| "These Are the Voyages..." | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Star Trek: Enterprise episode | |||
| Episodeno. | Season 4 Episode 22 | ||
| Directed by | Allan Kroeker | ||
| Written by | |||
| Featured music |
| ||
| Cinematography by | Douglas Knapp | ||
| Production code | 422 | ||
| Original air date | May 13, 2005 (2005-05-13) | ||
| Guest appearances | |||
| |||
| Episode chronology | |||
| |||
| Star Trek: Enterpriseseason 4 | |||
| List of episodes | |||
"These Are the Voyages..." is the series finale of the American science fiction television seriesStar Trek: Enterprise. The 22nd episode of thefourth season and the 98th of the series overall, it first aired onUPN in the United States on May 13, 2005. It is aframe story in which the 22nd-century events ofStar Trek: Enterprise are recounted in a 24th-centuryholodeck re-creation that is folded into theStar Trek: The Next Generation episode "The Pegasus", which aired eleven years earlier. It features guest starsJonathan Frakes,Marina Sirtis andJeffrey Combs, as well as a voice cameo fromBrent Spiner. Series creatorsRick Berman andBrannon Braga, who co-wrote the episode, conceived "These Are the Voyages..." as a valentine toStar Trek fans.
Set in the 22nd century, the series follows the adventures of the firstStarfleet starshipEnterprise, registration NX-01. In this episode, the story moves to the year 2370, when CommanderWilliam Riker grapples with making a difficult admission to hiscommanding officer about a cover-up. Riker, after consulting CounselorDeanna Troi, turns to the simulated events of the year 2161 for guidance, when the crew ofEnterprise travels home to Earth for both decommissioning and the formation of theUnited Federation of Planets.
Reaction to "These Are the Voyages..." was negative. Critics and cast alike believed theNext Generation frame robbed the characters and their fans of closure, and that the death of CommanderTrip Tucker felt forced and unnecessary. The final episode attracted 3.8 million viewers, the highest number since the previous season.
In 2370, CommanderWilliam Riker, aboardEnterprise-D, is troubled by the events depicted in theNext Generation episode "The Pegasus", and seeks guidance. At Lieutenant CommanderDeanna Troi's suggestion, Riker sets aholo-program to the date 2161, some six years after the events of "Terra Prime", to a time when the originalEnterprise (NX-01) is due to be decommissioned after ten years of active service. The starship and its crew are also returning to Earth for the signing of theFederation Charter, and CaptainJonathan Archer frets over the speech he will give to the assembled delegates.
En route, Riker and Troi observe asEnterprise is contacted byShran, a formerAndorian Imperial Guard officer whom Archer believed to be dead. Shran is married to Jhamel ("The Aenar"), and their young daughter has been kidnapped. He asks for Archer's help in rescuing her from Rigel X. Archer decides to assist, despite CommanderT'Pol's warning that they may be late returning for the ceremony. Riker joins theEnterprise crew as it assaults Shran's enemies and brings his daughter safely back. Troi also advises that Riker assume the role of ship's chef, hoping to earn the confidence of the simulated crew. As he prepares food with the crew, he learns more about their memories and impressions ofTrip Tucker.
He also watches as the kidnappers boardEnterprise, and how, in order to save Archer's life, Commander Tucker overloads two conduits and dies after being mortally wounded. Riker notices that Archer is troubled that he must write a speech about how worthwhile their explorations have been despite his friend's death, but T'Pol assures him Tucker would have considered it worthwhile. On Earth, Troi watches as Archer enters a crowded grand hall to give his speech and Riker joins her, now sure of what course he should take.[1] The final shot of the episode is a montage of the ships namedEnterprise: (NCC-1701-D,NCC-1701, and NX-01) as CaptainsJean-Luc Picard,James T. Kirk, and Archer recite the "Where no man has gone before" prologue.
