The Battle of Valmy byHorace Vernet, 1826. The white-uniformed infantry to the right are regulars while the blue-coated ranks to the left represent the citizen volunteers of 1791. TheMoulin de Valmy was burnt on the orders of Kellermann on the day of the battle.
In this early part of the Revolutionary Wars—known as theWar of the First Coalition—thenew French government was in almost every way unproven, and thus the small, localized victory at Valmy became a huge psychological victory for the Revolution at large. The outcome was thoroughly unexpected by contemporary observers—a vindication for the French revolutionaries and a stunning defeat for the vaunted Prussian army. The victory emboldened the newly assembledNational Convention toformally declare the end of monarchy in France and to establish theFrench Republic. Valmy permitted the development of the Revolution and all its resultant ripple effects, and for that it is regarded by historians as one of the most significant battles in history.
As theFrench Revolution continued, the monarchies of Europe became concerned that revolutionary fervor would spread to their countries. TheWar of the First Coalition was an effort to stop the revolution, or at least contain it to France. KingFrederick William II of Prussia had the support ofGreat Britain and theAustrian Empire to send theDuke of Brunswick towards Paris with a large army.[1] In the war's early encounters of mid-1792, French troops did not distinguish themselves,[2] and enemy forces advanced dangerously deep into France intending to pacify the country, restore the traditional monarchy, and end the Revolution. The French commanderCharles Dumouriez, meanwhile, had been marching his army northeast to attack theAustrian Netherlands, but this plan was abandoned because of the more immediate threat to Paris.[3] A second army under GeneralFrançois Kellermann was ordered to link up with him in a mutual defense.[4]
Just over half of the French infantry wereregulars of the oldRoyal Army, as were nearly all of the cavalry and, most importantly, theartillery,[3][5] which were widely regarded as the best in Europe at the time.[6][7] These veterans provided a professional core to steady the enthusiastic volunteer battalions.[8] Combined, Dumouriez'Army of the North and Kellermann'sArmy of the Centre totalled approximately 54,000 troops.[9] Heading towards them was Brunswick's coalition army of about 84,000, drilled Prussian and Austrian troops augmented by large complements ofHessians and emigres of the FrenchroyalistArmy of Condé.[9]
The invading army handily capturedLongwy on 23 August andVerdun on 2 September, then moved on towardParis through thedefiles of theForest of Argonne.[6] In response, Dumouriez halted his advance to the Netherlands and reversed course, approaching the enemy army from its rear.[3] FromMetz, Kellermann moved to his assistance, joining him at the village ofSainte-Menehould on 19 September.[6]The French forces were now east of the Prussians, behind their lines. Theoretically the Prussians could have marched straight towards Paris unopposed, but this course was never seriously considered: the threat to their lines of supply and communication was too great to be ignored. The unfavorable situation was compounded by bad weather and an alarming increase in sickness among the troops. With few other options available, Brunswick turned back and prepared to do battle.[3]
The troops trudged laboriously through a heavy downpour—"rain as of the days of Noah", in the words ofThomas Carlyle.[10] Brunswick headed through the northern woods believing he could cut off Dumouriez. At the moment when the Prussianmanœuvre was nearly completed, Kellermann advanced his left wing and took up a position on the slopes between Sainte-Menehould and Valmy.[6] He centered his command aroundan old windmill, which he quickly razed to prevent enemy artillery spotters from using it as a sighting location.[11] His veteran artillerists were well-placed upon its accommodating ridge to begin the so-called "Cannonade of Valmy".[12] Brunswick moved toward them with about 34,000 of his troops.[9] As they emerged from the woods, a long-range gunnery duel ensued and the Frenchbatteries proved superior. The Prussian infantry made a cautious, and fruitless, effort to advance under fire across the open ground.[3]
Valmy obelisk with statue of Kellermann
As the Prussians wavered, a pivotal moment was reached when Kellermann raised his hat and made his famous cry of"Vive la Nation". The cry was repeated again and again by all the French army, and had a crushing effect upon Prussian morale. The French troops sang "La Marseillaise" and "Ça Ira", and a cheer went up from the French line.[13] To the surprise of nearly everyone, Brunswick broke off the action and retired from the field. The Prussians rounded the French positions at a great distance and commenced a rapid retreat eastward. The two engaged forces had been essentially equal in size, Kellermann with approximately 36,000 troops and 40 cannon, and Brunswick with 34,000 and 54 cannon. Yet by the time Brunswick retreated, casualties had risen no higher than three hundred French and two hundred Prussians.[14]
