| "X of Swords" | |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Marvel Comics |
| Publication date | September – November2020 |
| Genre | Superhero |
| Main character(s) | X-Men Apocalypse Saturnyne The First Horsemen Swordbearers ofArakko |
| Creative team | |
| Writer(s) | Vita Ayala Ed Brisson Gerry Duggan Jonathan Hickman Tini Howard Benjamin Percy Zeb Wells Leah Williams |
| Artist(s) | Mahmud Asrar Viktor Bogdanovic Joshua Cassara Carmen Carnero Stefano Caselli Leinil Francis Yu Carlos Gomez Pepe Larraz Matteo Lolli Phil Noto Rod Reis R. B. Silva Marcus To |
| X of Swords | ISBN 978-1302927172 |
"X of Swords" (pronounced "Ten of Swords") is acomic bookcrossover story arc set during the larger "Krakoan Age" storyline, which debuted in September 2020, published byMarvel Comics.[1][2] It was part of Marvel's "Dawn of X" relaunch of itsX-Men books, following the"House of X" and "Powers of X" storylines. "X of Swords" was followed by the 2021 "Hellfire Gala" storyline.
"X of Swords" (September – November 2020) was the firstcrossover of theKrakoan Age since the relaunchHouse of X andPowers of X event it concluded theDawn of X publishing initiative and launched theReign of X publishing initiative.[3][4] As withPowers of X, "the 'X' in the title is meant to be read as 'Ten'".[1] It was initially teased inFree Comic Book Day 2020: X-Men #1[5] before being announced atC2E2 in February 2020 as the upcoming 15-part X-Men summer crossover storyline.[1][6] The title is a "reference to theTen of Swords", atarot card that "generally represents betrayal, rivalry and tragic endings".[1][7]
Banshee,Glob Herman, andTrinary were set to have roles in X of Swords storyline as teased inFree Comic Book Day 2020: X-Men #1 but Banshee was replaced with his daughterSiryn, Glob Herman withRockslide and Trinary was removed entirely. Regarding this, then-X-Men line's editor Jordan White revealed that Free Comic Book Day comics are done early and stories could change when revised, so they had meant to change the story and not the characters.[8]
Entertainment Weekly highlighted that "as with so many 2020 comics, X of Swords was hit by big pandemic delays"; the crossover was "a collaboration between more than 28 creators" and "the fact that the creative team was stretched across the globe meant they were all affected by COVID-19 in different ways".[9] On the impact of the pandemic,Excalibur andX-Corp writerTini Howard commented,
I don't know if it would have been the same book on the original schedule because tinkering with the schedule caused problems, but also enabled us to do certain things. Everything about that book is very much a product of the situation and people functioning under specific conditions probably more than any other comic I've been a part of. [...] We were all working together on it so much, partially because we didn't have anywhere else to go in lockdown. So we were kind of losing our minds together and making this book. In a way I think it saved my year.[9]
The groundwork for the storyline was established during Howard'sExcalibur run.[10][11] In June 2020, it was revealed that the crossover had increased to 24 issues – two prelude issues followed by a 22-part story.Screen Rant commented that in this style of crossover "creative teams work together, with normal stories suspended in favor of continuing the event".[12]X of Swords: Creation #1, by writersJonathan Hickman and Tini Howard with art by Pepe Larraz and Marte Gracia, was released in September 2020.[13] The final issue,X of Swords: Destruction #1 by the same creative team, was released in November 2020.[14] A 56-page companion guidebook,X of SwordsHandbook, in an encyclopedic style was released alongside the crossover; "each entry features multiple paragraphs detailing each character's known history up until this event".[15]
As part of the "Fresh Start" relaunch, an extra-sized issue in celebration of the long history of Marvel Comics includes a one-page story shows Apocalypse reminiscing about his originalFour Horsemen who were lost so long ago.[16]
During theHouse of X andPowers of X storyline, it is revealed thatMoira MacTaggert, an ally of the X-Men, is a mutant whose power is to live many "lives". In her ninth life, she allied with Apocalypse and they both rescued the First Horsemen.[17]Cypher andProfessor X travel to the mutant island ofKrakoa to establish the future foundation of their mutant paradise. Communicating with Krakoa, Cypher reveals its secret history.[18] X andMagneto invite all former mutant villains to live on the island including immortal Egyptian mutantApocalypse (En Sabah Nur). Both Krakoa and Apocalyse interact subtly – a hint of their shared past.[19]
