 Family Tree DNA: Genetic Testing Service Many Balkan people have already taken advantage of DNA testing to learnabout their connections with other families and ethnic groups, both nearand far. Once you've submitted your DNA sample, you'll be eligible tojoin the"Romania" project if you have ancestors who lived in Romania ineither or both of the genetic lines being tested.They don't limit their membership to ethnic Romanians. |
Romania is a Balkan country in the lower Danube valley. It's locatednorth of Bulgaria, southwest of Ukraine and Moldova, southeast of Hungary, and east of Serbia. Transylvania is a famous region of the country.
The much smaller Moldova is also a Romanian-speaking country and thereis considerable debate about whether Moldovans are really a separatepeople from Romanians. I personally consider them to be the same people.
TheRomanian language sounds beautiful and belongs to the Romance family inthe Eastern Romance division. Once written in a form of the Cyrillic alphabeteven in the 16th-19th centuries in much of Romania proper, but in Latin inTransylvania, during most of the 20th century the split was Latin in Romaniaproper and Cyrillic in Soviet-controlled Moldova. In 1989 Moldova switched tothe Latin script, so today Romania and Moldova both use the same writing system.
In comparison with other European ethnic groups, it is comparatively hard (as of 2012) to find detailed data on Romanian DNA.Nevertheless, I was able to find the following estimates for the frequenciesof Y-DNA haplogroups among Romanian people:
7.4% E
5.6% G
22.2% I or I2
5.6% J
20.4% R1a
13% R1b
Haplogroup I is also common in Bosnia and Herzegovina, in Serbia, in Croatia, in Sardinia, and in Scandinavian countries.Some of these peoples, especiallySardinians andSerbs, are believed to primarily descend from among the earliestEuropean settlers, prior to successive waves of new immigrations from the Near East.
Haplogroup I2a1b is found in especially high frequencies in northeastern Romania, Moldova, and central Ukraine.
I tried to parse out ethnic Romanians in Family Tree DNA's "Romania" group. As far as I can tell, for non-Jewish non-Hungarian non-German non-Roma ethnic Romanians their Y-DNA haplogroups include E1b1b1, G, I1, I2a, Q, and R1b1a2. This is in line with the expectations from the frequencies above. Their mtDNA haplogroups include H, H7, I, J, K1c1, M, U4, and U5.
The following Romaniansscore East Asian elements autosomally, per23andMe's estimates:
Emir Šehović, Martin Zieger, L. Spahić, D. Marjanović, and S. Dogan."A glanceof genetic relations in the Balkan populations utilizing network analysis based on in silico assigned Y-DNA haplogroups."Anthropological Review 81:3 (2018): pages 252-268. Published electronically on October 31, 2018.
Table 3 lists the following Y-DNA haplogroup proportions among the study's Romanian samples:14.4% I2a, 18.7% E1b1b, 12.7% R1a, 12.2% R1b, 5% I1, 2.6% J1, 8.4% J2a, 6% J2b.
Siiri Rootsi, Chiara Magri, Toomas Kivisild, Giorgia Benuzzi, Hela Help, Marina Bermisheva, Ildus A. Kutuev, Lororka Barać, Marijana Pericić, Oleg Balanovsky, Andrey Pshenichnov, Daniel Dion, Monica Grobei, Lev A. Zhivotovsky, Vincenza Battaglia, Alessandro Achilli, Nadia Al-Zahery, Jüri Parik, Roy King, Cengiz Cinnioğlu, Elsa Khusnutdinova, Pavao Rudan, Elena Balanovska, Wolfgang Scheffrahn, Maya Simonescu, Antonio Brehm, Rita Goncalves, Alexandra Rosa, Jean-Paul Moisan, Andre Chaventre, Vladimir Ferak, Sandor Füredi, Peter J. Oefner, Peidong Shen, Lars Beckman, Ilia Mikerezi, Rifet Terzić, Dragan Primorac, Anne Cambon-Thomsen, Astrida Krumina, Antonio Torroni, Peter A. Underhill, A. Silvana Santachiara-Benerecetti, Richard Villems, and Ornella Semino."Phylogeography of Y-chromosome haplogroup I reveals distinct domains of prehistoric gene flow in Europe."American Journal of Human Genetics 75:1 (July 1, 2004): pages 128-137. First electronically published on May 25, 2004.
