guilty
Marco RubioEnds.pngRepublicanFloridaNot guilty
Jon OssoffElectiondot.pngDemocraticGeorgiaGuilty
Raphael WarnockElectiondot.pngDemocraticGeorgiaGuilty
Brian E. SchatzElectiondot.pngDemocraticHawaiiGuilty
Mazie K. HironoElectiondot.pngDemocraticHawaiiGuilty
Mike CrapoEnds.pngRepublicanIdahoNot guilty
Jim RischEnds.pngRepublicanIdahoNot guilty
Tammy DuckworthElectiondot.pngDemocraticIllinoisGuilty
Dick DurbinElectiondot.pngDemocraticIllinoisGuilty
Mike BraunEnds.pngRepublicanIndianaNot guilty
Todd C. YoungEnds.pngRepublicanIndianaNot guilty
Joni ErnstEnds.pngRepublicanIowaNot guilty
Chuck GrassleyEnds.pngRepublicanIowaNot guilty
Jerry MoranEnds.pngRepublicanKansasNot guilty
Roger MarshallEnds.pngRepublicanKansasNot guilty
Mitch McConnellEnds.pngRepublicanKentuckyNot guilty
Rand PaulEnds.pngRepublicanKentuckyNot guilty
Bill CassidyEnds.pngRepublicanLouisianaGuilty
John Neely KennedyEnds.pngRepublicanLouisianaNot guilty
Angus KingGrey.pngIndependentMaineGuilty
Susan CollinsEnds.pngRepublicanMaineGuilty
Chris Van HollenElectiondot.pngDemocraticMarylandGuilty
Ben CardinElectiondot.pngDemocraticMarylandGuilty
Elizabeth WarrenElectiondot.pngDemocraticMassachusettsGuilty
Edward J. MarkeyElectiondot.pngDemocraticMassachusettsGuilty
Gary PetersElectiondot.pngDemocraticMichiganGuilty
Debbie StabenowElectiondot.pngDemocraticMichiganGuilty
Tina SmithElectiondot.pngDemocraticMinnesotaGuilty
Amy KlobucharElectiondot.pngDemocraticMinnesotaGuilty
Roger WickerEnds.pngRepublicanMississippiNot guilty
Cindy Hyde-SmithEnds.pngRepublicanMississippiNot guilty
Roy BluntEnds.pngRepublicanMissouriNot guilty
Josh HawleyEnds.pngRepublicanMissouriNot guilty
Jon TesterElectiondot.pngDemocraticMontanaGuilty
Steve DainesEnds.pngRepublicanMontanaNot guilty
Ben SasseEnds.pngRepublicanNebraskaGuilty
Deb FischerEnds.pngRepublicanNebraskaNot guilty
Catherine Cortez MastoElectiondot.pngDemocraticNevadaGuilty
Jacky RosenElectiondot.pngDemocraticNevadaGuilty
Maggie HassanElectiondot.pngDemocraticNew HampshireGuilty
Jeanne ShaheenElectiondot.pngDemocraticNew HampshireGuilty
Bob MenendezElectiondot.pngDemocraticNew JerseyGuilty
Cory BookerElectiondot.pngDemocraticNew JerseyGuilty
Tom UdallElectiondot.pngDemocraticNew MexicoGuilty
Martin HeinrichElectiondot.pngDemocraticNew MexicoGuilty
Chuck SchumerElectiondot.pngDemocraticNew YorkGuilty
Kirsten GillibrandElectiondot.pngDemocraticNew YorkGuilty
Richard BurrEnds.pngRepublicanNorth CarolinaGuilty
Thom TillisEnds.pngRepublicanNorth CarolinaNot guilty
John HoevenEnds.pngRepublicanNorth DakotaNot guilty
Kevin CramerEnds.pngRepublicanNorth DakotaNot guilty
Sherrod BrownElectiondot.pngDemocraticOhioGuilty
Rob PortmanEnds.pngRepublicanOhioNot guilty
Jim InhofeEnds.pngRepublicanOklahomaNot guilty
James LankfordEnds.pngRepublicanOklahomaNot guilty
Jeff MerkleyElectiondot.pngDemocraticOregonGuilty
Ron WydenElectiondot.pngDemocraticOregonGuilty
Bob Casey Jr.Electiondot.pngDemocraticPennsylvaniaGuilty
Pat ToomeyEnds.pngRepublicanPennsylvaniaGuilty
Sheldon WhitehouseElectiondot.pngDemocraticRhode IslandGuilty
Jack ReedElectiondot.pngDemocraticRhode IslandGuilty
Lindsey GrahamEnds.pngRepublicanSouth CarolinaNot guilty
Tim ScottEnds.pngRepublicanSouth CarolinaNot guilty
John ThuneEnds.pngRepublicanSouth DakotaNot guilty
Mike RoundsEnds.pngRepublicanSouth DakotaNot guilty
Bill HagertyEnds.pngRepublicanTennesseeNot guilty
Marsha BlackburnEnds.pngRepublicanTennesseeNot guilty
Ted CruzEnds.pngRepublicanTexasNot guilty
John CornynEnds.pngRepublicanTexasNot guilty
Mike LeeEnds.pngRepublicanUtahNot guilty
Mitt RomneyEnds.pngRepublicanUtahGuilty
Patrick LeahyElectiondot.pngDemocraticVermontGuilty
Bernie SandersGrey.pngIndependentVermontGuilty
Tim KaineElectiondot.pngDemocraticVirginiaGuilty
Mark WarnerElectiondot.pngDemocraticVirginiaGuilty
Maria CantwellElectiondot.pngDemocraticWashingtonGuilty
Patty MurrayElectiondot.pngDemocraticWashingtonGuilty
Joe Manchin IIIElectiondot.pngDemocraticWest VirginiaGuilty
Shelley Moore CapitoEnds.pngRepublicanWest VirginiaNot guilty
Tammy BaldwinElectiondot.pngDemocraticWisconsinGuilty
Ronald Harold JohnsonEnds.pngRepublicanWisconsinNot guilty
John BarrassoEnds.pngRepublicanWyomingNot guilty
Cynthia LummisEnds.pngRepublicanWyomingNot guilty

