From the 3rd century BC to 3rd century AD, northern Nubia was invaded and annexed to Egypt, ruled by theGreeks andRomans. This territory was known in the Greco-Roman world asDodekaschoinos.
Kush's collapse in the fourth century AD was preceded by an invasion from the EthiopianKingdom of Aksum and the rise of three Christian kingdoms:Nobatia,Makuria andAlodia. Makuria and Alodia lasted for roughly a millennium. Their eventual decline started not only the partition of Nubia, which was split into the northern half conquered by theOttomans and the southern half by theSennar sultanate, in the sixteenth century, but also a rapidIslamization and partialArabization of theNubian people. Nubia was reunited with theKhedivate of Egypt in the nineteenth century. Today, the region of Nubia is split between Egypt and Sudan.
Historically, the people of Nubia spoke at least two varieties ofNubian languages, a subfamily that includesNobiin (the descendant of Old Nubian),Dongolawi,Midob and several related varieties in the northern part of theNuba Mountains inSouth Kordofan. TheBirgid language was spoken north ofNyala inDarfur, but became extinct as late as 1970. However, the linguistic identity of the ancientKerma culture of southern and central Nubia (also known asUpper Nubia), is uncertain; some research suggests that it belonged to theCushitic branch of theAfroasiatic languages,[9][10] while more recent studies indicate that the Kerma culture belonged to theEastern Sudanic branch of Nilo-Saharan languages instead, and that other peoples of northern orLower Nubia north of Kerma (such as theC-Group culture and theBlemmyes) spoke Cushitic languages before the spread of Eastern Sudanic languages from southern orUpper Nubia.[11][12][13][14]
Nubia was divided into three major regions: Upper, Middle, and Lower Nubia, in reference to their locations along theNile. "Lower" referred to regions downstream (further north) and "upper" to regions upstream (further south).Lower Nubia lay between the First and the SecondCataracts within the current borders of Egypt, Middle Nubia lay between the Second and the Third Cataracts, andUpper Nubia lay south of the Third Cataract.[15]
Archaeological evidence attests to long histories of fishing-hunting-gathering, and later herding, throughout the Nile Valley.[16]
Affad 23 is anarchaeological site located in theAffad region of southern Dongola Reach in northernSudan,[17] which hosts "the well-preserved remains of prehistoric camps (relics of the oldest open-airhut in the world) and diversehunting andgathering loci some 50,000 years old".[18][19][20]
In southern Nubia (near modern Khartoum) from the ninth to the sixth millennia cal BC, Khartoum Mesolithic fisher-hunter-gatherers produced sophisticated pottery.[21]
By 5000 BC, the people who inhabited what is now called Nubia participated in theNeolithic Revolution. The Sahara became drier and people began to domesticate sheep, goats, and cattle.[22] Saharanrock reliefs depict scenes that have been thought to suggest the presence of acattle cult, typical of those seen throughout parts of Eastern Africa and the Nile Valley even to this day.[23] Nubian rock art depicts hunters using bows and arrows in the Neolithic period, which is a precursor to Nubian archer culture in later times.
Megaliths discovered atNabta Playa are early examples of what seems to be one of the world's firstastronomical devices, predatingStonehenge by almost 2,000 years.[24] This complexity as expressed by different levels of authority within the society there likely formed the basis for the structure of both the Neolithic society at Nabta and theOld Kingdom of Egypt.[25]
American anthropologist, Joseph Vogel wrote that:
"The period whensub-Saharan Africa was most influential in Egypt was a time when neither Egypt, as we understand it culturally, nor the Sahara, as we understand it geographically, existed. Populations and cultures now found south of the desert roamed far to the north. The culture ofUpper Egypt, which became dynastic Egyptian civilization, could fairly be called a Sudanese transplant."[26]
British AfricanistBasil Davidson outlined that "The ancient Egyptians belonged, that is, not to any specific Egyptian region or Near Eastern heritage but to that wide community of peoples who lived between the Red Sea and the Atlantic Ocean, shared a common "Saharan-Sudanese culture", and drew their reinforcements from the same great source, even though, as time went by, they also absorbed a number of wanderers from the Near East".[27]
Biological anthropologists Shomarka Keita and A.J. Boyce have stated that the "Studies of crania fromsouthern predynastic Egypt, from the formative period (4000-3100 B.C.), show them usually to be more similar to the crania of ancient Nubians, Kushites, Saharans, or modern groups from theHorn of Africa than to those of dynastic northern Egyptians or ancient or modern southern Europeans."[28]
Archaeological evidence has attested that population settlements occurred in Nubia as early as the Late Pleistocene era and from the 5th millennium BC onwards, whereas there is "no or scanty evidence" of human presence in the Egyptian Nile Valley during these periods, which may be due to problems in site preservation.[29] Several scholars have argued that the African origins of the Egyptian civilization derived from pastoral communities which emerged in both the Egyptian and Sudanese regions of the Nile Valley in the fifth millennium BCE.[30][31]
Dietrich Wildung (2018) examined Eastern Saharan pottery styles and Sudanese stone sculptures and suggested these artefacts were transmitted across the Nile Valley and influenced the pre-dynastic Egyptian culture in the Neolithic period.[32]
Nubia has one of the oldest civilizations in the world. This history is often intertwined with Egypt to the north.[33]: 16 Around 3500 BC, the second "Nubian" culture, termed the EarlyA-Group culture, arose in Lower Nubia.[34] They were sedentary agriculturalists,[22]: 6 traded with the Egyptians and exported gold.[35] This trade is supported archaeologically by large amounts of Egyptian commodities deposited in the A-Group graves. The imports consisted of gold objects, copper tools,faience amulets and beads, seals, slate palettes, stone vessels, and a variety of pots.[36] During this time, the Nubians began creating distinctive black topped, red pottery. The A-Group population have been described as ethnically “very similar” to the pre-dynasticEgyptians in physical characteristics.[37]
Around 3100 BC, the A-group transitioned from the Early to Classical phases. "Arguably royal burials are known only at Qustul and possibly Sayala."[35]: 8 During this period, the wealth of A-group kings rivaled Egyptian kings. Royal A-group graves contained gold and richly decorated pottery.[33]: 19 Some scholars believe Nubian A-Group rulers and early Egyptianpharaohs used related royal symbols; similarities in A-Group Nubia and Upper Egypt rock art support this position. Scholars from the University of Chicago Oriental Institute excavated atQustul (near Abu Simbel in Sudan), in 1960–64, and found artifacts which incorporated images associated with Egyptian pharaohs.
