"As It Was" is a song by English singer-songwriterHarry Styles, released throughErskine andColumbia on 1 April 2022 as the lead single from his third studio album,Harry's House (2022). The song was written by Styles alongside his producersKid Harpoon andTyler Johnson.
"As It Was" was widely acclaimed by music critics and entered at the top of theUK singles chart, becoming Styles' second solo number-one single, his first being "Sign of the Times" in April 2017. "As It Was" spent ten weeks at the top of the UK Singles Chart, becoming the longest-running number-one and best-selling single of 2022 in his home country. In the United States, it was his second chart-topper on theBillboard Hot 100, where it spent 15 non-consecutive weeks at number one, becoming the longest-running US number one by a UK act and thefourth-longest-running number one in the chart's history. It also spent 38 weeks in theBillboard Hot 100 top ten, making it the sixth longest-charting song in the region. It was ranked at number 500 onRolling Stone's 500 Greatest Songs of All Time on the 2024 revision.
"As It Was" was thebest-selling global single of 2022, earning 2.28 billion subscription stream equivalents globally according to theInternational Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI). Outside the UK and US, the song was a commercial success and topped the charts in 45 countries, including Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, France, Germany, Ireland, Lithuania, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Singapore, Sweden, and Norway.
Harry Styles announced the title of his third studio album asHarry's House on 23 March 2022, unveiling its artwork, a 40-second trailer, and the album's release date as 20 May 2022.[1][2] Five days later, he announced the title of its lead single as "As It Was", alongside 3 pictures of Styles facing away from the camera in a sequinned, sleeveless red outfit, and set its release date as 1 April 2022.[3][4][5] Simultaneously, posters bearing the lyrics "It's not the same As It Was" and a picture of Styles sitting on a big ball appeared in various cities.[6] He released a teaser of the music video on 30 March, which included an "energeticdrum beat" and a "sunny electric guitarriff", and depicted him in a red jumpsuit spinning in circles atop a motorised turntable.[7]
In an interview withBillboard, Kid Harpoon revealed Styles pushed for the track to become the lead single for the album campaign, stating: "It was Harry that pushed that through. He was like, ‘This is the one. I’m telling you.’ But everyone was like, ‘It should be this other one.’"[8]
"As It Was" was the last song written for Styles' third album,Harry's House.[9] The song was recorded atSony Music Entertainment CEORob Stringer's house in England. In an interview withConsequence of Sound, producer Kid Harpoon stated "We moved all the furniture out and put a drum kit in the TV room. "As It Was" was done in that setup. Harry came in with a riff idea, and we ran with it."[10] In an interview withHits Radio, Styles said the song was originally written slower before adding synths and drums.[11] He called the original voice note of the slower track "a death march" in an interview with Zane Lowe,[12] although the existence of this version has been disputed by Kid Harpoon.[13] Speaking toMusic Week, producer Tyler Johnson stated the track was almost completed in its final form after three or four days[14] with the bridge of the song being written a few days later.[15]
Johnson described the process of writing the single as: "Harry was sitting on theMoog One and I liked what he was playing, so I sat down and played as he started to write the melodies and the lyrics. I said to Harry, 'We need a lead line' and he just came up right away with the 'Dah, dah, dah...' part. He didn't hesitate. Then he started writing the second verse and referring to himself in the third person. So much of this song just came from Harry's heart. And then Tom, with this magical sense of hooks that he has, came up with the idea of doing, 'You know it's not the same...' in the chorus, which I was very impressed with. That turned out to be a very smart move."[14] Styles came up with the idea and melody of the tubular bells included on the track, and plays them on the finished product.[15]
The child's voice which opens the track is Styles' godchild Ruby Winston, daughter of producerBen Winston. Styles explained the addition in an interview withCapital Breakfast: "She used to try and call me before bedtime every night, and one time it didn't ring or something, so they sent me that. I dug it out when we were in the studio and put it in front of the song for some reason, and I kind of just fell in love with it, so it stuck."[16]
Styles described the meaning of the song as "about metamorphosis, embracing change and former self, perspective shift and all that kind of stuff. It just felt like the thing I wanted to say, the thing I wanted to be doing and the kind of music I wanted to make coming back."[17]