"Broken Bow",Enterprise's 2001 premiere episode, attracted 12.5 million viewers in its first broadcast,[3] but ratings quickly dropped to a low of 5.9 million viewers.Enterprise was threatened with cancellation by the third season.[4] The show survived by slashing its budget amid broadcasterUPN's schedule revamp.[5] The show was moved to Fridays in 2004, while the rest of UPN's programming became more female-friendly, in part due to the success ofAmerica's Next Top Model. The third season introduced a season-long story arc, to some of the best reviews of the entire series.[4] In the fourth season,Manny Coto became executive producer after writing and co-producing the show since 2003. While Coto's episodes were hailed by critics and fans as equaling the quality of previousStar Trek television series,[3] the average viewership dropped to 2.9 million,[5] with a series-low showing of 2.5 million in January 2005.[6] According toNielsen Media Research,Enterprise's final episode attracted 3.8 million viewers, an increase of 69% over the previous season's finale.[7][8]
On February 3, 2005,Paramount announced that the fourth season of the show would be its last.[9] The network waited until the series had been sold to syndication before making the announcement.[5] The cancellation marked the first time newStar Trek episodes would not appear on television in 18 years, sinceStar Trek: The Next Generation premiered.[6] The fourth season continued production so Paramount could sell an attractive 98 episodes to syndicates.[5]
ActressJolene Blalock (T'Pol) criticized the early stories as boring and lacking intriguing content. She felt earlyEnterprise scripts ignored basic tenets ofStar Trek chronology, and offered "revealing costumes instead of character development". UPN executives said the male-oriented episodes ofEnterprise did not mesh with the viewership of its other top shows, such asTop Model andVeronica Mars.[3]Brannon Braga suggested the reason for cancellation was viewer fatigue, noting that "after 18 years and 624 hours ofStar Trek, the audience began to have a little bit of overkill."[10] Fans criticized Berman and Braga for ignoringStar Trek canon and refusing to fix their shows. Michael Hinman, news coordinator forSyFy Portal, said that in addition to the oversaturation ofStar Trek, there "also is an oversaturation of Braga and Berman. [...] They couldn't sit back and say, 'You know, we just can't keep this fresh.' No, it was more about their stupid egos, and their nonsensical 'Even if it's broke, don't fix it' attitude."[11][12] Berman noted thatThe Next Generation faced little competition from other science fiction shows, whileEnterprise had to contend with a plethora of shows. For example, Friday viewing figures were higher forBattlestar Galactica.[5]
"These Are the Voyages..." was written by Braga and Berman, the pair's only script of the fourth season.Enterprise writerMike Sussman toldTrekNation in May 2005 that Braga had considered the idea of an episode crossover featuring characters from otherStar Trek series prior to the finale. Sussman's original idea for the episode was to haveThe Doctor ofStar Trek: Voyager treating an ill patient who may or may not have been Archer trapped in the future. Due to the subject matter, Sussman said his version would not have been suitable for the final episode.[14] In interviews, Berman said the episode had always been intended as the season finale regardless of cancellation, and gave conflicting answers as to whether Trip would still have been killed if the show had continued.[15][16]
Allan Kroeker directed the episode, his third series finale followingStar Trek: Deep Space Nine's "What You Leave Behind" andStar Trek: Voyager's "Endgame".[17] "These Are the Voyages..." featured guest appearances byJonathan Frakes andMarina Sirtis as theirNext Generation charactersWilliam Riker andDeanna Troi.Brent Spiner, anotherNext Generation veteran who had guest-starred earlier in the fourth season ofEnterprise, had an off-screen speaking role as the androidData.[17]Jeffrey Combs appeared as theAndorianShran, whom Coto had wanted to be a permanent addition to the cast in the event of another season.[18] The episode uses aframing story, so that it actually takes place in 2370 in theStar Trek universe aboard a holodeck on theEnterprise-D, specifically during the events of theStar Trek The Next Generation episode"The Pegasus".[19]
Filming of the final episode began on Friday, February 25, after the first half of the day was spent completing "Terra Prime". Principal photography took eight days, one day longer than usual. The snowy, complex set of Rigel X, first seen in the pilot episode, was used, as was the rarely seenEnterprise galley.Enterprise-D locations such as hallways and the observation lounge were re-created. Frakes and Sirtis arrived just as a "Save Enterprise" rally was being held outside the lot. Similar to "What You Leave Behind", many of the production staff cameoed for a large crowd scene at the end of the episode, as Archer prepares to give his speech. Fifteen "VIPs", including writersJudith and Garfield Reeves-Stevens,André Bormanis, and Manny Coto joined two dozen extras in forming part of the audience. The rest of the digital set was filled by a computer-generated crowd. After their parts were finished, the final dismissal of each cast member was met with applause.Jolene Blalock andScott Bakula were the last actors to be released, and Bakula gave a speech thanking the production crew for making the cast feel welcome. Filming ended on Tuesday, March 8, and the sets were struck. Frakes and Sirtis returned on March 9 to complete green-screen shots to be used when their characters entered or exited the holodeck.[17] Berman would not elaborate on the episode's content before it aired, saying, "It's going to have some surprising twists and turns. It's somewhat of a valentine."[5]
A series-ending wrap party was held for the cast and crew at theRoosevelt Hotel in April. Cast members spoke about their feelings about the end of the series.John Billingsley said the show "was a great ride, and it changed my life. It's something that will last forever for me." He was happy to say goodbye to the two-hour makeup sessions to create his character,Phlox. Many of the cast were taking a break and going on vacation before seeking new acting work. Among the notable guests wereStar Trek: Nemesis screenwriterJohn Logan, who was not affiliated withEnterprise; andPeter Weller, who appeared as a villain in "Terra Prime".[20]
"These Are the Voyages..." was negatively received by both critics and the show's cast, with it often being compared to being an episode ofStar Trek: The Next Generation.