Archeologist Bruce Williams studied the artifacts and concluded that "Egypt and Nubia A-Group culture shared the same official culture", "participated in the most complex dynastic developments", and "Nubia and Egypt were both part of the great East African substratum".[38] Williams also wrote that Qustul "could well have been the seat of Egypt's founding dynasty".[39][40] David O'Connor wrote that the Qustul incense burner provides evidence that the A-group Nubian culture in Qustul marked the "pivotal change" frompredynastic to dynastic "Egyptian monumental art".[41] However, "most scholars do not agree with this hypothesis",[42] as more recent finds in Egypt indicate that this iconography originated in Egypt instead of Nubia, and that the Qustul rulers adopted or emulated the symbols of Egyptian pharaohs.[43][44][45][46]
According toDavid Wengrow, the A-Group polity of the late 4th millenninum BCE is poorly understood since most of the archaeological remains are submerged underneath Lake Nasser.[47]Frank Yurco also remarked that depictions of pharonic iconography such as the royal crowns, Horus falcons and victory scenes were concentrated in the Upper EgyptianNaqada culture and A-Group Nubia. He further elaborated that "Egyptian writing arose in NaqadanUpper Egypt and A-Group Nubia, and not in the Delta cultures, where the directWestern Asian contact was made, further vitiates the Mesopotamian-influence argument".[48]
The archaeological cemeteries at Qustul are no longer available for excavations since the flooding ofLake Nasser.[49] The earliest representations of pharaonic iconography have been excavated from Nag el-Hamdulab inAswan, the extreme southern region of Egypt which borders the Sudan, with an estimated dating range between 3200 and 3100 BC.[50]
Writing developed in Egypt around 3300 BC. In their writings, Egyptians referred to Nubia as "Ta-Seti", or "The Land of the Bow," as the Nubians were known to be expert archers.[51] More recent and broader studies have determined that the distinct pottery styles, differing burial practices, different grave goods, and site distribution all indicate that the Naqada people and the Nubian A-Group people were from different cultures.
Kathryn Bard states that "Naqada cultural burials contain very few Nubian craft goods, which suggests that while Egyptian goods were exported to Nubia and were buried in A-Group graves, A-Group goods were of little interest further north."[52] According to anthropologist Jane Hill, there is no evidence that the pharaohs of theFirst Dynasty of Egypt buried atAbydos were of Nubian origin.[53] However, severalbiological anthropological studies have shown the Badarian and Naqada people to be closely related to the Nubian and other,tropical African populations.[54][55][56][57][58][59] Also, the proto-dynastic kings emerged from the Naqada region.[60][61]
A uniform culture of nomadic herders, called theGash group, existed from 3000 to 1500 BC to the east and west of Nubia.[22]: 8
In Lower Nubia, the A-group moved from the Classical to Terminal phase. At this time, kings at Qustul likely ruled all of Lower Nubia and demonstrated the political centralization of Nubian society.[22]: 21 The A-Group culture came to an end sometime between 3100 and 2900 BC, when it was apparently destroyed by the First Dynasty rulers of Egypt.[62] There are no records of settlement in Lower Nubia for the next 600 years. Old Kingdom Egyptian dynasties (4th to 6th) controlled uninhabited Lower Nubia and raided Upper Nubia.
The pre-Kerma developed into the Middle phase Kerma group. Some A-group people (transitioning to C-group) settled the area and co-existed with the pre-Kerma group.[22]: 25 Like other Nubian groups, the two groups made an abundance of red pottery with black tops, though each group made different shapes.[22]: 29 Traces of the C-group in Upper Nubia vanish by 2000 BC and Kerma culture began to dominate Upper Nubia.[22]: 25 The power of an independent Upper Nubia increased around 1700 BC and Upper Nubia dominated Lower Nubia.[22]: 25 An Egyptian official, Harkhuf, mentions that Irtjet, Setjet, and Wawat all combined under a single ruler. By 1650 BC, Egyptian texts started to refer to only two kingdoms in Nubia: Kush and Shaat.[22]: 32, 38 Kush was centered at Kerma and Shaat was centered on Sai island.[22]: 38 Bonnet posits that Kush actually ruled all of Upper Nubia, since "royal" graves were much larger in Kush than Shaat and Egyptian texts other than the Execration lists only refer to Kush (and not Shaat).[22]: 38–39
C-group Nubians resettled Lower Nubia by 2400 BC.[22]: 25 As trade between Egypt and Nubia increased, so did wealth and stability. Nubia was divided into a series of small kingdoms. There is debate over whether the C-group people,[63] who flourished from 2500 BC to 1500 BC, were another internal evolution or invaders. O'Connor states "a transition from A group into a later culture, the C-group, can be traced" and the C-group culture was typical of Lower Nubia from 2400 to 1650 BC.[22]: 25 Although they lived in close proximity to each other, Nubians did not acculturate much to Egyptian culture. Notable exceptions include C-group Nubians during the 15th Dynasty, isolated Nubian communities in Egypt, and some bowmen communities.[22]: 56 C-Group pottery is characterized by all-over incised geometric lines with white infill and impressed imitations of basketry. Lower Nubia was controlled by Egypt from 2000 to 1700 BC and Upper Nubia from 1700 to 1525 BC.
From 2200 to 1700 BC, thePan Grave culture appeared in Lower Nubia.[33]: 20 Some of the people were likely theMedjay (mḏꜣ,[64]) arriving from the desert east of the Nile river. One feature of Pan Grave culture was shallow grave burial. The Pan Grave and C-Group definitely interacted: Pan Grave pottery is characterized by more limited incised lines than the C-Group's and generally have interspersed undecorated spaces within the geometric schemes.[65]
11th Dynasty model of Nubian archers in the Egyptian army, from a tomb inAsyut (c. 2130–1991 BC).
