From 1920 to 1921, he was captain of the destroyerMomi, but was soon sent to shore duty with various assignments by theIJN General Staff. He became acommander in 1924. From 1925 to 1926, Nagumo accompanied a Japanese mission to study naval warfare strategy, tactics, and equipment inWestern Europe and theUnited States.
Nagumo (left) as captain ofTakao with fellow naval officers Shinichirō Machida and Ayao Inagaki at anizakaya, 1933–1934
After his return to Japan, Nagumo was assigned to duties in Chinese territorial waters. He was appointed captain of theriver gunboatSaga from 20 March 1926 to 15 October 1926, followed by the gunboatUji from 15 October 1926 to 15 November 1927. He then served as an instructor at the IJN Academy from 1927 to 1929. Nagumo was promoted tocaptain in November 1929 and assumed command of thelight cruiserNaka and from 1930 to 1931 was commander of the11th Destroyer Division. After serving in administrative positions from 1931 to 1933, he assumed command of theheavy cruiserTakao from 1933 to 1934, and the battleshipYamashiro from 1934 to 1935. He was promoted toRear Admiral on 1 November 1935.
From 1937 to 1938, he was commandant of the Torpedo School, and from 1938 to 1939, he was commander of the3rd Cruiser Division. Nagumo was promoted tovice admiral on 15 November 1939. From November 1940 to April 1941, Nagumo was commandant of the Naval War College.
Nagumo (front row, center) with the staff of the 1st Air Fleet onAkagi, 10 April 1941 – 14 July 1942Nagumo in the bridge ofAkagi en route to attack Pearl Harbor, 26 November – 7 December 1941
On 10 April 1941, Nagumo was appointedcommander-in-chief of the1st Air Fleet, the IJN's maincarrier battle group, largely due to his seniority. Many contemporaries and historians have doubted his suitability for this command, given his lack of familiarity withnaval aviation. Nagumo's friend and fellow admiralNishizō Tsukahara would say that: "He (Nagumo) was wholly unfitted by background, training, experience, and interest for a major role in Japan’s naval air arm."[4] Nagumo was appointed by the Navy General Staff, rather than the Combined Fleet. Vice-admiralJisaburō Ozawa was AdmiralIsoroku Yamamoto's choice for the command of First Air Fleet but Yamamoto did not have a strong enough case to remove Nagumo.[4]
Nagumo as commander of the First Air Fleet
By this time, he had visibly aged, physically and mentally. Physically, he suffered fromarthritis, possibly from his younger days as akendoka.[5] Mentally, he had become a cautious officer who carefully worked over the tactical plans of every operation in which he was involved; his inflexibility in command decisions became more apparent.[citation needed]
Admiral Tsukahara had doubts about Nagumo's appointment, and commented, "Nagumo was an officer of the old school, a specialist of torpedo and surface maneuvers.... He did not have any idea of the capability and potential of naval aviation." One son of Nagumo described him as a brooding father, obsessed with and later regretful about pressuring his sons into joining the IJN. In contrast, Nagumo's junior naval officers thought of him as a father figure.[5]
Despite his limited experience, he was a strong advocate of combining sea and air power, although he was opposed to Admiral Yamamoto's plan to attack theUnited States NavyNaval Station Pearl Harbor.[6] While commanding the First Air Fleet, Nagumo oversaw theattack on Pearl Harbor, but he was later criticized for his failure to launch a third attack,[7][8][9] which might have destroyed the fuel oil storage and repair facilities. This could have rendered the most important U.S. naval base in the Pacific useless, especially as the continued operation of the submarine base and the use of the intelligence station at the installation were critical factors in Japan's defeat in thePacific War.[10]
TheBattle of Midway, in June 1942, brought Nagumo's streak of victories to an end. During the battle, aMartin B-26 Marauder, seriously damaged by anti-aircraft fire, flew directly at thebridge of the aircraft carrierAkagi. The aircraft, either attempting a suicide ramming, or out of control, narrowly missed striking the carrier's bridge, which could have killed Nagumo, before it crashed into the ocean.[11][12]
Nagumo soon prepared to launch another attack on Midway, in direct violation of Yamamoto's order to keep the reserve strike force armed for anti-ship operations.[13] That change in plans required arming the available planes with bombs, suitable for attacking land targets, rather than torpedoes, designed for anti-ship actions.