Music critics described the song as a guitar-drivensynth-pop andnew wave track, a noticeable shift from Styles'srock-oriented sounds.[18][19][20][21][22] Chris Willman ofVariety noted it takes heavy inspiration fromDepeche Mode andA-ha, while also suggesting it adopted a style similar tothe Weeknd's 2019 single "Blinding Lights".[19]Euphoria magazine felt that Styles was inspired byJames Bay's 2018 single "Pink Lemonade", adding that the two songs sound "eerily similar".[23] Lyrically, "As It Was" is rooted in personal transitions and depicts a feeling of loss and loneliness.[24]
"As It Was" received widespread critical acclaim.NME's Rhian Daly gave the song five out of five stars, describing it as "not a million miles away from whereFine Line left off, but hardly retreading old ground." According to Daly, the track suggestsHarry's House will solidify Styles "as one of the current pop landscapes' greats".[26] Beau Beaumont-Thomas ofThe Guardian also rated the song five stars and called it "one of his very best", writing, "Many will pore over the gossipy, self-referential lyrics, but Styles's song is for everyone: an effervescent, high-tempo hit to have you clicking your heels."[25] In his review forRolling Stone,Rob Sheffield regarded "As It Was" as one of Styles's most "emotionally powerful" songs, calling it a "daring change-up" and a "straight-from-the-heart cry that's also an irresistible dance-floor challenge."[20] Sahar Ghadirian ofClash magazine deemed it a "powerhouse" and Styles "at his most vulnerable". Ghadirian appreciated the "dream fusion" of synth-pop with electro rock and commented that thebells end the song on "a euphoric high".[27] Thania Garcia ofVariety magazine described the song as being "new wave-inspired".[28] Hugh McIntyre ofForbes hailed the song as a "decade-defining smash."[29]
Evening Standard reviewer Jochan Embley meanwhile found the track inferior to the singer's previous singles "Watermelon Sugar" and "Adore You", but wrote that Styles and his collaborators "still know how to make an instantly enjoyable tune".[30] Olivia Horn ofPitchfork was less impressed and bemoaned that the song "winds down without any real payoff", citing the circuitousness of the lyrics as "a frequent shortcoming in Styles' songwriting."[31]
Entertainment Weekly named "As It Was" as the best song of 2022: "The synths gallop like excitable ponies while his warm-wash vocals swoop and dip, a sweet little slice of life-support disco for the lonely."[32]USA Today also chose it as the best song of the year: "At first, it sounds like a generically pretty pop song. But then you understand Styles' longing for the perfect something that was yanked away, his dreamy vocals taking on a sadness as he recalls that blissful bubble and resigns himself with a sigh to his current reality. The giggly opening by his goddaughter, pillowy '80s-rooted synths, tubular bells and urging beat contradict his pensiveness."[33]Billboard ranked it at number 3 on their "The 100 Best Songs of 2022" list: "Coming in at a lean 2:47, "As It Was" serves as a broader anthem about how nothing is "the same as it was" before thepandemic, but on a micro level, it turns out Styles isn't the same either as he grapples with fame and the realization that "he's no good alone" when left to his own devices and pills."[34]
BBC ranked it at number 3 on their "25 of the best songs released in 2022" list: "As It Was is a vapour trail of a song, silvery and airborne, as Harry Styles searches for meaning amidst break-ups and loneliness and personal turmoil."[35]NME ranked it at number 3 on their "The 50 best songs of 2022" list: "It's hard not to tumble into the vast emotional depths of 'As It Was' and look beyond everything else that made this song such a triumph. Change is a constant beneath the track's heart-raising BPM and twinkling melodies: here, Harry Styles' empathetic songwriting saw him fight for stability amid breakups and personal upheavals, finding strength in a renewed relationship with himself."[36]The Guardian ranked it at number 5 on their "The 20 best songs of 2022" list: "Occupying the slim valley betweenA-ha'sTake On Me andVampire Weekend, As It Was delivers bruised-peach hurt, sophisticated languor from the back seat of a tastefully expensive car. He can sing something as vague as "In this world, it's just us / You know it's not the same as it was" and make you feel that he really means it"[37]i-D ranked it at number 10 on their "The 100 best songs of 2022" list: "For an artist reckoning with blinding attention towards his public persona, this infectious, upbeat song about loneliness and change felt like a balm both for the artist and his fans."[38]