In 2300 BC, Nubia was first mentioned inOld Kingdom Egyptian accounts of trade missions. The Egyptians referred to Lower Nubia as Wawat, Irtjet, and Setju, while they referred to Upper Nubia as Yam. Some authors believe that Irtjet and Setju could also have been in Upper Nubia.[22]: 32 They referred to Nubians dwelling near the river as Nehasyu.[22]: 26
FromAswan, the southern limit of Egyptian control at the time, Egyptians imported gold, incense, ebony, copper, ivory, and exotic animals from tropical Africa through Nubia. Relations between the Egyptians and Nubians showed peaceful cultural interchange, cooperation, and mixed marriages. Nubian bowmen that settled at Gebelein during the First Intermediate Period married Egyptian women, were buried in Egyptian style, and eventually could not be distinguished from Egyptians.[22]: 56
Older scholarship noted that some Egyptian pharaohs may have had Nubian ancestry.[66][67] Richard Loban expressed the view thatMentuhotep II of the 11th Dynasty "was quite possibly of Nubian origin" and cited historical evidence which mentioned thatAmenemhet I, founder of the 12th Dynasty, "had a Ta Seti or Nubian mother".[68][69][70] Dietrich Wildung has argued that Nubian features were common in Egyptian iconography since the pre-dynastic era and that several pharaohs such asKhufu andMentuhotep II were represented with these Nubian features.[71]
Frank Yurco wrote that "Egyptian rulers of Nubian ancestry had become Egyptians culturally; as pharaohs, they exhibited typical Egyptian attitudes and adopted typical Egyptian policies". Yurco noted that some Middle Kingdom rulers, particularly some pharaohs of theTwelfth Dynasty had strong Nubian features, due to the origin of the dynasty in the Aswan region of southern Egypt. He also identified the pharaoh Sequenre Tao of theSeventeenth Dynasty, as having Nubian features.[72] Many scholars in recent years have argued that the mother of Amenemhat I, founder of theTwelfth Dynasty was of Nubian origin.[73][74][69][75][76][77][78]
After a period of withdrawal, theMiddle Kingdom of Egypt conquered Lower Nubia from 2000 to 1700 BC.[22]: 8, 25 By 1900 BC, King Sesostris I began building a series of towns below the Second Cataract with heavy fortresses that had enclosures and drawbridges.[33]: 19 Sesotris III relentlessly expanded his kingdom into Nubia (from 1866 to 1863 BC) and erected massive river forts includingBuhen,Semna,Shalfak andToshka atUronarti to gain more control over the trade routes in Lower Nubia. They also provided direct access to trade with Upper Nubia, which was independent and increasingly powerful during this time. These Egyptian garrisons seemed to peacefully coexist with the local Nubian people, though they did not interact much with them.[79]
Medjay was the name given byancient Egypt to nomadic desert dwellers from east of the Nile River. The term was used variously to describe a location, the Medjay people, or their role/job in the kingdom. They became part of the Egyptian military as scouts and minor workers before being incorporated into the Egyptian army.[citation needed] In the army, the Medjay served as garrison troops in Egyptian fortifications in Nubia and patrolled the deserts as a kind ofgendarmerie,[80] or elite paramilitary police force,[81] to prevent their fellow Medjay tribespeople from further attacking Egyptian assets in the region.[81]
The Medjay were often used to protect valuable areas, especially royal and religious complexes. Although they are most notable for their protection of the royal palaces and tombs inThebes and the surrounding areas, the Medjay were deployed throughout Upper and Lower Egypt; they were even used duringKamose's campaign against theHyksos and became instrumental in turning the Egyptian state into a military power.[82][83] After theFirst Intermediate Period of Egypt, the Medjay district was no longer mentioned in written records.[84]
The Western Deffufa of SudanDaggers of bone and copper, 1750–1450 BC, Kerma, British Museum EA55442
From the Middle Kerma phase, the first Nubian kingdom to unify much of the region arose. The Classic Kerma culture, named for its royal capital atKerma, was one of the earliest urban centers in the Nile region and oldest city in Africa outside of Egypt.[85][22]: 50–51 The Kerma group spoke either languages of theCushitic branch[9][10] or, according to more recent research,Nilo-Saharan languages of theEastern Sudanic branch.[11][12][13][14]
By 1650 BC (Classic Kerma phase), the kings of Kerma were powerful enough to organize the labor for monumental town walls and large mud brick structures, such as the Eastern and Western Deffufas (50 by 25 by 18 meters). They also had rich tombs with possessions for the afterlife and largehuman sacrifices.George Andrew Reisner excavated sites at the royal city of Kerma and found distinctiveNubian architecture, such as large pebble covered tombs (90 meters in diameter), a large circular dwelling, and a palace-like structure.[22]: 41 Classic Kerma rulers employed "a good many Egyptians", according to the Egyptian Execration texts.[22]: 57
Mirror. Kerma Period, 1700–1550 BC.
Kerma culture was militaristic, as attested by many archers' burials and bronze daggers/swords found in their graves.[22]: 31 Other signs of Nubia's military prowess are the frequent use of Nubians in Egypt's military and Egypt's need to construct numerous fortresses to defend their southern border from the Nubians.[22]: 31 Despite assimilation, the Nubian elite remained rebellious during Egyptian occupation. There were numerous rebellions and "military conflict occurred almost under every reign until the 20th dynasty".[86]: 102–103 At one point, Kerma came very close to conquering Egypt: Egypt suffered a serious defeat at the hands of theKingdom of Kush.[87][88]
According to Davies, head of the jointBritish Museum and Egyptian archaeological team, the attack was so devastating that, if the Kerma forces had chosen to stay and occupy Egypt, they might have permanently eliminated the Egyptians and brought the nation to extinction. During Egypt's Second Intermediate period, the Kushites reached the height of their Bronze Age power and completely controlled southern trade with Egypt.[22]: 41 They maintained diplomatic ties with the Thebans and Hyksos until the New Kingdom pharaohs brought all of Nubia under Egyptian rule from 1500 to 1070 BC.[22]: 41 After 1070 BC, there were continued hostilities with Egypt, which led Nubians to concentrate in Upper Nubia.[22]: 58 Within 200 years, a fully formed Kushite state, based at Napata, began to exert its influence on Upper (Southern) Egypt.[22]: 58–59
When the Middle Kingdom Egyptians pulled out of the Napata region around 1700 BC, they left a lasting legacy that was merged with indigenous C-group customs. Egyptians remaining at the garrison towns started to merge with the C-group Nubians in Lower Nubia. The C-group quickly adopted Egyptian customs and culture, as attested by their graves, and lived together with the remaining Egyptians in garrison towns.[22]: 41 After Upper Nubia annexed Lower Nubia around 1700 BC, the Kingdom of Kush began to control the area. At this point, C-group Nubians and Egyptians began to proclaim their allegiance to the Kushite King in their inscriptions.[22]: 41 Egypt conquered Lower and Upper Nubia from 1500 to 1070 BC. However, the Kingdom of Kush survived longer than Egypt.
