Karl Rudolf Gerd von Rundstedt (12 December 1875 – 24 February 1953) was a GermanGeneralfeldmarschall (Field Marshal) in theHeer (Army) ofNazi Germany andOberbefehlshaber West (Commander-in-Chief in the West) duringWorld War II. At the end of the war, aged 69, with over 52 years of service, he was the Army's most senior officer.
He was dismissed after the Germandefeat in Normandy in July 1944 but was again recalled as Commander-in-Chief in the West in September, holding this post until his final dismissal byAdolf Hitler in March 1945. Though aware of the various plots to depose Hitler, Rundstedt neither supported nor reported them. He also served as chairman of theEhrenhof, a military committee discharging20 July plotters from the Wehrmacht, so that they could be tried andmurdered by theVolksgerichtshof, ashow trial.
After the war, he was charged withwar crimes, but did not face trial due to his age and poor health. He was released in 1949, and died in 1953.
Gerd von Rundstedt was born inAschersleben, north ofHalle inPrussian Saxony (now inSaxony-Anhalt). He was the eldest son of Gerd Arnold Konrad von Rundstedt, a cavalry officer who served in theFranco-Prussian War. The Rundstedts are an oldJunker family that traced its origins to the 12th century and classed as members of theUradel, or old nobility, although they held no titles and were not wealthy. Virtually all the Rundstedt men since the time ofFrederick the Great had served in thePrussian Army. Rundstedt's mother, Adelheid Fischer, was ofHuguenot (French Protestant) descent.[1] He was the eldest of four brothers, all of whom became Army officers. Rundstedt's education followed the path ordained for Prussian military families: the junior cadet college atDiez, nearKoblenz, then the military academy atLichterfelde in Berlin.[2]
Unable to meet the cost of joining a cavalry regiment,[3] Rundstedt joined the 83rd Infantry Regiment in March 1892 as a cadet officer (Portepee Fähnrich). The regiment was based atKassel inHesse-Kassel, which he came to regard as his home town and where he maintained a home until 1945. He undertook further training at the military college (Kriegsschule) atHannover, before being commissioned as a lieutenant in June 1893. He made a good impression on his superiors.[citation needed] In 1896 he was made regimental adjutant, and in 1903 he was sent to the prestigiousWar Academy (Kriegsakademie) in Berlin for a three-year staff officer training course. At the end of his course Rundstedt was described by his final report as "an outstandingly able officer ... well suited for the General Staff."[4] He married Luise "Bila" von Goetz in January 1902 and their only child, Hans Gerd von Rundstedt, was born in January 1903.
Rundstedt joined the General Staff of the German Army in April 1907 serving there until July 1914, when he was appointed chief of operations to the 22nd Reserve Infantry Division. This division was part of XI Corps, which in turn was part of GeneralAlexander von Kluck's First Army. In 1914 this Army was deployed along the Belgian border, in preparation for the invasion of Belgium and France, in accordance with the German plan for victory in the west known as theSchlieffen Plan.
Rundstedt served as 22nd Division's chief of staff during theinvasion of Belgium, but he saw no action since his Division was held in reserve during the initial advance. In December 1914, suffering from a lung ailment, he was promoted to Major and transferred to the military government ofAntwerp. In April 1915 his health recovered, and he was posted as chief of staff to the 86th Infantry Division which was serving as part of GeneralMax von Gallwitz's forces on theEastern Front. In September he was once again given an administrative post, as part of the military government of German-occupied Poland, based inWarsaw. He stayed in this post until November 1916, until he was promoted by being made chief of staff to an Army Corps, XXV Reserve Corps, which was fighting in theCarpathians. Here he saw much action against the Russians. In October 1917 he was appointed chief of staff to LIII Corps, in northern Poland. The following month, however, theOctober Revolution led to the collapse of the Russian armies and the end of the war on the eastern front. In August 1918 Rundstedt was transferred to the west, as chief of staff to XV Corps inAlsace, under GeneralFelix Graf von Bothmer. Here he remained until the end of the war in November. Bothmer described him as "a wholly excellent staff officer and amiable comrade." He was awarded theIron Cross, first class, and was recommended for thePour le Mérite, but did not receive it. He thus ended World War I, although still a major, with a high reputation as a staff officer.[5]
Rundstedt's Corps disintegrated in the wake of defeat and theGerman Revolution, but while most officers were demobilised, he remained in the Army, apparently at the request of GeneralWilhelm Groener, who assumed leadership of the shattered Army. He briefly rejoined the General Staff, but this was abolished under the terms of theTreaty of Versailles, signed in June 1919. In October, Rundstedt was posted to the staff of Military District (Wehrkreis) V, based inStuttgart, under General Walter von Bergmann. He was there when the attempted military coup known as theKapp Putsch took place in March 1920. Bergmann and Rundstedt, like most of the Army leadership, refused to support the coup attempt: Rundstedt later described it as "a failure and a very stupid one at that."[6] This was not an indication of any fondness for theWeimar Republic on Rundstedt's part – he remained a monarchist.[7] It was a reflection of his view that Army officers should not interfere in politics, and should support the government of the day, whatever its nature: a view he was to hold firmly to throughout his career. He testified at theNuremberg trials in 1946: "We generals did not concern ourselves with politics. We did not take part in any political discussions, and we did not hold any political discussions among ourselves."[8]
Rundstedt rose steadily in the small 100,000-man army (theReichswehr) allowed to Germany by the Versailles Treaty. In May 1920 he was made chief of staff to the 3rd Cavalry Division, based inWeimar, thus achieving his early ambition of being a cavalry commander. He was promoted to lieutenant-colonel (Oberstleutnant) in 1920, and to full colonel in 1923, when he was transferred toWehrkreis II, based inStettin. In 1926 he was made chief of staff to Group Command (Gruppenkommando) 2, which covered the whole of western Germany and was based inKassel, and promoted to major general (Generalmajor). In 1928 Rundstedt finally left staff positions behind him and was made commander of the 2nd Cavalry Division, based inBreslau. This was considered a front-line posting, given Germany's tense relations withPoland and the fact that Poland at this time had a much bigger army than Germany.
In January 1932, Rundstedt was appointed commander ofWehrkreis III, based inBerlin, and also given command of the3rd Infantry Division. This brought him, at 57, into the highest ranks of the German Army, reflected in his promotion to Lieutenant General (Generalleutnant). It also inevitably brought him into close contact with the political world, which was in a disturbed state due to theGreat Depression and subsequent rise of Hitler'sNazi Party. The Defence Minister, GeneralKurt von Schleicher, was scheming to bring the Nazis into the government, and the Chancellor,Franz von Papen, was planning to overthrow theSocial Democrat government of Prussia, Germany's largest state. Despite his dislike of politics, Rundstedt could not remain uninvolved in these matters. In July 1932 Papen used his emergency powers to dismiss the Prussian Government. Martial law was briefly declared in Berlin and Rundstedt was made martial law plenipotentiary. He protested to Papen about this and martial law was lifted after a few days. In October Rundstedt was promoted to full General and given command ofGruppenkommando 1, covering the whole of eastern Germany.
In January 1933 Hitler became chancellor, and within a few months, dictator. The Defence Minister, GeneralWerner von Blomberg, ensured that the Army remained loyal to the new regime. In February he arranged for Hitler to meet with senior generals, including Rundstedt. Hitler assured the generals that he favoured a strong Army and that there would be no interference with its internal affairs. Rundstedt was satisfied with this, but made it clear in private conversations that he did not like the Nazi regime. He also said, however, that he would do nothing to oppose it.[9] In 1934, when GeneralKurt Freiherr von Hammerstein-Equord resigned as chief of staff, Hitler wished to appoint GeneralWalther von Reichenau to succeed him. Rundstedt led a group of senior officers in opposing the appointment, on the grounds that Reichenau was too openly a supporter of the regime. Hitler and Blomberg backed down and GeneralWerner Freiherr von Fritsch was appointed instead. When Fritsch was forced to resign in 1938, Rundstedt again blocked Reichenau's appointment, and the post went to GeneralWalther von Brauchitsch.[10]
Like most of the Army, Rundstedt feared the growing power of theSturmabteilung (SA) and was relievedwhen it was purged, although he and many others were angered that two generals, Schleicher andvon Bredow, were killed. He was among the senior officers who later persuaded Hitler to have these two officers posthumously (but secretly) rehabilitated. Some sources also claim he was among those senior officers who demandedcourts-martial for those responsible for the murders, although Rundstedt didn't testify to that at Nuremberg. The Army was uncomfortable with the purge but Rundstedt, and the rest of the Army, still took the personal oath of loyalty to Hitler that Blomberg introduced.[11] Rundstedt also supported the regime's plans for rearmament, culminating in the denunciation of the Treaty of Versailles in 1935, which was followed by the reintroduction of conscription. By 1935, when he turned 60, Rundstedt was the senior officer of the German Army in terms of service, and second only to Blomberg in rank. Recognising his status, Hitler cultivated him, appointing him as Germany's representative at the funeral ofKing George V in January 1936.
Given his prestige, Rundstedt was a central figure in theBlomberg–Fritsch Affair which engulfed the German Army in early 1938. This was a political manoeuvre by senior NazisHermann Göring andHeinrich Himmler to strengthen their positions within the Nazi regime at the expense of the military leadership. Together they forced the resignation of both Blomberg and Fritsch, the former under threat of blackmail because of his second wife's dubious past, and the latter on fabricated charges of homosexuality. On 31 January, Rundstedt and the Army Chief of Staff, GeneralLudwig Beck, representing the officer corps, had an angry meeting with Hitler.[12] Rundstedt agreed that Blomberg had disgraced himself and demanded that he be court-martialled, which Hitler refused. On the other hand, he defended Fritsch, correctly accusing Himmler of having fabricated the allegations against him. He insisted that Fritsch have the right to defend himself before a Court of Honour, which Hitler reluctantly agreed to. Beck promoted Rundstedt as Fritsch's successor, but Rundstedt declined, and the post went to Brauchitsch. At Beck's urging, Fritsch challenged Himmler to a duel, but Rundstedt (as senior officer of the Army) declined to pass on Fritsch's letter.[13][a]
During 1938 and 1939 Beck and other senior officers were hatching plots to remove Hitler from power if he provoked a new war with Britain and France overCzechoslovakia or Poland, a war they were convinced Germany would lose. Rundstedt was aware of these plots, and Beck tried to recruit him to the plotters' ranks, knowing of his disdain for the Nazi regime. But Rundstedt stuck firmly to his position that officers should not be involved in politics, no matter how grave the issues at stake. On the other hand, he did not report these approaches to Hitler or theGestapo, then or later. From a purely military point of view, Rundstedt was apprehensive about Hitler's plans to attack Czechoslovakia, since he believed that Britain and France would intervene and Germany would be defeated.[14] Brauchitsch lacked the courage to oppose Hitler directly, but agreed to Beck's request for a meeting of senior commanders. At the meeting widespread opposition to Hitler's plans to coerce Czechoslovakia over theSudetenland issue was expressed. Beck urged the officers to oppose Hitler's plans openly, but Rundstedt, while agreeing about the dangers of war before Germany was fully re-armed, would not support him, but declared himself unwilling to provoke a new crisis between Hitler and the Army.[15] He advised Brauchitsch not to confront Hitler, apparently afraid that Brauchitsch would be dismissed and replaced by Reichenau.[16] When Hitler heard about the meeting, Beck was forced to resign. Even after this, two of Rundstedt's friends, GeneralsErwin von Witzleben andErich Hoepner, remained involved in anti-Hitler plots and continued to try to recruit him.[17]
In November 1938, shortly after his division had taken part in the bloodless occupation of the Sudetenland, Rundstedt retired from the Army with the rank of Colonel-General (Generaloberst), second only to the rank of Field Marshal. It was suggested that Hitler had forced him out, either because of his opposition to the plan to invade Czechoslovakia or because of his support for Fritsch,[18] but this seems not be the case: he had in fact asked permission to retire some time earlier.[19] Just short of his 63rd birthday, he was not in good health and missed his family – he was now a grandfather. Moreover, despite their recent confrontations, he remained on good terms with Hitler, who made him honorary colonel (Chef) of his old regiment on his retirement. Rundstedt also agreed that in the event of war he would return to active service.[20]
Rundstedt's retirement did not last long. By early 1939 Hitler had decided to force a confrontation with Poland over thePolish Corridor, and planning for a war with Poland began. In May, Hitler approved Rundstedt's appointment as commander of Army Group South, to invade Poland fromSilesia andSlovakia. His chief of staff was GeneralErich von Manstein, his chief of operations ColonelGünther Blumentritt. His principal field commanders would be (from west to east as they entered Poland) GeneralJohannes Blaskowitz (8th Army), GeneralWalther von Reichenau (10th Army), and GeneralWilhelm List (14th Army).[citation needed]
Rundstedt's armies advanced rapidly into southern Poland, capturingKraków on 6 September, but Reichenau's over-ambitious attempt to takeWarsaw by storm on 9 September was repelled. Soon after, Blaskowitz's exposed northern flank was attacked by the PolishPoznań Army, leading to the major engagement of the Polish campaign, theBattle of the Bzura. Rundstedt and Manstein travelled to Blaskowitz's headquarters to take charge, and by 11 September the Poles had been contained in a pocket aroundKutno. By 18 September the Poznan Army had been destroyed, and Warsaw was besieged. Reichenau's forces tookLublin on 11 September, while List's army was advancing to the east towardsLvov, where they eventually linked up with Soviet forces advancing from the east under the terms of theMolotov–Ribbentrop Pact. Warsaw surrendered on 28 September, and by 6 October fighting in southern Poland had ceased.