This study found that 22% of the people of Romania and Moldova belong to the Y-DNA haplogroup I.
Alexandru Varzari, Wolfgang Stephan, Vadim Stepanov, Florina Raicu,R. Cojocaru, Y. Roschin, C. Glavce, V. Dergachev, M. Spiridonova,H. D. Schmidt, and E. Weiss."Population history of the Dniester-Carpathians: evidence from Alu markers."Journal of Human Genetics 52:4 (2007): pages 308-316.First published electronically on February 16, 2007.Based on Alexandru Varzari'sdissertation "Population History of the Dniester-Carpathians: Evidence from Alu Insertion and Y-Chromosome Polymorphisms" for the Faculty of Biology Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität on July 27, 2006.Abstract:
"The area between the Dniester and the eastern Carpathian mountain range is at a geographical crossroads between eastern Europe and the Balkans. Little is known about the genetics of the population of this region. We performed an analysis of 12 binary autosomal markers in samples from six Dniester-Carpathianpopulations: two Moldavian, one Romanian, one Ukrainian and two Gagauz populations. The results were compared with gene frequency data from culturally and linguistically related populations from Southeast Europe and Central Asia. Small genetic differences were found among southeastern European populations (in particular those of the Dniester-Carpathian region). The observed homogeneity suggests either a very recent common ancestry of all southeastern European populations or strong gene flow between them. Despite this low level of differentiation, tree reconstruction and principle component analyses allowed a distinction between Balkan-Carpathian (Macedonians, Romanians, Moldavians, Ukrainians and Gagauzes) and eastern Mediterranean (Turks, Greeks and Albanians) population groups. The genetic affinities among Dniester-Carpathian and southeastern European populations do not reflect their linguistic relationships. The results indicate that the ethnic and genetic differentiations occurred in these regions to a considerable extent independently of each other. In particular, Gagauzes, a Turkic-speaking population, show closer affinities to their geographical neighbors than to other Turkic populations."
Relu Cocoş, Sorina Schipor, Montserrat Hervella, Petru Cianga, Roxana Popescu, Claudia Bănescu, Mihai Constantinescu, Alina Martinescu, and Florina Raicu."Genetic affinities among the historical provinces of Romania and Central Europe as revealed by an mtDNA analysis."BMC Genetics (March 7, 2017).
The scientists studied the mitochondrial DNA haplogroups of 714 Romanian people hailing from all historical provinces of Romania: Wallachia, Dobrudja, Moldavia, and Transylvania. They found most haplogroups are homogeneously distributed throughout Romania and that most of them are European in origin while a small portion found in all parts of Romania originate fromEast Asia. Transylvanian Romanians are more closely related to Central Europeans than other Romanians are. Romanians from Wallachia, Moldavia, and Dobrudja are similar to Balkan peoples.
Maria A. Perkova, Urszula Rogalla, Tomasz Grzybowski, Elza K. Khusnutdinova, Irina Dambueva, and Ilia Zakharov."Complete Mitochondrial DNA Analysis of Eastern Eurasian Haplogroups Rarely Found in Populations of Northern Asia and Eastern Europe."PLoS ONE 7(2) (February 21, 2012): e32179.Excerpts:
"[...] The results of our study provided an additional support for the existence of limited maternal gene flow between eastern Asia/southern Siberia and eastern Europe revealed by analysis of modern and ancient mtDNAs previously [...] It is noteworthy that another eastern Asian specific lineage, C5c1, revealed exclusively in some European populations (Poles, Belorussians,Romanians), shows evolutionary ages within frames of 6.6-11.8 kya depending on the mutation rates values [12]. [...] Prehistoric migrations associated with the distribution of the pottery-making tradition initially emerged in the forest-steppe belt of northern Eurasia starting at about 16 kya and spread to the west to reach the south-eastern confines of eastern European Plain by about 8 kya [60] could be suggested as a potential cause for eastern Asian mtDNA haplogroups appearance in Europe. [...]"