Nubian PrinceHeqanefer bringing tribute for KingTutankhamun, 18th dynasty, Tomb of Huy. Circa 1342 – c. 1325 BCThe Turin Papyrus Map, dating to about 1160 BC
After the Theban 17th DynastyNew Kingdom of Egypt (c. 1532–1070 BC) expelled the Canaanite Hyksos from Egypt, they turned their imperial ambitions to Nubia. By the end ofThutmose I's reign (1520 BC), all of Lower Nubia had been annexed. After a long campaign, Egypt alsoconquered the Kingdom of Kerma in Upper Nubia and held both areas until 1070 BC.[86]: 101–102 [22]: 25 The Egyptian empire expanded into the Fourth Cataract, and a new administrative center was built atNapata, which became agold and incense production area.[89][90] Egypt became a prime source of gold in the Middle East. The primitive working conditions for the slaves are recorded byDiodorus Siculus.[91] One of the oldest maps known is of a gold mine in Nubia: theTurin Papyrus Map dating to about 1160 BC; it is also one of the earliest characterized road maps in existence.[92]
Nubians were an integral part of New Kingdom Egyptian society. Some scholars state that Nubians were included in the18th Dynasty of Egypt's royal family.[93]Ahmose-Nefertari, "arguably the most venerated woman in Egyptian history",[94] was thought by some scholars such asFlinders Petrie to be of Nubian origin because she is most often depicted with black skin.[66][95]: 17 [96] The mummy ofAhmose-Nefertari's father,Seqenenre Tao, has been described as presenting "tightly curled, woolly hair", with "a slight build and strongly Nubian features".[97] Some modern scholars also believe that in some depictions, her skin color is indicative of her role as a goddess of resurrection, since black is both the color of the fertile land of Egypt and that of the underworld.[98][99]: 90 [100][94][101]: 125 However, there is no known depiction of her painted during her lifetime (she is represented with the same light skin as other represented individuals in tomb TT15, before her deification); the earliest black skin depiction appears in tomb TT161,c. 150 years after her death.: 11–12, 23, 74–5 [101]: 125 Egyptologist Barbara Lesko wrote in 1996 that Ahmose-Nefertari was "sometimes portrayed by later generations as having been black, although her coffin portrait gives her the typical light yellow skin of women."[102] In 2009, Egyptologist Elena Vassilika, noting that in a wooden statuette of the queen (now at theMuseo Egizio) the face is painted black but the arms and feet are light in color, argued that the reason for the black coloring in that case was religious and not genetic.[103]: 78–9
In 1098–1088 BC, Thebes was "the scene of a civil war-like conflict between the High Priest of Amun of Thebes Amenhotep and the Viceroy of KushPanehesy (= the Nubian)". It was chaotic and many tombs were plundered. Instead of sending soldiers to restore order,Ramesses XI put Panehesy in control of that area's military and appointed him Director of Granaries. Panehesy stationed his troops in Thebes to protect the city from thieves, but it resembled a military occupation of Thebes to the High Priest, which later led to the Civil war in Thebes.[86]: 104–105 By 1082 BC, Ramesses XI finally sent help to the High Priest. Panehesy continued his revolt and the city of Thebes suffered from "war, famine, and plunderings".[86]: 106 Panehesy initially succeeded and the High Priest fled Thebes. Panehesy pursued the High Priest as far as Middle Egypt before Egyptian forces pushed Panehesy and his troops out of Egypt and into Lower Nubia.[86]: 106 Ramesses sent new leadership to Thebes:Herihor was named the new High Priest of Thebes (and effectively King of Southern Egypt) and Paiankh was named the new Viceroy of Kush. Paiankh recaptured former Egyptian holdings in Lower Nubia as far as the second Nile cataract, but could not defeat Panehesy in Lower Nubia, who ruled the area until his death.[86]: 106 Herihor's descendants became rulers of Egypt's 21st and 22nd Dynasties.
Pyramids of Kushite rulers atNuriPyramid of Taharqa at Nuri , 51.75m in side length and possibly as much as 50m high, was the largest built in Sudan.[1]Pharaoh Taharqa of Ancient Egypt's 25th Dynasty. Ashmolean Museum, Oxford UK
There are competing theories on the origins of the Kushite kings of the 25th Dynasty:[104] some scholars believe they were Nubian officials that learned "state level organization" by administering Egyptian-held Nubia from 1500 to 1070 BC,[22]: 59 such as the rebel Viceroy of Kush, Panehesy, who ruled Upper Nubia and some of Lower Nubia after Egyptian forces withdrew.[86]: 110 Other scholars believe they are descended from families of the Egyptianized Nubian elite supported by Egyptian priests or settlers.[105][106][107][104] Children of elite Nubian families were sent to be educated in Egypt then returned to Kush to be appointed in bureaucratic positions to ensure their loyalty. During the Egyptian occupation of Nubia, there were temple towns with Egyptian cults, but "production and redistribution" was based mostly on indigenous social structures.[86]: 111
The El Kurru chiefdom likely played a major role in the development of the Kingdom of Kush due to its access to gold producing areas, control of caravan routes,[86]: 112 more arable land, and participation in international trade.[86]: 121 "There can be no doubt that el-Kurru was the burial place of the ancestors of the Twenty-Fifth Dynasty."[86]: 112 The early el-Kurru burials resemble Nubian Kerma/C-group traditions (contracted body, circular stone structures, burial on a bed).[86]: 121 However, by 880–815 BC, Nubian burials at el-Kurru became more Egyptian in style with "mastabas, or pyramid on mastabas, chapels, and rectangular enclosures".[86]: 117, 121–122 Alara, the first el-Kurru prince, and his successor,Kashta, were buried at el-Kurru.[86]: 123
Later documents mention Alara as the 25th Dynasty's founder and "central to a myth of the origins of the kingdom".[86]: 124–126 Alara's sister was the priestess of Amun, which created a system of royal secession and an "ideology of royal power in which Kushite concepts and practice were united with contemporary Egyptian concepts of kingship".[86]: 144 Later, Kashta's daughter, the Kushite princess Amenirdis, was installed as God's Wife of Amun Elect and later Divine Adoratrice (effectively governor of Upper Egypt), which signaled the Kushite conquest of Egyptian territories.[86]: 148
The Napatan Empire ushered in the age of Egyptian archaism, or a return to a historical past, which was embodied by a concentrated effort at religious renewal and restoration of Egypt's holy places.[86]: 169 Piye expanded theTemple of Amun at Jebel Barkal[35] by adding "an immense colonnaded forecourt".[86]: 163–164 Shabaka restored the great Egyptian monuments and temples, "unlike his Libyan predecessors".[86]: 167–169 Taharqa enriched Thebes on a monumental scale."[86] At Karnak, the Sacred Lake structures, the kiosk in the first court, and the colonnades at the temple entrance are all built by Taharqa and Mentuemhet. In addition to architecture, the Kingdom of Kush was deeply influenced by Egyptian culture.[108][109][110] By 780 BC,Amun was the main god of Kush and "intense contacts with Thebes" were maintained.[86]: 144 Kush used the methods of Egyptian art and writing.[111] The Nubian elite adopted many Egyptian customs and gave their children Egyptian names. Although some Nubian customs and beliefs (e.g. burial practices) continued to be practiced,[86]: 111 Egyptianization dominated in ideas, practices, and iconography.[112] The cultural Egyptianization of Nubia was at its highest levels at the times of both Kashta and Piye.[113]
Kashta peacefully became King of Upper and Lower Egypt with his daughter Amendiris as Divine Adoratrice of Amun in Thebes.[86]: 144–146 Rulers of the 23rd Dynasty withdrew from Thebes to Heracleopolis, which avoided conflict with the new Kushite rulers of Thebes. Under Kashta's reign, the Kushite elite and professional classes became significantly Egyptianized.
The city-state ofNapata was the spiritual capital of Kush and it was from there thatPiye (spelled Piankhi or Piankhy in older works) invaded and took control ofEgypt.[116] Piye personally led the attack on Egypt and recorded his victory in a lengthy hieroglyphic filledstele called the "Stele of Victory".[86]: 166 Piye's success in achieving the double kingship after generations of Kushite planning resulted from "Kushite ambition, political skill, and the Theban decision to reunify Egypt in this particular way", and not Egypt's utter exhaustion, "as frequently suggested in Egyptological studies."[35] Due to archaism, Piye mostly used the royal titulary of Tuthmosis III, but changed the Horus name from "Strong bull appearing (crowned) in Thebes" to "Strong bull appearing in Napata" to announce that the Kushites had reversed history and conquered their former Thebaid Egyptian conquerors.[86]: 154 He also revived one of the greatest features of the Old and Middle Kingdoms: pyramid construction. As an energetic builder, he constructed the oldest known pyramid at the royal burial site ofEl-Kurru.