From the first days of the invasion, there had been incidents of German troops shooting Polish soldiers after they had surrendered, and killing civilians, especiallyPolish Jews. Some of these incidents were the work of units of theSS-VT, forerunner of theWaffen-SS, but some involved regular Army units.[21] Rundstedt's biographer says: "There is certainly no evidence that Rundstedt ever condoned, let alone encouraged, these acts."[22] Rundstedt told Reichenau that such actions did not have his authorisation.[21] In fact, both Rundstedt and Blaskowitz complained to the chief of staff, GeneralFranz Halder, about the Army Command's apparent tolerance of such incidents. Nevertheless, as commander of Army Group South, Rundstedt was legally responsible for the behaviour of his troops, and these incidents later formed part of the charges ofwar crimes against him.
Behind the Army came SSEinsatzgruppen (task forces) commanded byTheodor Eicke, who began systematically executing Jews and members of the Polish educated classes.[23] OneEinsatzgruppe commanded byUdo von Woyrsch operated in 14th Army's area. AtDynów Woyrsch's men herded the town's Jews into thesynagogue then burned it down. By 20 September, over 500 Jews had been killed.[24] In 1939, this was still too much for most German Army officers to stand. After complaints from numerous officers, Rundstedt banned Woyrsch's units from the area, but after his departure his order was rescinded.[25] On 20 October Rundstedt resigned his command and was transferred to the western front.[b]
On 25 October, Rundstedt took up his new post as commander of Army Group A, facing the French border in theArdennes mountains sector, and based inKoblenz. To his northArmy Group B under GeneralFedor von Bock faced the Dutch and Belgian borders, while to his southArmy Group C under GeneralWilhelm Ritter von Leeb faced the French along theMaginot Line. Manstein was again his chief of staff and Blumentritt his chief of operations, although Manstein soon departed to command an infantry corps and was replaced by GeneralGeorg von Sodenstern. Rundstedt's main field commanders (from north to south) were Blaskowitz (9th Army), List (12th Army) and GeneralErnst Busch (16th Army).[27]
Hitler's original plan was to attack in late November, before the French and British had time fully to deploy along their front. The plan, devised by Hitler, was essentially for a re-run of the invasion of 1914, with the main assault to come in the north, through Belgium and the Netherlands, then wheeling south to capture Paris, leaving the French Army anchored on the Maginot Line. Most senior officers were opposed to both the timing and the plan. Rundstedt, Manstein, Reichenau (commanding 6th Army in Army Group B), List and Brauchitsch remonstrated with Hitler in a series of meetings in October and November. They were opposed to an offensive so close to the onset of winter, and they were opposed to launching the main attack through Belgium, where the many rivers and canals would hamper armoured operations. Manstein in particular, supported by Rundstedt, argued for an armoured assault by Army Group A, across the Ardennes to the sea, cutting the British and French off in Belgium. This "Manstein Plan" was the genesis of theblitzkrieg of May 1940.
A combination of bad weather, the arguments of his generals, and a breach of security when the details of the original plan fell into Allied hands, eventually led Hitler to agree to postpone the attack until early 1940, when it was again delayed by theinvasion of Denmark and Norway. In February, Hitler finally accepted the Manstein Plan. GeneralGünther von Kluge's 4th Army and GeneralMaximilian Reichsfreiherr von Weichs's 2nd Army were transferred from Army Group B to Rundstedt's command. GeneralEwald von Kleist was now to commandPanzer (Armoured) Group Kleist, consisting of three armoured corps, led byHeinz Guderian,Georg-Hans Reinhardt andGustav Anton von Wietersheim. These armoured corps were to be the spearhead of the German thrust into France. Although Manstein is often credited for the change of plans, he himself acknowledged Rundstedt's decisive role. "I would stress that my commander, Colonel-General von Rundstedt, agreed with my view throughout, and backed our recommendations to the full. Without his sanction we could never have kept up our attempts to changeOKW's mind."[28]
During this hiatus, the group of senior officers who were plotting against Hitler's war plans, led by Halder, renewed their efforts, convinced that an attack in the west would lead to a war which Germany would lose. Brauchitsch agreed with Halder's fears, but continued to vacillate about opposing Hitler – he asked Reichenau and Rundstedt to remonstrate with Hitler, but they refused.[29] Witzleben suggested that Rundstedt, Leeb and Bock should jointly refuse to carry out Hitler's orders to carry out the attack. Two of the conspirators,Abwehr officersHans Oster andHans Bernd Gisevius, discussed this with Leeb, who turned them down but did not report them.[30] On 13 March, Himmler came to Koblenz to give the generals, including Rundstedt, an ideological lecture, in the course of which he made it clear that the atrocities against civilians which some of them had witnessed in Poland had been carried out on his orders, and with the approval of Hitler. "I do nothing that the Führer does not know", he said.[31]
The attack was finally launched on 10 May. By 14 May, armoured units underHermann Hoth and Guderian had crossed theMeuse and had broken open the Allied front. As planned, the British and French had advanced into Belgium to meet Bock's offensive, and were in danger of being cut off there by a German thrust to the sea. Both Hitler and Rundstedt had doubts about the safety of allowing the armoured corps to get too far ahead of their infantry support, however. Hitler sent the chief of staff of theArmed Forces Supreme Command (Oberkommando der Wehrmacht, OKW), GeneralWilhelm Keitel, to Rundstedt's headquarters, to urge caution. In Halder's words, Hitler was "frightened by his own success ... afraid to take any chance."[32] Guderian objected vehemently to being ordered to halt, and Rundstedt was forced to mediate between Hitler and his impetuous armoured commanders, who were backed by Halder. By 20 May, Guderian's tanks had reached the sea to the west ofAbbeville and closed the trap on the British and French, who were already in retreat to theEnglish Channel ports.
By this time, however, Kleist's armoured forces were thinly stretched and had suffered losses of up to 50% of their tanks.[33] Kleist asked Rundstedt for a pause while the armoured units recovered and the infantry caught up, and Rundstedt agreed to this. At the same time, Göring attempted to persuade Hitler that theLuftwaffe could destroy the trapped Allied armies, freeing the German forces to turn south towards Paris. Hitler accepted this view, and on 24 May issued what became known as theHalt Order, preventing the German armour from rapidly capturingCalais andDunkirk. The Luftwaffe were unable to destroy the Allied armies, however, and the halt allowed theBritish Expeditionary Force and many French troops to beevacuated from Dunkirk. This decision, for which Hitler, Rundstedt and Kleist shared responsibility, proved very costly to Germany's war effort in the long term. After the war, Rundstedt described the Halt Order as "an incredible blunder" and assigned full blame to Hitler. His biographer concedes that this "does not represent the whole truth", because the original impetus for a pause came from Kleist and Rundstedt himself.[34]
Attention then turned to the attack on the French armies to the south. On 29 May, Hitler came to Rundstedt's headquarters atCharleville-Mézières to discuss the new offensive. Bock's Army Group B on the right was to advance on Paris, while Rundstedt's Army Group A, now consisting only of List's 12th Army, Weichs's 2nd Army and Busch's 16th Army, was to attack towardsSoissons andRheims. Rundstedt's attack began on 9 June, and within a few days had broken the French resistance. By 12 June, his forces were across theMarne and advancing south-east towardsAlsace.Dijon fell on 16 June andLyon on 20 June. By this time French resistance was crumbling and on 22 June the French requested an armistice. In July, Hitler announced that Rundstedt and a number of other field commanders were to be promoted to the rank of Field Marshal (Generalfeldmarschall) during the1940 Field Marshal Ceremony. Although Rundstedt wished to resume his retirement, he was persuaded by Hitler to stay in France and set up headquarters atSaint-Germain-en-Laye about 20 km (12 mi) outside Paris. There he oversaw the planning for the proposed invasion of Britain,Operation Sealion, but never took the prospects for this operation seriously, and was not surprised when Hitler called it off in September after the Luftwaffe's setback in theBattle of Britain. Even then, Rundstedt was not to be allowed to retire, when in October Hitler appointed him Commander-in-Chief West (Oberbefehlshaber West, or OB West).[35]
By July 1940 Hitler was turning his mind to the invasion of theSoviet Union, commissioning GeneralErich Marcks to prepare preliminary plans.[36] Although the Hitler-Stalin pact had served Germany's interests well, both strategically and economically, his whole career had been based on anti-communism and the belief that "Jewish Bolshevism" was the main threat to Germany and theAryan race.[37][38] In December Hitler made a firm decision for an attack on the Soviets the following spring, codenamedOperation Barbarossa. At this point Rundstedt learned that he was to give up his quiet life in occupied France and assume command of Army Group South, tasked with the conquest of Ukraine. Leeb would command in the north, heading forLeningrad, and Bock in the centre, charged with capturingMoscow. On the way, the three army groups were to encircle and destroy theRed Army before it could retreat into the Russian interior.[39]
Rundstedt, like most German officers, had favoured the policy of good relations with the Soviets followed by theReichswehr commander GeneralHans von Seekt during the Weimar Republic years, when the Soviet connection was seen as a counter to the threat from Poland. He was also apprehensive about launching a new war in the east while Britain was undefeated.[40] If so, he did nothing to oppose them, and in this he was in company even with officers who disliked and opposed Hitler's regime, such as Halder, who threw themselves into planning the invasion, and believed it would succeed. Even the most experienced officers shared Hitler's contempt for the Soviet state and army. "You have only to kick in the door," Hitler told Rundstedt, "and the whole rotten structure will come crashing down."[41]
In March Rundstedt left Paris to set up Army Group South's headquarters inBreslau. On the way he attended a conference in Berlin at which Hitler addressed senior officers. He made it clear that the ordinary rules of warfare would not apply to the Russian campaign. "This is a war of extermination", he told them. "We do not wage war to preserve the enemy."[42][c] This gave the generals a clear warning that they would be expected not to obstruct Hitler's wider war aims in the east – the extermination of the Jews and the reduction of the Slavic peoples to serfdom under a newHerrenvolk (Master race) of German settlers. As part of this strategy, theCommissar Order was issued, which stated that all Red Armycommissars were to be executed when captured.[43] Rundstedt testified at Nuremberg about the attitude of the Army to this Order: "Our attitude was unanimously and absolutely against it. Immediately after the conference we approached Brauchitsch and told him that this was impossible ... The order was simply not carried out."[8] This latter statement was clearly untrue, as the Commissar Order was widely carried out.[44] But whether Rundstedt knew this was another matter, and this question was later to figure prominently in the issue of whether to charge him with war crimes.[45]
