After the1994 murder of both of his parents and his sister, Atif Rafay, along with friend Sebastian Burns, become suspects. Although the murders happened in the United States, Rafay and Burns, Canadian citizens, returned to Canada after local police found insufficient evidence to keep them. Back in Canada, in coordination with the USFederal Bureau of Investigation, theRoyal Canadian Mounted Police use the controversialMr. Big investigative technique to extract confessions from the suspected killers.

The trial of Atif Rafay and Sebastian Burns begins in Seattle, Washington. The court refuses to allow the defense to present evidence that the murders may have been conducted by the religious extremist groupJamaat ul-Fuqra, and both are thereafter found guilty and sentenced tolife in prison. Both continue to maintain their innocence.

In 1997, Teresa Haught is murdered, and then the nightclub the crime took place in is burned down. The police immediately finger Wesley Myers for the crime, and after hours of interrogation, extract three confessions from him: one in writing, one on tape, and one in front of a television reporter. Myers denies his guilt at trial and claims his confession was false, but is still found guilty. In 2012, a retrial is ordered after a judge determines Myers' constitutional rights were violated, but fearing another jury trial, Myers pleads guilty tovoluntary manslaughter, and is sentenced to time served, thus being freed. Myers continues to maintain his innocence.

In 2002 a fire started by agas can burns down a house in the small town ofZeeland, Michigan, killing 14-year-old Robin Boes ofsmoke inhalation. Investigators extract a confession from the teen's mother, Karen Boes, and she goes on to be convicted of first-degree murder and is sentenced to life in prison without the possibility ofparole. Despite this, she maintains her innocence, and continues to claim her confession was false.

Catherine Fuller, 49, is brutally raped, robbed and murdered inWashington D.C. in 1984. Investigating detectives immediately suspectgang violence, and connect the murder to the 8th and H Street Crew, which participants in the documentary claim never existed. Casting a wide net, seventeen people are arrested for the crime, and the State's main witness, Clifton Yarborough, names all of them in being present during the attack. Police ignore inconsistencies in Yarborough's story, and also the fact that Yarborough himself has alow IQ and suffers from alearning disability. All seventeen men stand trial at once, which causes a chaotic and divided defense; the defense lawyers turn the men against each other, saying in court that while it's possible some of the accused did it, the alibis of many of the men are solid. The jury finds eight of the accused guilty after months of deliberation - and appeals bring the case all the way to theSupreme Court of the United States. Although the court rejected the appeal inTurner v. United States, the accused still maintain their innocence.

On Labor Day in the year 2000, John Lavelle Lynn and Robert Arthur VanAllen, an owner and an employee of anauto salvage yard respectively, are murdered. Out of hundreds of potential witnesses, police eventually question Buddy Woodall, the nephew of one of the slain men. Woodall, represented by attorney Chris Adams^[1] confesses, not to the murder, but to helping another man, David Wimberly, carry out the murder. The men are tried separately, and Woodall is convicted; but, due to lack of evidence, the case against Wimberly is dropped by the prosecutor. In 2014, theSupreme Court of Georgia upholds Woodall's conviction, despite alleged problems with the trial and conduct of the police. Buddy Woodall continues to maintain his innocence.^[2]

While on a family outing,Lawrence DeLisle'sFord LTD station wagon is driven off the edge of a pier inDownriver, Michigan with himself, his wife, and all four of his children inside. When the car hits the water, thewindshield shatters, allowing DeLisle and his wife to get free. Rescue workers attempt to save the four children, but all four never regain consciousness. DeLisle originally claims that hisleg cramped, causing him to lose control of the vehicle, but later confesses during an interrogation his attorney would later liken tohypnosis. While the court rules the confession inadmissible, it is still made available to the media. In the ensuingtrial by media, newspapers and television stations comment on the tape without directly reproducing it, which would be against the court order. Despite the confession never being read in court, the jury finds DeLisle guilty for four murders and oneattempted murder of his wife on August 1, 1990. Despite exhausting all of his appeals, DeLisle continues to maintain his innocence, blaming the car instead.

Without a lawyer to advise him, weary truck driver Kenneth Osburn confesses to murdering 17-year-old Casey Crowder following an exhausting interrogation.

The double murder of Wayne and Sharmon Stock in Nebraska sparks a hunt for those responsible and a bizarre series of interviews that raise more questions than they answer.

In a long interview with police, Angelika Graswald admits to being "OK with" her fiancé drowning during a kayaking expedition. Cops and media pounce.

AfterHamid Hayat admits to attending a terrorist camp, lawyers and his family question whether the taped confession reveals a very different truth.