According to the revised chronology,Shebitku "brought the entire Nile Valley as far as the Delta under the empire of Kush and is 'reputed' to have had Bocchoris, dynast of Sais, burnt to death".[117][86]: 166–167 Shabaka "transferred the capital to Memphis".[86]: 166 Shebitku's successor,Taharqa, was crowned in Memphis in 690 BC[86][33] and ruled Upper and Lower Egypt as Pharaoh from Tanis in the Delta.[118][117] Excavations at el-Kurru and studies of horse skeletons indicate the finest horses used in Kushite and Assyrian warfare were bred in and exported from Nubia. Horses and chariots were key to the Kushite war machine.[86]: 157–158
Taharqa's reign was a prosperous time in the empire with a particularly large Nile river flood and abundant crops and wine.[119][86] Taharqa's inscriptions indicate that he gave large amounts of gold to the temple of Amun at Kawa.[120] His army undertook successful military campaigns, as attested by the "list of conquered Asiatic principalities" from the Mut temple at Karnak and "conquered peoples and countries (Libyans, Shasu nomads, Phoenicians?, Khor in Palestine)" from Sanam temple inscriptions.[86] László Török mentions the military success was due to Taharqa's efforts to strengthen the army through daily training in long-distance running and Assyria's preoccupation with Babylon and Elam.[86] Taharqa also built military settlements at the Semna and Buhen forts and the fortified site of Qasr Ibrim.[86]
Imperial ambitions of theMesopotamian-basedAssyrian Empire made war with the 25th Dynasty inevitable. Taharqa conspired with Levantine kingdoms against Assyria:[121] in 701 BC, Taharqa and his army aidedJudah and KingHezekiah in withstanding a siege by KingSennacherib of the Assyrians (2 Kings 19:9; Isaiah 37:9).[122] There are various theories (Taharqa's army,[123] disease, divine intervention, Hezekiah's surrender, Herodotus' mice theory) as to why the Assyrians failed to take Jerusalem and withdrew to Assyria.[124] Sennacherib's annals record Judah was forced into tribute after the siege and Sennacherib became the ruler of the region.[125] However, this is contradicted by Khor's frequent utilization of an Egyptian system of weights for trade and the twenty-year cessation in Assyria's pattern of repeatedly invading Khor (as Assyrians had before 701 and after Sennacherib's death).[126][127] In 681 BC, Sennacherib was murdered by his own sons inBabylon.
In 679 BC, Sennacherib's successor, KingEsarhaddon, campaigned in Khor, destroyed Sidon, and forced Tyre into tribute in 677–676 BC. Esarhaddon invaded Egypt proper in 674 BC, but according to Babylonian records, Taharqa and his army outright defeated the Assyrians.[128] In 672 BC, Taharqa brought reserve troops from Kush, as mentioned in rock inscriptions.[86] Taharqa's Egypt still had influence in Khor during this period as Tyre's King Ba'lu "put his trust upon his friend Taharqa". Further evidence wasAshkelon's alliance with Egypt and Esarhaddon's inscription asking "if the Kushite-Egyptian forces 'plan and strive to wage war in any way' and if the Egyptian forces will defeat Esarhaddon at Ashkelon".[129] However, Taharqa was defeated in Egypt in 671 BC when Esarhaddon conquered Northern Egypt, captured Memphis, and imposed tribute before withdrawing.[118] Pharaoh Taharqa escaped to the south, but Esarhaddon captured the Pharaoh's family, including "Prince Nes-Anhuret and the royal wives",[86] and sent them to Assyria. In 669 BC, Taharqa reoccupied Memphis and the Delta, and recommenced intrigues with the king of Tyre.[118]
Esarhaddon led his army to Egypt again and, after his death in 668 BC, command passed toAshurbanipal. Ashurbanipal and the Assyrians defeated Taharqa again and advanced as far south as Thebes, but direct Assyrian control was not established.[118] The rebellion was stopped and Ashurbanipal appointedNecho I, who had been king of the citySais, as his vassal ruler in Egypt. Necho's son,Psamtik I, was educated at the Assyrian capital ofNineveh during Esarhaddon's reign.[citation needed] As late as 665 BC, the vassal rulers of Sais, Mendes, and Pelusium were still makingovertures[a] to Taharqa in Kush.[86] The vassals' plot was uncovered by Ashurbanipal and all rebels but Necho of Sais were executed.[86]
Taharqa's successor,Tantamani, sailed north from Napata with a large army to Thebes, where he was "ritually installed as the king of Egypt".[86]: 185 From Thebes, Tantamani began his reconquest and regained control of Egypt as far north as Memphis.[86]: 185 [118] Tantamani's dream stele states that he restored order from the chaos, where royal temples and cults were not being maintained.[86]: 185 After conquering Sais and killing Assyria's vassal, Necho I, in Memphis, "some local dynasts formally surrendered, while others withdrew to their fortresses".[86]: 185
The Kushites had influence over their northern neighbors for nearly 100 years until they were repelled by the invading Assyrians. The Assyrians installed the native26th Dynasty of Egypt underPsamtik I and they permanently forced the Kushites out of Egypt around 590 BC.[130]: 121–122 The heirs of the Kushite empire established their new capital atNapata, which was also sacked by the Egyptians in 592 BC. The Kushite kingdom survived for another 900 years after being pushed south toMeroë. The Egyptianized culture of Nubia grew increasingly Africanized after the fall of the 25th Dynasty until QueenAmanishakhete acceded in 45 BC.[citation needed] She temporarily arrested the loss of Egyptian culture, but then it continued unchecked.[113]
Due to pressure from Assyrians and Egyptians,Meroë (800 BC –c. 350 AD) became the southern capital of theKingdom of Kush.[86] According to partially deciphered Meroitic texts, the name of the city was Medewi or Bedewi. Meroë was in southern Nubia by the east bank of the Nile, about 6 km north-east of the Kabushiya station near Shendi, Sudan, and about 200 km northeast ofKhartoum. Meroë is mentioned in first-century ADPeriplus of the Erythraean Sea: "farther inland, in the country towards the west, there lies a city called Meroe". In fifth-century BC, Greek historianHerodotus described it as "a great city...said to be the mother city of the other Ethiopians."[131][132] Together,Musawwarat es-Sufra,Naqa, and Meroë formed the Island of Meroe.