Barbarossa was initially scheduled for May, at the beginning of the Russian spring, but was postponed until June because unseasonably wet weather made the roads impassable for armour (not because of the German invasion of Yugoslavia and Greece in April, as is commonly supposed).[46] Rundstedt moved his headquarters toTarnów in south-eastern Poland. Since the dividing line betweenArmy Group Centre and Army Group South was just south ofBrest-Litovsk, he was in command of more than half of the total German-Soviet front. Sodenstern was again his chief of staff. Under his command were (from north to south) Reichenau (6th Army), Kleist (1st Panzer Army) and GeneralCarl-Heinrich von Stülpnagel (17th Army). These three armies, bunched between Lublin and the Carpathians, were to thrust south-eastwards into Ukraine, aiming to captureKiev and encircle and destroy the Soviet forces west of theDnieper. In the south, GeneralEugen Ritter von Schobert (11th Army), supported by the Hungarian and Romanian armies, and also an Italian Army Corps, was to advance intoBessarabia (nowMoldova) and the southern Ukraine. It's unlikely that Rundstedt thought a decisive victory was possible at this point; while saying farewell to the commander of Army Group North in early May, he remarked: "See you again in Siberia."[47]
The attack began on 22 June. Despite ample warning from intelligence sources and defectors,Joseph Stalin and the Soviet Command were caught by surprise, and the Germans rapidly broke through the frontier defences, helped by their total command of the air.[48][49] But the Soviet commander in northern Ukraine, Colonel-GeneralMikhail Kirponos, was one of the better Soviet generals, and he commanded the Red Army's largest and best-equipped force: nearly a million men and 4,800 tanks.[50] The Germans soon encountered stubborn resistance. Rundstedt testified at Nuremberg: "The resistance at the frontier was not too great, but it grew continually as we advanced into the interior of the country. Very strong tank forces, tanks of a better type, far superior to ours, appeared."[8] The Soviet tank armies were in fact stronger than the German panzer divisions, and in theT-34 they possessed a superior tank: Kleist called it "the finest tank in the world."[51][page needed] Rundstedt said after the war: "I realised soon after the attack that everything that had been written about Russia was wrong."[52] But at this stage of the war the Red Army tank commanders lacked the tactical skill and experience of the German panzer commanders, and after ten days of bitter fighting Kleist's armour broke through, reachingZhitomir, only 130 km from Kiev, on 12 July. By 30 July the Red Army in Ukraine was in full retreat.[53] Rundstedt and his commanders were confident that they could seize Kiev "off the march," that is, without a prolonged siege.[54]
Despite these successes, the campaign did not go according to plan.[55] The front door was "kicked in", but the Red Army was not destroyed, and the Soviet state did not collapse. Once this became apparent, at the end of July, Hitler and his commanders had to decide how to proceed. Hitler ordered Army Group Centre to pause atSmolensk, while the panzer divisions were shipped to the north and the south.[56][d]
Although Rundstedt opposed this diversion of forces, he was its beneficiary as attention was shifted to the southern front. He also benefited from disastrous decisions made by the Soviets. On 10 July Stalin appointed his old crony MarshalSemyon Budyonny commander in Ukraine, with orders to stop the German advance at all costs. Budyonny ordered Kirponos to push his forces forwards to Kiev andUman, despite the danger of encirclement, rather than withdraw and make a stand on the Dnieper. Rundstedt therefore decided to break off the advance towards Kiev, and to direct Kleist's armour south-eastwards, towardsKrivoy Rog. By 30 July the Germans were atKirovograd, 130 km east of Uman, cutting off the Soviet line of retreat (which had in any case been forbidden by Stalin). Meanwhile, Schobert's 11th Army was advancing north-eastwards from Bessarabia. On 2 August the two armies met, trapping over 100,000 Soviet troops, virtually all of whom were killed or captured. Southern Ukraine was thus left virtually defenceless, and by 25 August, when they enteredDniepropetrovsk, the Germans had occupied everything west of the Dnieper (exceptOdessa, which held out until October). Nevertheless, this had all taken longer than expected, and the Red Army was showing no signs of collapse. Rundstedt wrote to his wife on 12 August: "How much longer? I have no great hope that it will be soon. The distances in Russia devour us."[57][e]
Neither the success at Uman nor what followed at Kiev would have happened had Rundstedt not backed his subordinates and resisted Hitler's interference in the conduct of the campaign. As during the French campaign, Hitler was panicked by his own success. By early July he was full of anxiety that the German armour was advancing too quickly, without infantry support, and that it was exposed to Soviet counter-attacks. On 10 July Brauchitsch arrived at Rundstedt's headquarters atBrody, with instructions from Hitler that Kleist was to turn south towardsVinnitsa and link up with Schobert's army there, rather than continue south-east to Kirovograd. This would still have trapped many Soviet divisions, but it would have allowed the mass of Soviet forces at Uman and Kiev to escape. Rundstedt defended Kleist's ability to execute the larger encirclement, and persuaded Brauchitsch that he was right. Brauchitsch then contacted Halder, who succeeded in persuading Hitler to support Rundstedt. This was a sign that Rundstedt still had Hitler's respect, as were Hitler's two visits to Rundstedt's armies during this period.[58][59]
After Uman Budyonny's forces massed around Kiev – over 700,000 men – were left dangerously exposed, with Kleist's 1st Panzer Army regrouping to the south-east and GeneralHeinz Guderian's 2nd Panzer Army (part of Army Group Centre) smashing GeneralYeromenko's Briansk Front and advancing south fromGomel inWhite Russia, on a line well east of Kiev. The danger of encirclement was obvious, but Stalin stubbornly refused to consider withdrawal, despite warnings from both Budyonny and Kirponos that catastrophe was imminent. Budyonny has been freely blamed by postwar writers for the disaster at Kiev, but it is clear that while he was out of his depth as a front commander, he warned Stalin of the danger, and was dismissed for his pains.[60] On 12 September Kleist crossed the Dnieper atCherkasy heading north-east, and on 16 September his tanks linked up with Guderian's atLokhvitsa, nearly 200 km east of Kiev. Although many Soviet troops were able to escape eastwards in small groups, around 600,000 men – four whole armies comprising 43 divisions, nearly one-third of the Soviet Army's strength at the start of the war – were killed or captured, and the great majority of those captured died in captivity.[61] Kiev fell on 19 September. Kirponos was killed in action on 20 September, shortly before resistance ceased.
Rundstedt had thus presided over one of thegreatest victories in the history of warfare. But this catastrophe for the Red Army resulted far more from the inflexibility of Stalin than it did from the talents of Rundstedt as a commander or the skill of the German Army.David Stahel, a recent historian of the Kiev campaign, wrote: "Germany had been handed a triumph far in excess of what its exhausted armoured forces could have achieved without Stalin's obduracy and incompetence."[62] In fact both the German Army and the Red Army were driven more by the dictates of their respective political masters rather than by the decisions of the military professionals. Stahel sums the situation up with his chapter heading: "Subordinating the generals: the dictators dictate."[63] Kirponos could have withdrawn most of his army across the Dnieper in time had Stalin allowed him to do so, and Rundstedt himself acknowledged this.[64] Had this happened, Rundstedt's forces would have been in no state to give chase: they were exhausted after two months of ceaseless combat. Despite their successes, they had sustained high levels of casualties and even higher levels of loss of equipment, both of which were impossible to replace. By September the German Army in the Soviet Union had suffered nearly 500,000 casualties.[65][f] In a statement to the Army on 15 August, Rundstedt acknowledged: "It is only natural that such great effort would result in fatigue, the combat strength of the troops has weakened and in many places there is a desire for rest." But, said Rundstedt: "We must keep pressure on the enemy for he has many more reserves than we."[66] This was a remarkable admission so early in the Russian campaign, and it showed that Rundstedt was already well aware of how unrealistic the German belief in a quick victory had been.
Despite the monumental efforts and initial successes ofOperation Barbarossa, by late 1941, the German advance began to falter significantly. Rundstedt’s forces, along with the rest of theWehrmacht, faced an increasingly dire situation as they pushed deeper into Soviet territory. The logistical nightmare became more pronounced, with supply lines overextended and insufficient resources to maintain the pace of the advance. The harsh Russian winter arrived earlier than expected, bringing with it temperatures that plummeted to unprecedented lows, wreaking havoc on both men and machinery. German troops, unprepared for such extreme conditions, suffered from frostbite and hypothermia, severely impacting their combat effectiveness. Equipment and vehicles, not designed for sub-zero temperatures, frequently malfunctioned or were rendered inoperable. TheRed Army, though battered, began to regroup and launch counteroffensives, exploiting the Germans' weakened state. Rundstedt, aware of the grim reality, acknowledged the growing resilience and capability of the Soviet forces. The campaign that was envisioned as a quick, decisive victory was now evolving into a drawn-out war of attrition, with the Germans struggling to maintain their foothold against a resurgent and determined enemy. This shift marked the beginning of a protracted and brutal conflict that would eventually drain the German war effort and contribute to the ultimate downfall of theThird Reich.
1941 pencil postcard sent from Gerd von Rundstedt to his wife from the Front.
Despite the triumph at Kiev, by the end of September Rundstedt was becoming concerned about the state of his command. After three months of continuous fighting, the German armies were exhausted, and the Panzer divisions were in urgent need of new equipment as a result of losses in battle and damage from the poorly-paved Ukrainian roads. As autumn set in, the weather deteriorated, making the situation worse.[67] Rundstedt wanted to halt on the Dnieper for the winter, which would allow the German Army time to rest and be re-equipped.[68] But the German armies could not rest, for fear the Soviet southern armies (now commanded by the stubborn MarshalSemyon Timoshenko) would regroup and consolidate a front on theDonets or theDon.[69] So, soon after the fall of Kiev, the offensive was resumed. Reichenau advanced east towardsKharkov and Kleist and Stülpnagel headed south-east towards the lower Donets. In the south 11th Army and the Romanians (commanded by Manstein following the death of Schobert) advanced along theSea of Azov coast towardsRostov.
