"What Russia Should Do with Ukraine" (Russian:Что Россия должна сделать с Украиной,romanized: Chto Rossiya dolzhna sdelat s Ukrainoy),[a][1] is an article written by Timofey Sergeytsev and published by the Russianstate-owned news agencyRIA Novosti.[2] The article calls for the full destruction of Ukraine as a state, as well as the full destruction of the Ukrainiannational identity in accordance with Russia's aim to accomplish the "denazification" of the latter.[3][4]
It was published on 3 April 2022 in the context of the ongoingRussian invasion of Ukraine,[2] on the same day asthe bodies of dozens of civilians were discovered after the retreat of Russian forces from Ukrainian city ofBucha.[3][5][6] The article caused international criticism and outrage[3][7][8] and has been condemned as evidence ofgenocidal intent.[9][10][11]
The article advocates for "brutal censorship" of theUkrainian culture and large-scale "de-ukrainization" of Ukrainians on the territories occupied by Russia in the2022 invasion of Ukraine.[4][12][8]
Sergeytsev insists that Ukraine'sethnocentrism is an artificial perversion,[13] that Ukraine's existence is "impossible" as anation-state,[12] and that the word "Ukraine" itself cannot be allowed to exist.[3][4] According to the author, Ukraine should be dismantled and replaced with several states under direct control by Russia.[14] He adds that the "ethnic component of self-identification" of Ukraine would also be rejected after its occupation by Russia.[12]
The author claims that "most likely the majority" of Ukrainian civilians are "passive Nazis and Nazi accomplices. They supported the Nazi authorities and pandered to them",[12] thus, they "technically" cannot be punished as war criminals, but can be subjected to "denazification" and are to blame.[15] While Sergeytsev notes that there are no Nazi parties, symbols, racist laws, or other evidence of actual Nazism, he counters that by asserting that "Ukrainian Nazism is unique due to its amorphism and ambiguity", which is, perTimothy Snyder, equivalent to a "special Russian definition of Nazism".[5] The author asserts thatBanderites are actually marginal to "Ukro-nazism", and that the real menace isPro-Europeanism.
Sergeytsev claims that the "Banderite" elite has to be "liquidated", and adds that the remaining Ukrainians must "assimilate the experience" of the war "as a historical lesson and atonement for [their] guilt". After the war,forced labor, imprisonment and the death penalty would be used as punishment. After that, the population would be "integrated" into "Russian civilization".[12] The author describes the planned actions as a "decolonization" of Ukraine.[13][14]
According toAnton Shekhovtsov, writing inHaaretz, the article is an expanded version of a 2016 article[16][17][18] by Russian columnist Alexander Zhuchkovsky,[19] who is linked toRussian Imperial Movement. In that article, Zhuchkovsky called for the dehumanization of Ukrainians, saying "It is natural and right, as we are fighting not against people but against enemies, [...] not against people but against Ukrainians."[20]
The author of the text,Timofey Sergeytsev, advisedVictor Pinchuk's projects from 1998 to 2000, including Pinchuk's 1998 parliamentary election campaign in Ukraine, and was a member of the Board of Directors ofInterpipe Group.[21]
He was born in 1963[22] inChelyabinsk,Soviet Russia. He studied at theMoscow Institute of Physics and Technology in 1980, where he was a student ofGeorgy Shchedrovitsky.[23][24]
In 1999, he worked for the presidential campaign of then incumbent Ukrainian presidentLeonid Kuchma. In September 2004, he was a consultant toViktor Yanukovych. In 2010, he worked withArseniy Yatsenyuk.[21] During Russia’s2012 presidential elections, he worked as a consultant for Russian billionaireMikhail Prokhorov and his partyRight Cause.[25] In 2012, Sergeitsev co-produced the Russian feature filmMatch which was criticized forUkrainophobia.[26] In 2014, it was banned on the territory of Ukraine as propaganda.[27][28]
According toDer Tagesspiegel, Sergeitsev supports the (since 2015) pro-Putin (formerly opposition) political partyCivic Platform financed by one of the oligarchs from Putin's inner circle.[4] According toEuractiv, Sergeitsev is "one of the ideologists of modernRussian fascism".[29]
Dmitry Medvedev, the current deputy chairman of theSecurity Council of Russia, as well as formerpresident of Russia between 2008 and 2012 and formerprime minister of Russia between 2012 and 2020, reiterated the main points of the article a few days after its publication. According to Medvedev, "a passionate segment of Ukrainian society has been praying to theThird Reich",[30] Ukraine is a Nazi state like the Third Reich that must be "denazified" and "eradicated", and the result will be a collapse of Ukraine as a state.[31] Medvedev claims that the collapse is a path towards "open Eurasia fromLisbon toVladivostok".[31] Medvedev has continued this rhetoric, posting lengthy diatribes against Ukraine aimed at domestic audiences. For example, in his "On Fakes and True History", he claimed that "the very essence of Ukrainianness, fed by anti-Russian venom and lies about its identity, is one big sham".[32]