The town's importance gradually increased fromthe beginning of the Meroitic Period, especially from the reign ofArakamani (c. 280 BC) when the royal burial ground was transferred to Meroë fromNapata (Jebel Barkal). Excavations revealed evidence of important, high ranking Kushite burials, from the Napatan Period (c. 800 – c. 280 BC) in the vicinity of the settlement called the Western cemetery. They buried their kings in small pyramids with steeply sloped sides that were based on New Kingdom Viceroy designs.[105] At its peak, the rulers of Meroë controlled the Nile Valley over a north–south straight-line distance of more than 1,000 km (620 mi).[133]
People of the Meroitic period preserved many ancient Egyptian customs but were unique in many respects. TheMeroitic language was spoken in Meroë and Sudan during the Meroitic period (attested from 300 BC) before becoming extinct around 400 AD. They developed their own form of writing by using Egyptianhieroglyphs before switching to a cursive alphabetic script with 23 signs.[134] It was split into two types: Meroitic Cursive, which was written with astylus and used for general record-keeping; and Meroitic Hieroglyphic, which was carved in stone or used for royal or religious documents. It is not well understood due to the scarcity ofbilingual texts.[clarification needed] The earliest inscription in Meroitic writing dates from between 180 and 170 BC. These hieroglyphics were found engraved on the temple of QueenShanakdakhete. Meroitic Cursive is written horizontally, and is read from right to left like all Semitic orthographies.[135] The Meroitic people worshiped the Egyptian gods as well as their own, such asApedemak and the lion-son ofSekhmet (orBast).
Meroë was the base of a flourishing kingdom whose wealth was centered around a strongiron industry and international trade withIndia andChina.[136] Metalworking is believed to have happened in Meroë, possibly throughbloomeries andblast furnaces.[137] The centralized control of production within the Meroitic empire and distribution of certain crafts and manufactures may have been politically important. Other important sites were Musawwarat es-Sufra and Naqa.Musawwarat es-Sufra, which is now a UNESCOWorld Heritage Site, was constructed in sandstone. Its main features were the Great Enclosure, the Lion Temple ofApedemak (14×9×5 meters), and the Great Reservoir. The Great Enclosure is the main structure of the site. Much of the large labyrinth-like building complex, which covers approximately 45,000 m2, was erected in third-century BC.[138]
The scheme of the site is, so far, without parallel in Nubia andancient Egypt. According to Hintze, "the complicated ground plan of this extensive complex of buildings is without parallel in the entire Nile valley".[139] The maze ofcourtyards includes three (possible) temples, passages, low walls that prevent any contact with the outside world, about 20 columns, ramps and two reservoirs.[140][141] There is some debate about the purpose of the buildings, with earlier suggestions including a college, a hospital, and an elephant-training camp.[142] The Lion Temple was constructed byArnekhamani and bears inscriptions in Egyptian hieroglyphs, representations of elephants and lions on the rear inside wall, and reliefs of Apedemak depicted as a three-headed god on the outside walls.[143] The Great Reservoir is ahafir to retain as much as possible of the rainfall of the short, wet season. It is 250 m in diameter and 6.3 m deep.[144]
Herodotus mentioned an invasion of Kush by theAchaemenid ruler Cambyses II, however, he mentions that "his expedition failed miserably in the desert".[118]: 65–66 Derek Welsby states "scholars have doubted that this Persian expedition ever took place, but... archaeological evidence suggests that the fortress ofDorginarti near the second cataract served as Persia's southern boundary."[118]: 65–66
The GreekPtolemaic Kingdom underPtolemy II Philadelphus invaded Nubia in 275 BC and annexed the northern twelve miles of this territory, subsequently known as theDodekaschoinos ('twelve-mile land').[153] Throughout the 160s and 150s BC,Ptolemy VI has also reasserted Ptolemaic control over the northern part of Nubia.[154][155]
There is no record of conflict between the Kushites and Ptolemies. However, there was a serious revolt at the end of Ptolemy IV's reign and the Kushites likely tried to interfere in Ptolemaic affairs.[118]: 67 It is suggested that this led to Ptolemy V defacing the name of Arqamani on inscriptions at Philae.[118]: 67 "Arqamani constructed a small entrance hall to the temple built by Ptolemy IV at Pselchis and constructed a temple at Philae to which Ptolemy contributed an entrance hall."[118]: 66 There is evidence of Ptolemaic occupation as far south as the Second Cataract, but recent finds at Qasr Ibrim, such as "the total absence of Ptolemaic pottery", have cast doubts on the effectiveness of the occupation.[118]: 67 Dynastic struggles led to the Ptolemies abandoning the area, so "the Kushites reasserted their control...with Qasr Ibrim occupied" (by the Kushites) and other locations perhaps garrisoned.[118]: 67
According to Welsby, after the Romans assumed control of Egypt, they negotiated with the Kushites at Philae and drew the southern border of Roman Egypt at Aswan.[118]: 67 Theodore Mommsen and Welsby state the Kingdom of Kush became a client Kingdom, which was similar to the situation under Ptolemaic rule of Egypt. Kushite ambition and excessive Roman taxation are two theories for a revolt supported by Kushite armies.[118]: 67–68 The ancient historians,Strabo and Pliny, give accounts of the conflict with Roman Egypt.
Meroitic prince smiting his enemies (early first century AD)
Strabo describes a war with theRomans in first-century BC. He stated that the Kushites "sacked Aswan with an army of 30,000 men and destroyed imperial statues...at Philae."[118]: 68 A "fine over-life-size bronze head of the emperor Augustus" was found buried in Meroe in front of a temple.[118]: 68 After the initial victories ofKandake (or "Candace")Amanirenas against Roman Egypt, the Kushites were defeated andNapata was sacked.[156] Napata's fall was not a crippling blow to the Kushites and did not frighten Candace enough to prevent her from again engaging in combat with the Roman military. In 22 BC, a large Kushite force moved northward with the intention of attacking Qasr Ibrim.[157]
Alerted to the advance, Petronius again marched south and managed to reach Qasr Ibrim and bolster its defences before the invading Kushites arrived. Welsby states after a Kushite attack on Primis (Qasr Ibrim),[118]: 69–70 the Kushites sent ambassadors to negotiate a peace settlement with Petronius, which succeeded on favourable terms.[156] Trade between the two nations increased and the Roman Egyptian border being extended to "Hiera Sykaminos (Maharraqa)."[157]: 149 [118]: 70 This arrangement "guaranteed peace for most of the next 300 years" and there is "no definite evidence of further clashes."[118]: 70
During this time, different parts of the region divided into smaller groups with individual leaders (or generals), each commanding small armies of mercenaries. They fought for control of what is now Nubia and its surrounding territories, leaving the entire region weak and vulnerable to attack. Meroë would eventually be defeated by the new risingKingdom of Aksum to their south ruled byKing Ezana. A stele ofGe'ez of an unnamed ruler ofAksum thought to be Ezana was found at the site of Meroë. From his description, inGreek, he was "King of theAksumites and theOmerites" (i.e. ofAksum andHimyar). It is likely this king ruled sometime around 330 AD. While some authorities interpret these inscriptions as proof that the Axumites destroyed the kingdom ofMeroe, others note that archeological evidence points to an economic and political decline in Meroe around 300.[158] Moreover, some view the stele as military aid from Aksum to Meroe to quell the revolt and rebellion. From then on, the Romans referred to the area asNobatia.
Around 350 AD, the area was invaded by theKingdom of Aksum and the Meroitic kingdom collapsed. Three smallerChristian kingdoms replaced it: the northernmost wasNobatia (capital Pachoras; now modern-dayFaras, Egypt) between the first and second cataract of theNile River; in the middle wasMakuria (capitalOld Dongola), and southernmost wasAlodia (capital Soba). King Silky of Nobatia defeated theBlemmyes and recorded his victory in aGreek language inscription carved in the wall of the temple of Talmis (modernKalabsha) around 500 AD.
