Rating:9
Approval:87.7% (16 votes)
This is the sort of anime that takes a lot of heat, and judging from the opinions I've seen in reviews and other writings on Chikyuu Shoujo Arjuna, I get the impression this is one you'll either really love or really hate. I'm going to go out on a limb and make some people mad by saying this, but I'm quite convinced that strong dislike for Arjuna goes hand-in-hand with complete denial or misunderstanding of what it's about. This is a story about topics that are uncomfortable for most people, even those already acquainted with the natural world, ecological responsibility, and conservation. This is a story about the core of human ignorance, our obsession with taking the easy path, and what it really means to save or protect something, once human constructs are all stripped away.
I first read about Chikyuu Shoujo Arjuna on someone's recommendations list on Greencine, and it sounded really interesting. But then I looked it up on AniDB, and got a very different impression. Between the horrible synopsis and the ridiculous genre classifications (as of my writing: Magic, Romance, and Super Power), I got the feeling this would be a cheesy Captain Planet immitation made for young children. I couldn't have been more mistaken.
The only thing that convinced me to give Arjuna a try was reading the credits and seeing Yoko Kanno's name. I was a bit unsure what to think after the first two episodes, which seem more like they're made to get shallow action fans hooked than contribute to the story, but the beauty of the composition caught me right from the beginning: the unconventional opening, interweaving of future scenes, beautiful animation and 'camera work', and most notably the choreography and integration of music with the action.
In all technical and artistic aspects, Chikyuu Shoujo Arjuna is a gem. The music is Yoko Kanno and Maaya at their best, with songs ranging from catchy-yet-not-sappy (Mameshiba, Kakusei, Cloe, Baiku) to calm and soothing (Sanctuary, Aqua Aqua). Some of the songs have a little bit of an Indian feel to them, but not extremely so. Even if you have no interest in this series whatsoever, get both OST discs, because it's among the best anime music you'll ever hear.
The animation is also quite impressive. There's just a huge range of style, from a mostly-still sketch/watercolor type look during some of the previews to fluid full-motion sequences with breathtaking color and contrast, and even some live action clips. None of the animation is choppy, and I find myself remembering lots of big scenes where the backgrounds were highly non-static, and where the foregrounds also conveyed a lot more motion and fluidity than I'm used to seeing in anime.
I say it was the first two episodes I expect were made to hook viewers, but what got me hooked on Arjuna were the third and fourth episode where the pace and tone changed completely, from action to something serene and contemplative. Much of my appreciation for what happened at this point was very personal, and may not be received the same way by others; I found it reminding me of all the feelings, intentions, and self-promises I'd gone through as I discovered many of the same sorts of things Juna did growing up, reminding me of my commitments to do what I could not to harm the world and to make something better of myself. I can't expect others to feel the same sort of nostalgia, but perhaps if these ideas aren't something already close to you, Arjuna will make you think about things you've never considered before.
To me, Arjuna's greatest strength and the defining aspect that set it apart from all the other anime I've seen was the time it devoted to simple presence on the earth. This mostly takes the form of Juna's self-discovery of what living as a being on the earth entails, as she's forced to experience nature in a way reminiscent of Thoreau's Walden and to explore the question of how the world can possibly be saved, in a simlar sense to the notion of "saving the world" in Daniel Quinn's Ishmael. Sometimes the self-discovery element of Arjuna manifests as Socratic-style dialogues between various 'philosopher' personae and Juna and her boyfriend Tokio, while at other times it's silent and conveyed mostly through the visuals and music.
Clearly this is anime for people who both think and feel and care with the depths of their hearts, but it will also inevitably annoy you if you're such a person. Despite her intimate connection with the earth, Juna is incredibly naive, and continually responds to some of the most basic truths about the world as if they were deep revelations, which at times can feel like it's mocking your intelligence. If you're the sort of person who wants a heroic protagonist who always knows what's going on and makes the right decisions, you won't like Juna. But what does make Juna likable is her complete rejection of apathy, and determination to do something to change things even if her naivete leads her to do the wrong thing and make the situation worse. And what's more, making you feel belittled and ignorant as you see things through Juna's eyes is part of the power of the message of the work.