Vote on constitutionality of the trial (February 9, 2021)

The Senate upheld the constitutionality of the trial after hearing a debate on the subject on February 9, 2021. All Democrats and six Republicans supported the motion:[20]

Vote on motion challenging constitutionality of the trial (January 26, 2021)

Sen.Rand Paul (R-Ky.) requested a vote on the constitutionality of the trial on January 26, 2021. The Senate voted to table that motion by 55-45. All Democrats and five Republicans voted down the motion:[21]

Relevant links

U.S. House vote on article of impeachment

On January 13, 2021, the House impeached Trump for incitement of insurrection by a vote of 232 to 197.

House debates and votes on article of impeachment against President Donald Trump, January 13, 2021
House vote on impeachment of Trump for incitement of insurrection (January 13, 2021)
RepresentativePartyStateVote to impeach
AdamsDemocratic Party DemocraticNCYes
AderholtRepublican Party RepublicanALNo
AguilarDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
AllenRepublican Party RepublicanGANo
AllredDemocratic Party DemocraticTXYes
AmodeiRepublican Party RepublicanNVNo
ArmstrongRepublican Party RepublicanNDNo
ArringtonRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
AuchinclossDemocratic Party DemocraticMAYes
AxneDemocratic Party DemocraticIAYes
BabinRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
BaconRepublican Party RepublicanNENo
BairdRepublican Party RepublicanINNo
BaldersonRepublican Party RepublicanOHNo
BanksRepublican Party RepublicanINNo
BarrRepublican Party RepublicanKYNo
BarragánDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
BassDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
BeattyDemocratic Party DemocraticOHYes
BentzRepublican Party RepublicanORNo
BeraDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
BergmanRepublican Party RepublicanMINo
BeyerDemocratic Party DemocraticVAYes
Bice (OK)Republican Party RepublicanOKNo
BiggsRepublican Party RepublicanAZNo
BilirakisRepublican Party RepublicanFLNo
Bishop (GA)Democratic Party DemocraticGAYes
Bishop (NC)Republican Party RepublicanNCNo
BlumenauerDemocratic Party DemocraticORYes
Blunt RochesterDemocratic Party DemocraticDEYes
BoebertRepublican Party RepublicanCONo
BonamiciDemocratic Party DemocraticORYes
BostRepublican Party RepublicanILNo
BourdeauxDemocratic Party DemocraticGAYes
BowmanDemocratic Party DemocraticNYYes
Boyle, Brendan F.Democratic Party DemocraticPAYes
BradyRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
BrooksRepublican Party RepublicanALNo
BrownDemocratic Party DemocraticMDYes
BrownleyDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
BuchananRepublican Party RepublicanFLNo
BuckRepublican Party RepublicanCONo
BucshonRepublican Party RepublicanINNo
BuddRepublican Party RepublicanNCNo
BurchettRepublican Party RepublicanTNNo
BurgessRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
BushDemocratic Party DemocraticMOYes
BustosDemocratic Party DemocraticILYes
ButterfieldDemocratic Party DemocraticNCYes
CalvertRepublican Party RepublicanCANo
CammackRepublican Party RepublicanFLNo
CarbajalDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
CárdenasDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
CarlRepublican Party RepublicanALNo
CarsonDemocratic Party DemocraticINYes
Carter (GA)Republican Party RepublicanGANo
Carter (TX)Republican Party RepublicanTXNo
CartwrightDemocratic Party DemocraticPAYes
CaseDemocratic Party DemocraticHIYes
CastenDemocratic Party DemocraticILYes
Castor (FL)Democratic Party DemocraticFLYes
Castro (TX)Democratic Party DemocraticTXYes
CawthornRepublican Party RepublicanNCNo
ChabotRepublican Party RepublicanOHNo
CheneyRepublican Party RepublicanWYYes
ChuDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
CicillineDemocratic Party DemocraticRIYes
Clark (MA)Democratic Party DemocraticMAYes
Clarke (NY)Democratic Party DemocraticNYYes