Christianity had been introduced to the region by the fourth century: BishopAthanasius of Alexandria consecrated Marcus as bishop ofPhilae before his death in 373 AD.John of Ephesus records that aMiaphysite priest named Julian converted the king and his nobles of Nobatia around 545 AD. He also writes that the kingdom of Alodia was converted around 569. However,John of Biclarum wrote that the kingdom of Makuria converted toCatholicism the same year, suggesting that John of Ephesus might be mistaken. Further doubt is cast on John's[clarification needed] testimony by an entry in the chronicle of theGreek Orthodox Patriarch of AlexandriaEutychius of Alexandria, which states that in 719 AD the church of Nubia transferred its allegiance from theGreek to theCoptic Orthodox Church. After the official Christianization of Nubia, the Isis cult of Philae remained for the sake of the Nubians[citation needed]. The edict of Theodosius I (390 AD) was not enforced at Philae. Later attempts to suppress the cult of Isis led to armed clashes between the Nubians and Romans. Finally, in 453 AD, a treaty recognizing the traditional religious rights of Nubians at Philae was signed.
By the seventh century, Makuria expanded and became the dominant power in the region. It was strong enough to halt the southern expansion ofIslam after theArabs had taken Egypt. After several failed invasions the new Muslim rulers agreed to a treaty with Dongola, calledBaqt, to allow peaceful coexistence and trade, contingent on the Nubians making an annual payment consisting of slaves and other tributes to the Islamic Governor at Aswan; it guaranteed that any runaway slaves were returned to Nubia.[159] The treaty was kept for six hundred years.[159] Throughout this period, Nubia's main exports were dates and slaves, though ivory and gold were also exchanged for Egyptian ceramics, textiles, and glass.[160] Over time the influx of Arab traders introduced Islam to Nubia and it gradually supplantedChristianity. After an interruption in the annual tribute of slaves, the Egyptian Mamluk ruler invaded in 1272 and declared himself sovereign over half of Nubia.[159] While there are records of a bishopTimothy atQasr Ibrim in 1372, his see included Faras. It is also clear that the cathedral of Dongola had been converted to a mosque in 1317.[161]
The influx ofArabs and Nubians to Egypt and Sudan had contributed to the suppression of the Nubian identity following the collapse of the last Nubian kingdom around 1504. A vast majority of the Nubian population is currently Muslim, and the Arabic language is their main medium of communication in addition to their indigenous Nubian language. The unique characteristic of Nubian is shown in their culture (dress, dances, traditions, and music).
In the fourteenth century, the Dongolan government collapsed and the region was divided and dominated by Arabs. Several Arab invasions into the region and the establishment of smaller kingdoms occurred over the next few centuries. Northern Nubia was brought under Egyptian control, while the south was controlled by theKingdom of Sennar in the sixteenth century. The entire region came under Egyptian control duringMuhammad Ali's rule in the early nineteenth century, and later became a joint Anglo-Egyptiancondominium.
The paleo-demography of Nubians from theUpper Paleolithic to late 16th century BC were analyzed by Aleksandra Pudlo. Mesolithic period inhabitants were characterized as robust and tall, with strong alveolar prognathism. During the Neolithic, Nubians were less robust and shorter, retaining some prognathism, but having facial shape changes and a narrower nasal index. Over a period of 8,500 years, the features had shifted a considerable degree. The variety of morphological forms which occurred was considered a result of the combination of two distinct traits, with Pudlo concluding: "Nubians were hardly a homogeneous population. Neither the climate nor the specific geographic conditions in the region they inhabited were conducive of such homogeneity." The populations were possibly influenced by migration waves coming from the north, but these movements did not prevent repeated contacts of the people of Nubia with other regions further south in Africa.[162]
Findings were recorded in 2016 on Nubian remains over a period of 11,000 years: "Taken together, our results suggest a dramatic shift in cranial morphology between the Mesolithic and the A-group cultural group, with little perceptible change in cranial shape between A-group and the later farming groups. In the case of the mandible, we observe the largest morphological change between the Mesolithic and the A-group, but also see morphological differentiation between the early farmers (A and C-group) and the later farming groups (Pharaonic and Meroitic specimens)." Changes were attributed to factors such as in situ adaptation or influxes of people, as well as migration of farmers. Nonetheless, authors concluded further studies with larger samples and a combination of morphometric analyses and ancient DNA are needed.[163]
In 2003, archaeologistCharles Bonnet led a team of Swiss archaeologists to excavate nearKerma and discovered a cache of monumental black granite statues of the Pharaohs of the25th Dynasty of Egypt, now displayed at theKerma Museum. Among the sculptures are ones belonging to the dynasty's last two pharaohs,Taharqa andTanoutamon, whose statues are described as "masterpieces that rank among the greatest in art history".[164] Craniometric analysis of Kerma fossils that compared them to various other early populations inhabiting theNile Valley andMaghreb found that they were morphologically close toPredynastic Egyptians fromNaqada (4000–3200 BC).[165] Dental trait analysis of Kerma fossils found affinities with various populations inhabiting theNile Valley,Horn of Africa, andNortheast Africa, especially to other ancient populations from the central and northern Sudan. Among the sampled populations, the Kerma people were overall nearest to theKush populations inUpper Nubia, theA-Group culture bearers ofLower Nubia, andEthiopians.[166]
In the early-1970s, many Egyptian and Sudanese Nubians were forcibly relocated to make room forLake Nasser afterdams were constructed atAswan.[167] Nubian villages can be found north of Aswan on the west bank of the Nile and onElephantine Island. Many Nubians now live in large cities likeCairo andKhartoum.[167]
In 2014, a male infant skeleton was recovered during an excavation in what is present-day Wadi Halfa from the Christian Period (500-1400 C.E.), located near the Second Cataract of the Nile in the Republic of the Sudan. The results from the Principal component analysis (PCA) had the individual placed between African and European clusters. Furthermore, the individual was assigned to mitochondrial haplogroup L5a1a, a branch of the ancient L5 haplogroup with origins in East Africa.[168]
Another analysis in 2015 studied a Nubian individual from an archeological site in Kulubnarti. The geographic ancestry of the individual was estimated to be closer to Middle Eastern, and Central and South Asians, rather than to any African populations.[169]
Sirak et al. 2021 obtained and analyzed the whole genomes of 66 individuals from the site ofKulubnarti situated in northern Nubia between the 2nd and 3rd cataract, near the modern Egyptian border, and dated to theChristian period between 650 and 1000 CE. The samples were obtained from two cemeteries. The samples' genetic profile was found to be a mixture betweenWest Eurasian andSub SaharanDinka-related ancestries, with ~60% West Eurasian related ancestry that likely came from ancient Egyptians but ultimately resembles that found inBronze orIron AgeLevantines, and ~40% Dinka-related ancestry.
