Born inMalone, New York, Wheeler pursued a legal career after attending theUniversity of Vermont. After serving in various local positions, he won election to theNew York State Legislature. He served in Congress from 1861 to 1863 and from 1869 to 1877. He was widely respected for his integrity and refused a salary increase after Congress passed an1873 pay raise that he opposed.
After the1876 Republican National Convention settled onRutherford B. Hayes as the party's presidential nominee after seven ballots, the delegates nominated Wheeler for vice president. Nominated by CongressmanLuke P. Poland, Wheeler surged into an early lead overFrederick T. Frelinghuysen,Marshall Jewell, andStewart L. Woodford to clinch the nomination on the first ballot. Wheeler was nominated because he was popular among his colleagues and had worked to avoid making enemies in Congress. In addition, as a resident of the populous Eastern state ofNew York, he provided geographical balance to the ticket, since Hayes was from the populousMidwest state of Ohio. The Republican ticket prevailed in the contentious1876 presidential election, though they lost the popular vote. Though they had not known each other before the convention, Wheeler and Hayes got along amicably while in office. They chose not to seek second terms, and Wheeler returned to Malone, New York, after the end of his term. He died in 1887 and was buried at Morningside Cemetery in Malone.
During his House tenure, Wheeler served as chairman of the Committee on Pacific Railroads (42nd Congress) and theCommittee on Commerce (43rd Congress).
Wheeler's reputation for honesty was celebrated byAllan Nevins in his introduction to John F. Kennedy'sProfiles in Courage.Roscoe Conkling, a Senator and New York State political boss, once offered, "Wheeler, if you will act with us, there is nothing in the gift of the State of New York to which you may not reasonably aspire." Wheeler declined with "Mr. Conkling, there is nothing in the gift of the State of New York which will compensate me for the forfeiture of my self-respect."[5]
Wheeler served as president of New York'sNorthern Railroad.[6] He was also president of the New York State Constitutional Convention which met from June 1867 to February 1868. In his speech accepting the position, he made a strong case for racial equality:
"[W]e owe it to the cause of universal civil liberty, we owe it to the struggling liberalism of the old world,...that every man within [New York], of whatever race or color, or however poor, helpless, or lowly he may be, in virtue of his manhood, is entitled to the full employment of every right appertaining to the most exalted citizenship."[7]
When Congress voted for a pay raise in 1873 and made it retroactive for five years (theSalary Grab Act), Wheeler not only voted against the raise but also returned his salary increase to the Treasury Department.[1]
Wheeler was responsible for the so-calledWheeler Compromise of 1875, which settled a volatile political situation inLouisiana[8] but eventually led to the withdrawal of federal troops and the end ofReconstruction.
Wheeler was considered a "safe" choice for the vice presidential nomination, as he had not made many enemies over the course of his political career, though Roscoe Conkling himself supported the former congressman from New York,Stewart L. Woodford. When the time came for the convention to nominate a vice presidential candidate, congressmanLuke P. Poland of Vermont nominated Wheeler, who immediately surged to the lead over Woodford and several other candidates. By the time the roll call reached New York, the result was apparent, and Woodford withdrew, enabling New York to cast all its votes for Wheeler.[9] Wheeler won the nomination with 366 votes to the 89 for his nearest rivalFrederick T. Frelinghuysen, who later served on theElectoral Commission which decided the 1876 election in favor of Hayes and Wheeler.