CleaverDemocratic Party DemocraticMOYes
ClineRepublican Party RepublicanVANo
CloudRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
ClyburnDemocratic Party DemocraticSCYes
ClydeRepublican Party RepublicanGANo
CohenDemocratic Party DemocraticTNYes
ColeRepublican Party RepublicanOKNo
ComerRepublican Party RepublicanKYNo
ConnollyDemocratic Party DemocraticVAYes
CooperDemocratic Party DemocraticTNYes
CorreaDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
CostaDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
CourtneyDemocratic Party DemocraticCTYes
CraigDemocratic Party DemocraticMNYes
CrawfordRepublican Party RepublicanARNo
CrenshawRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
CristDemocratic Party DemocraticFLYes
CrowDemocratic Party DemocraticCOYes
CuellarDemocratic Party DemocraticTXYes
CurtisRepublican Party RepublicanUTNo
Davids (KS)Democratic Party DemocraticKSYes
DavidsonRepublican Party RepublicanOHNo
Davis, Danny K.Democratic Party DemocraticILYes
Davis, RodneyRepublican Party RepublicanILNo
DeanDemocratic Party DemocraticPAYes
DeFazioDemocratic Party DemocraticORYes
DeGetteDemocratic Party DemocraticCOYes
DeLauroDemocratic Party DemocraticCTYes
DelBeneDemocratic Party DemocraticWAYes
DelgadoDemocratic Party DemocraticNYYes
DemingsDemocratic Party DemocraticFLYes
DeSaulnierDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
DesJarlaisRepublican Party RepublicanTNNo
DeutchDemocratic Party DemocraticFLYes
Diaz-BalartRepublican Party RepublicanFLNo
DingellDemocratic Party DemocraticMIYes
DoggettDemocratic Party DemocraticTXYes
DonaldsRepublican Party RepublicanFLNo
Doyle, Michael F.Democratic Party DemocraticPAYes
DuncanRepublican Party RepublicanSCNo
DunnRepublican Party RepublicanFLNo
EmmerRepublican Party RepublicanMNNo
EscobarDemocratic Party DemocraticTXYes
EshooDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
EspaillatDemocratic Party DemocraticNYYes
EstesRepublican Party RepublicanKSNo
EvansDemocratic Party DemocraticPAYes
FallonRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
FeenstraRepublican Party RepublicanIANo
FergusonRepublican Party RepublicanGANo
FischbachRepublican Party RepublicanMNNo
FitzgeraldRepublican Party RepublicanWINo
FitzpatrickRepublican Party RepublicanPANo
FleischmannRepublican Party RepublicanTNNo
FletcherDemocratic Party DemocraticTXYes
FortenberryRepublican Party RepublicanNENo
FosterDemocratic Party DemocraticILYes
FoxxRepublican Party RepublicanNCNo
Frankel, LoisDemocratic Party DemocraticFLYes
Franklin, C. ScottRepublican Party RepublicanFLNo
FudgeDemocratic Party DemocraticOHYes
FulcherRepublican Party RepublicanIDNo
GaetzRepublican Party RepublicanFLNo
GallagherRepublican Party RepublicanWINo
GallegoDemocratic Party DemocraticAZYes
GaramendiDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
GarbarinoRepublican Party RepublicanNYNo
Garcia (CA)Republican Party RepublicanCANo
García (IL)Democratic Party DemocraticILYes
Garcia (TX)Democratic Party DemocraticTXYes
GibbsRepublican Party RepublicanOHNo
GimenezRepublican Party RepublicanFLNo
GohmertRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
GoldenDemocratic Party DemocraticMEYes
GomezDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
Gonzales, TonyRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
Gonzalez (OH)Republican Party RepublicanOHYes
Gonzalez, VicenteDemocratic Party DemocraticTXYes
Good (VA)Republican Party RepublicanVANo
Gooden (TX)Republican Party RepublicanTXNo
GosarRepublican Party RepublicanAZNo
GottheimerDemocratic Party DemocraticNJYes
GrangerRepublican Party RepublicanTXNot voting
Graves (LA)Republican Party RepublicanLANo
Graves (MO)Republican Party RepublicanMONo
Green (TN)Republican Party RepublicanTNNo
Green, Al (TX)Democratic Party DemocraticTXYes
Greene (GA)Republican Party RepublicanGANo
GriffithRepublican Party RepublicanVANo
GrijalvaDemocratic Party DemocraticAZYes
