Movatterモバイル変換


[0]ホーム

URL:


Jump to content
WikipediaThe Free Encyclopedia
Search

2024 Montana Initiative 128

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Initiative 128

November 5, 2024 (2024-11-05)
A constitutional initiative that would amend the Montana Constitution to expressly provide a right to make and carry out decisions about one's own pregnancy, including the right to abortion. It would prohibit the government from denying or burdening the right to abortion before fetal viability. It would also prohibit the government from denying or burdening access to an abortion when a treating health-care professional determines it is medically indicated to protect the pregnant patient's life or health. The initiative would prevent the government from penalizing patients, health-care providers, or anyone who assists someone in exercising their right to make and carry out voluntary decisions about their pregnancy.
Results
Choice
Votes%
Yes345,07057.76%
No252,30042.24%
Valid votes597,370100.00%
Invalid or blank votes00.00%
Total votes597,370100.00%

County results
Congressional district results
Precinct results

Yes

  90–100%
  80–90%
  70–80%
  60–70%
  50–60%

No

  90–100%
  80–90%
  70–80%
  60–70%
  50–60%

Elections in Montana
Presidential elections
Presidential primaries
Democratic
2000
2004
2008
2016
2020
2024
Republican
2008
2012
2016
2020
2024
U.S. Senate elections
U.S. House of Representatives elections

Initiative 128 was aballot initiative that appeared on the ballot on November 5, 2024, to establish in theConstitution of Montana aright to abortion up tofetal viability. The initiative was approved by 57.8 percent of voters.[1]

History

[edit]
Main article:Abortion in Montana

In 1999, theMontana Supreme Court ruled inArmstrong v. State that the state constitution'sright to privacy includes abortion access. GovernorGreg Gianforte called on the Montana Supreme Court to revisit its decision inArmstrong, following theU.S. Supreme Court's decision inDobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, which overturnedRoe v. Wade andPlanned Parenthood v. Casey.[2] In May 2023, the Montana Supreme Court unanimously ruled inWeems v. State that the right to abortion was protected under the state constitution's right to privacy, reaffirming its prior ruling inArmstrong.[3]

In November 2022, Montana voters narrowly rejectedLegislative Referendum 131, which would have defined certain infants as "born alive" and compelled medical practitioners to provide life-sustaining care to them, no matter the prognosis, with 52.55 percent of voters opposed.[4] Since then, Gianforte has signed into law several bills restricting abortion access, including legislation to bandilation and evacuation abortions and another prohibitingMedicare andMedicaid funding for abortions, unless they are the result of rape or incest,[5] though many of these laws have been challenged or struck down in court.[6][7][8]

In November 2023, Montanans Securing Reproductive Rights (MSRR) proposed Ballot Measure #14, which would affirm the right to abortion in the Montana Constitution.[9] In January 2024, Attorney GeneralAustin Knudsen challenged the legal sufficiency of the ballot initiative, claiming that the measure "logrolls multiple distinct political choices into a single initiative" and "limits the ability of the state to provide for public health and safety".[10] The Montana Supreme Court rejected Knudsen's challenge in a 6–1 ruling in March 2024,[11] after which Knudsen sought to rewrite the language of the ballot initiative, which was immediately challenged by the MSRR as "confusing, argumentative, and prejudicial".[12] The Supreme Court again rewrote the ballot language in a 6–0 ruling on April 1, 2024, and allowed the ballot initiative to bypass the requirement that it go before an interim committee for an up or down vote since Knudsen never found the proposal to be legally sufficient.[13] Following this ruling, Montana Senate PresidentJason Ellsworth formed a new special select committee to study judicial oversight and reforms, accusing the Supreme Court of overstepping the separation of powers and alleging multiple other courts of violating the state constitution.[14] Ellsworth also issued a subpoena to Jacobsen for all records tied to Ballot Issue 14, which he said would be "used by a legislative interim committee" to review the ballot issue.[15] The legislative interim committee met on April 18 and voted 6–0 not to support Ballot Measure #14, with the two Democratic members of the committee and groups making up Montanans Securing Reproductive Rights declining to attend the meeting.[16]

