TheKu Klux Klan (KKK) used the phrase at the organization's peak in the 1920s, when racist,xenophobic sentiment was widespread;[13][14] it informed many of their members who ran for political office.[15] TheImmigration Act of 1924, sponsored byWashington U.S. representativeAlbert Johnson, was a legislative expression of xenophobia. It targeted Japanese, eastern and southern European immigrants by excluding them on the basis of ethnicity and national origin in an effort to preserve the country’s existing ethnic demographics.[16] Johnson's leading role in the immigration restriction bill elicited strong support from the KKK.[17]
In later periods, the slogan was used byPat Buchanan, who praised the non-interventionist WWII America First Committee and said "the achievements of that organization are monumental."[23] Buchanan's "call for an America First foreign policy has been compared with the America First Committee."[24]
"President Trump's Six Months of America First", a video released by theWhite House
Donald Trump, who had run against Pat Buchanan in the2000 Reform Party presidential primaries, first revived the slogan in a November 2015op-ed inThe Wall Street Journal.[25] In its early going, the Trump campaign publicized an article byJeff Kuhner on theWorld Tribune praising the candidate as a "nationalist who seeks to put America first";[26] campaign managerCorey Lewandowski (who later published a book with the title)[27] promoted Trump with the phrase;[28][29] and bothSarah Palin[30] andChris Christie[31] featured it in their endorsements of Trump. Trump later incorporated the slogan into his daily repertoire following a suggestion byDavid E. Sanger during an interview withThe New York Times in March 2016, borrowing it from an article that appeared earlier in the month in USA Today[32] and written by U.S. diplomatArmand Cucciniello.[33][34] In subsequent months, without referencing Pat Buchanan's prior usage or theAmerica First Committee, candidate Trump promised that "'America First' would be the major and overriding theme" of his administration, and advocated nationalist, anti-interventionist positions.[35][34]
In 2017, the administration proposed afederal budget for 2018 with both "Make America Great Again" and "America First" in its title, with the latter referencing its increases to military, homeland security, and veteran spending, cuts to spending that goes towards foreign countries, and 10-year objective of achieving abalanced budget.[48]
The administration branded its 2017National Security Strategy of the U.S. as "an America First National Security Strategy". The introduction to that document reads "This National Security Strategy puts America first. An America First National Security Strategy is based on American principles, a clear-eyed assessment of U.S. interests, and a determination to tackle the challenges that we face. It is a strategy of principled realism that is guided by outcomes, not ideology."[49]
Trump's use of the slogan was criticized by some for carrying comparisons to the America First Committee;[50] however, Trump denied being an isolationist, and said:
Not isolationist, I’m not isolationist, but I am ‘America First.’ So I like the expression. I’m ‘America First.’[51]
A number of scholars (such asDeborah Dash Moore), commentators (such asBill Kristol) and Jewish organizations (including theAnti-Defamation League andJewish Council for Public Affairs) criticized Trump's use of the slogan because of its historical association withnativism and antisemitism.[51][52] Others have argued that Trump was never a non-interventionist.[53] Columnist Daniel Larison fromThe American Conservative wrote that "Trump was quick to denounce previous wars as disasters, but his complaint about these wars was that the U.S. wasn't 'getting' anything tangible from them. He didn't see anything wrong in attacking other countries, but lamented that the U.S. didn't 'take' their resources" and that "he never called for an end to the wars that were still ongoing, but talked only about 'winning' them."[54]
Trump's "America First" policy has been described as a major factor in the perceived increase in the international non-interventionism of the U.S. in the late 2010s, and various media critics such asThe New Yorker have described the policy as "America Alone".[7][8][9]
White nationalist commentatorNick Fuentes has made contemporary use of the phrase, citing Trump andhis presidency as an inspiration for his show.
In mid-2016, while running for a Louisiana Senate seat,David Duke, former Grand Wizard of the KKK, publicly claimed that he was "the first major candidate in modern times to promote the term and policy of America first"[55] (although was preceded by Donald Trump).[25][33][34]
Trump's successor as U.S. president,Joe Biden, discontinued many of Trump'sCOVID-19-related "America First" policies at the beginning of his presidency, but he initially kept the Trump administration'sCOVID-19 vaccine export ban in place.[56] As of May 2021, the U.S. had started exporting vaccines out of its borders.[57] TheU.S. House Select Committee on the January 6 Attack describedfar-right political commentatorNick Fuentes and formerIdentity Evropa leader Patrick Carey as leaders of the "America First" movement in asubpoena issued in January 2022.[58]
Following Trump's inauguration, the policy and its phrasing became a subject of international satire through theEvery Second Counts video contest inspired by Dutch comedianArjen Lubach.News satire television programs initially throughout Europe, and later from around the world, comically appealed to Trump to acknowledge their own countries in light of Trump's nationalist slogan, with a narrator mimicking Trump's voice, speech patterns, and exaggerated speaking style.[59][60] Lubach's initial version, for example, ended by noting that "We totally understand it's going to be America first, but can we just say: The Netherlands second?".[61][62]
Several prominent U.S. officials from both political parties have criticized aspects of the “America First” approach. Former Secretaries of State Hillary Clinton and Mike Pompeo both described the Pentagon’s “America First” reset as a “disaster,” warning that it could put the United States at a competitive disadvantage against countries like China and Russia.[64] Clinton also argued that focusing U.S. attention solely on the Western Hemisphere might embolden adversaries abroad, while Pompeo agreed, emphasizing that the U.S. should maintain its global influence.[64]
This debate highlights a clear divide in U.S. politics. Supporters of the slogan argue that putting national interests first is essential to protect the country at home. Critics contend that an “America Alone” approach could isolate the United States and weaken the international partnerships and alliances that have sustained its global influence.[65]
Analysts and policy commentators have identified several challenges associated with the doctrine. These include reduced U.S. credibility in international institutions and reduced influence in coalition diplomacy. Some observers have also noted tensions within the America First movement, as some supporters feel the administration’s words do not always align with its actions on immigration, trade, and economic policies. Together, these critiques highlight a tension between prioritizing national interests alone and maintaining the cooperative frameworks essential for U.S. leadership abroad.[66][65]
^Cox, Michael; Durham, Martin (2000). "The Politics of Anger: The Extreme Right in the United States". In Hainsworth, Paul (ed.).The Politics of the Extreme Right: From the Margins to the Mainstream. London/New York: Pinter. p. 287.ISBN1-85567-459-9.
^abTrump, Donald J. (November 10, 2015)."Ending China's Currency Manipulation".The Wall Street Journal.Archived from the original on May 16, 2020. RetrievedJuly 9, 2020.The American people need an administration that will tell them the truth and a president who will put America first. That's what I intend to do.
^abMcKay, Hollie:"How President Trump delivered on a number of foreign policy pledges," October 22, 2020,Fox News, retrieved January 19, 2024; quote:"Trump doubled-down by withdrawing the United States from a bevy of United Nations agencies and institutions, such as the World Health Organization and the Human Rights Council."
^abO'Reilly, Andrew:"Trump administration withdrawing from UN Human Rights Council," June 19, 2018,Fox News, retrieved January 19, 2024; quote:"The move... extends a broader Trump administration pattern of stepping back from international agreements and forums under the president's "America First" policy."