The Soviet armies were in a poor state after the catastrophes of Uman and Kiev, and could offer only sporadic resistance, but the German advance was slowed by the autumn rains and the Sovietscorched earth policy, which denied the Germans food and fuel and forced them to rely on overstretched lines of supply. Rundstedt's armies were also weakened by the transfer of units back to Army Group Centre to take part in the attack on Moscow (Operation Typhoon).[67] Reichenau did nottake Kharkov until 24 October. Nevertheless, during October Rundstedt's forces won another great victory when Manstein and Kleist's tanks reached the Sea of Azov, trapping two Soviet Armies aroundMariupol and taking over 100,000 prisoners.[70] This victory enabled Manstein to undertake theconquest of the Crimea (apart from the fortress city ofSevastopol) against only weak opposition, while Kleist advanced towards Rostov.[71] Despite these defeats, the Red Army was able to fall back on the Don in reasonably good order, and also to evacuate many of the industrial plants of theDonbass.
On 3 November Brauchitsch visited Rundstedt's headquarters atPoltava, where Rundstedt told him that the armies must halt and dig in for the winter. But Hitler drove his commanders on, insisting on an advance to theVolga and into theNorth Caucasus, to seize the oilfields atMaikop. These demands put Rundstedt under severe strain. The Germans were more than 300 km from Maikop and 500 km from the Volga atStalingrad. On the other hand, they were over 1,000 km from their starting point in eastern Poland, and even further from their supply bases in Germany. The Russian winter set in with full force in mid-November. The Germans were short of food, fuel, ammunition, vehicles, spare parts and winter clothing.Partisan activity was growing in their rear areas, threatening their supplies. Rundstedt was now 65 and not in good health – he was a heavy smoker, and in October in Poltava he suffered a mild heart attack.[72] He increasingly resorted to drink to cope with the strain.[73] He was now in the position of having to launch a new offensive against his better judgement, with exhausted troops in very adverse conditions. This was a recipe for defeat, but Rundstedt obeyed Hitler's orders.
Kleist, his units reinforced by Waffen-SS GeneralSepp Dietrich's1st SS Division (theLeibstandarte Adolf Hitler), attacked on 17 November, andcaptured Rostov on the 21st. But the Soviets had had time to prepare, and launched a counter-offensive on the 25th. On the 28th Rundstedt authorised Kleist to withdraw from Rostov and establish a front on theMius, 70 km to the west. When Hitler heard of this the next day, he ordered that Rostov should be held, although it had in fact already been evacuated. Rundstedt replied by insisting on his decision, and adding: "Should confidence in my leadership no longer exist, I beg to request someone be substituted who enjoys the necessary confidence of theSupreme Command."[74] Hitler took Rundstedt at his word, and on 1 December he dismissed him, replacing him with Reichenau.[g] The new commander saw at once that Rundstedt was right, and succeeded in persuading Hitler, viaHalder, to authorise the withdrawal. This was the first significant defeat the German Army suffered in World War II, and Rundstedt was the first senior commander to be dismissed.[75]
Hitler, however, immediately realised that he had gone too far in arbitrarily sacking the most senior commander of the German Army. He arrived in Poltava on 3 December, where he found both Reichenau andSepp Dietrich firm in defending the correctness of Rundstedt's actions. Sodenstern explained the full circumstances of the retreat from Rostov to Hitler, an explanation which Hitler grudgingly accepted. Hitler then met with Rundstedt and excused himself on the grounds that it had all been a misunderstanding. He suggested that Rundstedt take a period of leave, "and then once more place your incomparable services at my disposal." On 5 December, his honour restored, Rundstedt left Poltava, never to return to the Russian front.[76]
Shortly after his return toKassel, on his 66th birthday, Rundstedt received a cheque from Hitler for 250,000 Reichsmarks.[h] This was part ofHitler's policy of buying the continuing loyalty of his senior commanders. Many found this offensive, but none turned down these gifts. Rundstedt tried to do the next best thing by failing to cash the cheque. By February this was attracting adverse comment in Berlin, and Rundstedt then cashed it. Some writers have sought to connect Rundstedt's acceptance of this money with his continuing refusal to support the resistance movement against Hitler's regime within the German Army.[78] In fact Rundstedt refused to have anything to do with the money, handing it over to his daughter-in-law, and it was still untouched at his death in 1953.[i]
In April 1941, during the planning phase of Barbarossa, Himmler and Brauchitsch had agreed that as the Army conquered Soviet territory, it would be handed over at once to the SS and the German Police, now fused under Himmler's leadership in theHSSPF (Higher SS and Police Leadership).[80][81][page needed] Himmler set up fourEinsatzgruppen under the overall command ofReinhard Heydrich. In Rundstedt's area of command,Einsatzgruppe C, commanded byOtto Rasch, operated in northern Ukraine, andEinsatzgruppe D, commanded byOtto Ohlendorf, operated in southern Ukraine.
TheEinsatzgruppen were initially ordered to establish "security" in the rear areas by killing communists and partisans, but by 1941 the identity between Jews and communism was strongly established in the minds of most SS men and Police officers. In July Himmler told an SS gathering: "This nation [Russia] has been united by the Jews in a religion, a world-view, called Bolshevism."[82] From the beginning, therefore, theEinsatzgruppen mostly killed Jews: initially only adult males, but after a few months indiscriminately. By December 1941, when Rundstedt was dismissed as commander of Army Group South,Einsatzgruppen C and D had killed between 100,000 and 150,000 people. In addition, various units participated in killing 33,000 Kiev Jews atBabi Yar in September 1941, only days after the city was occupied by the Army.
The Army didparticipate directly in these mass killings: officers of Reichenau's 6th Army took part in organising the massacre at Babi Yar.[83] On 10 October he issued an order (known as the "Reichenau Order") headedConduct of the Troops in the East, in which he said: "The primary goal of the campaign against the Jewish-Bolshevist system is the absolute destruction of the means of power and the eradication of the Asian influence in the European cultural sphere ... Therefore, the soldier must have full understanding of the necessity of hard but just atonement of Jewish subhumanity [Untermenschentum]."[84][85][j] Two days later Rundstedt circulated it to all his senior commanders, with the comment: "I thoroughly concur with its contents." He urged them to release their own versions and to impress upon their troops the need to exterminate the Jews.[87][84]
Since Reichenau's order was widely understood as endorsing the mass killings of Ukrainian Jews which were going on behind the German lines, with which 6th Army at any rate was actively co-operating, Rundstedt's open endorsement of its strongly anti-Semitic language clearly contradicts his later assertions that he did not know what theEinsatzgruppen were doing. He told interrogators in 1946 that he was aware of just one atrocity, atBerdichev on 30 July.[88] At Nuremberg he sought to portray the issue in terms ofanti-partisan warfare: "Disorderly, irregular warfare behind the front of the Army must bring very great misery to the population of the country affected. No army in the world can tolerate such conditions for any length of time, but in the interests of the security and protection of its own troops it must take sharp, energetic measures. But this should, of course, be done in a correct and soldierly manner."[89] Rundstedt shared the general German Army prejudice against theOstjuden (Eastern Jews) found in the Soviet Union. He describedZamość as "a dirty Jewish hole."[90]
In September 1941 Rundstedt issued an order that soldiers were not to participate in or take photos of "Jewish operations",[91][92] indicating awareness of their existence. The killings took place with the knowledge and support of the German Army in the east.[93]
Under Rundstedt's command, Army Group South actively participated in the policies outlined in theHunger Plan, the Nazi racial starvation policy, by "living off the land" and denying food supplies to Soviet prisoners of war and civilians. German troops "plundered huge quantities of livestock, grain and dairy produce", enough to feed themselves and to create substantial reserves for the Reich. However, due to transportation problems, the supplies could not be shipped to Germany and much of them spoiled during the winter of 1941/1942. As a consequence, mass starvation set in within urban areas, especially in Kiev and Kharkov.[94]
In March 1942 Hitler re-appointed Rundstedt OB West, in succession to Witzleben, who was ill. He returned to the comfortable headquarters in the Hotel Pavillon Henri IV in Saint-Germain, which he had occupied in 1940–41. Rundstedt's command of French and his good relationship with the head of the collaborationistVichy regime, MarshalPhilippe Pétain,[95] were considerable assets. But his position was to grow increasingly difficult. Hitler did not intend giving him real authority, seeing him as a dignified figurehead.[k] Although he was commander of the German Army in the west, charged with defending the coasts of France and Belgium against attack by the western Allies, the military governors in Paris and Brussels (Rundstedt's former subordinate Carl-Heinrich von Stülpnagel andAlexander von Falkenhausen respectively) were not under his direct command, and he had no control over the Navy or Air Force. He also had no control over the SS and Gestapo operations in France: the HSSPF in Paris,Carl Oberg, answered only to Himmler.[97]
Secondly, the internal situation in France had changed greatly since Rundstedt's departure in March 1941. Hitler's attack on the Soviet Union had led theFrench Communist Party to abandon its previous neutrality (its slogan was "Neither Pétain norde Gaulle"),[98] and launch activeresistance against the Germans and the Vichy regime. The result was an escalating cycle of assassinations and reprisal killings that rapidly alienated the hitherto quiescent French population. On 20 October French Communists assassinated the German commander inNantes, Karl Hotz, triggering the execution of over 100 French hostages.[99] As military governor, Stülpnagel directed the policy of executing hostages. Rundstedt had no direct control over the Army's response to Resistance attacks. Nevertheless, many held him responsible, then and later.
Rundstedt had more direct responsibility for theCommando Order of 1942, which later served as the basis of war crimes charges against him. There were in fact two German orders concerning captured Alliedcommandos. The first was issued by Rundstedt in July 1942, and stated that captured Alliedparachutists were to be handed over to the Gestapo,whether in uniform or not, rather than madeprisoners of war. This was a response to the increasing number of British agents being parachuted into France by theSpecial Operations Executive. The second was issued by Hitler personally in October, following theDieppe Raid by the British and Canadians on the coast of France. It stipulated that all captured Allied commandos were to be executed, again regardless of whether they were in uniform. As a consequence, six British commandos captured inOperation Frankton, a raid on shipping atBordeaux in December 1942, were executed by the German Navy. Although Rundstedt neither ordered nor was informed of this action, he was later held responsible as German commander in France.[100]
Meanwhile, the military situation for the Germans was deteriorating. The entry of theUnited States into the war in December 1941 raised the likelihood of an Allied invasion of France. Hitler's response was to order the construction of theAtlantic Wall, a system of coastal fortifications from Norway to the French-Spanish border, to be constructed by theOrganisation Todt using slave labour. There was also a steady build-up of German forces in France, despite the demands of the eastern front. By June Rundstedt commanded 25 divisions.[101] In November 1942 the Allies invadedFrench North Africa (Operation Torch). When the Vichy authorities in Africa surrendered after token resistance, the Germans responded by occupying all of France and dissolving what remained of the French Army. Rundstedt travelled to Vichy to placate Pétain, who threatened to resign but backed down after soothing words from Rundstedt. At the same time, in the Soviet Union, Rundstedt's old command, Army Group South, was facing disaster atStalingrad, the turning point of World War II in Europe.