Montana Secretary of StateChristi Jacobsen sent MSRR its ballot petition on April 5, 2024, a day after the Montana Supreme Court ordered her to do so.[17][18] MSRR began collecting signatures for Initiative 128 in April 2024,[19] and submitted about 117,000 signatures for the ballot initiative on June 21, 2024.[20][21] In July 2024, MSRR accused theMontana Secretary of State of invalidating the signatures of inactive voters,[22] prompting a legal challenge.[23] On July 16, Lewis and Clark County District Court judge Mike Menahan ordered the Montana Secretary of State to revert rule changes that led its office to invalidate these signatures and to restore the ones it had rejected.[24] Jacobsen appealed this ruling to the Montana Supreme Court, which unanimously upheld Menahan's ruling.[25] County election officials verified 81,163 signatures as of July 24, 2024, putting Initiative 128 on the 2024 general ballot.[26]

Campaign

[edit]

Initiative 128 was supported by Montanans Securing Reproductive Rights, which is led by Martha Fuller, the president of Planned Parenthood Advocates of Montana, and includes theACLU of Montana andForward Montana.[19] It was opposed by the Montana Life Defense Fund, which is chaired by Jeff Laszloffy, the president of theMontana Family Foundation.[27] As of October 2024, pro-amendment groups spent over $11 million on ads supporting Initiative 128, compared to about $105,000 for the referendum's opponents.[28]Susan B. Anthony Pro-Life America andStudents for Life of America have also reported spending about $160,000 on canvassing efforts opposing Initiative 128.[29]

Supporters of Initiative 128 argued that the constitutional amendment is necessary to prevent Republican legislators from passing bills to restrict abortion in the state.[30] The initiative's opponents argued that the amendment, if passed, would enablelate-term abortions and overturn state laws banningMedicaid funding for abortion and requiring parental notification for minors that terminate their pregnancies. Initiative 128 would allow the government to regulate abortions after fetal viability, which it defines as the point in pregnancy when a treating medical provider finds that there is a significant likelihood that a fetus would be able to survive outside the uterus without extraordinary medical measures.[29]

Endorsements

[edit]
Yes

U.S. Senators

Statewide officials

State legislators

Individuals

Organizations

No

U.S. representatives

Statewide officials

State legislators

  • Jason Ellsworth, president of the Montana Senate (2023–present) from the 43rd district (2019–present) (Republican)[43]
  • Jodee Etchart, state representative from the 48th district (2023–present) (Republican)[16]
  • Chris Friedel, state senator from the 26th district (2021–present) (Republican)[44]
  • Greg Hertz, state senator from the 6th district (2021–present) (Republican)[45]
  • Caleb Hinkle, state representative from the 68th district (2021–present) (Republican)[16]
  • Amy Regier, state representative from the 6th district (2021–present) (Republican)[43]
  • Keith Regier, state senator from the 3rd district (2017–present) (Republican)[16]
  • Linda Reksten, state representative from the 12th district (2021–present) (Republican)[45]

Individuals

Organizations

Declined to endorse

Organizations

Opinion polls

[edit]
Poll sourceDate(s)
administered
Sample
size[b]
Margin
of error
ForAgainstUndecided
MSU Billings[48]September 30 – October 16, 2024760 (LV)± 3.6%60%25%10%

Results

[edit]
2024 Montana Initiative 128[49]
ChoiceVotes%
Referendum passedYes345,07057.76
No252,30042.24
Total votes597,370100.00

By congressional district

[edit]

"Yes" won both congressional districts, which both elected Republicans.[50]

DistrictYesNoRepresentative
1st61%39%Ryan Zinke
2nd54%46%Matt Rosendale (118th Congress)
Troy Downing (119th Congress)

Reactions

[edit]