GrothmanRepublican Party RepublicanWINo
GuestRepublican Party RepublicanMSNo
GuthrieRepublican Party RepublicanKYNo
HaalandDemocratic Party DemocraticNMYes
HagedornRepublican Party RepublicanMNNo
Harder (CA)Democratic Party DemocraticCAYes
HarrisRepublican Party RepublicanMDNot voting
HarshbargerRepublican Party RepublicanTNNo
HartzlerRepublican Party RepublicanMONo
HastingsDemocratic Party DemocraticFLYes
HayesDemocratic Party DemocraticCTYes
HernRepublican Party RepublicanOKNo
HerrellRepublican Party RepublicanNMNo
Herrera BeutlerRepublican Party RepublicanWAYes
Hice (GA)Republican Party RepublicanGANo
Higgins (LA)Republican Party RepublicanLANo
Higgins (NY)Democratic Party DemocraticNYYes
HillRepublican Party RepublicanARNo
HimesDemocratic Party DemocraticCTYes
HinsonRepublican Party RepublicanIANo
HollingsworthRepublican Party RepublicanINNo
HorsfordDemocratic Party DemocraticNVYes
HoulahanDemocratic Party DemocraticPAYes
HoyerDemocratic Party DemocraticMDYes
HudsonRepublican Party RepublicanNCNo
HuffmanDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
HuizengaRepublican Party RepublicanMINo
IssaRepublican Party RepublicanCANo
JacksonRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
Jackson LeeDemocratic Party DemocraticTXYes
Jacobs (CA)Democratic Party DemocraticCAYes
Jacobs (NY)Republican Party RepublicanNYNo
JayapalDemocratic Party DemocraticWAYes
JeffriesDemocratic Party DemocraticNYYes
Johnson (GA)Democratic Party DemocraticGAYes
Johnson (LA)Republican Party RepublicanLANo
Johnson (OH)Republican Party RepublicanOHNo
Johnson (SD)Republican Party RepublicanSDNo
Johnson (TX)Democratic Party DemocraticTXYes
JonesDemocratic Party DemocraticNYYes
JordanRepublican Party RepublicanOHNo
Joyce (OH)Republican Party RepublicanOHNo
Joyce (PA)Republican Party RepublicanPANo
KaheleDemocratic Party DemocraticHIYes
KapturDemocratic Party DemocraticOHYes
KatkoRepublican Party RepublicanNYYes
KeatingDemocratic Party DemocraticMAYes
KellerRepublican Party RepublicanPANo
Kelly (IL)Democratic Party DemocraticILYes
Kelly (MS)Republican Party RepublicanMSNo
Kelly (PA)Republican Party RepublicanPANo
KhannaDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
KildeeDemocratic Party DemocraticMIYes
KilmerDemocratic Party DemocraticWAYes
Kim (CA)Republican Party RepublicanCANo
Kim (NJ)Democratic Party DemocraticNJYes
KindDemocratic Party DemocraticWIYes
KinzingerRepublican Party RepublicanILYes
KirkpatrickDemocratic Party DemocraticAZYes
KrishnamoorthiDemocratic Party DemocraticILYes
KusterDemocratic Party DemocraticNHYes
KustoffRepublican Party RepublicanTNNo
LaHoodRepublican Party RepublicanILNo
LaMalfaRepublican Party RepublicanCANo
LambDemocratic Party DemocraticPAYes
LambornRepublican Party RepublicanCONo
LangevinDemocratic Party DemocraticRIYes
Larsen (WA)Democratic Party DemocraticWAYes
Larson (CT)Democratic Party DemocraticCTYes
LattaRepublican Party RepublicanOHNo
LaTurnerRepublican Party RepublicanKSNo
LawrenceDemocratic Party DemocraticMIYes
Lawson (FL)Democratic Party DemocraticFLYes
Lee (CA)Democratic Party DemocraticCAYes
Lee (NV)Democratic Party DemocraticNVYes
Leger FernandezDemocratic Party DemocraticNMYes
LeskoRepublican Party RepublicanAZNo
Levin (CA)Democratic Party DemocraticCAYes
Levin (MI)Democratic Party DemocraticMIYes
LieuDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
LofgrenDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
LongRepublican Party RepublicanMONo
LoudermilkRepublican Party RepublicanGANo
LowenthalDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
LucasRepublican Party RepublicanOKNo
LuetkemeyerRepublican Party RepublicanMONo
LuriaDemocratic Party DemocraticVAYes
LynchDemocratic Party DemocraticMAYes
MaceRepublican Party RepublicanSCNo
MalinowskiDemocratic Party DemocraticNJYes
MalliotakisRepublican Party RepublicanNYNo
Maloney, Carolyn B.Democratic Party DemocraticNYYes