As part of the "Dawn of X" relaunch,Cyclops,Rachel Summers, and youngCable travel to a mysterious island on the ocean, where they meet enigmatic characterSummoner. It is then revealed that the island is a fragment of Krakoa, with which the living island reunites.[20] Weeks later, Summoner recounts the story of the separation of Krakoa andArakko, the result of an invasion from the dimension of Amenth.[20]
In the newExcalibur title of "Dawn of X", it is shown that Apocalypse wants to tap into the magical spring source that isOtherworld, ruled by Omniversal MajestrixSaturnyne. This new approximation of Krakoa's mutants and the inhabitants of Otherworld sets the stage for a future confrontation.[21] Some time later, Apocalypse gathers his fellow X-Ternals, and sacrifices some of them to create a portal to connect Krakoa to Otherworld.[22]
It is discovered that the first incarnation of the Horsemen are actually the biological children of Apocalypse and his wifeGenesis who was also sent with Arakko. Following that, Apocalypse went to the Summoner and directed him to the portal to Otherworld where he could return to Arakko, while being accompanied byUnus the Untouchable and Banshee. However, what Apocalypse did not expect was that this was all an elaborate plan created by his own children so they could return and overthrow Krakoa with their fellow Arakkii mutants and Daemon army. Apocalypse himself was soon attacked and critically injured by his daughterWar, being forced to retreat to Krakoa to heal their wounds and prepare for war between the two groups.[23]
Former studentRockslide suffers a surprise attack by Summoner, who destroys his psychic essence. Hurrying back to Krakoa, the Five proceed to restore his physical husk, but, when X begins to telepathically download his memories, the fiveCerebro mainframes fry and short circuit. Apprehensive, the Five convene with the Quiet Council to inform them that once a mutant is killed in Otherworld, this creates problems for the resurrection process. When the Five attempt to resurrect Rockslide, they create an amalgam of the different Rockslide variants who is later dubbedWrongslide.[23][24]
Polaris acts as a medium and delivers the list of swords and cryptic hints about the chosen champions of Krakoa.[23][24]Magik is the first one to rise to the occasion.[24]Wolverine and Arakkii mutantSolem are sent to a Hell-like dimension to reach legendary bladesmithMuramasa, and ask him to forge new blades for the tournament. Solem gets both of the new Muramasa swords, but yields one to Logan in exchange for a favor.[25]Storm travels toWakanda to request permission to borrow an ancient relic from the Royal Family: a mystical sword named Skybreaker, made of vibranium and previously wielded by a legendary Wakandan king. Due to the Royal Family's refusal, Ororo is forced to steal it only to face her ex-sister in-lawShuri, before leaving the country.[26]
In Krakoa, Cypher shares his worries withWarlock and the Living Island, while training under Magik for the upcoming tournament. Meanwhile, the Quiet Council decides to take a different approach instead of sending a mutant with little battle experience:[27] they agree to sendMister Sinister and hisHellions on a secret mission to sabotage the contest.[28] Young Cable, Jean Grey and Cyclops travel to theS.W.O.R.D. space station and Cable activates it with his sword, the Light ofGalador.[23] The trio soon discovers that an extradimensional army known as the Vescora massacred the station's occupants. After dealing with this threat, young Cable joins the other swordbearers.[29] In Otherworld, siblingsBetsy Braddock (the newCaptain Britain) andBrian Braddock (Captain Avalon) trick Saturnyne into forging the Starlight Sword, while also acquiring the Sword of Might.[30]
Still reeling from the betrayal of his children, Apocalyse reminisces about the time he lost his wife Genesis and children, the First Horsemen, when Okkara was split into two islands. Soon after, he asks Gorgon to accompany him to Egypt to retrieve his own sword (akhopesh) for the upcoming tournament.[31] In Arakko, the First Horsemen begin to assemble their forces for the upcoming tournament, all the while revealing underlying tensions among themselves and between a few of the major players of Krakoa's side.[32][25][33]
After the chosen Swordbearers of Arakko and Krakoa travel to the Otherworld, they are welcomed by Saturnyne. Both parties intermingle and try to discover each other's secrets and weaknesses. Apocalypse encounters his former wife Genesis, who reveals the story of her banishment while Storm shares a dance with the Horseman ofDeath.[34][35][36]