Footnote 12 in the above article by Perkova et al. cites the article below:
Miroslava V. Derenko, Boris Abramovich Malyarchuk, Tomasz Grzybowski, Galina A. Denisova, Urszula Rogalla, Maria A. Perkova, Irina Dambueva, and Ilia Zakharov."Origin and post-glacial dispersal of mitochondrial DNA haplogroups C and D in northern Asia."PLoS One 5: e15214.Excerpt:
"Several mtDNAs with the same control-region motif were detected earlier at a low frequency in some European, Asian and southern Siberian populations - in Poles (0.4%), Belorussians (0.3%),Romanians (0.6%), Persians (0.2%), Kirghiz (1.1%), Altaians (0.9%), Teleuts (7.5%), Khakassians (0.9%) and Shors (4%) [4], [10], [22]-[28]."Footnote 26: B. Egyed, A. Brandstätter, J. A. Irwin, Z. Pádár, T. J. Parsons, and W. Parson, "Mitochondrial control region sequence variations in the Hungarian population: analysis of population samples from Hungary and from Transylvania (Romania)," in Forensic Sci. Int. Genet. 1 (2007): pages 158-162.
Simon C. Heath, Ivo G. Gut, Paul Brennan, James D. McKay, Vladimir Bencko,Eleonora Fabianova, Lenka Foretova, Michel Georges, Vladimir Janout,Michael Kabesch, Hans E. Krokan, Maiken B. Elvestad, Jolanta Lissowska, Dana Mates,Peter Rudnai, Frank Skorpen, Stefan Schreiber, José M. Soria,Ann-Christine Syvänen, Pierre Meneton, Serge Herçberg, Pilar Galan,Neonilia Szeszenia-Dabrowska, David Zaridze, Emmanuel Génin, Lon R. Cardon, and Mark Lathrop."Investigation of the fine structure of European populations with applications to disease association studies."European Journal of Human Genetics 16 (2008): pages 1413-1429.
Romanian data is included. Excerpt:
"A striking feature of the samples used for this study is howwell the geographic origin of the samples appears tocorrelate with the genetic origin, so that separating thesamples by country of origin or on the basis of geneticmeasures gives similar results. The only major deviationfrom this pattern is with the Romanian samples thatappear to be closer to the Spanish samples (further 'west')than their geographic position would indicate. This couldbe because of the historical close ties between Romania andItaly, but further studies would be required to confirm this."
G. Cardos, V. Stoian, N. Miritoiu, A. Comsa, A. Kroll, S. Voss, and Alexander Rodewald."Paleo-mtDNA analysis and population genetic aspects of old Thracian populations from South-East of Romania."Romanian Society of Legal Medicine 12:4 (2004): pages 239-246.
To what degree, if any, are the ancient Thracian people related to modern-day Romanians? That was a goal of this study. Excerpts:
"We have performed a study of mtDNA polymorphisms (HVR I and HVR IIsequences) on the skeletal remains of some old Thracian populations fromSE of Romania, dating from the Bronze and Iron Age in order to show theircontribution to the foundation of the modern Romanian genetic pool and thedegree of their genetic kinships with other old and modern human Europeanpopulations. [...] Computing the frequency of common pointmutations of the present-day European population with the Thracianpopulation has resulted that the Italian (7.9%), the Albanian (6.3%) andthe Greek (5.8%) have shown a bias of closer genetic kinship with theThracian individuals than the Romanian and Bulgarian individuals (only4.2%). [...] So far we can justsuppose, that the old Thracian populations would have been able tocontribute to the foundation of the Romanian modern genetic pool. MoremtDNA sequences from Thracian individuals are needed in order to performan complex objective statistical analysis."
Alexander Rodewald, G. Cardos, and C. Tesio."Analysis of mitochondrial DNA haplotypes of old human populations from the Bronze and Iron Age from Romania."A paper to be presented at The European Human Genetics Conference 2012in Nuremberg, Germany, June 23-26, 2012.Thracian Turks descend from local people who converted to Islam when the Ottoman Empire controlled the region.Excerpts from the Abstract:"Our genetic study was focused on old human populations from the Bronze and Iron Ages from Romania [...] Concerning the genetic relationships at mitochondrial level, old human populations from Romania have shown closer genetic relationship to Turks of Thracian origin, whilemodern Romanians were closer to modern Bulgarian, Italian, Greek and Spanish populations."