The catastrophe of Stalingrad prompted renewed efforts by dissident German officers to remove Hitler from power while there was still time, as they believed, to negotiate an honourable peace settlement. The conspirators were centered on Halder, Beck and Witzleben, but by 1943 all had been removed from positions of authority. The real movers were now more junior officers:Henning von Tresckow, chief of staff of Army Group Centre,Friedrich Olbricht, Chief of the Armed Forces Replacement Office, andClaus Schenk Graf von Stauffenberg, a member of the Replacement Army staff. Their strategy at this time was to persuade the senior field commanders to lead a coup against Hitler. Their initial target was Manstein, now commandingArmy Group Don, but he turned Tresckow down at a meeting in March 1943. Several sources say that Rundstedt was also approached, although they do not say specifically who approached him.[l] In any case, he refused to get involved, although both Stülpnagel and Falkenhausen were recruits to the conspiracy.[105] By one account, he complained: "Why always me? Let Manstein andKluge do it." He toldGerhard Engel, one of Hitler's adjutants, that he was "too old and had had enough."[106]
It was true, however, that Rundstedt was well past his best. The military historianChester Wilmot wrote soon after the war: "The truth was that Rundstedt had lost his grip. He was old and tired and his once active brain was gradually becoming addled, for he had great difficulty in sleeping without the soporific aid of alcohol."[107] Events in June 1944 showed that this was an exaggeration: Rundstedt was still capable of clear thought and decisive action. But his health was a matter of increasing concern to his staff and his family. His son Leutnant Hans-Gerd von Rundstedt was posted to his command as an aide-de-camp, partly to monitor his health and report back to Bila in Kassel. In one of his letters, Hans-Gerd referred to his father's "somewhat plentiful nicotine and alcohol consumption," but assured his mother that Rundstedt's health was basically sound. Nevertheless, in May 1943 Rundstedt was given leave and was sent to a sanatorium atBad Tölz, south ofMunich, which was also the site of anSS-Junker school. Later he stayed some time atGrundlsee inAustria, and was received by Hitler at his summer house atBerchtesgaden, a sign of Hitler's continuing respect for him. He was back at work by July.[108]
TheAllied invasion of Italy in September 1943 removed Rundstedt's fears that France would be invaded that summer, but he could not have doubted that themassive build-up of American troops in Britain meant that a cross-channel invasion would come in 1944.[109] In October Rundstedt sent Hitler a memorandum on the defensive preparations. He placed no faith in the Atlantic Wall, seeing it merely as useful propaganda. He said: "We Germans, do not indulge in the tiredMaginot spirit."[110] He argued that an invasion could only be defeated by a defence in depth, with armoured reserves positioned well inland so that they could be deployed to wherever the invasion came, and launch counter-offensives to drive the invaders back. There were several problems with this, particularly the lack of fuel for rapid movements of armour, the Allied air superiority which enabled them to disrupt the transport system, and the increasingly effective sabotage efforts of the French resistance. Hitler was not persuaded: his view was that the invasion must be defeated on the beaches. Characteristically, however, he told Rundstedt he agreed with him, then sent Field MarshalErwin Rommel to France with orders to hasten the completion of the Atlantic Wall; while Rundstedt remained the commander in France, Rommel became the official commander of Army Group B. Rundstedt was extremely angered by this decision; although he admired Rommel's tactical skill, he knew from his colleagues that Rommel was notoriously difficult to work with and would mostly be able to ignore Rundstedt's authority thanks to his patronage by Hitler andGoebbels. Rommel in fact agreed with Rundstedt that the Atlantic Wall was a "gigantic bluff", but he also believed that Allied air power made Rundstedt's proposed defense plan impossible; like Hitler, he believed the invasion could only be stopped on the beach itself.[111]
By the spring of 1944 Rommel had turned the mostly nonexistent 'Wall' into a formidable defensive line, but since he believed the invasion would come somewhere betweenDunkirk and the mouth of theSomme, much of his work was directed at strengthening the wrong area, although in late 1943 he had focused on Normandy. As fears of an imminent invasion mounted, conflict broke out among the commanders. Rommel wanted the armoured divisions positioned close to the coast, mostly in the area he considered at highest risk. The commander of armoured forces in France, GeneralLeo Freiherr Geyr von Schweppenburg, backed by Rundstedt, strongly disagreed, wanting his forces to be positioned inland to preserve their manoeuvrability. Eventually Hitler intervened, imposing a compromise: half the armour would be allocated to the Army Groups defending the beaches, and half would be kept in reserve under Geyr von Schweppenburg; the latter, however, were not to be deployed without Hitler's direct order. Hitler made matters worse by appointing Rommel commander of Army Group B, covering all of northern France. This unworkable command structure was to have dire consequences when the invasion came.[112][113]
Theinvasion duly came before dawn on 6 June 1944, inNormandy, far to the west of the sector where Rundstedt and Rommel had expected it. Rommel was on leave in Germany, many of the local commanders in Normandy were at a conference inRennes, and Hitler was asleep at Berchtesgaden. But Rundstedt, now 68, was up before 03:00,[114] trying to take charge of a confusing situation. He immediately saw that the reported Allied airborne landings in Normandy presaged a seaborne invasion. He contacted OKW and demanded that he be given authority to deploy the armoured reserves, but OKW could not agree to this without Hitler's approval. Hitler's refusal came through at 10:00, followed by his change of mind at 14:30, by which time the Allies were well ashore and the cloud cover had lifted, preventing the armour from moving until dusk. In mid-afternoon Rundstedt ordered that "the Allies [be] wiped out before the day's end, otherwise the enemy would reinforce and the chance would be lost",[115] but it was too late. Rundstedt's biographer concludes: "If Hitler had released the Panzer reserves as soon as Rundstedt had asked for them, the Allies would have experienced a much harder day on 6 June than they did."[116] The historianStephen E. Ambrose wrote: "The only high-command officer who responded correctly to the crisis at hand was Field Marshal Rundstedt, the old man who was there for window-dressing and who was so scorned by Hitler and OKW ... Rundstedt's reasoning was sound, his actions decisive, his orders clear."[117]
Being right was little consolation to Rundstedt. By 11 June it was evident that the Allies could not be dislodged from their beach-head in Normandy. Their total command of the air and the sabotage of roads and bridges by the Resistance made bringing armoured reinforcements to Normandy slow and difficult, but without them there was no hope of an effective counter-offensive. Supported by Rommel, he tried to persuade Keitel at OKW that the only escape was to withdraw from Normandy to a prepared defensive line on theSeine, but Hitler forbade any withdrawal. On 17 June Hitler flew to France and met Rundstedt and Rommel at hiscommand bunker nearSoissons. Both Field Marshals argued that the situation in Normandy required either massive reinforcements (which were not available) or a rapid withdrawal. Remarkably, they both also urged that Hitler find a political solution to end the war, which Rommel told him bluntly was unwinnable.[118][m] Hitler ignored all their demands, requiring "fanatical" defence and a counter-attack with whatever was available. Rommel warned Hitler about the inevitable collapse in the German defences, but was rebuffed and told to focus on military operations.[119]
It was during the desperate German attempts to bring reserve units to the front that men of theDas Reich SS Panzer Division destroyed the village ofOradour-sur-Glane in central France, in retaliation for partisan attacks in the area.[120][page needed] Rundstedt was German commander-in-chief in France, had orderedDas Reich to head north to Normandy, and had previously condoned tough action against partisans who had killed or tortured German officers or personnel, including the shooting of hostages. He also authorised the use of terror against civilians. This was enough for the French government to demand after the war that he stand trial for the massacre at Oradour.[121]
On 29 June Rundstedt and Rommel were summoned to Berchtesgaden for a further meeting with Hitler, at which they repeated their demands, and were again rebuffed. On his return to Saint-Germain, on 30 June, Rundstedt found an urgent plea from Schweppenburg, who was commanding the armoured force atCaen, to be allowed to withdraw his units out of range of Allied naval gunfire, which was decimating his forces. Rundstedt at once agreed, and notified OKW of this decision. On 1 July he received a message from OKW countermanding his orders. In a fury, he phoned Keitel, urging him to go to Hitler and get the decision reversed. Keitel pleaded that this was impossible. "What shall we do?" he asked. Rundstedt is said to have replied "Macht Schluss mit dem Krieg, ihr Idioten!" (one version of the story as told by Blumentritt did not include the "ihr Idioten"). This literally means "End the war, you idiots!", but has commonly been reported in English-language accounts as "Make peace, you idiots!" There has been some doubt raised as to whether Rundstedt actually said this, butWilmot says the incident was recounted to him andLiddell Hart by Blumentritt, who was present.[122][n]
Keitel conveyed to Hitler that Rundstedt felt unable to cope with the increased demands, and Hitler relieved him of his command, replacing him with Kluge. It is likely that Hitler had already decided that Rundstedt should be replaced after the meetings of 17 and 29 June. It was officially given out that Rundstedt was retiring on the grounds of age and ill-health. Hitler wrote him a "very cordial" letter, and awarded him the Oak Leaves to hisKnight's Cross, one of the highest of the new decorations created in 1940. Rundstedt departed Saint-Germain for the last time on 4 July, accompanied by his son, and was driven back to the sanatorium at Bad Tölz, to be reunited with his wife. He told Rommel on departing that he would never hold another military command.[123]
Rundstedt had resisted all attempts to recruit him to the various conspiracies against Hitler that had been operating inside the German Army since 1938. Although he had not denounced or reported any of the officers who had approached him, he had shown no sympathy with their appeals. By June 1944 the conspirators had given up on him (and indeed on all the senior field commanders), so he was not approached by the group around Tresckow and Stauffenberg who hatched the unsuccessfulplot to kill Hitler with a bomb at theWolf's Lair (Wolfsschanze), his headquarters inEast Prussia, and had no inkling of what was planned.[124][124] When he heard of the attempt on 20 July, his reaction was very hostile. A year later, in June 1945, he told the investigating commission preparing for the Nuremberg Trials: "I would never have thought of such a thing, that would have been base, bare-faced treachery."[124][o] Since he had every reason to try to put himself in a sympathetic light at Nuremberg, this certainly reflects his view in June 1944. He also argued, however, that the attempt to kill Hitler was pointless, because the German Army and people would not have followed the conspirators. "The Army and also the people still believed in Hitler at that time, and such an overthrow would have been quite unsuccessful." He reiterated his traditional sense of his duty as a soldier: had he supported the plot, he said, "I would have emerged and been considered for all time the greatest traitor to my Fatherland."[124]
Officers like Rundstedt who argued that acoup against Hitler would not have won support in the Army or among the German people were, in the view of most historians, correct.Joachim Fest, writing of Tresckow, said: "Even officers who were absolutely determined to stage a coup were troubled by the fact that everything they were contemplating would inevitably be seen by their troops as dereliction of duty, as irresponsible arrogance, and, worst, as capable of triggering a civil war."[125] On the attitude of the people, Fest wrote: "Most industrial workers remained loyal to the regime, even as the war ground on."[126]
Rundstedt delivering the eulogy for Erwin Rommel, October 1944
Hitler was determined not only to punish those involved in the plot, but to break the power, status, and cohesion of the Prussian officer corps once and for all. Since traditionally German officers could not be tried by civilian courts, he decided that the Army must expel all those accused of involvement. They could then be tried before thePeople's Court (Volksgerichtshof), a special court established in 1934 to try political crimes and presided over by the fanatical NaziRoland Freisler. Hitler therefore ordered the convening of a "Court of Honour" (Ehrenhof) to carry out the expulsions, and appointed Rundstedt to head it. The other senior members were Generals Keitel and Guderian,[129][q]Walther Schroth, andKarl-Wilhelm Specht. This court considered only evidence placed before it by the Gestapo. No defence counsel was permitted, and none of the accused was allowed to appear. On this basis, several officers were expelled from the Army, while others were exonerated. Among those the court declined to expel were Halder (who had no involvement in the plot), andHans Speidel, Rommel's chief of Staff (who was deeply implicated).[124] Those expelled appeared in batches before the People's Court, where after perfunctory trialsmost of them were executed by hanging. Rundstedt and Heinz Guderian have been singled out as the two who most contributed to Rommel's expulsion from the army, especially as both had good reason to dislike him; however, Rommel and Rundstedt had always had a grudging respect for one another, and Rundstedt later served as Hitler's representative at Rommel'sstate funeral[130] inUlm.