After the feast, Saturnyne announces the challenges. Aside from one-on-one battles, she forces the Swordbearers to compete in a series of extravagant contests.[37]
Notable contests include: the apparent death of Captain Britain againstIsca the Unbeaten, shattering into glass-like fragments; the marriage of Cypher andBei the Blood Moon; andGorgon being killed after a fierce battle againstWhite Sword and his One Hundred Champions. Finally, with the score tied, Saturnyne announces the last match: Apocalyse versus Genesis possessed byAnnihilation.[38][39]
In the meantime, Sinister and the Hellions arrive in Amenth to sabotage the Arakkii team, but their mission goes awry when they encounterTarn the Uncaring and his Locus Vile. Theirs is a bloody battle, and four of their number (including Sinister, secretly a clone) are killed. The other Hellions barely escape through a portal to Krakoa, but as soon as they return, the real Sinister kills the survivors to keep his true purpose during the mission a secret: stealing gene samples from Arakkii mutants.[40]
Before his duel with Bei, Cable telepathically communicates withJean Grey and Cyclops on Krakoa. Saturnyne notices the interference and cuts their contact. Fearing for Cable's life, the heroes present their case to the Quiet Council: they intend to take as many mutants to the Otherworld and rescue Krakoa's champions. They also feel the need to reinstate the X-Men as a permanent team to defend their interests.[41]
When Apocalypse wins the duel against Genesis, Annihilation seizes full control of its host and summons the hordes of Amenthi Daemons to invade Krakoa. Cable uses S.W.O.R.D.'s space station to transport everyone they can gather to Otherworld's battlefield (including a rebornCaptain Britain Corps), in the middle of an all-out war between Krakoa's and Amenth's armies. During the battle, Apocalypse manages to take the Annihilation Helm from Genesis and, overcoming its corruptive influence, makes Amenth's forces surrender. Saturnyne, satisfied with this conclusion, asks both Krakoa and Arakko to trade prisoners, as a token of goodwill: Apocalypse chooses to accompany his wife and children back to Amenth, in exchange for Arakko (and consequently all its mutant inhabitants) returning to Earth, so Krakoa can reunite with its "twin" at last.[41]
Saturnyne is crowned Queen in Otherworld and gets what sheneeded, but not what shewanted: Brian Braddock's heart.[41]
The conclusion of X of Swords saw the X-Men comics line transition from theDawn of X era to theReign of X era, which involved the launch of new titles and Vita Ayala taking over writing duties onNew Mutants.
With Apocalypse leaving Krakoa to be with his wife and children in Amenth, and Jean Grey stepping down from her leadership position to form the X-Men, the Quiet Council now has two empty seats.[42][43] The remaining members now try to pick names to fill the void.[42][43]
InX-Men, with Cyclops and Jean Grey having decided to work outside the Quiet Council and take a strike team to rescue the Champions in Otherworld, the pair begin work on forming Krakoa's first official X-Men team.[43]
In the newly launchedS.W.O.R.D. byAl Ewing, the Krakoans take hold of the S.W.O.R.D space station and reposition it as their satellite base, under the command of AgentAbigail Brand.[44][45]
InExcalibur, Saturnyne has rebuilt the Captain Britain Corps with alternate reality counterparts of Elizabeth Braddock. The original Betsy, however, remains missing after her battle with Isca the Unbeaten, leaving the Excalibur team on a desperate search to find her.[46]
| Issue | Release date | Writer | Artist | Colorist | Comic Book Roundup rating[47] | Estimated sales to North American retailers (first month) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Excalibur (vol. 4) #12 | September 16, 2020 | Tini Howard | Marcus To | Erick Arciniega | 8.1 from 7 professional critics | 29,500–35,000[48] |
| X-Men (vol. 5) #12 | September 16, 2020 | Jonathan Hickman | Leinil Francis Yu | Sunny Gho | 8.2 from 10 professional critics | 75,000–90,000[48] |
| Chapter | Issue[49] | Release date | Writer(s) | Artist(s) | Colorist | Comic Book Roundup rating[47] | Estimated sales to North American retailers (first month) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | X of Swords: Creation #1 | September 23, 2020 | Jonathan Hickman Tini Howard | Pepe Larraz | Marte Gracia | 8.4 from 18 professional critics | 115,000–140,000[48] |