In addition to Juna, thoughtful viewers who sympathize with Juna and with the planet will probably also be annoyed by Tokio, Juna's down-to-earth and oftentimes cynical boyfriend. He gets her down a lot with thinking along the lines of "There's nothing we can do to change it," and a complete failure to understand what she cares about and what she's experiencing. While frustrating to viewers like myself, and while it leads to disappointment again and again, this setup is what makes the treatment of romance in Arjuna really fitting to the message of the series. What develops is a story of the strain on relationships when one of the people involved begins to realize and focus everything upon an ideal that's dear to her, but that's ignored or scorned by society at large. Beyond romantic relationships, this sort of tension can and does extend to all human relationships, both in Arjuna and in the real world, and its treatment in the anime lends a huge deal of depth and credibility to the story that otherwise would be missing. I must also comment that the whole setup of starting Juna and Tokio out as a troubled couple provided a refreshing deviation from the typical "boy meets girl, they fall in love" pattern so often seen.
Want more that will annoy you? There's also the whole aspect of dogmatism and preaching, which you'll find in any review of Arjuna, and which will most likely get on your nerves whether you accept or reject the content of the message. All I can say about this is that if your ears and mind are closed, you'll end up thinking Arjuna tried to give you all the answers, and that those answers were (depending on whether you love or hate the earth) either incredibly shallow and insufficient or incredibly manipulative and full of political agendas. But either way you're mistaken, because if you actually watch the series and listen, you'll find that Arjuna leaves you with a lot more questions than it answers, and even the simplistic answers it does give at times are called into serious question before it's all over. There are lots of characters who think they have all the answers, but there is no all-knowing character, not even Chris. If you treat them all as human beings in search of their own truth, rather than as narrators bearing the word of god, you'll get a lot more out of this series.
At times there is a good bit of overplayed melodrama or mushy romantic scenes. What sets Arjuna apart and keeps it from being brought down by stuff like this is that it invariably interrupts these with comic relief and lightheartedness before they get pathetic. I'll avoid spoiling anything later in the series, but once you see the kiss scene at the beginning of the first episode you'll know what I mean.
As an activist and as a person who works hard to love and respect the planet, I really enjoyed and appreciated Chikyuu Shoujo Arjuna. I can't promise you'll feel the same about it, but what I feel I have done is given you a fair treatment of the aspects one might find positive or negative, and why I find them positive. I would not recommend this as a first series for introducing a random friend to anime, but on the other hand, if you know someone who already has a strong affinity towards nature and environmental conservation, it might make a really good introductory anime for such a person.
Although I rate Arjuna very highly, it's not quite among my all-time favorite anime. While it's technically very beautiful and inspires a lot of valuable thoughs while watching, the depth and complexity of the story and characters don't match up to the series I see as the very best of anime. Still, however, I find Arjuna one of the most enjoyable series to watch again and again; perhaps this is because it doesn't rely upon the story so much as the serenity and presence it conveys to make it compelling.
I also find it very commendable that Arjuna tackles the issues it does, while most anime brushes social and environmental justice issues aside and tries to hold onto a sort of moral neutrality, pretend like nothing's wrong, and sometimes even poke fun at environmentalism. In this sense Arjuna was very refreshing, and perhaps even gave me some new perspectives on Japan. It's a shame the series wasn't better-received by fans. Regardless of what you think from my review or others, this is really ground-breaking anime, and anyone serious about anime should at least see it once and give it a chance. I hope my review will have provided some perspectives through which to make it more enjoyable if you're not used to this sort of thing.
Finally, I must just say again that I found Chikyuu Shoujo Arjuna both very enjoyable and personally moving. It prompted me to dig back up thoughts and ideals I'd held precious a long time ago and ask myself where they went, and that in itself was worth more than most anime I've seen.