Does papyrus grow where there is no marsh?Papyrus is a plant that thrives in wet, marshy environments, particularly in regions like Egypt and along the Nile River. In the context of Job, Bildad is using this imagery to illustrate the necessity of a proper environment for growth. The papyrus plant, known for its use in making ancient paper, symbolizes something that cannot exist without its essential conditions. This reflects the broader biblical theme that spiritual growth and righteousness require a foundation in God’s truth and presence. The rhetorical question implies that just as papyrus cannot grow without a marsh, a person cannot thrive spiritually without God.
Do reeds flourish without water?
Reeds, similar to papyrus, are dependent on water to survive and flourish. This imagery is used to emphasize the importance of sustenance and the right conditions for life. In biblical symbolism, water often represents life, cleansing, and the Holy Spirit. The question suggests that just as reeds need water, humans need spiritual nourishment to prosper. This can be connected to other scriptures, such asPsalm 1:3, which describes a righteous person as a tree planted by streams of water, yielding fruit in season. The implication is that spiritual vitality is contingent upon a relationship with God, much like the dependence of reeds on water.
Persons / Places / Events
1.
Bildad the ShuhiteOne of Job's three friends who comes to comfort him. In this chapter, Bildad is speaking, offering his perspective on Job's suffering and the nature of God's justice.
2.
JobA man described as blameless and upright, who fears God and shuns evil. He is undergoing severe trials and suffering, which prompts discussions with his friends about the reasons for his afflictions.
3.
Papyrus and ReedsThese are plants that require a marshy, water-rich environment to grow. Bildad uses them as metaphors to illustrate the necessity of a proper foundation for growth and prosperity.
Teaching Points
The Necessity of a Strong FoundationJust as papyrus and reeds need water to thrive, our spiritual lives require a foundation rooted in God's word and presence. Without this, we cannot flourish.
Dependence on God for GrowthBildad's metaphor reminds us that true prosperity and growth come from being connected to God, much like plants need water. We must seek His guidance and sustenance daily.
The Role of Trials in Revealing FoundationsBildad's words, though part of a misguided argument, can remind us that trials often reveal the strength of our spiritual foundations. Are we deeply rooted in faith, or are we easily swayed by circumstances?
Community and AccountabilityBildad's interaction with Job, though flawed, highlights the importance of community and accountability in our spiritual journey. We need others to remind us of God's truths, even if their perspectives are sometimes imperfect.
Lists and Questions
Top 10 Lessons from Job 8
Job 8:11–13 compares the fate of sinners to papyrus plants withering; does this metaphor conflict with other biblical teachings about God’s mercy?
What constitutes a spiritual attack?
In Job 11:8, is Sheol literally beneath the earth, and if so, why is there no archaeological evidence of it?
2 Thessalonians 3:3 - How can believers claim 'the Lord is faithful' if historical evidence suggests countless faithful people still suffer or face calamity?(11)
The flagis the plant of
Genesis 41:2, which the cattle feed upon. This figure is enforced by a second, that, namely, of the spider's web, the most fragile and transient of tenements.
Verse 11 -
Can the rush grow up without mire? The word translated "rush" (
גמא) is that which occurs also in Exodus if. 3:
Isaiah 18:2 and Isaiah 35:7, as designating a plant common in Egypt, and which is only found in these four places. It is generally admitted that the "papyrus" is meant "a plant of the
Cyperaceae or sedge family, which was formerly common in Egypt" (Hooker, in Smith's 'Dict. of the Bible,' vol. 3. p. 1019). The chief peculiarity of the papyrus is its triangular stem, which rises to the height of six or seven, sometimes even of thirteen or fourteen, feet, and terminates in a bunch of thread-like flowering branchlets. The pith of these stems was the material of which the ancient Egyptians made their paper. The papyrus is a water-plant, and needs an abundant supply, but would often spring up out of any small pool which the Nile left as it retired, and, when the water failed from the peel, would rapidly wither away. A fine papyrus plant was on view, with other water-plants, in the circular greenhouse in Kew Gardens, towards the end of the season of 1890. Can the flag grow without water "The flag" (
אחוּ) seems to be the ordinary sedge, or marah-plant. Like the papyrus, it would often spring up in all its greenness from a pool or pond left by the retiring river, and then in a few days, when the water was dried up, would wither away. Both images represent the prosperity of the wicked, and were probably proverbial.
Parallel Commentaries ...
Hebrew
Does papyrusגֹּ֭מֶא(gō·me)Noun - masculine singular
Strong's 1573:An absorbent, the bulrush, the papyrusgrowהֲיִֽגְאֶה־(hă·yiḡ·’eh-)Verb - Qal - Imperfect - third person masculine singular
Strong's 1342:To mount up, to rise, be majesticwhere there is noבְּלֹ֣א(bə·lō)Preposition-b | Adverb - Negative particle
Strong's 3808:Not, nomarsh?בִצָּ֑ה(ḇiṣ·ṣāh)Noun - feminine singular
Strong's 1207:A swampDo reedsאָ֥חוּ(’ā·ḥū)Noun - masculine singular
Strong's 260:A bulrush, any marshy grassflourishיִשְׂגֶּה־(yiś·geh-)Verb - Qal - Imperfect - third person masculine singular
Strong's 7685:To grow, increasewithoutבְלִי־(ḇə·lî-)Adverb
Strong's 1097:Failure, nothing, destruction, without, not yet, because not, as long aswater?מָֽיִם׃(mā·yim)Noun - masculine plural
Strong's 4325:Water, juice, urine, semen
Links
Job 8:11 NIVJob 8:11 NLTJob 8:11 ESVJob 8:11 NASBJob 8:11 KJV
Job 8:11 BibleApps.comJob 8:11 Biblia ParalelaJob 8:11 Chinese BibleJob 8:11 French BibleJob 8:11 Catholic Bible
OT Poetry: Job 8:11 Can the papyrus grow up without mire? (Jb) 