| 2 | X-Factor (vol. 4) #4 | September 30, 2020 | Leah Williams | Carlos Gomez | Israel Silva | 8.4 from 8 professional critics | 50,000–60,000[48] |
| 3 | Wolverine (vol. 7) #6 | October 7, 2020 | Benjamin Percy | Viktor Bogdanovic | Matt Wilson | 7.8 from 11 professional critics | 85,000–95,000[50] |
| 4 | X-Force (vol. 6) #13 | 7.7 from 11 professional critics | 48,000–53,000[50] | ||||
| 5 | Marauders #13 | Vita Ayala | Matteo Lolli | Edgar Delgado | 8.0 from 10 professional critics | 46,000–51,000[50] | |
| 6 | Hellions #5 | October 14, 2020 | Zeb Wells | Carmen Carnero | David Curiel | 8.2 from 10 professional critics | 41,500–46,000[50] |
| 7 | New Mutants (vol. 4) #13 | Ed Brisson | Rod Reis | 8.5 from 8 professional critics | 45,000–50,000[50] | ||
| 8 | Cable (vol. 4) #5 | Gerry Duggan | Phil Noto | 8.1 from 8 professional critics | 32,500–36,000[50] | ||
| 9 | Excalibur (vol. 4) #13 | October 21, 2020 | Tini Howard | R. B. Silva | Nolan Woodard | 7.7 from 8 professional critics | 42,000–47,000[50] |
| 10 | X-Men (vol. 5) #13 | Jonathan Hickman | Mahmud Asrar | Sunny Gho | 7.8 from 12 professional critics | 90,000–100,000[50] | |
| 11 | X of Swords: Stasis #1 | October 28, 2020 | Tini Howard Jonathan Hickman | Pepe Larraz Mahmud Asrar | Marte Gracia | 7.5 from 13 professional critics | 61,500–68,000[50] |
| 12 | X-Men (vol. 5) #14 | November 4, 2020 | Jonathan Hickman | Mahmud Asrar Leinil Francis Yu | Sunny Gho | 7.5 from 9 professional critics | Not yet available |
| 13 | Marauders #14 | Gerry Duggan Benjamin Percy | Stefano Caselli | Edgar Delgado | 7.5 from 8 professional critics | ||
| 14 | Marauders #15 | November 11, 2020 | 7.6 from 8 professional critics | ||||
| 15 | Excalibur (vol. 4) #14 | Tini Howard | Phil Noto | 7.3 from 11 professional critics | |||
| 16 | Wolverine (vol. 7) #7 | Benjamin Percy Gerry Duggan | Joshua Cassara | Guru-eFX | 7.9 from 10 professional critics | ||
| 17 | X-Force (vol. 6) #14 | November 18, 2020 | 7.5 from 11 professional critics | ||||
| 18 | Hellions #6 | Zeb Wells | Carmen Carnero | David Curiel | 7.7 from 9 professional critics | ||
| 19 | Cable (vol. 4) #6 | Gerry Duggan | Phil Noto | 8.0 from 9 professional critics | |||
| 20 | X-Men (vol. 5) #15 | November 25, 2020 | Jonathan Hickman | Mahmud Asrar | Sunny Gho | 8.2 from 11 professional critics | |
| 21 | Excalibur (vol. 4) #15 | Tini Howard | Mahmud Asrar Stefano Caselli | Sunny Gho Rachelle Rosenberg | 7.7 from 7 professional critics | ||
| 22 | X of Swords: Destruction #1 | Jonathan Hickman Tini Howard | Pepe Larraz | Marte Gracia | 7.8 from 15 professional critics | ||
| Title | Release date |
|---|---|
| X of Swords Handbook #1 | October 14, 2020[51] |
| Title | Material collected | Format | Publication date | ISBN |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| X of Swords | X of Swords: Creation #1,X of Swords: Stasis #1,X of Swords: Destruction #1,X-Men (vol. 5) #12-15,Excalibur (vol. 4) #13-15,Marauders (vol. 1) #13-15,X-Force (vol. 6) #13-14,New Mutants (vol. 4) #13,Wolverine (vol. 7) #6-7,Cable (vol. 4) #5-6,Hellions (vol. 1) #5-6,X-Factor (vol. 4) #4 | Hardcover | January 19, 2021[52] | ISBN 978-1302927172 |
| X of Swords vol. 1 | Trade paperback | June 1, 2021[53] | ISBN 978-1846532917 | |
| X of Swords | January 11, 2022[54] | ISBN 978-1302929978 |
Susana Polo ofPolygon highlighted the risk this crossover took in its structure by eschewing the main miniseries with tie-ins format and instead doing "something we see way less often" by telling a story through existing series – "it all felt like a single contiguous narrative, no need for a narration box to pop through the fourth wall to tell you that you should only read this tie-in issue if you've already readSpider-Man #42069 or what have you".[55] Polo thought a "downside" was that "readers had to buy alot more books" in a two month span, however, it was a rewarding crossover to read. She commented "If the creative teams had not kept such a high polish on the art, stakes, character forward storytelling, and making sureX of Swords felt like one story and not a clumsy game of Exquisite Corpse, this could have been very different. This format might be harder to pull off than the usual event comic structure, it might require a lot more heft on the part of writers, artists, and editors, but it sure made a damn enjoyable comic".[55] Jim Dandeneau, forDen of Geek, highlighted that the X of Swords "setup promised what was essentially a season ofDragon Ball Super in an X-Men comic", however, "once the tournament started, it ended up being the fighting equivalent ofWhose Line Is It Anyway – the rules were made up and the points didn't matter. [...] When it came down to it,X of Swords was anExcalibur story, and it honored that book's roots by being multiversal, very silly, and full of effective character growth. And very, very good".[56]