Initiative 128 would not go into effect until July 1, 2025, though many state laws restricting abortion were blocked or struck down by state courts before this date under the Montana Supreme Court'sArmstrong decision.[51][52][53] In June 2025, the Montana Family Foundation filed a lawsuit seeking to block the implementation of Initiative 128, arguing that Initiative 128 should be declarednull and void because the State of Montana did not print the complete text of the amendment on the ballot and or provide voters who registered to vote on Election Day with voter guides containing the full text of the amendment.[54] The Montana Supreme Court unanimously ruled to dismiss the challenge to the amendment on July 1, saying that the lawsuit was poorly timed and failed to adequately develop a set of facts.[55]

During the 2025 legislative session, Republican state lawmakers introduced several bills to restrict abortions in Montana, despite Initiative 128's passage, with Senate PresidentMatt Regier calling the newly added constitutional amendment "poorly written" and saying that some of the terms used in its language should be defined.[56] Republican state representativeLee Deming introduced a bill that would add an amendment to the Constitution of Montana giving embryos "personhood" rights, overturning Constitutional Initiative 128.[57] The personhood amendment passed the House in a 57–43 vote,[58] but died in the Senate after passing 33–17, nine votes short of the 100 "aye" votes needed to pass a referendum to amend the constitution.[59] Lawmakers tabled a number of other bills that sought to restrict abortion during the 2025 legislative session, but passed two bills prohibiting pregnancy centers from "interfering with work" by state and local government and banning the sale of whole human bodies and human fetal tissue.[60] Both bills were signed into law by Governor Gianforte in May 2025.[61][62]

See also

[edit]

Notes

[edit]
  1. ^abNational and Montana chapters
  2. ^Key:
    A – all adults
    RV – registered voters
    LV – likely voters
    V – unclear