No incident in Rundstedt's career has damaged his posthumous reputation as much as his involvement in this process.John Wheeler-Bennett wrote in 1967: "To such a nadir of supine degradation had come the child ofScharnhorst andGneisenau andMoltke." He called the Court "the final farce of casuistry" and accused the officer corps of washing its hands,Pilate-like, of their comrades. Rundstedt's biographer writes: "This was something for which some Germans, while they were prepared to forgive him everything else, could and cannot excuse him."[131] Speidel, despite the fact that he was spared, was bitterly critical of Rundstedt after the war, when he became a senior officer in the newWest German Army.Blumentritt, always loyal to his oldChef, complained in 1953: "He has had to endure vindictiveness and jealousy even up to and after the hour of his death."[132]
The aftermath of the 20 July plot coincided with the rout of the German armies in both the east and the west. In the eastOperation Bagration destroyed Army Group Centre and drove the Germans out of Byelorussia and eastern Poland: they were also forced out of the Balkans. In the west, the Americans, British and Canadians broke out of the Normandy pocket and swept across France, taking Paris on 25 August and Brussels on 3 September. The German command in the west was reorganised following the suicide of Kluge, the arrest of Stülpnagel and the incapacitation of Rommel.[r] Field MarshalWalter Model, known as "the Führer's fireman" for his reputation for stabilising dangerous situations, was appointed both OB West and commander of Army Group B on 16 August, but even he could not do justice to both jobs. At Blumentritt's urgent request, supported by Model, Hitler agreed to ask Rundstedt to resume his post as OB West, which at a meeting on 1 September he agreed to do, saying "My Führer, whatever you order, I shall do to my last breath."[133]
The appointment of Rundstedt was at least in part a propaganda exercise. He was the most senior and one of the best known German Army commanders, both in Germany and abroad. His formidable reputation inspired confidence at home and trepidation among the enemy. His appointment was designed to impress the Allies, reassure the German people, and bolster the morale of the officer corps after the shock of 20 July and the subsequent purge.[134] The Allies believed Rundstedt to be a far more powerful and influential figure than he in fact was, regarding him with "respect, almost awe" as the master strategist of the German Army – something he would not find helpful after the war.[135] He had already appeared on the cover ofTime magazine in August 1942, and did so again in August 1944, when it was suggested, quite wrongly, that he was behind the 20 July plot.[136] There were even suggestions that he would take over leadership of the German state.[137] But Hitler saw Rundstedt as a figurehead: he intended that operational control on the western front remain with the energetic and ruthless Model, a committed Nazi. Rundstedt, on the other hand, saw himself as the voice of experience, restraining the younger Model, whom he described as "courageous but impulsive."[138]
With the comforts of Saint-Germain no longer available, Rundstedt established his headquarters nearKoblenz. His chief of staff was now the capable GeneralSiegfried Westphal. Under Rundstedt was Model, commanding Army Group B and facing the British and Canadians as they advanced through Belgium and into the Netherlands, and the Americans as they advanced into the Ardennes in southern Belgium and Luxembourg. Further south,Army Group G, commanded by GeneralHermann Balck, faced the Americans in Lorraine and Alsace, down to the Swiss border. In October, Army Group H in the north was split off from Model's very extended front, and was placed under the command of the paratroop generalKurt Student.
Rundstedt believed even at this stage that an effective defensive line could only be established on theRhine, but this would have meant giving up large areas of German territory, and Hitler would not countenance it. He insisted that a stand be made on theWest Wall (known to the Allies as the Siegfried Line), a defensive system built along Germany's western frontiers in 1938–40, but partly dismantled in 1943–44 to provide materials for the Atlantic Wall.[139] Model told OKW that this would require 25 divisions of fresh troops, but these were no longer to be had. Instead the line was held by patched-up divisions escaping from the debacle in France, andVolksgrenadier divisions made up from transferred Navy and Air Force personnel, older men and teenagers: these units were fit for static defence, but not much else.[140]
Nevertheless, the Germans now had certain advantages. In military terms, it is easier to defend a fixed line than it is to take one by storm. They were now fighting in defence of their own frontiers, and this stiffened resolve. They no longer had to deal with partisans sabotaging their supply lines, and they were close to their own sources of supply in Germany. The Allies on the other hand had severe logistical problems, with their supply lines running all the way back to the Normandy beaches. The great port ofAntwerp was in their hands, but the Germans still controlled the mouth of theScheldt, so the Allies could not use it as a supply port. In September the American tank armies in Lorraine literally ran out of fuel, and during October the Allied offensive gradually lost momentum and came to a halt on a line well west of the German border in most sectors, although the frontier city ofAachen fell on 21 October. With the failure of the British attempt to force a crossing of the Rhine atArnhem (Operation Market Garden) in late September, the chance of invading Germany before the winter set in was lost, and Rundstedt was given time to consolidate his position.[141]
Hitler, however, had no intention of staying on the defensive in the west over the winter. As early as mid-September he was planning a counter-offensive.[142] By October, with the front stabilising, he had decided on anattack in the Ardennes, designed to split the British and American fronts at a weakly held point, cross the Meuse and recapture Antwerp. On 27 October Rundstedt and Model met with GeneralAlfred Jodl, chief of operations at OKW, and told him flatly that they considered this impossible with the available forces. Instead they suggested a more modest operation to destroy the Allied concentrations around Liège and Aachen. Jodl took their views back to Hitler, but on 3 November he told them that the Führer's mind was made up, and that he wanted the attack to begin before the end of November. The spearhead was to be the6th Panzer Army, commanded by Sepp Dietrich and largely made up of Waffen-SS units such as theLeibstandarte,Das Reich andHitlerjugend, and the5th Panzer Army, commanded by GeneralHasso von Manteuffel.
Model persuaded Jodl that the deadline was unrealistic, and on 2 December he and Westphal went to Berlin to argue their case with Hitler. Rundstedt refused to go, because, he said, he hated listening to Hitler's monologues.[143] This marked his effective abdication as a military leader: he was now only a figurehead, and apparently content to be so. After the war he disowned all responsibility for the offensive: "If old von Moltke thought that I had planned that offensive he would have turned over in his grave."[144] Hitler arrived on the western front on 10 December to supervise the offensive, which was now set for 16 December. He gave orders directly to the army commanders, bypassing both Rundstedt and Model. Manteuffel said: "The plan for the Ardennes offensive was drawn up completely by OKW and sent to us as a cut-and-dried Führer order."[145][146]
Taking advantage of surprise and poor weather (which helped neutralise the Allies' command of the air), the offensive made initial progress, breaking through the weak American formations in this quiet sector of the front. But the Allies were quick to react, and the Germans were soon falling behind their ambitious timetables. To the north, Dietrich's 6th Panzer Army was blocked by stubborn defence atSt. Vith andElsenborn Ridge and advanced little more than 20 km. Manteuffel, in the centre, did better, reachingCelles, a few kilometres short of the Meuse, on 25 December. This was a penetration of about 80 km, less than halfway to Antwerp, and on such a narrow front as to create an indefensible salient. The resistance of the American garrison atBastogne greatly delayed the advance, making a forcing of the Meuse impossible. When the cloud cover lifted on 24 December, the Allied air forces attacked with devastating effect. Rundstedt urged OKW to halt the offensive, lest the "bulge" created by the German advance become a "second Stalingrad", but Hitler was determined to press on.[147] A few days later U.S. forces attacked from the north and south of the bulge, forcing the Germans first to halt and then to retreat.[148]
Waffen-SS units under Rundstedt's overall command committed war crimes during the campaign in the West, including theMalmedy massacre, which was perpetrated by troops under the command ofJoachim Peiper. His unit of the SS divisionLeibstandarte was under the command ofWilhelm Mohnke.[149][page needed] Peiper's battle group (Kampfgruppe) was charged with seizing the bridges over the Meuse ahead of the advance of the 6th Panzer Army. On 17 December, nearMalmedy, a group of Peiper's men, opened fire on a large group of unarmed U.S. prisoners of war, killing 84. Responsibility for this crime ran from Peiper to Mohnke to Dietrich to Model to Rundstedt, although none of them had been present and none had ordered such action. When Rundstedt heard about it, he ordered an investigation, but in the chaos of the failing offensive nothing came of this.[citation needed]
Although such occurrences were commonplace on the Eastern Front from both sides, they were a rarity in the West, and the outraged Americans were determined to prosecute all those with responsibility for this massacre. Here Rundstedt's problem was his reputation. The Ardennes offensive was known to the Allies as "the Rundstedt offensive", and the Allied press routinely described him as being in charge of it. The British commander in Europe, Field MarshalBernard Montgomery, said on 7 January 1945: "I used to think that Rommel was good, but my opinion is that Rundstedt would havehit him for six. Rundstedt is the best German general I have come up against."[150] Since Rundstedt, as far as the Allies knew, was in charge of the offensive, it followed for them that he was responsible for what his subordinates did during it.[citation needed]
On 8 January, Hitler authorised Manteuffel to withdraw from the tip of the bulge, and on 15 January he gave up the whole enterprise and returned to Berlin. By the end of January the Germans were back where they had started. But the offensive had burned up the last of Rundstedt's reserves of manpower, equipment and fuel, and as a result neither the West Wall nor the Rhine could be properly defended. On 18 February, as the Allies entered Germany, Rundstedt issued an appeal to the German Army to resist the invader, urging the troops to "gather round the Führer to guard our people and our state from a destiny of horror." Hitler rewarded his loyalty with the Swords to his Knight's Cross. Despite fierce resistance in places, the Germans were forced back from the West Wall during February, and a series of Allied offensives, rolling from north to south, drove across theRhineland towards the great river.[151] On 2 March the Americans reached the Rhine nearDüsseldorf. Rundstedt had been aware as early as September of the importance of the many bridges over the Rhine, and of the necessity of denying them to the enemy. He made careful plans for the bridges to be blown up if the enemy reached the Rhine.[152] On 7 March, however, these plans failed when the Americanscaptured theLudendorff Bridge atRemagen intact, and rapidly established a bridgehead on the eastern bank. This could hardly be blamed on Rundstedt, but he was the commander and Hitler needed a scapegoat.[citation needed]
On 9 March Hitler phoned Rundstedt and told him he was to be replaced byAlbert Kesselring, to be transferred from Italy. That was the end of Gerd von Rundstedt's military career after 52 years.
