| Year | National Champions | Player of the Year | Coach of the Year |
|---|
| 1997 | Findlay (OH) (4) | Bo Hurley (QB),Findlay (OH) | Dick Strahm (3) |
| 1998 | Azusa Pacific | Jack Williams (RB),Azusa Pacific | Vic Shealy |
| 1999 | Northwestern Oklahoma | Eddie Eviston (QB),Georgetown (KY) | Tim Albin |
| 2000 | Georgetown (KY) (2) | Eddie Eviston (QB),Georgetown (KY) (2) | Bill Cronin |
| 2001 | Georgetown (KY) (3) | Eddie Eviston (QB),Georgetown (KY) (3) | Bill Cronin (2) |
| 2002 | Carroll | Nick Kortan (RB),Sioux Falls | Carl Poelker |
| 2003 | Carroll (2) | Tyler Emmert (QB),Carroll | Mike Van Diest |
| 2004 | Carroll (3) | Cory Jacquay (RB),Saint Francis (IN) | Kevin Donley (2) |
| 2005 | Carroll (4) | Tyler Emmert (QB),Carroll (2) | Mike Van Diest (2) |
| 2006 | Sioux Falls (2) | Brian Kurtz (LB),Saint Francis (IN) | Kalen DeBoer |
| 2007 | Carroll (5) | Chad Cavender (QB),Sioux Falls | Mike Van Diest (3) |
| 2008 | Sioux Falls (3) | Owen Koeppen (LB),Carroll | Kalen DeBoer (2) |
| 2009 | Sioux Falls (4) | Lorenzo Brown (QB),Sioux Falls | Kalen DeBoer (3) |
| 2010 | Carroll (6) | Jon Ryan (WR),Sioux Falls | Mike Van Diest (4) |
| 2011 | Saint Xavier | Chance Demarais (RB),Carroll | Mike Feminis |
| 2012 | Marian | Jimmy Coy (QB),Saint Xavier | Steve Ryan |
| 2013 | Grand View | Kyle Schuck (WR),Morningside | Mike Woodley |
| 2014 | Southern Oregon | Austin Dodge (QB),Southern Oregon | Mark Henninger |
| 2015 | Marian (2) | Ryan Kasdorf (QB),Morningside | Mark Henninger (2) |
| 2016 | Saint Francis (IN) | Logan Brettell (QB),Baker | Kevin Donley (3) |
| 2017 | Saint Francis (IN) (2) | Nick Ferrer (QB),Saint Francis (IN) | Kevin Donley (4) |
| 2018 | Morningside | Trent Solsma (QB),Morningside | Steve Ryan (2) |
| 2019 | Morningside (2) | Charles Salary (RB),Marian (IN) | Steve Ryan (3) |
| 2020 | Lindsey Wilson | Tyson Kooima (QB),Northwestern (IA) | Chris Oliver |
| 2021 | Morningside (3) | Joe Dolincheck (QB),Morningside | Steve Ryan (4) |
| 2022 | Northwestern (IA) | Joe Dolincheck (QB),Morningside (2) | Matt McCarty |
| 2023 | Keiser | Jalyn Gramstad (QB),Northwestern (IA) | Doug Socha |
| 2024 | Grand View (2) | Jackson Waring (QB),Grand View | Myles Russ |
| 2025 | | | |