References

[edit]
  1. ^Choi, Joseph (November 6, 2024)."Montana enshrines abortion access into state constitution".The Hill. RetrievedNovember 6, 2024.
  2. ^Schubert, Keith (August 2, 2022)."Gov. Gianforte urges supreme court to reconsider Armstrong decision".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  3. ^Ehrlick, Darrell (May 12, 2023)."Montana Supreme Court says advance practice nurses can perform abortion care".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  4. ^"Montana voters reject "born alive" abortion referendum".Associated Press. November 10, 2022. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  5. ^Miller, Blair (May 16, 2023)."Gianforte signs additional abortion restriction bills; one court challenge already refiled".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  6. ^Riley, John (May 18, 2023)."Montana court puts hold on new law banning common abortion procedure".KTVH. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  7. ^Miller, Blair (September 27, 2023)."Judge grants restraining order blocking abortion licensure requirement from taking effect".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  8. ^Ragar, Shaylee (February 29, 2024)."Montana judge declares 3 laws restricting abortion unconstitutional".NPR. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  9. ^Girten, Nicole (November 27, 2023)."Abortion advocates submit ballot issue affirming right to terminate pregnancy in Montana".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  10. ^abMiller, Blair (January 18, 2024)."Attorney general says proposed Montana abortion ballot issue not legally sufficient".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  11. ^Miller, Blair (March 19, 2024)."Montana Supreme Court says abortion ballot proposal can move forward".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  12. ^Miller, Blair (March 26, 2024)."Knudsen rewrites abortion initiative ballot statement; proponents ask Supreme Court to reject it".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  13. ^Miller, Blair (April 1, 2024)."Supreme Court writes ballot statement for proposed abortion constitutional amendment".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  14. ^Miller, Blair (April 2, 2024)."In wake of court decisions, Montana Senate GOP forms select committee on 'judicial reform'".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  15. ^Miller, Blair (April 2, 2024)."Ellsworth subpoenas abortion initiative from Secretary of State after court says it can skip review".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  16. ^abcdefMiller, Blair (April 18, 2024)."Republican legislators hold hearing on abortion ballot initiative; vote won't appear on petition".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  17. ^Miller, Blair (April 5, 2024)."Jacobsen sends group ballot petition to start collecting signatures for abortion initiative".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  18. ^Miller, Blair (April 4, 2024)."Supreme Court orders Jacobsen to send abortion ballot petition to group".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  19. ^abcdeMiller, Blair (April 17, 2024)."Group kicks off signature gathering efforts for Montana abortion access ballot petition".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  20. ^Edelman, Adam; Pipia, Lindsey (June 21, 2024)."Montana organizers collect enough signatures to advance abortion rights ballot measure".NBC News. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  21. ^Miller, Blair (June 21, 2024)."Montanans Securing Reproductive Rights turns in "record" 117K signatures for abortion petition".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  22. ^Miller, Blair (July 9, 2024)."Montana abortion petition group alleges Secretary of State wrongfully tossing signatures".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  23. ^Ehrlick, Darrell (July 10, 2024)."Montana reproductive rights group sues Secretary of State".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  24. ^Szpaller, Keila (July 17, 2024)."Montana judge tells Secretary of State not to change rules midstream for counting signatures".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  25. ^Szpaller, Keila (July 24, 2024)."Montana Supreme Court denies Secretary of State request it take over initiative case".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  26. ^Miller, Blair (July 24, 2024)."Two Montana ballot initiative groups say they've met signature requirements".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  27. ^abSilvers, Mara (May 30, 2024)."How Montana's abortion rights campaign is seeking signatures — while dodging the opposition".Montana Free Press. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  28. ^Mulvihill, Geoff (October 4, 2024)."Abortion-rights groups are outraising opponents 8-to-1 on November ballot measures".Associated Press. RetrievedOctober 8, 2024.
  29. ^abcdSilvers, Mara (October 30, 2024)."CI-128: How to make sense of Montana's abortion rights amendment".Bozeman Daily Chronicle. RetrievedNovember 4, 2024.
  30. ^abSilvers, Mara (October 25, 2024)."From the pulpit, abortion initiative opponents urge congregations to vote against CI-128".Montana Free Press. RetrievedNovember 4, 2024.