On 26 April 2022, Putin's national security adviserNikolai Patrushev said that "the Americans by using their proteges in Kyiv decided to create an antipode of our country, cynically choosing Ukraine for this, trying to divide an essentially single nation" and that "the result of the policy of the West and the Kyiv regime under its control can only be the disintegration of Ukraine into several states".[33]
Russian opposition politicianLeonid Gozman, former co-chairman ofRight Cause, called Sergeytsev a "scumbag".[25]Andrei Kolesnikov, a political analyst atCarnegie Moscow Center, said that consultants like Sergeytsev can be used to create strategies for authorities but they "don’t have any serious influence on anything".[25]
President of UkraineVolodymyr Zelenskyy said that the article is proof of the Russian Federation'splans to carry out a genocide of Ukrainian citizens.[10] He noted that in order to denote the genocide of Ukrainians in the article the terms "de-Ukrainisation" and "de-Europeanization" were used. In his opinion, this is a part of the evidence for a future tribunal against Russianwar crimes in Ukraine.[9][34]
According to a representative of Ukraine at Russian-Ukrainian peace negotiationsMykhailo Podoliak, the article is an official call for mass murders of Ukrainians because of their ethnicity, and will be considered as such by international criminal courts.[11] The Minister of Culture and Information Policy of UkraineOleksandr Tkachenko commented:[9]
Cynically, the author speaks about Ukrainian Nazism. When we see exactly the opposite: Russia is mass murdering Ukrainians because of their national identity. What should I call it? I will answer straight away: it is genocide of the Ukrainian people by Russia.
The head of theLatvian Ministry of Foreign AffairsEdgars Rinkēvičs called the article "ordinary fascism".[35] Former Canadian ambassador to UkraineRoman Waschuk said that "It's essentially a rhetorical 'licence to kill' Ukrainians."[3]
In Germany in April 2022,Bundestag deputyThomas Heilmann filed a lawsuit with the Berlin prosecutor against the author of the article. According to Heilmann, the article may be a violation of theConvention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide.[36]
In Ukraine in May, the Ukrainian Prosecutor General's Office opened a pre-trial investigation in the case.[37] The death penalty is forbidden under Ukrainian law, and is subject to a moratorium in Russia, as of 2024[update].[38] On 8 July 2022, a month afterit sentenced three prisoners of war to death, theDonetsk People's Republic lifted a moratorium on the death penalty.[39]
According toMika Aaltola, director of theFinnish Institute of International Affairs, the article showed Russian war propaganda "developing in a worrying direction".[40] Latvia-based Russian mediaMeduza wrote that the article is "essentially a blueprint for thegenocide" of Ukrainians.[13] Oxford expert on Russian affairs Samuel Ramani stated that the article "represents mainstreamKremlin thinking".[30] The American historianTimothy Snyder wrote that the text "advocates the elimination of the Ukrainian people as such".[41] He later noted that it uses a special definition of the word "Nazi": "a Nazi is a Ukrainian who refuses to admit being a Russian". In his opinion, the article reveals thegenocidal intent of Russia.[5]
Slavoj Žižek wrote: "So, Russia plans to do with Ukraine whatBertolt Brecht describes in his 1953 poem "The Solution": dissolve the people and elect another. By reading Sergeytsev's mad ravings alongside Putin's claim thatLenin invented Ukraine, we can discern the current Russian position. Ukraine has two fathers: Lenin, who invented it, and Hitler, who inspired today's “ukronazis” to actualize Lenin's invention".[42]
An article in the official state Russian news agency RIA Novosti advocates the elimination of the Ukrainian people as such. The text is so despicable that I'm not going to link to it. Will write about it later.
Part of theRusso-Ukrainian war (2022–present) | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Overview |
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Military engagements |
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| War crimes | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Reactions |
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Impact |
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Key people |
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Related | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