The precipitous end to the action provoked elation among the French.[3] The question of exactly why the Prussians withdrew has never been definitively answered. Most historians ascribe the retreat to some combination of the following factors: the highly defensible French position[3] together with the rapidly growing numbers of reinforcements and citizen volunteers[15] with their discouraging and thoroughly unexpectedélan[16] which persuaded the cautious Brunswick to spare himself a dangerous loss of manpower,[17] particularly when theRussian invasion of Poland had already raised concerns for Prussia's defensibility in the east.[15] Others have put forward more shadowy motives for the decision, including a secret plea byLouis XVI to avoid an action which might cost him his life, and even bribery of the Prussians, allegedly paid for with theBourbon crown jewels.[18]
An analysis by Munro Price, reader in history at the University of Bradford and a modern specialist in this period, concludes that there is no convincing proof of bribery turning back the Prussians.[19] The more likely explanation remains that, having initially adopted an aggressive strategy, Brunswick lacked the will to carry it through when confronted by an unexpectedly determined and disciplined opposition.[20] Brunswick had actually been offered command of the French armies prior to the outbreak of war and émigré factions subsequently used this as a basis to allege treachery on his part. In any case, the battle ended decisively, the French pursuit was not seriously pressed,[21] and Brunswick's troops managed a safe if inglorious eastward retreat.[22]
This engagement was the turning point of the Prussians' campaign. Beset with food shortages anddysentery, their retreat continued well past theRhine River.[22] French troops soon struck forward into Germany,taking Mainz in October. Dumouriez once again moved against theAustrian Netherlands and Kellermann ably secured the front at Metz.[22]
Dumouriez would bear a harsh change of fortune: after one more influential success in November 1792 atJemappes, he was by the following year a broken man. His army had suffered such catastrophic losses that he defected to the royalist side for the rest of his life.[23] Kellermann, however, continued in a long and distinguished military career. In 1808 he was ennobled byNapoleon and becameDuke of Valmy.[24]
A modern replica of the windmill atValmy stands amid a memorial site.
In terms of military history the battle introduced features that reshaped modern warfare. It exemplified key components of "total war" in terms of political propaganda,psychological warfare, and eager participation of large numbers of politicized civilians.[12]
After a while the battle came to be celebrated as the first great victory of the armies of the French Revolution.[25] In the variedhistoriography of the French Revolution, it is typically portrayed as the first victory of acitizen army, inspired byliberty andnationalism. Many thousands of volunteers did indeed swell the ranks, but at least half of the French forces were professional soldiers, particularly among Kellermann's critical artillery units.[3] The French artillery also held a tactical advantage in its modernGribeauval gun system which proved highly successful on the battlefield.[7] But in popular conception, Valmy was a victory of citizen-soldiers: the battle was emblemized by Kellermann's cry, augmented by the troops' singing of "La Marseillaise" and the "Ça Ira" while under fire.[22]
On the day of the battle, the Legislative Assembly had duly transferred its power to the National Convention.[21]Over the next two days, flush with the news from Valmy, the new Convention deputiesabolished the monarchy and proclaimed theFrench Republic.[26] The victory was a much-needed source of pride for the revolutionary French state, and provided enduring inspiration for the years that followed.[16] It was considered by many contemporaries to be a miraculous event for France, and a "decisive defeat" for one of the most effective armies in Europe.[27] Scholars continue to count it among the most significant clashes in military history.[14][28]
The Prussians themselves recognized the importance of the battle, not merely as a setback in the war but as a crucial advancement for the Revolution as a whole.[29] The German writer and poetJohann Wolfgang von Goethe, who was present at the battle with the Prussian army, later wrote that he was approached by some of his comrades in a state of dejection. He had previously cheered them up with memorable and clever quotes but his only consolation this time was, "Here and today, a new epoch in the history of the world has begun, and you can boast you were present at its birth."[26]
Mauzaisse Jean Baptiste - Louis-Philippe visite le champ de bataille de Valmy - 1837
In command of a brigade ofdragoons at the battle was the 18 year-oldLouis Philippe, futureDuke of Orleans andKing of the French.[30][31] In his official report of the battle, Kellerman singled out the young Louis Philippe for his courage during the cannonade. Decades later, Louis Philippe's military service was used to justify theOrleanist bid for the throne in the immediate aftermath of theJuly Revolution of 1830.[32] To legitimize himself in the eyes of liberals and nationalists, Louis-Philippe promoted himself as a patriotic citizen-king who had served in the army of the First Republic. He commissioned artworks depicting his military service such asThe National Guard of Paris Departs for the Army andLouis-Philippe visiting the battlefield of Valmy.