 | |||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||
 County results Rice: 50–60% 60–70% 70–80% Adams: 50–60% | |||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||
The1876 Massachusetts gubernatorial election was held on November 7. IncumbentRepublican governorAlexander H. Rice was re-elected to a second term in office over former Minister to Great BritainCharles F. Adams.
Rice was nominated without opposition at the convention in Worcester on September 5.[1]
Former governor William Gaston, who had been the party nominee in the prior three elections, was considered an early favorite for a fourth nomination.[2] However, a movement to draftCharles F. Adams, the former Minister to Great Britain during theCivil War, was brought about by New York associates of GovernorSamuel Tilden, who had become the party's presidential nominee and national leader at the1876 Democratic National Convention in June.[2]
At the convention, the boom for Adams was led by delegates from Western Massachusetts and supported on the grounds that an Adams nomination would lend support to Tilden's reformist campaign for president.[2] Opposition to Adams came from conservative Bourbon Democrats, who opposed Adams for his former membership in the Republican Party, and Irish-born Democrats.[2]
U.S. representativeWilliam W. Warren was named permanent chairman of the convention at Worcester on September 6.[2][3] He gave a long speech embracing Tilden, Adams, and Gaston and opposed to the Grant administration's policy of protective tariffs and failure to resume specie payments.[2][a]
When the Committee on Resolutions was announced, competing cheers were made forPatrick Collins, a Gaston supporter from Boston, andJames Scollay Whitney, an Adams supporter from the West. Whitney gave a speech explaining that a compromise would be reached between the parties and a recess was called.[2] During the recess, Gaston allegedly received a telegram from Tilden requesting his withdrawal.[3]
During a recess, Gaston withdrew his name from consideration. He was welcomed to the stage and withdrew his name, moving to nominate Adams by acclamation. Whitney declined calls to for him to "Call for the Nays!" and the ticket was carried without dissent recorded.[2] Gaston was made an elector-at-large for the Tilden ticket,[2][3] though some hoped that he would be nominated for lieutenant governor on the assumption that Adams would join the Tilden cabinet.[2]
There were some rumors that Adams would decline the nomination,[4] but nothing came of them.
The Rice campaign faced opposition from prohibitionists, labor reformers, and conservative Republicans. There were rumors of U.S. representativeBenjamin Butler, a powerful kingmaker from Lowell, throwing his support behind Prohibition candidate John I. Baker in revenge for Rice's support ofEbenezer R. Hoar's independent campaign against Butler. The Labor Reform Party also urged support for Baker.[5] Adams's strength was among intellectuals, reformers, and in the West.[6]
During the campaign, U.S. senatorJames G. Blaine attacked Adams for his conduct during the War andhis earlier proposal to preserve slavery by constitutional amendment.[7]
Ultimately, Rice won re-election with an increased majority, although far smaller thanRutherford B. Hayes's majority in the presidential election, owing to the Prohibition campaign against him.
| Party | Candidate | Votes | % | ±% | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Republican | Alexander H. Rice (incumbent) | 137,665 | 53.59% | ||
| Democratic | Charles Francis Adams Sr. | 106,850 | 41.59% | ||
| Prohibition | John I. Baker | 12,274 | 4.78% | ||
| Others | Others | 115 | 0.05% | ||
| Republicanhold | Swing | ||||
.jpg)
.jpeg)