Before the episode aired, Blalock called the episode "appalling."[21][22] She followed up her remarks by saying she was upset over the finale being an episode ofThe Next Generation rather than an end forEnterprise.[23]
Connor Trinneer, who played CommanderTrip Tucker, felt the finale should have had a memorable farewell that he described as a "M*A*S*H moment", but the producers did not want such an element.[15] Trinneer liked the finale and was satisfied by it as an actor; his character had plenty to do and he enjoyed working with Frakes.[24]Anthony Montgomery (who played EnsignTravis Mayweather) was displeased with the finale and said: "I feel there could have been a more effective way to wrap things up for our show as well as the franchise as a whole. It just seemed to take a little bit away from what theEnterprise cast and crew worked so diligently to achieve over the past four years."[25] While Frakes enjoyed working with Sirtis again, he said "the reality is it was a bit of a stretch to have us shut down [theEnterprise cast's] show," and that in hindsight it was a disservice to them.[13] The early criticism forced the show's producers to hold a conference and address the issue. Braga admitted there was cast unrest, but defended the episode as a way to close not justEnterprise butStar Trek as a whole.[26]
Berman said: "I've read a lot of the criticisms and I understand how some people feel, but [Braga] and I spent a lot of time coming up with the idea and a somewhat, I would say, unique ending to a series, especially when you're ending it prematurely. [...] You never like to disappoint people, but I think it's nonsense to say that it was more aNext Generation episode than anEnterprise episode. The only elements of [The Next Generation] that were present were there as a sounding board to allow us to look at a mission that took place six years after 'Terra Prime'."[27] Braga later admitted that killing Tucker "wasn't a great idea",[28] and called making the finaleTNG-centric his biggest regret of the series.[29] Coto said he liked the episode and found the script to be very moving. He said he considered the two-part story "Demons" and "Terra Prime" the quasi-finale of the season and calledThese Are the Voyages... "a kind of post-season episode" and actual farewell toStar Trek.[30]
Reviewers were also critical of theNext Generation tie-in.Sci Fi Weekly's Patrick Lee said the framing story "reduces [theEnterprise cast] to the status of lab rats." Lee further noted that even without the guest appearances, the episode did not live up to the best offerings of the season, including "In a Mirror, Darkly".[21]National Post's Alex Strachan called theNext Generation cameos reminders of betterStar Trek, compared to the "bad make-up effects, bad acting, bad music" of the latest show.[31] Rob Salem of theToronto Star said the cameos served no narrative purpose, and that the episode "robs [the] characters (and their fans) of any significant long-term development or satisfying sense of closure."[32] Reviewers also criticized the episode's ending, where viewers never got to see Archer's rousing speech.[33][34]IGN said the episode was "Berman and Braga's parting shot, making sure that everyone knew who was in charge," and that the sharp contrast between "These Are the Voyages..." and "Terra Prime" brought into relief the reason neither should be allowed to produceStar Trek ever again.[34]
The death of Tucker was another point of controversy. Salem described the development as "a major character is pointlessly killed off in service of a pointless plot device,"[32] a complaint echoed byIGN.[34] ActorConnor Trinneer, who played Trip, said during a convention appearance that the character had "gotten out of much worse scrapes than that," and the death seemed forced. The writers, Trinneer contended, wanted to kill off a character to "get the fans talking," and so Trip was killed off simply to manipulate viewers.[35] Several critics ended their reviews by saying that whether fans would be disappointed or pleased by the episode, the majority of casual viewers would not care one way or another.[31][36][37]
Newspapers coveringEnterprise's cancellation and its final episode often said the failure ofEnterprise was evidence that the franchise had moved too far from its roots and grown too dark. Andy Dehnart ofMSNBC said that "while the writers and production designers deserve credit for offering worlds that were perhaps slightly more believable, they lost the fantastic, wondrous approach to space travel thatThe Next Generation borrowed from the originalStar Trek and then perfected."[38]USA Today's Michael Peck said that without the "dreams" of earlier series, "Star Trek becomes just another television drama."[39] Melanie McFarland of theSeattle Post-Intelligencer, meanwhile, said the show "never found the sense of uniqueness within theTrek universe that every version that came before it possessed."[40]
Den of Geek, while acknowledging critiques of the finale, said "These Are the Voyages..." was the tenth best episode of the series, praising the inclusion of Riker and Troi and remarking the "undeniable joy in seeing the familiar and beloved characters back on screen."[41]Den of Geek later ranked it 6th on its list of the 15 worst episodes of all Star Trek.[42]
WhatCulture ranked this episode the 19th worst episode of allStar Trek,[43]CBR rated it 4th worst[44] andScreenRant called it the worst episode of the entire franchise to-date.[45]CNET polled fans at the 50th anniversary Star Trek convention in Las Vegas, and "These Are the Voyages..." was voted the worst episode of allStar Trek.[46]
The episode was released onDVD home media as part of the season fourbox set on November 1, 2005 in the United States.[47] The episode was released in HD with surround sound on theBlu-ray release of the final season ofEnterprise, which was made available on April 29, 2014.[48] It was also one of threeEnterprise episodes included in the DVD box setStar Trek Fan Collective - Captain's Log.[49]
I thought it would be cool to do a valentine to all of Star Trek.
But there also is an oversaturation of Braga and Berman.
Blalock has famously decried the finale
I don't know where to begin with that one," she finally stammers. "The final episode is ... appalling.
he was pleased that the producers used the last episode to tell a Trip story
one of the worst TV finales of all time