Alexandru Varzari, Vladimir Kharkov, Alexey G. Nikitin, Florina Raicu, Kseniya Simonova, Wolfgang Stephan, Elisabeth H. Weiss, and Vadim Stepanov."Paleo-Balkan and Slavic Contributions to the Genetic Pool of Moldavians: Insights from the Y Chromosome."PLoS One 8(1) (January 16, 2013): e53731.
This study included 125 Y-DNA samples from Moldavian males from the villages of Karahasani and Sofia and they were compared to other European populations including 54 Romanians living in eastern Romania and 53 Ukrainians living in eastern Moldova. According to Table 2, the lesser-common Y-DNA haplogroups among the Moldovians were I-M253 (4.8%), J-M267 (4%), J-M172* (3.2%), I-M223 (3.2%), E-M123 (2.4%), E-M78* (1.6%), R-M405 (1.6%), G-P15* (0.8%), J-M67* (0.8%), N-P43 (0.8%), N-M178 (0.8%), Q-M242 (0.8%), T-M70 (0.8%). Those who registered 0.8% frequency represent only 1 individual each. Their more common haplogroups are listed in the Abstract, excerpted below:
"[...] In Moldavians, 19 Y chromosome haplogroups were identified, the most common being I-M423 (20.8%), R-M17* (17.6%), R-M458 (12.8%), E-v13 (8.8%), R-M269* and R-M412* (both 7.2%). In Romanians, 14 haplogroups were found including I-M423 (40.7%), R-M17* (16.7%), R-M405 (7.4%), E-v13 and R-M412* (both 5.6%). In Ukrainians, 13 haplogroups were identified including R-M17 (34.0%), I-M423 (20.8%), R-M269* (9.4%), N-M178, R-M458 and R-M73 (each 5.7%). Our results show that a significant majority of the Moldavian paternal gene pool belongs to eastern/central European and Balkan/eastern Mediterranean Y lineages. Phylogenetic and AMOVA analyses based on Y-STR loci also revealed that Moldavians are close to both eastern/central European and Balkan-Carpathian populations. The data correlate well with historical accounts and geographical location of the region and thus allow to hypothesize that extant Moldavian paternal genetic lineages arose from extensiverecent admixture between genetically autochthonous populations of the Balkan-Carpathian zone and neighboring Slavic groups."
Ramona Hodișan, Dana C. Zaha, Claudia Jurca, Codruta D. Petchesi, and Marius Bembea."A Review of Genetic Diversity Based on the Y Chromosome in the Romanian Population."Cureus 16:8 (August 23, 2024): e67593.
A summary of previous papers.
Garrett Hellenthal, George B. J. Busby, Gavin Band, James F. Wilson,Cristian Capelli, Daniel Falush, and Simon Myers."A Genetic Atlas of Human Admixture History."Science 343:6172 (February 14, 2014): pages 747-751.Companion website.
In analyzing the genetics of 13 Romanian people, the team detected an admixture event that occurred sometime around the year 1054, and almost certainly between 886 and 1194. One part of their ancestry is related to peoples like Lithuanians and Finns while the other part is related to peoples like Greeks, Cypriots, and Southern Italians including Sicilians.
Montserrat Hervella, Mihai Rotea, Neskuts Izagirre, Mihai Constantinescu, Santos Alonso, Mihai Ioana, Cătălin Lazăr, Florin Ridiche, Andrei Dorian Soficaru, Mihai G. Netea, and Concepcion de-la-Rua."Ancient DNA from South-East Europe Reveals Different Events during Early and Middle Neolithic Influencing the European Genetic Heritage."PLoS ONE 10:6 (June 8, 2015): e0128810.
Page 11 notes that modern people from Romania are genetically "very close" to people representing the ancient Boian, Zau, and Gumelniţa cultures who lived on Romanian territories (both Transylvania and southeastern Romania near the Bulgarian border) during the Middle-to-Late Neolithic period (5500-4500 B.C.E.). This determination was made on the basis of mtDNA found at 5 sites from those cultures.