  31. ^abEhrlick, Darrell (September 6, 2024)."Tester, Planned Parenthood leader rally in Bozeman for reproductive freedom".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  32. ^Tapia, Sonny (September 26, 2024).""Freeda Womb" stops in Helena, speakers encourage awareness of reproductive rights".The Independent Record. RetrievedOctober 10, 2024.
  33. ^"Montana abortion ballot initiative CI-128 receives $5M boost".NonStop Local. October 5, 2024. RetrievedOctober 8, 2024.
  34. ^abInman, Taylor (October 8, 2024)."Abortion access supporters and opponents hold rallies over proposed ballot initiative".Daily Inter Lake. RetrievedOctober 8, 2024.
  35. ^Busch, Laurenz (September 22, 2024)."Q&A: Monica Tranel talks housing, reproductive rights and keeping Montana purple".Bozeman Daily Chronicle. RetrievedOctober 10, 2024.
  36. ^Miller, Blair (September 6, 2024)."Chamber of Commerce endorses in Supreme Court races; ACLU launches 'educational' campaign".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  37. ^"FFRF Action Fund grants support for 11 pro-abortion state referenda".ffrfaction.org. September 24, 2024. RetrievedOctober 13, 2024.
  38. ^abSzpaller, Keila (June 18, 2024)."Montanans for Choice launches new 'reproductive freedom' campaign".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  39. ^Graf, Carly (June 17, 2024)."Abortion is on the ballot in Montana, supporters and opponents agree".The Independent Record. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  40. ^Miller, Blair (October 14, 2024)."Zinke and Tranel participate in western district debate as ballots reach mailboxes".Daily Montanan. RetrievedOctober 15, 2024.
  41. ^Ehrlick, Darrell (August 2, 2024)."Gianforte revives debunked abortion claim for ballot initiative".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  42. ^Koopman, Roger (September 20, 2024)."Roger Koopman: CI-128's message — my body has rights, their life does not".Bozeman Daily Chronicle. RetrievedOctober 10, 2024.
  43. ^abMichels, Holly (April 18, 2024)."GOP legislators vote against abortion initiative, Dems don't participate in meeting".The Independent Record. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  44. ^Silvers, Mara (April 18, 2024)."Republicans vote to oppose constitutional abortion rights measure".Montana Free Press. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  45. ^abNiemeyer, Kristi (October 10, 2024)."Legislative Forum Part II: Candidates on abortion rights, housing & education".Lake County Leader. RetrievedOctober 10, 2024.
  46. ^abcGoral, Grant (May 8, 2024)."Montana Catholic Bishops Oppose Abortion Ballot Initiative".National Catholic Register. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  47. ^Szpaller, Keila (August 22, 2024)."Sheehy criticizes ballot measures, including initiative to protect abortion".Daily Montanan. RetrievedSeptember 14, 2024.
  48. ^MSU Billings
  49. ^"2024 Statewide General Election Canvass".Secretary of State of Montana. December 11, 2024. RetrievedDecember 11, 2024.
  50. ^"Montana Secretary of State".electionresults.mt.gov. RetrievedOctober 4, 2025.
  51. ^Szpaller, Keila (November 18, 2024)."Abortion clinics can stay open; judge extends block on license requirement for now".Daily Montanan. RetrievedJuly 10, 2025.
  52. ^Ehrlick, Darrell (March 12, 2025)."State court strikes down two abortion laws passed in '23".Daily Montanan. RetrievedJuly 10, 2025.
  53. ^Ehrlick, Darrell (June 11, 2025)."Montana Supreme Court strikes down trio of abortion bills as unconstitutional".Daily Montanan. RetrievedJuly 10, 2025.
  54. ^Szpaller, Keila (June 23, 2025)."Abortion Policy Government & Politics Montana Family Foundation sues over Constitutional amendment to protect abortion".Daily Montanan. RetrievedJuly 10, 2025.
  55. ^Ehrlick, Darrell (July 2, 2025)."Montana Supreme Court won't hear case challenging abortion amendment".Daily Montanan. RetrievedJuly 10, 2025.
  56. ^O'Connell, Mike Dennison, Sue (January 25, 2025)."Medicaid expansion debate will affect other health policy issues before the Legislature".Daily Montanan. RetrievedJuly 10, 2025.{{cite news}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  57. ^Ehrlick, Darrell (February 10, 2025)."'Personhood' bill moves to Montana House Floor".Daily Montanan. RetrievedJuly 10, 2025.
  58. ^Hansen, Jordan (March 26, 2025)."Personhood bill likely won't reach constitutional threshold".Daily Montanan. RetrievedJuly 10, 2025.
  59. ^Batura, Sean (May 1, 2025)."Bill that sought referendum on legal personhood fails in leg".The Livingston Enterprise. RetrievedJuly 10, 2025.
  60. ^Szpaller, Keila (April 21, 2025)."'Personhood' for embryos fails, other abortion bills head to governor's desk".Daily Montanan. RetrievedJuly 10, 2025.
  61. ^"House Bill 388".2025 Capitol Tracker. Montana Free Press. RetrievedJuly 10, 2025.
  62. ^"Senate Bill 154".2025 Capitol Tracker. Montana Free Press. RetrievedJuly 10, 2025.

External links

[edit]
U.S.
President
U.S.
Senate
U.S.
House

(election
ratings
)
Governors
Lieutenant
governors
Attorneys
general
Secretaries
of state
State
treasurers
State
auditors
Judicial
Other
statewide
elections
State
legislative
Mayors
Local
States and
territories
Ballot
measures
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=2024_Montana_Initiative_128&oldid=1315071327"
Categories:
Hidden categories:

[8]ページ先頭

©2009-2025 Movatter.jp