However, when Nagumo received scouting reports that American ships were in the area, he changed plans and ordered his planes be rearmed with torpedoes to attack American ships.[14] The situation caught his aircraft in-between, with half his planes armed with torpedoes and the other half with bombs and no time to switch everything back to torpedoes.
American dive-bombers attackedAkagi,Kaga andSōryū, resulting in fires and further explosions due to unsecured ordnance, crippling all three. After the attack, Nagumo appeared to have gone into a state of shock;[15] he stood near the ship's compass looking out at the flames on his ship and two other carriers, and despite being asked to shift his flag to another vessel, Nagumo was reluctant, muttering, “It's not time yet”. Nagumo's chief of staff, Rear AdmiralRyūnosuke Kusaka, was able to persuade him; Nagumo nodded, with tears in his eyes.[16] Nagumo and his staff were forced to evacuate through the forward windows of the bridge by rope. An expert in judo, Nagumo landed lightly, whereas Kusaka badly sprained both ankles and was burned during the evacuation.[17]
The First Air Fleet lost four carriers during the turning point of thePacific War, and the massive losses of carrier aircraft maintenance personnel would prove detrimental to the performance of the IJN in later engagements. The loss of the four carriers, their aircraft, and their maintenance crews, plus the loss of 120 experienced pilots, resulted in Japan losing the strategic initiative in the Pacific.[18]
In the aftermath of the battle, Kusaka found a downcast Nagumo, seemingly contemplating suicide; Kusaka eventually talked him out of it. Following the battle, Nagumo appeared to have lost his aggressiveness and effectiveness; he teared up when talking about the events of Midway to his two sons in 1944.[19]
Later naval operations, Guadalcanal campaign and the Battle of Saipan
Afterwards, Nagumo was reassigned as commander-in-chief of theThird Fleet and commanded aircraft carriers in theGuadalcanal campaign in the battles of theEastern Solomons and theSanta Cruz Islands. Despite the Japanese victory at the Santa Cruz[20] Nagumo himself acknowledged that the attrition imposed to the Japanese Imperial Navy in these actions, especially with the loss of experienced pilots, was "shattering strategic loss for Japan", nowithstanding the tactical success.[21]
On 11 November 1942, Nagumo was reassigned to Japan, where he was given command of theSasebo Naval District. He then transferred to theKure Naval District on 21 June 1943. From October 1943 to February 1944, Nagumo was once again made commander-in-chief of First Fleet, which was by that time largely involved in only training duties to conserve what little remained of Japan's air force.[citation needed]
The Battle of Saipan began on 15 June 1944. The IJN, under Vice AdmiralJisaburō Ozawa, was overwhelmed within days by theU.S. 5th Fleet in the decisiveBattle of the Philippine Sea, where Japan lost three fleet carriers and about 600 aircraft, none of which could be replaced. Nagumo and his Army peer Lieutenant GeneralYoshitsugu Saito were now on their own to keep control ofSaipan.
On 6 July 1944, Nagumo, unable to defend his position any longer and refusing to be taken captive, killed himself with a pistol shot to his temple. Defeated commanders were expected to performseppuku in accordance withbushido, but he may not have had the time for such a complex ritual. His remains were recovered byU.S. Marines in a remote cave where he had been forced to maintain his headquarters due to extensive bombardment.[22] He was posthumously made a full admiral and awarded the Grand Cordon of theOrder of the Golden Kite.
Nagumo family in 1943 with Chūichi Nagumo in the middle
Nagumo's grave is located at the Ōbai-in sub-temple ofEngaku-ji inKamakura, next to the grave of his son, Susumu Nagumo, who was killed in battle aboard the destroyerKishinami on 4 December 1944.