Between 1851 and 1865, Brethren periodicals began to be published under progressive editorsHenry Kurtz,James Quinter, andHenry Holsinger.[11] At the same time, Kinsey's father-in-law, Peter Nead, was the primary leader for thereactionary[12][13] wing of the Brethren,[14][15] also known at the time as Old Order Brethren.[15][better source needed] Out of this group[b] emerged a new periodical,The Vindicator, with Kinsey as editor.[14][17][18] It was first published on 1 March 1870[10][15][16] as an eight-page monthly,[12][13][16] composed of scriptural interpretations, exhortations to piety, and news on church affairs.[15] One of its goals was to counter the influence of progressive Brethren periodicals.[19][20]
A major controversy among the Brethren arose over the authority of tradition and the role of the church in establishing achurch order orordnung, known as the "order of the Brethren".[21] InThe Vindicator, Kinsey rejected that the church had any authority to change or adapt the order, as it was based upon Scripture.[22][17] This view sharply contrasted with other Brethren at the time. The group that became theChurch of the Brethren revered tradition and supported the role of the church in discerning an ordnung, but held this order to be changeable. Meanwhile, the faction that became theBrethren Church rejected any need for a unifiedchurch order or agreement on practices not explicitly defined inChristian scripture, and sought to eliminate some Brethren traditions which they felt lacked support from scriptures.[21][17][c]
In around 1874, Kinsey handed over control of his business interests to others in order to devote himself to the service of the church.[17] He was a hymn writer.[8] In 1878, Kinsey was one of four men appointed and financially supported by the Southern Ohio District of the Brethren to engage in missionary work in Kentucky. This work was largely unsuccessful.[23]
A significant part of Kinsey's ministry was also his ongoing publishing. The Vindicator was expanded to 32 pages per issue.[3][24] His work was not well received by the majority of Brethren; Kinsey was reprimanded by the 1881 Brethren Annual Meeting for encouraging dissension and criticizing church authorities.[25] The Old German Baptist Brethrensplit at this conference,[26][19] with Nead and Kinsey as their primary leaders.[27] The proliferation of unauthorized and uncontrolled periodicals has been claimed as a major cause of this division.[28][29][19][30][d] In 1882, at their first meeting, the Old German Baptist Brethren recognizedThe Vindicator as their official publication.[15][14][3][30] Kinsey was alsoordained as anelder in 1882.[4][additional citation(s) needed]
Kinsey died on 8 June 1883.[17][31][3] He was succeeded as editor by Joseph I. Cover.[32][33]The Vindicator set a precedent of conservative periodicals that was followed byMennoniteGeorge R. Brunk'sSword and Trumpet.[14][e] Kinsey has continued to be influential in the Old German Baptist Brethren.[34][35]The Vindicator continues to be published for the Old German Baptist Brethren as of 2008[update].[36][15]
Boyers, Auburn A. (1971). "The Brethren, annual conference, and education: Denominational publications".Brethren Life and Thought.16 (Winter).ISSN0006-9663.
Durnbaugh, Donald F. (1997). "Sustainers or seducers? The rise and meaning of church-related institutions".Mennonite Quarterly Review.71 (3): 345-364.ISSN0025-9373.
Miller, Marcus (1983). "Vindicator, The". In Durnbaugh, Donald F. (ed.).The Brethren Encyclopedia. Vol. 2. Brethren Encyclopedia, Incorporated. p. 1306-07.ISBN9780936693040.