The two cemeteries showed minimal differences in their West Eurasian/Dinka ancestry proportions. These findings in addition to multiple cross cemetery relatives that the analyses have revealed indicate that people of both the R and S cemeteries were part of the same population despite the archaeological and anthropological differences between the two burials showing social stratification.
Modern Nubians, despite their superficial resemblance to the Kulubnarti Nubians on the PCA, were not found to be descended from Kulubnarti Nubians without additional later admixtures. Modern Nubians were found to have an increase in Sub-Saharan ancestry along with a change in their west Eurasian ancestry from that which was found in the ancient samples.[170]
A sample from historic Lower Nubia, in the Nubian site of Sayala during the 3rd-6th Century AD, belonged to mtDNA haplogroup J1c.[171]
In 2022, DNA was sequenced from the hair of a Kerma period individual (4000 BP), and the results revealed close genetic affinity to early pastoralists from the Rift Valley in eastern Africa during thePastoral Neolithic.[172]
^abElmar Edel:Zu den Inschriften auf den Jahreszeitenreliefs der "Weltkammer" aus dem Sonnenheiligtum des Niuserre, Teil 2. In: Nachrichten der Akademie der Wissenschaften in Göttingen, Nr. 5. Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, Göttingen 1964, pp. 118–119.
^abChristian Leitz et al.:Lexikon der ägyptischen Götter und Götterbezeichnungen, Bd. 6: H̱-s. Peeters, Leuven 2002,ISBN90-429-1151-4, p. 697.
^abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyzaaabacadaeO'Connor, David (1993).Ancient Nubia: Egypt's Rival in Africa. University of Pennsylvania, USA: University Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology. pp. 1–112.ISBN0924171286.
^Vogel, Joseph (1997).Encyclopedia of precolonial Africa : archaeology, history, languages, cultures, and environments. Walnut Creek, Calif.: AltaMira Press. pp. 465–472.ISBN0761989021.
^Davidson, Basil (1991).Africa in history : themes and outlines (Rev. and expanded ed.). New York: Collier Books. p. 15.ISBN0684826674.
^Keita, Shomarka and Boyce, A.J. (December 1996)."The Geographical Origins and Population Relationships of Early Ancient Egyptians", In Egypt in Africa, Theodore Celenko (ed). Indiana University Press. pp. 20–33.ISBN978-0253332691.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
^E. Pischikova, J. P. Budka, & K. Grifn (Eds. (2018).Wildung, D "African in Egyptian Art" In Thebes in the first millennium BC : art and archaeology of the Kushite period and beyond. London. pp. 300–380.ISBN978-1906137595.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
^abcdeHaynes, Joyce (1992).Nubia: Ancient Kingdoms of Africa. Boston, Massachusetts, USA: Museum of Fine Arts. pp. 8–59.ISBN0878463623.
^Shaw, Ian; Jameson, Robert, eds. (2002).A Dictionary of Archaeology. Wiley. p. 433.ISBN978-0-631-23583-5.
^abcdEmberling, Geoff (2011). Kim, Julienne (ed.).Nubia: Ancient Kingdoms of Africa. New York University: The Institute for the Study of the Ancient World. pp. 5–57.ISBN9780615481029.
^Mohktar, Gamal (1981).General History of Africa volume 2: Ancient Civilizations of Africa: (Unesco General History of Africa. London: Heinemann Educational Books. p. 148.ISBN978-0435948054.
^Williams, Bruce (2011).Before the Pyramids. Chicago, Illinois: Oriental Institute Museum Publications. pp. 89–90.ISBN978-1-885923-82-0.
^Wengrow, David (2023)."Ancient Egypt and Nubian: Kings of Flood and Kings of Rain" in Great Kingdoms of Africa, John Parker (eds). [S.l.]: THAMES & HUDSON. pp. 1–40.ISBN978-0500252529.
^Frank J.Yurco (1996)."The Origin and Development of Ancient Nile Valley Writing," in Egypt in Africa, Theodore Celenko (ed). Indianapolis, Ind.: Indianapolis Museum of Art. pp. 34–35.ISBN0-936260-64-5.
Hafsaas, Henriette (2021). "The C-Group People in Lower Nubia: Cattle Pastoralists on the Frontier between Egypt and Kush". In Geoff Emberling; Bruce Beyer Williams (eds.).The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Nubia. Oxford University Press. pp. 157–177.doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780190496272.013.10.
^Erman & Grapow,Wörterbuch der ägyptischen Sprache, 2, 186.1–2
^de Souza, A.M. 2019. "New Horizons: The Pan-Grave Ceramic Tradition in Context. London: Golden House"
^Van de Mieroop, Marc (2021).A history of ancient Egypt (Second ed.). Chichester, West Sussex. p. 99.ISBN978-1119620877.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
^Fletcher, Joann (2017).The story of Egypt : the civilization that shaped the world (First Pegasus books paperback ed.). New York. pp. Chapter 12.ISBN978-1681774565.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
^Mokhtar, G. (1990).General History of Africa II:Ancient Civilizations of Africa. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. pp. 1–118.ISBN978-0-520-06697-7.
^Martin Bernal (1987),Black Athena: Afroasiatic Roots of Classical Civilization. The Fabrication of Ancient Greece, 1785-1985, vol. I. New Jersey, Rutgers University Press
^Gitton, Michel (1973). "Ahmose Nefertari, sa vie et son culte posthume".École Pratique des Hautes études, 5e Section, Sciences Religieuses.85 (82): 84.doi:10.3406/ephe.1973.20828.ISSN0183-7451.
^Tyldesley, Joyce. Chronicle of the Queens of Egypt. Thames & Hudson. 2006.ISBN0-500-05145-3
^Hodel-Hoenes, S & Warburton, D (trans),Life and Death in Ancient Egypt: Scenes from Private Tombs in New Kingdom Thebes, Cornell University Press, 2000, p. 268.
^The Remarkable Women of Ancient Egypt, by Barbara S. Lesko; page 14; B.C. Scribe Publications, 1996;ISBN978-0-930548-13-1
^Vassilika, Elena (2009).I capolavori del Museo Egizio di Torino (in Italian). Florence: Fondazione Museo delle antichità egizie di Torino.ISBN978-88-8117-950-3.
^Gilda Ferrandino and Matteo Lorenzini; 3D Reconstruction of the Lion Temple at Musawwarat es Sufra: 3D model and domain ontologies; in: The Kushite World (2015). Proceedings of the 11th International Conference for Meroitic Studies;Vienna, 1–4 September 2008.
^Claudia Näser; The Great Hafir at Musawwarat as-Sufra. Fieldwork of the Archaeological Mission of Humboldt University Berlin in 2005 and 2006. On: Between the Cataracts. Proceedings of the 11th Conference of Nubian Studies. Warsaw University, 27 August – 2 September 2006; In: Polish Centre of Mediterranean Aerchaeology University of Warsaw. PAM Supplement Series 2.2./1-2.
^Basil Davidson,Old Africa Rediscovered, Prentice-Hall 1970.
.jpg)
.JPG)
.jpg)
.jpg)