On 11 March Rundstedt had a final audience with Hitler, who thanked him for his loyalty. He then returned to his home in Kassel, but bombing and the Allied advance into western Germany made him decide to move his family, first to Solz, a village south of Kassel, then toWeimar, then toBayreuth, and finally back to the sanatorium at Bad Tölz where he had stayed several times before. Rundstedt's heart condition had worsened and he also suffered from arthritis. There was no attempt at further escape: Rundstedt, accompanied by Bila and Hans Gerd and a few staff, stayed at Bad Tölz until it was occupied by American forces on 1 May, the day after Hitler's suicide in Berlin. That evening he was made a prisoner of war by troops from the36th Infantry Division.[153]
Rundstedt complained publicly several times during and after the war: "Without Hitler's consent, I can't even move my own sentry from my front door around to the back!" Privately with other generals he referred to Hitler as thatBohemian corporal.Wilhelm Keitel once asked Hitler "Do you realise that Rundstedt called you a Bohemian corporal?" and Hitler replied "Yes, but he's the best field marshal I have."[154]
Rundstedt and his son, Hans Gerd von Rundstedt, following their capture.
Generalfeldmarschall von Rundstedt was initially held at the Allied facility for detaining high-ranking German officials, known as ASHCAN, in a hotel atMondorf-les-Bains in Luxembourg. Out of consideration for his rank and state of health, Hans Gerd was allowed to accompany him. At the end of May they were moved to an American detention centre atWiesbaden. Here Rundstedt was extensively questioned byU.S. Army interrogators about his career and actions during the war. During this period decisions were being made about which German leaders were to be put on trial for war crimes at theNuremberg trials. Rundstedt was the most senior German officer in Allied custody. He was accused of responsibility for war crimes in Poland (the shooting of surrendered soldiers in 1939), the Soviet Union (the actions of theEinsatzgruppen in 1941), Britain (theCommando Order of 1942) and France (theOradour massacre of 1944). Eventually the International Military Tribunal (IMT) decided that no German field commanders would be tried at Nuremberg. Instead "the General Staff and High Command of the German Armed Forces" was collectively indicted.[155] The only Army officers individually indicted were the OKW chiefs Keitel and Jodl, but they had never been field commanders.
In July Rundstedt was handed over to British custody.[s] He was held first atWilton Park inBuckinghamshire, then atGrizedale Hall in Cumbria, then atIsland Farm nearBridgend inGlamorgan, South Wales. The British climate badly affected his arthritis, making him increasingly lame. His heart condition became worse and he was periodically depressed. One interviewer wrote: "A limp, exhausted body racked by constant pain due to weakened arteries is now the remnant of the relentless figure that once waved a Marshal's baton."[157] During this period he was extensively interviewed by the military writerBasil Liddell Hart, who later used these and other interviews as the basis for his booksThe Other Side of the Hill and its U.S. equivalentThe German Generals Talk, published in 1948. Liddell Hart and Rundstedt developed a close rapport, and the relationship was to prove very valuable to Rundstedt over the next few years. Liddell Hart wrote of him: "Rundstedt makes an increasingly favourable impression on me ... He is dignified without being arrogant, and essentially aristocratic in outlook."[158]
When Rundstedt learned that he was not to be tried personally at Nuremberg, he wrote to the Tribunal asking permission to appear as a defence witness for the Army high command. In May 1946 he was summoned to appear. When he leftIsland Farm, all the 185 senior officers being held there lined up to salute him. On 19 June he appeared before a preliminary hearing of the IMT Commission.[159] Since he was a witness, not a defendant, the questioning was not intended to prove Rundstedt's guilt: it was designed to bolster the prosecution's case that the high command had functioned as an organisation and that it was collectively responsible for the German invasions of various countries between 1939 and 1941 and also for the war crimes committed during those invasions. Rundstedt was adamant that the high command played no part in the decisions to invade Poland, Norway, France or the Soviet Union. He insisted that the Army had obeyed the laws of war and was not responsible for the actions of theEinsatzgruppen. He also denied that the Army had deliberately starved three million Soviet prisoners of war to death in 1941–42.
On 12 August Rundstedt took the stand before the IMT itself.[160] His counsel, DrHans Laternser, took him over the same ground which had been covered before the commission. He insisted that military law was "always binding for us older leaders", and that officers who broke these laws were court-martialed. He stated: "As senior soldier of the German Army, I will say this: we accused leaders were trained in the old soldierly traditions of decency andchivalry. We lived and acted according to them, and we endeavoured to hand them down to the younger officers."[161] Cross-examined by the British prosecutorPeter Calvocoressi, he stuck to his position that the high command did not function as an organisation. Senior commanders discussed only operational matters, he said: political and strategic questions were decided by Hitler and the OKW. Rundstedt made a good impression as a witness. Calvocoressi later commented: "He was not going to let on how much he and his colleagues had known or done. He did this well – or anyway successfully."[162]
The success of Rundstedt's efforts was shown in October 1946, when the IMT handed down its verdicts. Keitel and Jodl were to be hanged, but the Army high command as a whole was acquitted. The verdict read: "According to the indictment, this group consists of about 130 officers who held certain positions in the military hierarchy between 1938 and 1945 ... The Tribunal does not find that they were an organisation ... They were only an aggregation of those who happened to hold high rank in a certain period ... These men have, however, been a disgrace to the profession of arms, and they have made a mockery of obedience to orders. They were a ruthless military caste, and were guilty of crimes and should be brought to trial as individuals."[163] Thus the possibility was left open that Rundstedt could still face individual prosecution for his actions.
Rundstedt returned to Island Farm to await developments.Otto John, a German lawyer who had been active in the German resistance, arrived in October to interview the prisoners and make recommendations on possible future war crimes prosecutions. John and Rundstedt got on well, and in November John arranged for Hans Gerd von Rundstedt, who was suffering from the early stages of throat cancer, to be released and sent home. In April 1947 the Allied War Crimes Investigation Group operating in Germany recommended that Rundstedt should not face prosecution.[164] The U.S. government, however, did not accept this recommendation and insisted that Rundstedt, Manstein, Brauchitsch and General Rudolf Strauss (an Army commander on the Russian front in 1941) should stand trial. All four were in British custody. In AugustTelford Taylor, the U.S. Chief Counsel for War Crimes, formally advised the British Attorney-General,Sir Hartley Shawcross, of his intentions. The grounds for the prosecution would be theCommissar Order of 1941, theCommando Order of 1942, the murder of Soviet prisoners-of-war, the conscription and deportation of civilians in occupied countries asforced labour, and the responsibility of the named officers for the invasions of Poland, France, Yugoslavia, the Soviet Union and other countries.
The British, however, were extremely reluctant to act. British public opinion had rapidly shifted (as it did after World War I) away from anti-German sentiment towards a desire for reconciliation. There was a strong feeling that putting elderly and sick men on trial three years after the war was unjust. There was also the fact that many of the events referred to by the Americans had taken place in the Soviet Union and Poland, which were now, with the onset of theCold War, political adversaries and no longer cooperating with western war crimes investigations. The British Military Governor in Germany,Air MarshalSir Sholto Douglas, was strongly opposed. He wrote: "We are apparently prepared to send these men, including one who is 73, to trial by the Americans. I frankly do not like this. I feel that if the Americans wish to be critical in our inaction in trying war criminals, I should prefer that they should continue to criticise rather than that we should commit an injustice in order to avoid their criticism."[165]
Rundstedt and the other officers knew nothing of the proposed prosecutions. In June 1947, his son Hans Gerd was admitted to hospital and it soon became apparent that his cancer was inoperable. In December Rundstedt was granted compassionate leave by the British government to visit the hospital in Hanover where Hans Gerd was being treated. On Christmas Day he saw his wife for the first time since May 1945, and his grandchildren for the first time since 1941. Hans Gerd died on 12 January 1948: "a blow from which he never really recovered."[166] On Rundstedt's return he was given a medical examination. The doctors reported "a markedly senile general physique", chronic arterio-sclerosis, osteoarthritis in most of his joints, and failing memory. The examiners advised that to put him on trial would "adversely affect his health." A similar recommendation was made about Brauchitsch, although Manstein was judged fit to stand trial. As a result, theSecretary of State for War,Manny Shinwell, recommended to Foreign SecretaryErnest Bevin that the prosecutions should not proceed. Bevin was put in a quandary, fearing the reactions of countries such as France and Belgium if Rundstedt were to be released. In March the Soviet government formally demanded Rundstedt's extradition to the Soviet Union.
Meanwhile, the Americans had requested that Rundstedt and Manstein be brought to Nuremberg to appear as a witness in theHigh Command Trial, in which a number of prominent generals, including Leeb, Blaskowitz (who committed suicide during the trial),Hugo Sperrle,Georg von Küchler andHermann Hoth were on trial for war crimes. In May, therefore, Rundstedt was transferred from Island Farm to a military hospital in Norfolk. On 22 July Rundstedt left the hospital and the next day he and Manstein were flown to Nuremberg. But the presiding judge in the case ruled that he would not allow Rundstedt or Manstein to testify unless they were first informed whether they were themselves in danger of prosecution. Thus Rundstedt and Manstein discovered for the first time that the Americans had requested their indictment. As a result, they refused to testify. They were then transferred to a military hospital nearMunster. Here conditions were so bad that Brauchitsch went on a hunger strike.
In August the matter became public when Liddell Hart launched a press campaign to have the four officers released. He was supported by figures such asMichael Foot,Victor Gollancz andLord De L'Isle, VC. On 27 August the government responded by formally announcing that the four would be tried by a British military court in Hamburg. Items in Rundstedt's indictment included: "the maltreatment and killing of civilians and prisoners of war ... killing hostages, illegal employment of prisoners of war, deportation of forced labour to Germany ... mass execution of Jews ... and other war crimes, yet to be specified."[167] On 24 September the four were moved to a military hospital in Hamburg, where they were allowed to be visited by their families. It was here that Brauchitsch died suddenly of heart failure on 18 October. This led to a renewed outcry in Britain for the trial to be abandoned. Nevertheless, Bevin was determined to press ahead, and on 1 January 1949 Rundstedt, Manstein and Strauss were formally charged. Hugo Laternser was engaged as Rundstedt's counsel, and Liddell Hart and others in Britain collected material for the defence. The Bishop of Chichester,George Bell, announced that he would bring in a motion in theHouse of Lords critical of the government. This was a serious threat since the Lords had the power to compel the government to produce documents.
By April the public debate in Britain was becoming so damaging that the government decided that the best option was to back down as gracefully as it could. The government's resolve was stiffened by the refusal of the Soviet government to provide any evidence for the trial. Further medical reports were commissioned, with varying results. A team of British Army doctors eventually reported that Rundstedt and Strauss were unfit to stand trial, and the government used this as a pretext to abandon the trial. On 28 April Cabinet considered the medical reports, and asked the Lord Chancellor,Lord Jowitt, to prepare a report for its next meeting. On 5 May Cabinet accepted his recommendation that Rundstedt and Strauss be released, but that Manstein's trial should go ahead.[t] Rundstedt was formally advised of his release on 19 May, but since he had nowhere to go he stayed in the hospital until 26 May, when he finally left British custody and went to the home of his brother Udo atRatzeburg in Schleswig-Holstein.
Rundstedt was now a free man after four years in custody, but it brought him little joy.[168] He was 73, frail and in poor health. He had no home, no money and no income. The family home inKassel had been requisitioned by the Americans, and the Rundstedt estate inSaxony-Anhalt was in the Soviet Zone and had been confiscated. His wife was living inSolz, but this was in the American Zone, where he could not travel because the Americans (who were displeased by the British decision to release him) still regarded him as a Class 1 war criminal under thedenazification laws then in force. Likewise, his money, in a bank account in Kassel, was frozen because of his classification, which also denied him a military pension. The British had assured him that he would not be arrested or extradited if he stayed in the British Zone, but the Americans had made no such guarantee. "It is an awful situation for me and my poor wife," he wrote to Liddell Hart. "I would like to end this life as soon as possible."[169]
Meanwhile, Rundstedt was in a hospital inHanover with nowhere to live, and the newSPD administration inLower Saxony had no interest in helping ex-Field Marshals of the Third Reich at a time when there was an acute housing shortage across Germany.[u] He and Bila were temporarily housed in an elderly persons' home nearCelle.