Maloney, SeanDemocratic Party DemocraticNYYes
MannRepublican Party RepublicanKSNo
ManningDemocratic Party DemocraticNCYes
MassieRepublican Party RepublicanKYNo
MastRepublican Party RepublicanFLNo
MatsuiDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
McBathDemocratic Party DemocraticGAYes
McCarthyRepublican Party RepublicanCANo
McCaulRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
McClainRepublican Party RepublicanMINo
McClintockRepublican Party RepublicanCANo
McCollumDemocratic Party DemocraticMNYes
McEachinDemocratic Party DemocraticVAYes
McGovernDemocratic Party DemocraticMAYes
McHenryRepublican Party RepublicanNCNo
McKinleyRepublican Party RepublicanWVNo
McNerneyDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
MeeksDemocratic Party DemocraticNYYes
MeijerRepublican Party RepublicanMIYes
MengDemocratic Party DemocraticNYYes
MeuserRepublican Party RepublicanPANo
MfumeDemocratic Party DemocraticMDYes
Miller (IL)Republican Party RepublicanILNo
Miller (WV)Republican Party RepublicanWVNo
Miller-MeeksRepublican Party RepublicanIANo
MoolenaarRepublican Party RepublicanMINo
MooneyRepublican Party RepublicanWVNo
Moore (AL)Republican Party RepublicanALNo
Moore (UT)Republican Party RepublicanUTNo
Moore (WI)Democratic Party DemocraticWIYes
MorelleDemocratic Party DemocraticNYYes
MoultonDemocratic Party DemocraticMAYes
MrvanDemocratic Party DemocraticINYes
MullinRepublican Party RepublicanOKNo
Murphy (FL)Democratic Party DemocraticFLYes
Murphy (NC)Republican Party RepublicanNCNot voting
NadlerDemocratic Party DemocraticNYYes
NapolitanoDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
NealDemocratic Party DemocraticMAYes
NeguseDemocratic Party DemocraticCOYes
NehlsRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
NewhouseRepublican Party RepublicanWAYes
NewmanDemocratic Party DemocraticILYes
NorcrossDemocratic Party DemocraticNJYes
NormanRepublican Party RepublicanSCNo
NunesRepublican Party RepublicanCANo
O'HalleranDemocratic Party DemocraticAZYes
ObernolteRepublican Party RepublicanCANo
Ocasio-CortezDemocratic Party DemocraticNYYes
OmarDemocratic Party DemocraticMNYes
OwensRepublican Party RepublicanUTNo
PalazzoRepublican Party RepublicanMSNo
PalloneDemocratic Party DemocraticNJYes
PalmerRepublican Party RepublicanALNo
PanettaDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
PappasDemocratic Party DemocraticNHYes
PascrellDemocratic Party DemocraticNJYes
PayneDemocratic Party DemocraticNJYes
PelosiDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
PenceRepublican Party RepublicanINNo
PerlmutterDemocratic Party DemocraticCOYes
PerryRepublican Party RepublicanPANo
PetersDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
PflugerRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
PhillipsDemocratic Party DemocraticMNYes
PingreeDemocratic Party DemocraticMEYes
PocanDemocratic Party DemocraticWIYes
PorterDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
PoseyRepublican Party RepublicanFLNo
PressleyDemocratic Party DemocraticMAYes
Price (NC)Democratic Party DemocraticNCYes
QuigleyDemocratic Party DemocraticILYes
RaskinDemocratic Party DemocraticMDYes
ReedRepublican Party RepublicanNYNo
ReschenthalerRepublican Party RepublicanPANo
Rice (NY)Democratic Party DemocraticNYYes
Rice (SC)Republican Party RepublicanSCYes
RichmondDemocratic Party DemocraticLAYes
Rodgers (WA)Republican Party RepublicanWANo
Rogers (AL)Republican Party RepublicanALNo
Rogers (KY)Republican Party RepublicanKYNo
RoseRepublican Party RepublicanTNNo
RosendaleRepublican Party RepublicanMTNo
RossDemocratic Party DemocraticNCYes
RouzerRepublican Party RepublicanNCNo
RoyRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
Roybal-AllardDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
RuizDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
RuppersbergerDemocratic Party DemocraticMDYes
RushDemocratic Party DemocraticILYes
RutherfordRepublican Party RepublicanFLNo