NPR ranked it at number 12 on their "100 Best Songs Of 2022" list: "Like a fling who would have never dated you in real life saying arrivederci at summer's end, this song is by turns forlorn, resigned, apologetic and a little caddish. Its slippery nostalgia is grounded in a synth line evoking the New Romantic era of Styles' parents' youth and in the singer's cool, bossa nova-ish croon, which sounds like the way it feels when that departing lover wistfully strokes your hair. The Easter-eggy verses matter to fans, but the chorus is what made "As It Was" so sticky in 2022: It renders regret comfortable, a service everyone needs in a time of chronic heartbreak."[39]Complex ranked it at number 27 on their "50 Best Songs of 2022" list: ""As It Was" is a beautiful, mesmerizing record that lives up to all the buzz it's generated onTikTok (and everywhere else on the internet and radio). It carries an energetic tone thanks to the uptempo instrumentation, and Harry Styles adds layers of emotion with his soft vocals. "As It Was" is a fun and danceable record that continues to demonstrate his power as one of the biggest pop stars in the world."[40]Paste ranked it at number 29 on their "The 50 Best Songs of 2022" list: "Our first glimpse into Harry Styles' newest era, where he is fully immersed in his own flamboyant intricacies, the song is a thoughtful rumination on the exhaustion that stems from not enough love and too much fame."[41]
The Fader ranked it at number 33 on their "The 100 best songs of 2022" list: "OnHarry's House lead single "As It Was," the singer hits an effervescent pitch both sonically and conceptually, expressing a willingness to embrace introspection while delivering one of the most textured performances in his loaded discography."[42]Pitchfork ranked it at number 100 on their "The 100 Best Songs of 2022" list: ""As It Was" is the kind of twinkly little confection that would easily get the indie kids pogoing at any local DIY dance night at any point in the last two decades. It just happens to have been recorded by one of the biggest pop stars in the world in 2022 instead of, say,the Strokes twenty years earlier. "You know it's not the same as it was," Harry Styles sighs, giving a nod to the easy bait of nostalgia. A pointillist synth line tap dances through the song, and all over that nagging pandemic-era malaise we're all desperately trying to shake. Resistance is futile."[43]
Associated Press placed it on their "Top Songs of 2022" list: "The song is deceptively upbeat with a jingly synth-pop beat and a little kid's voice as the intro and wedding bells at the end. But the lyrics are self-referentially melancholic as he accepts the reality of change that even he is not quite ready for."[44]Esquire placed it on their "The 45 Best Songs of 2022" list: ""As It Was" was Harry Styles first single this year, and it did not disappoint. This glittering track fuels nostalgia as Styles sings about life which is, of course, always changing. (Reality bites!)"[45]
"As It Was" was praised by many musicians and those within the entertainment industry.Sir Elton John declared the track as "one of the great records of the year" and that it should winSong of The Year atThe Grammys.[46]Lindsay Buckingham praised the song as "a great pop song" in discussion withOmar Apollo.[47]Jon Bon Jovi stated "It is not going to be the same as it was folks, I love that because he gave you a slap upside the head and said, “I’m here with you but doing it on my terms.”[48] Artists such asJorja Smith andArcade Fire also covered the song in theLive Lounge.[49][50]
"As It Was" was an immediate success; it earned theGuinness World Records title for the most streamed track onSpotify within 24 hours by a male artist, and broke theApple Music streaming record for most first-day streams for a 2022 release.[66][67] The song also opened atop theBillboard Global 200 with the greatest global streaming week of 2022, becoming Styles's first number-one on the tally.[68] Globally, "As It Was" was thebest-selling global single of 2022, earning 2.28 billion subscription streams equivalents globally according to theInternational Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI).[69] It was also the fifth best-selling global single of 2023 with 1.46 billion subscription streams equivalents.[70] "As It Was" ranked as the most popular song on Spotify and the second most popular song on Apple Music in 2022.[71] It was the 3rd most streamed song on Spotify and the 14th biggest song on Apple Music in 2023.[72][73]
The song reached number one on the official charts of Australia,[74] Austria,[75] Belgium,[76] Croatia,[77] Denmark,[78] Germany,[79] Greece,[80] Ireland,[81] Israel,[82] Lithuania,[83] the Netherlands,[84] New Zealand,[85] Slovakia,[86] Sweden,[87] and Switzerland.[88]
In the UK, "As It Was" became Styles's second solo number-one on thesingles chart, debuting with the biggest sales and streaming weeks of any single in 2022.[89] It spent ten weeks at number one on the UK singles chart, becoming the longest-running number one of the year in the UK.[90] It became the most-streamed track (149.6 million streams), most physically purchased (12,000 units), most digitally downloaded (47,000 units) and overall, best-selling (1.3 millionequivalent units) track in the UK in 2022, as of October 2022[update].[91] It was the 9th biggest song in the UK in 2023 according to theOfficial Charts Company.[92]