Alex Abad-Santos ofVox thought the crossover, with its "dependence onHouse of X and its robust roster of characters and mythology", was a story "that's way too big to serve as a starting point" – "X of Swords is the reward for sticking with the X-Men through a tumultuous era, and it hurtles their story forward with real consequence and thrill".[57] Abad-Santos commented that "as is Hickman's MO,X of Swords veers toward complex, sometimes impenetrable fantasy. [...]X of Swords introduces a sprawling maze of rules and bylaws and lore that would be difficult to explain to someone who hasn't cracked the book. At the same time, it kicks off the kind of story you immediately want to share with your friends because you need someone to talk to about what you just read".[57] Oliver Sava, forThe A.V. Club, didn't view the crossover as "perfect", commenting that "the mythologizing of Arakko gets repetitive, especially when one of the issues (X-Men #14) reuses artwork from a previous chapter, pairing it with a new script showing a different perspective of the same events. There are going to be plenty of readers annoyed at the fight fake-outs, and you can't blame them when that's what the promotional materials promised".[58] Sava thought it succeeded as a crossover by "letting individual series hold on to their unique voices while still telling a cohesive story. [...] The Krakoa experiment isn't losing any steam, and the confidence and excitement of this crossover suggests that the best is still to come as seeds take root and the X-Men's world continues to grow".[58] Kofi Outlaw ofComicBook.com similarly highlighted that some readers will "feel the world-building is a bait-and-switch on the big battle event that X of Swords promised" as the crossover "invested a lot of time, panels, and chart work to establish the larger layout of Otherworld, its various kingdoms, various species, and their socio-political order".[59] He commented that "the first half of X of Swords seemed like every fantasy-genre epic orGame of Thrones season, with major characters out questing to obtain some all-importantMacGuffins" and the switch in the second half to a tournament "has been a smorgasbord of fantasy-genre tropes, that are often hilariously fun in an X-Men setting. [...] It's absurd in the best kind of way - especially if you're a longtime fantasy fan". Outlaw opined that the real test of the crossover was if the Arakko and Otherworld story building have an impact "on the larger X-Men mythos" going forwards.[59]
Ben Morin, forAIPT in 2022, called the crossover a "fine event" which "works well at paying off several through-lines for the era, while also ushering in new status quo changes. Though the expansive worldbuilding does eventually get in the way of the story, it's still impressive, especially with how it all culminates in the final issues. The writing quality varies across the titles, but the art is consistently great".[60] In reviewing the collectedtrade paperback edition, Morin thought it was a cost effective way to read the crossover with the "omission of theExcalibur #12 prelude issue" as the "only disappointing aspect"; he highlighted that "the collection does also utilize a neat design layout to structure the books with graphics denoting each issue, which also blends really well with theinfographic pages".[60] In 2024, D. Emerson Eddy ofThe Beat viewedX of Swords as "a capsule of both the micro and macro approaches to storytelling that were inherent across the line. While there is some linear flow from chapter to chapter, each segment is given its own voice and purpose by the various creative teams. [...] Overall, the artwork through the crossover is stunning. Not a weak link to be found" with each artist's style remaining distinct. Although he did feel a reader would be "better informed" by reading the comics leading into the crossover, Eddy thought the various perspectives in the story avoided the common crossover pitfall of disjointed voices since "the story is structured in a way that each shines as its own part of the whole". He commented that "X of Swords is a masterful work that I feel captures the joy and limitless possibility of the early Krakoan era. A fantastic otherworldly adventure that adds an incredible amount of lore, depth, and story possibilities to the world as a whole".[61]