RyanDemocratic Party DemocraticOHYes
SalazarRepublican Party RepublicanFLNo
SánchezDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
SarbanesDemocratic Party DemocraticMDYes
ScaliseRepublican Party RepublicanLANo
ScanlonDemocratic Party DemocraticPAYes
SchakowskyDemocratic Party DemocraticILYes
SchiffDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
SchneiderDemocratic Party DemocraticILYes
SchraderDemocratic Party DemocraticORYes
SchrierDemocratic Party DemocraticWAYes
SchweikertRepublican Party RepublicanAZNo
Scott (VA)Democratic Party DemocraticVAYes
Scott, AustinRepublican Party RepublicanGANo
Scott, DavidDemocratic Party DemocraticGAYes
SessionsRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
SewellDemocratic Party DemocraticALYes
ShermanDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
SherrillDemocratic Party DemocraticNJYes
SimpsonRepublican Party RepublicanIDNo
SiresDemocratic Party DemocraticNJYes
SlotkinDemocratic Party DemocraticMIYes
Smith (MO)Republican Party RepublicanMONo
Smith (NE)Republican Party RepublicanNENo
Smith (NJ)Republican Party RepublicanNJNo
Smith (WA)Democratic Party DemocraticWAYes
SmuckerRepublican Party RepublicanPANo
SotoDemocratic Party DemocraticFLYes
SpanbergerDemocratic Party DemocraticVAYes
SpartzRepublican Party RepublicanINNo
SpeierDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
StantonDemocratic Party DemocraticAZYes
StauberRepublican Party RepublicanMNNo
SteelRepublican Party RepublicanCANo
StefanikRepublican Party RepublicanNYNo
SteilRepublican Party RepublicanWINo
SteubeRepublican Party RepublicanFLNo
StevensDemocratic Party DemocraticMIYes
StewartRepublican Party RepublicanUTNo
StiversRepublican Party RepublicanOHNo
StricklandDemocratic Party DemocraticWAYes
SuozziDemocratic Party DemocraticNYYes
SwalwellDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
TakanoDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
TaylorRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
Thompson (CA)Democratic Party DemocraticCAYes
Thompson (MS)Democratic Party DemocraticMSYes
Thompson (PA)Republican Party RepublicanPANo
TiffanyRepublican Party RepublicanWINo
TimmonsRepublican Party RepublicanSCNo
TitusDemocratic Party DemocraticNVYes
TlaibDemocratic Party DemocraticMIYes
TonkoDemocratic Party DemocraticNYYes
Torres (CA)Democratic Party DemocraticCAYes
Torres (NY)Democratic Party DemocraticNYYes
TrahanDemocratic Party DemocraticMAYes
TroneDemocratic Party DemocraticMDYes
TurnerRepublican Party RepublicanOHNo
UnderwoodDemocratic Party DemocraticILYes
UptonRepublican Party RepublicanMIYes
ValadaoRepublican Party RepublicanCAYes
Van DrewRepublican Party RepublicanNJNo
Van DuyneRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
VargasDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
VeaseyDemocratic Party DemocraticTXYes
VelaDemocratic Party DemocraticTXYes
VelázquezDemocratic Party DemocraticNYYes
WagnerRepublican Party RepublicanMONo
WalbergRepublican Party RepublicanMINo
WalorskiRepublican Party RepublicanINNo
WaltzRepublican Party RepublicanFLNo
Wasserman SchultzDemocratic Party DemocraticFLYes
WatersDemocratic Party DemocraticCAYes
Watson ColemanDemocratic Party DemocraticNJYes
Weber (TX)Republican Party RepublicanTXNo
Webster (FL)Republican Party RepublicanFLNot voting
WelchDemocratic Party DemocraticVTYes
WenstrupRepublican Party RepublicanOHNo
WestermanRepublican Party RepublicanARNo
WextonDemocratic Party DemocraticVAYes
WildDemocratic Party DemocraticPAYes
Williams (GA)Democratic Party DemocraticGAYes
Williams (TX)Republican Party RepublicanTXNo
Wilson (FL)Democratic Party DemocraticFLYes
Wilson (SC)Republican Party RepublicanSCNo
WittmanRepublican Party RepublicanVANo
WomackRepublican Party RepublicanARNo
WrightRepublican Party RepublicanTXNo
YarmuthDemocratic Party DemocraticKYYes
YoungRepublican Party RepublicanAKNo
ZeldinRepublican Party RepublicanNYNo