"As It Was" entered at number one on theBillboard Hot 100, becoming Styles' second number-one single after "Watermelon Sugar" (2019).[93] The song garnered the most single-day streams on Spotify in the United States, surpassingOlivia Rodrigo's "Drivers License" (2021).[94] After the single's debut at No. 1, "As It Was" fell out of the No. 1 position and returned multiple times between April and September 2022; when it returned to No. 1 for the week ending 3 September 2022, it became the first song ever to have five separate runs in the top position.[95] "As It Was" spent 15 weeks atop theBillboard Hot 100, becoming the longest-running US number one by a UK act, the second longest-running No. 1 with no accompanying artists (i.e. a solo-billed song) and the fourth longest running number-one in the chart's history.[96][97] In addition, "As It Was" spent 18 weeks at number one on theCanadian Hot 100.[98]
The music video for "As It Was" was released alongside the song.[99] In the clip, Styles joins dancer Mathilde Lin on a turning platform and performs choreography byYoann Bourgeois[100][101] in theBarbican to release negative emotions.[18] The video was filmed in London: apart from theBarbican Centre and Barbican Conservatory, atLindley Hall near theHouses of Parliament, and at thepenguin pool atLondon Zoo.[102] It was directed byTanu Muino, who stated that directing for Styles was "a bucket list dream come true" but, on the second day of shooting, Muino's home country ofUkraine was invaded by Russia, rendering the process a "bittersweet" experience; nevertheless, Muino and her team from Ukraine "poured so much love into this video and you can see it on screen. The music video references a photo mural of industrial designersCharles and Ray Eames on exhibit atLACMA as Styles and his love interest grow further apart.[103] It will be a music video I will never forget and now I can happily retire.".[99] Styles later released aBehind The Scenes version of the making of the music video.[104]
Styles performed "As It Was" for the first time at theCoachella Valley Music and Arts Festival on 15 and 22 April 2022.[130] At the'One Night Only' performance forHarry's House, Styles surprised the crowd atUBS Arena with an encore of the track. Speaking on the experience toRolling Stone, Styles stated: "We came offstage, and I went into my dressing room and just wanted to sit by myself for a minute, AfterOne Direction, I didn’t expect to ever experience anything new. I kind of felt like, ‘All right, I’ve seen how crazy it can get and I think there was something about it where I was … not terrified, but I just needed a minute. Because I wasn’t sure what it was. Just that the energy felt insane."[131]
Styles performed As It Was at the65th Annual Grammy Awards with a rotating stage and routine choreographed in the style of the music video by Yoann Bourgeois.[132] However, a technical malfunction caused the stage to rotate the wrong way and forced the dancers with Styles to perform the dance in reverse.[133] Dancers included in the routine stated "there was nothing we could do to stop it" once the performance began.[132] Styles "called the team in charge to make sure they were OK" after the performance according to Grammys set designer Julio Himede.[133]
^Brathwaite, Lester Fabian; Greenblatt, Leah; Hall, Gerrad; Lamphier, Jason; Myers, Owen; Travis, Emlyn (14 December 2022)."The 10 best songs of 2022".Entertainment Weekly.Archived from the original on 10 December 2022. Retrieved10 December 2022.
^Caraballo, Ecleen Luzmila; Skelton, Eric; McKinney, Jessica; Rose, Jordan; Blanchet, Brenton (21 December 2022)."The Best Songs of 2022". Complex.Archived from the original on 18 April 2023. Retrieved18 April 2023.
^Ross, Alex Robert; Darville, Jordan; Williams-Kirtley, Gyasi; Renshaw, David; Raw, Son; Madden, Emma; Paul, Larisha; Elder, Sajae; Helfand, Raphael (15 December 2022)."The 100 best songs of 2022".The Fader.Archived from the original on 16 December 2022. Retrieved18 April 2023.
^ab"ČNS IFPI". IFPI ČR. Note: Select SK SINGLES DIGITAL TOP 100 and insert 202214 into search.Archived from the original on 3 November 2020. Retrieved11 April 2022.
^"APRA AMCOS: 2023 APRA Music Awards".APRA AMCOS (Australasian Performing Right Association and Australasian Mechanical Copyright Owners Society). 27 April 2023.Archived from the original on 6 May 2023. Retrieved30 April 2023.
^"Top 100 Brasil: 26 September 2022 - 30 September 2022" (in Brazilian Portuguese).Crowley Broadcast Analysis.Archived from the original on 31 July 2019. Retrieved16 May 2022.Note: In SEMANA REFERÊNCIA select 26 September 2022 – 30 September 2022. To access the full Top 100, click on VER TOP 100 COMPLETO and enter your name and email. Then enter the code you received by email.
^"ČNS IFPI" (in Czech). Hitparáda – Radio Top 100 Oficiální. IFPI Czech Republic.Note: Select 23. týden 2022 in the date selector. Retrieved 13 June 2022.
^"ČNS IFPI" (in Czech). Hitparáda – Digital Top 100 Oficiální. IFPI Czech Republic.Note: Select 14. týden 2022 in the date selector. Retrieved 11 April 2022.
^"Top Singles (Week 17, 2022)" (in French). Syndicat National de l'Édition Phonographique.Archived from the original on 10 May 2022. Retrieved2 May 2022.
^"Media Forest – Weekly Charts".Media Forest. Retrieved September 24, 2024.Note: Select 'Songs – TV'. Romanian and international positions are rendered together by the number of plays before resulting an overall chart.
^"ČNS IFPI" (in Slovak). Hitparáda – Radio Top 100 Oficiálna. IFPI Czech Republic.Note: Select 31. týden 2022 in the date selector. Retrieved 8 August 2022.