Governor Hayes, when he heard of Wheeler's nomination, wrote to his wife Lucy: "I am ashamed to say: Whois Wheeler?" Hayes and Wheeler had not served in the House of Representatives at the same time, so Hayes was unfamiliar with his running mate.[10]
At the Republican National Convention,Frederick Douglass asked if the GOP would adhere to its pro-civil rights roots.[11] The advocacy of Hayes and Wheeler, among a faction of Northern Republicans, was to abandon Reconstruction efforts and instead make conciliatory appeals to SouthernWhiggery.[12]
Wheeler was inaugurated on March 4, 1877, and served until March 4, 1881.[13] During Wheeler's term, the Hayes administration pursued an alliance between Northern Republicans and Old Southern Whigs, effectively abandoning post-Civil WarReconstruction. Hayes intended for the former Whigs who largely made up the South's business and merchant classes to replace the Democratic planter class as the dominant force in Southern government and politics. Events did not play out as Hayes envisioned, which meant that the end of Reconstruction enabled Democrats, largely former supporters of the Confederacy, to reassert control over black residents, including passage ofJim Crow laws that lasted well into the twentieth century.[14]
Since Wheeler was a recent widower, his wife having died one year before he took office,[1] he was a frequent guest at the White House's alcohol-free luncheons. As vice president, Wheeler presided over the Senate. According to Hayes, Wheeler "was one of the few Vice Presidents who were on cordial terms, intimate and friendly, with the President. Our family were heartily fond of him."[1]
Hayes had announced at the start of his administration that he would not run for a second term. Wheeler did not run for the 1880 Republican presidential nomination, and retired at the end of his term.
When First LadyLucy Webb Hayes found out about Wheeler's status as a widower without children, she and her husband felt it was their duty to take the lonely Wheeler into their social circle. Wheeler was grateful for their kindness, and during the spring of 1878, he asked Lucy to accompany him on a fishing trip in theAdirondacks. Lucy accepted and joined Wheeler on May 31. On their first day, they caught a largetrout that weighed about 13 pounds. Wheeler sent it to the president; Hayes telegraphed jokingly that he thought it was more like 13 ounces. Hayes was actually surprised at the size of the fish, and had it served at an informal dinner with cabinet members and senators. The next day, Wheeler and Lucy were traveling back to Malone when a group of children began waving red flags. Touched by the act, Wheeler stopped their carriage so he could introduce the first lady to the children. The trip lasted eleven days, and when Lucy and her daughter Fanny returned to Washington, she wrote to Wheeler to thank him for "a wild and joyous time".[15]
In January 1881, Wheeler received 10 votes in theNew York State Legislature's Republican caucus to determine a nominee for the U.S. Senate seat held by DemocratFrancis Kernan.[16] The Republican nomination went toThomas C. Platt, who received 54 caucus votes.[16] The Republicans controlled the legislature, and Platt defeated Kernan 104 votes to 50.[16]
Wheeler retired to Malone following the end of his vice presidential term on March 4, 1881.[17] In May 1881, Platt andRoscoe Conkling resigned their U.S. Senate seats in a dispute with PresidentJames A. Garfield over control of patronage in New York,triggering two special elections.[18] In thelegislative election for Platt's seat, it took six weeks of balloting to elect a candidate.[18] Wheeler's name was in consideration, and he received as many as 23 votes beforeWarner Miller was elected with 76 votes on the 46th ballot.[18]
Wheeler suffered from several illnesses throughout his life and was in increasingly poor health during his later years.[3] He died at his home at 10:10 a.m. on Saturday, June 4, 1887.[19] The funeral was held at the Congregational church in Malone.[20] He was interred next to his wife in Malone's Morningside Cemetery on June 7, 1887.[21]
^ab"William A. Wheeler (1877–1881)".U.S. Presidents: Rutherford B. Hayes. Charlottesville, VA: Miller Center, University of Virginia. 4 October 2016. RetrievedSeptember 29, 2022.
^abcdePorter, Robert Percival; MacMillan, Thomas C.; Jones, William P., eds. (1887)."New York Senatorial Election of 1881".The Inter Ocean Curiosity Shop (First ed.). Chicago, IL: The Inter Ocean Publishing Company. p. 167 – viaGoogle Books.
Quigley, David.Second Founding: New York City, Reconstruction, and the Making of American Democracy (New York: Farrar. Straus, and Giroux – Hill and Wang, 2004),ISBN0-8090-8514-3.