Article of impeachment

The following document contains the text of the article of impeachment.

Supporting materials prepared by the House Committee on the Judiciary

On January 12, 2021, the House Judiciary Committee Majority Staff prepared the following report providing background materials on the breach of the Capitol and the standards and argument for impeachment.

Constitutionality of Senate trial of former president

The question of whether the Senate can hold a trial for and convict a former president is unsettled. Article II, Section 4 of the U.S. Constitution provides:[22]

The President, Vice President and all civil Officers of the United States, shall be removed from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.[23]
—Article II, Section 4, of the U.S. Constitution

Article I, Section 3, of the Constitution, also states the following:

Judgment in Cases of Impeachment shall not extend further than to removal from Office, and disqualification to hold and enjoy any Office of honor, Trust or Profit under the United States: but the Party convicted shall nevertheless be liable and subject to Indictment, Trial, Judgment and Punishment, according to Law.[23]
—Article I, Section 3, Clause 7, of the U.S. Constitution


J. Michael Luttig, who served on theU.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit for 25 years, said that such a trial would be unconstitutional. He interpreted the language of Section 4 to refer to an official in office.[24]

Luttig said, "The very concept of constitutional impeachment presupposes the impeachment, conviction and removal of a president who is, at the time of his impeachment, an incumbent in the office from which he is removed. Indeed, that was the purpose of the impeachment power, to remove from office a president or other 'civil official' before he could further harm the nation from the office he then occupies."[24]

Laurence Tribe, a professor emeritus at Harvard Law School, said that the Senate had the constitutional authority to pursue proceedings against a former present. He said that Article I, Section 3, distinguishes between removal and disqualification. He said,

"To be sure, a former officer may no longer be 'removed' even upon conviction by a two-thirds vote. But that has no bearing on whether such an ex-officer may be barred permanently from office upon being convicted. That separate judgment would require no more than a simple majority vote," Tribe said. "Concluding otherwise would all but erase the disqualification power from the Constitution’s text: If an impeachable officer became immune from trial and conviction upon leaving office, any official seeing conviction as imminent could easily remove the prospect of disqualification simply by resigning moments before the Senate’s anticipated verdict."[25]

The Congressional Research Service said in a report on January 15, 2021, "Though the text is open to debate, it appears that most scholars who have closely examined the question have concluded that Congress has authority to extend the impeachmentprocess to officials who are no longer in office."[26]

Click on one of the following links for additional arguments for and against the constitutionality of the trial:

Which presidents have been impeached?

See also:Impeachment of federal officials

This section provides a brief history of the impeachment of presidents. Of the other three presidents who have had articles of impeachment against them adopted, two were acquitted by the U.S. Senate and one resigned before the full U.S. House vote took place.

Andrew Johnson

On February 24, 1868, PresidentAndrew Johnson (Union) became the first sitting president to be impeached. FollowingCongress' passage of the Tenure of Office Act forbidding the president from removing federal officials without the approval of Congress, Johnson firedSecretary of War Edwin Stanton and replaced him withUlysses S. Grant. Johnson hoped to challenge the constitutionality of the Act.

TheHouse charged him with violating the Act and passed an impeachment resolution 126-47. Johnson was acquitted by theSenate on May 16, 1868, by a vote of 35-19, one vote short of two-thirds. SevenRepublican senators broke ranks with the party to prevent Johnson's conviction.[27]

Richard Nixon

Three articles of impeachment for obstruction of justice, misuse of power, and contempt of Congress were approved by the House Judiciary Committee against PresidentRichard Nixon (R) in July 1974. The charges followed Nixon's involvement in covering up the attempted burglary and wiretapping of the Democratic National Committee headquarters at Watergate two years earlier.

Nixon resigned on August 8, 1974, before the articles of impeachment went to a full floor vote in the House.[28]

Bill Clinton

PresidentWilliam Jefferson Clinton (D) was impeached by theU.S. House on charges of perjury and obstruction of justice on December 19, 1998. The first article of impeachment for perjury passed the House by a vote of 228-206, while the second vote on obstruction of justice passed by 221-212. The charges stemmed from an affair Clinton had with White House staffer Monica Lewinski. House Republicans accused Clinton of lying and having others lie to hide the affair. Two other charges, perjury in regards to an affair with Paula Jones and abuse of power, were rejected by the House.[29]

With 708 days remaining in his second term as president, the Senate acquitted Clinton on both charges brought up by the House on February 12, 1999. The perjury charge failed by a vote of 45-55 while the obstruction of justice charge failed on a tied vote of 50-50.[30]