Grave in Stöcken
In the last years of his life, Rundstedt became a subject of increasing interest and was interviewed by various writers and historians. His former chief of staff, Günther Blumentritt, visited him frequently, and began work on an apologetic biography, which was published in 1952. In 1951 he was portrayed sympathetically byLeo G. Carroll in a film about Rommel,The Desert Fox.[171] Blumentritt and Liddell Hart raised money to provide nursing care for the Rundstedts. Bila died on 4 October 1952; Rundstedt died of heart failure on 24 February 1953 in Hanover. (He had already been at retirement age when theSecond World War began.) He was buried in theStöcken City Cemetery.[citation needed]
Rundstedt's defence at the trial was that as a soldier he had a duty to obey the orders of the legitimate government, whoever that was, and whatever the orders were. He would have fully agreed with Manstein's remark toRudolf von Gersdorff: "Preußische Feldmarschälle meutern nicht." ("Prussian field marshals do not mutiny.")[172]
Since the charges brought against Manstein were almost identical to those brought against Rundstedt, it is worth quoting the remarks made by the prosecutor at Manstein's trial,Sir Arthur Comyns Carr: "Contemporary German militarism flourished briefly with its recent ally, National Socialism, as well as or better than it had in the generals of the past. Many of these have made a mockery of the soldier's oath of obedience to military orders. When it suits their purpose they say they had to obey; when confronted with Hitler's brutal crimes which are shown to have been within their general knowledge, they say they disobeyed. The truth is they actively participated in all these crimes, or sat silent and acquiescent, witnessing the commission of crimes on a scale larger and more shocking than the world has ever had the misfortune to know."[173]
Rundstedt was left in no doubt by Hitler and Himmler what German occupation would mean for the people of Poland and the Soviet Union, yet he applied his military talents to the conquest of both countries. He approved of the Reichenau Order orSeverity Order and must have known what it portended for the Jews of Ukraine, yet "sat silent and acquiescent" while theEinsatzgruppen did their work. He claimed that the Army would have liked to feed the three million Soviet POWs, yet he apparently took no interest in their fate once they were taken to the rear. He asserted that he had an absolute duty as an officer to obey orders, yet claimed to have disobeyed both the Commissar Order in Russia and the Commando Order in France. These inconsistencies were exposed both at Nuremberg, in the trials of theEinsatzgruppen leaders (who also claimed they had a duty to obey distasteful orders) and in the 1947 trials of senior officers, and in Manstein's trial in 1949. They would certainly also have been exposed if Rundstedt had come to trial. On this basis, his biographer concludes: "If Rundstedt had stood trial, it is clear from the Manstein case that he would have been found guilty of some of the charges levelled against him".[174]
519th recipient of Oak Leaves for his Knight's Cross on 1 July 1944 asGeneralfeldmarschall andOberbefehlshaber West (commander in chief west)[176]
133rd recipient of Oak Leaves and Swords for his Knight's Cross on 18 February 1945 asGeneralfeldmarschall andOberbefehlshaber West (commander in chief west)[176]
^Fritsch was eventually exonerated by a Court of Honour, but was not re-instated.
^Fest says that Rundstedt "left his post in horror after a short period," but does not cite a source for this observation.[26]
^This quotation is a paraphrase of Hitler's actual words, as recorded in General Halder's diary.
^Military historian B. H. Liddell Hart's views were based on extensive interviews with former German Army commanders, notably Rundstedt, with whom he developed a close relationship.
^Rundstedt was actually in Ukraine, not Russia, but like most Germans of this period he drew no distinction.
^The Soviets had suffered many more, but they had a larger population to recruit from, and could train new recruits quicker and more cheaply.
^Mawdsley says that Rundstedt resigned, but this is incorrect. Rundstedt's letter was not a resignation, but an invitation to Hitler to dismiss him if he had lost confidence in him.[71]
^Testimony of DrHans Lammers, head of Hitler's chancellery, at theNuremberg trials.[77] Lammers administered the system of bonuses, which was, as he said, a system dating back to Frederick the Great. He said Rundstedt was also given an estate near Breslau in Silesia, but no other source mentions this.
^The Rundstedt family did not access the money, by then considerably devalued, until 1982.[79]
^Heer & Naumann extensively document the involvement of 6th Army in massacres of Jews and others.[86]
^"But now he was to be little more than a figurehead, a role which he accepted because of his sense of patriotic duty outweighed his professional pride."[96]
^Messenger says that he was approached byGerhard Engel, one of Hitler's adjutants, urging him to approach Hitler about the military situation, but Engel was not a member of the anti-Hitler conspiracy.[102] Fest refers to "the officer sent by Groscurth (theAbwehr officerHelmuth Groscurth) to Rundstedt", but does not name him.[103] InStauffenberg, Hoffmann refers to "efforts made to persuade" Rundstedt, but does not say who made them. The approaches were probably made through Rundstedt's aide-de-camp, Hans-Viktor von Salviati, who was later executed for his role in the anti-Hitler plot.[104]
^Wilmot's account is based on conversations with Blumentritt and GeneralHans Speidel, who were both present.
^Blumentritt seems to have given several versions of the story to postwar questioners.
^Unfortunately the text of Rundstedt's testimony before the Commission, as opposed to his testimony before the International Military Tribunal itself, is not available online.
^Some believed Rundstedt to be a "very old friend" of Witzleben.[127] But according to Messenger, "Outside his family he had no close friends as such."[128]
^Messenger and Wheeler-Bennett both suggest that the Court of Honour was Guderian's idea, agreed on as part of a deal withMartin Bormann to limit the scope of the purge which Hitler wanted to carry out in the officer corps.
^Rommel was injured when an Allied plane strafed his staff car on 17 July. In October he committed suicide rather than face charges of complicity in the 20 July plot.
^His biographer has not been able to determine why this was done.[156]
^Manstein was convicted in December 1949 on the basis of charges almost identical to those brought against Rundstedt, and sentenced to 18 years in prison. He was paroled on medical grounds in August 1952.
^Self-government in the German states had been restored in 1947. Lower Saxony became an SPD stronghold, and the government's attitude reflected the strong anti-militarist mood in Germany in the wake of the war. The Minister-President,Hinrich Kopf, said he "would not lift a finger for a war criminal".[170]
Hamburg Institute for Social Research (1999).The German Army and Genocide: Crimes against War Prisoners, Jews, and other Civilians in the East, 1939–1944. New York: New Press.ISBN978-1-56584-525-1. (Reproduces many photos taken by German soldiers of mass killings of Jews and public executions of so-called partisans and others)
Hargreaves, Richard (2008).The Germans in Normandy. Mechanicsburg, PA: Stackpole Books.ISBN978-0-8117-3513-1.
Hastings, Max (1983).Das Reich: Resistance and the March of the 2nd SS Panzer Division through France, June 1944. London: Pan.ISBN978-0-330-26966-7.
Heer, Hannes; Naumann, Klauss, eds. (2000).War of Extermination: The German Military in World War II, 1941–1944. New York: Berghahn Books.ISBN978-1-57181-232-2.
Hillgruber, Andreas (1989). "War in the East and the Extermination of the Jews". In Marrus, Michael (ed.).Part 3, The "Final Solution": The Implementation of Mass Murder, Volume 1. The Nazi Holocaust – Historical Articles on the Destruction of European Jews. Westpoint, Connecticut: Meckler. pp. 85–114.ISBN0-88736-266-4.
Liddell Hart, Basil (1999).The Other Side of the Hill. London: Pan.ISBN9780330373241. (original edition Cassell 1948OCLC4823888)
Lieb, Peter (2014). "Chapter 5: Rommel in Normandy". In Beckett, Ian F. W. (ed.).Rommel Reconsidered. Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania: Stackpole Books.ISBN978-0-8117-1462-4.
Melvin, Mungo (2011).Manstein: Hitler's Greatest General. London: Phoenix.ISBN978-0-7538-2853-3.
Messenger, Charles (2011).The Last Prussian: A Biography of Field Marshal Gerd von Rundstedt 1875–1953. Pen & Sword.ISBN978-1-84884-662-3.
Neillands, Robin (2006).The Battle for the Rhine 1944: Arnhem and the Ardennes: The Campaign in Europe, 1944–45. London: Cassell Military.ISBN978-0-304-36736-8.
"Der "Reichenau-Befehl": Das Verhalten der Truppe im Ostraum" [The "Reichenau Order": The Behavior of the Troops in the Eastern Region].NS-Archiv: Dokumente zum Nationalsozialismus [Nazi Archive: Documents on National Socialism] (in German). 12 October 1941. Retrieved14 August 2021.
Reynolds, Michael (2009).The devil's Adjutant: Jochen Peiper, Panzer Leader. Barnsley: Pen & Sword Military.ISBN978-1-84884-010-2.
Rhodes, Richard (2003).Masters of Death: The SS Einsatzgruppen and the Invention of the Holocaust. Vintage.ISBN978-0-375-70822-0.
Scherzer, Veit (2007).Die Ritterkreuzträger 1939–1945 Die Inhaber des Ritterkreuzes des Eisernen Kreuzes 1939 von Heer, Luftwaffe, Kriegsmarine, Waffen-SS, Volkssturm sowie mit Deutschland verbündeter Streitkräfte nach den Unterlagen des Bundesarchives [The Knight's Cross Bearers 1939–1945 The Holders of the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross 1939 by Army, Air Force, Navy, Waffen-SS, Volkssturm and Allied Forces with Germany According to the Documents of the Federal Archives] (in German). Jena, Germany: Scherzers Militaer-Verlag.ISBN978-3-938845-17-2.
Stahel, David (2012).Kiev 1941: Hitler's Battle for Supremacy in the East. Cambridge.ISBN978-1-107-01459-6.
Strachan, Hew (2006). "Time, Space and Barbarisation: the German Army and the Eastern Front in Two World Wars". In Kassimeris, George (ed.).The Barbarization of Warfare. New York: NYU Press. p. 80.ISBN9780814747971.
Thomas, Franz (1998).Die Eichenlaubträger 1939–1945 [The Oak Leaves Bearers 1939–1945] (in German). Vol. 2: L–Z. Osnabrück, Germany: Biblio-Verlag.ISBN978-3-7648-2300-9.
Wheeler-Bennett, John (1967).The Nemesis of Power: The German Army in Politics 1918–1945. Macmillan.OCLC58591736.
Wilmot, Chester (1952).The Struggle for Europe. Collins.OCLC838157. (This book is out of date as military history, but is of historical interest as much of it was based on interviews with participants while their memories were fresh.)
Blumentritt, Günther (1952).Von Rundstedt: The Man and the Soldier. Odhams Press.OCLC41400011. (This book is of historical interest as the first biography of Rundstedt, written by one of his close associates, but it is not a reliable historical source.)
Clark, Christopher (2006).Iron Kingdom: The Rise and Downfall of Prussia, 1600–1947. London: Allen Lane.ISBN978-0-7139-9466-7.
.svg)
