Movatterモバイル変換


[0]ホーム

URL:


Jump to content
WikipediaThe Free Encyclopedia
Search

Implied freedom of political communication

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Implied right within the Constitution of Australia


Constitution of Australia
Chapters of the Constitution
Text of the Constitution
The full text ofConstitution of Australia at Wikisource
flagAustralia portal

At the Federal level in Australia, there is no explicitly stated protection forfreedom of expression in legislation nor theAustralian Constitution.[Note 1][Note 2] Instead, the Constitution implies afreedom of political communication through an interpretation ofSection 7 andSection 24.[1] The principle was established by High Court rulings in 1992.[2][3][4]

The implied freedom of political communication serves as anegative right, since it restricts the legislative power of Commonwealth and State parliaments.[5]

TheMcCloy v New South Wales case refined a proportionality test, for assessing a law's compatibility with the implied freedom of political communication.[6]

Background

[edit]

TheConstitution of Australia contains no provision expressly guaranteeing freedom of speech, or most other rights comparable to theUnited States Bill of Rights. Many of the delegates to theconstitutional conventions considered that such protections were unnecessary or even insulting toward Australian parliaments, and in some cases were concerned that they would undermine existing laws discriminating againstracial minorities.[7]

In 1942,H. V. Evatt proposed an amendment to the Australian constitution to grant sweeping powers to the federal government for post-war reconstruction, which also would have enshrined theFour Freedoms, including freedom of speech. A pared back version of the amendment which would also only have effect for five years after the end of the war was put to areferendum in 1944. The campaign mostly focused on the powers to be granted to the federal government, and the referendum was defeated.[8]

Australian Constitutional Law expert, Professor Emerita Anne Twomey, presented the 1988 High Court caseDavis v Commonwealth – in which a law concerning slogans about Australia's bicentenary of European colonisation was partially invalidated due to impacts on freedom of expression – as an indirect precursor to the implied freedom of political communication.[9]

Court cases

[edit]

The following legal cases illustrate the extent to which the implied freedom of political communications does, and does not, apply.

Related High Court decisions

[edit]

The implied freedom of political communication can also be invoked by state supreme courts, allowing them to invalidate or uphold state legislation, as evidenced below.

RelatedNSW Supreme Court decisions

[edit]

RelatedSupreme Court of Victoria decision

[edit]

Notes

[edit]
  1. ^TheAustralian Capital Territory,Victoria andQueensland have passed human rights legislation which protects freedom of expression at the State level, but the protection may not be entrenched.
  2. ^State legislation, including human rights charters, can be overridden by Federal legislation, but subject to Section 51 and Section 109 of the Constitution.

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
  1. ^Griffiths, Leanne (January 2005)."The Implied Freedom of Political Communication: The State of the Law Post Coleman and Mulholland"(PDF).James Cook University Law Review.12:93–94.
  2. ^"Freedom of information, opinion and expression".Australian Human Rights Commission. Retrieved1 January 2026.
  3. ^Nationwide News Pty Ltd v Wills [1992] HCA 46 (30 September 1992)
  4. ^Australian Capital Television Pty Ltd v Commonwealth [1992] HCA 45 (30 September 1992)
  5. ^"Freedom of information, opinion and expression".Australian Human Rights Commission. 18 October 2025.
  6. ^McCloy v New South Wales [2015] HCA 34 (7 October 2015)
  7. ^La Nauze, John Andrew (1974).The making of the Australian constitution. Studies in Australian Federation (Reprinted ed.). Hong Kong: Melbourne University Press. pp. 227–232.ISBN 978-0-522-84016-2.
  8. ^Beck, Luke (2018).Religious Freedom and the Australian Constitution: Origins and Future. ICLARS Series on Law and Religion Ser. Milton: Routledge. pp. 130–142.ISBN 978-1-351-25775-6.
  9. ^Anne Twomey (31 December 2025)."Prohibiting political chants and slogans". Constitutional Clarion YouTube channel. Retrieved1 January 2026.
Legislative power
Executive power
Judicial power
Other institutions
Doctrines
Amendments
Constitutional texts
Other topics
By chapter
By section
Enumerated legislative
powers (Section 51)
Stub icon

This article related toAustralian law is astub. You can help Wikipedia byadding missing information.

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Implied_freedom_of_political_communication&oldid=1335512492"
Categories:
Hidden categories:

[8]ページ先頭

©2009-2026 Movatter.jp