See also

Footnotes

  1. 1.01.11.2The New York Times, "Live Senate Vote Results: Impeachment Charge Against Trump," February 13, 2021
  2. 2.02.1Associated Press, "Republicans block measure calling for quick removal of Trump," January 11, 2021
  3. CNN, "House Democrats introduce impeachment resolution, charging Trump with 'incitement of insurrection,'" January 11, 2021
  4. NBC New York, "Latest Updates: Trump Calls Impeachment Push ‘Continuation of Greatest Witch Hunt,'" January 12, 2021
  5. 5.05.1Speaker of the House, "Pelosi Announces House Will Deliver Article of Impeachment to Senate on January 25," January 22, 2021
  6. 6.06.1CBS News, "Trump's impeachment trial to begin week of February 8," January 23, 2021
  7. 7.07.1Politico, "Trump's second impeachment trial launches with questions over witnesses," January 25, 2021
  8. Sen. Patrick Leahy, "Comment On Presiding Over The Impeachment Trial Of President Donald Trump," January 25, 2021
  9. CNN, "Trump quickly rejects impeachment managers' request for testimony at impeachment trial," February 4, 2021
  10. 10.010.1The New York Times, "Trump Names Two Members of Impeachment Defense Team," January 31, 2021
  11. CNN, "Senators sworn in for Trump impeachment trial," January 26, 2021
  12. Forbes, "Reports: Trump Hires Attorney Butch Bowers After Struggling To Form Impeachment Defense Team," January 21, 2021
  13. CNN, "House impeaches Trump for role in deadly Capitol riot," January 13, 2021
  14. 14.014.1Congressional Research Service, "Impeachment and removal," October 29, 2015
  15. The Hill, "Pelosi names 9 impeachment managers," January 12, 2021
  16. The Post and Courier, "Butch Bowers, SC’s go-to GOP lawyer, seen as steady hand in Trump’s impeachment defense," January 22, 2021
  17. CNN, "Three new lawyers added to Trump’s impeachment defense, boosting team to five," January 29, 2021
  18. ABC News, "Donald Trump's entire legal team quits week before impeachment trial," January 30, 2021
  19. United States Senate, "Question: Guilty or Not Guilty (Article of Impeachment Against Former President Donald John Trump )," accessed February 15, 2021
  20. Senate.gov, "On the Motion (Is Former President Donald John Trump Subject to a Court of Impeachment for Acts Committed While President?)," February 9, 2021
  21. Vox, "A stunt from Rand Paul reveals limited Republican support for impeachment," January 26, 2021
  22. Constitution Center, "Article II: Executive Branch," accessed January 25, 2021
  23. 23.023.1Note: This text is quoted verbatim from the original source. Any inconsistencies are attributable to the original source.
  24. 24.024.1The Washington Post, "Once Trump leaves office, the Senate can’t hold an impeachment trial," January 12, 2021
  25. The Washington Post, "The Senate can constitutionally hold an impeachment trial after Trump leaves office," January 13, 2021
  26. Congressional Research Service, "The Impeachment and Trial of a Former President," January 15, 2021
  27. PBS, "The Impeachment of Andrew Johnson," accessed March 27, 2014
  28. History, "The Watergate Scandal: A Timeline," June 10, 2019
  29. New York Times, "IMPEACHMENT: THE OVERVIEW -- CLINTON IMPEACHED; HE FACES A SENATE TRIAL, 2D IN HISTORY; VOWS TO DO JOB TILL TERM'S 'LAST HOUR'," December 22, 1998
  30. Washington Post, "The Senate Acquits President Clinton," February 13, 1999
v  e
2020 United States presidential election
OverviewsPresidential Elections-2016-badge.png
Primaries and election dates
Democratic nomination
Democratic debates
Republican nomination
Issues
v  e
Ballotpedia
About
Editorial Content
Geoff Pallay, Director of Editorial Content and Editor-in-ChiefKen Carbullido, Vice President of Election Product and Technology StrategyNorm Leahy, Senior EditorDaniel Anderson, Managing EditorRyan Byrne, Managing EditorCory Eucalitto, Managing EditorMandy McConnell, Managing EditorDoug Kronaizl, Local Elections Project ManagerJaclyn BeranMarielle BrickerJoseph BrusgardEmma BurlingameKelly CoyleThomas EllisFrank FestaNicole FisherBrianna HoseaJoseph GreaneyThomas GrobbenJaime Healy-PlotkinTyler KingGlorie MartinezNathan MaxwellEllie MikusJackie MitchellEllen MorrisseyMackenzie MurphyKaley PlatekSamantha PostAdam PowellEthan RiceSpencer RichardsonVictoria RoseBriana RyanMyj SaintylMaddy SaluckaMaddie Sinclair JohnsonAbbey SmithAlexis ThackerJanie ValentineJoel WilliamsSamuel WonacottTrenton Woodcox